Season 11 · Episode 48

The Rise of Skywalker

2 hr 39 min Explicit Full episode
The Rise of Skywalker
Movie Meltdown
0:00
2:38:48
MP3

About this episode

Movie Meltdown - Episode 511 This episode we celebrate Life Day and the final chapter in the Skywalker saga... The Rise of Skywalker. Join us as we discuss the finer points of this latest movie. How effective it is as the last movie in this most recent trilogy. And how well it wraps up this huge story arc that has meant so much to so many people - for generations.  And as we try to recollect just which stories are canon and which ones are legends, we also address… The Mandalorian, The Good Place, Kevin Feige, inching into evil, force powers, Maz Kanata, Warwick Davis, are there raisins in here, influenced by the fanbase, D-0, luck your way into awesomeness, Lucas' plan, murderbot, skimming off the top, It's like… high energy and high concept, that's why chaotic evil always fails, Samuel L Jackson, why not Chewie, J.J. Abrams, old sitcoms and burritos, five-minute morality, gentrifying Tatooine, is it okay to be massacring those people, cruisin' the clubs, the big reveals, Asimov's laws of robotics, setting up love interests, Anthony Daniels, my understanding of the family trees of Star Wars universe, Billy Dee Williams, force ghosts, lightsaber fighting techniques, Rian Johnson, being cousins, the feel of the universe, the story vs. behind the scenes, droids with issues, Adam Driver, stakes and fake-outs, giant snake, government funding, Disney and the system that rigs itself.   Spoiler Alert: Full spoilers for The Rise of Skywalker. You have been warned!  "...your job is to make this movie, that's going to make them… feel differently and see things differently - not the other way around."

Transcript

Automatically generated, so expect the odd misheard name.

This is Billy Dee Williams and you're listening to Movie Meltdown. The following feature has been rated R by the Motion Picture Association of America. It is intended for mature audiences and parental discretion is advised. It's showtime, folks. Enjoy the show.

Our nuclear reactor pumping out one million kilowatts of power. Bob, I got a bad feeling on this one, alright? I mean, I got a bad feeling. What's up, and welcome to Movie Meltdown. I'm Brian.

I'm Jacqueline. I'm Phillip. I'm Jeff. And happy Life Day! Yay!

We have come together to celebrate the most holiest of holidays, Life Day. And by that, I mean I've bastardized it and turned it into whatever the hell I want every December. So it's probably not even December. Didn't somebody on the internet figure out when it is? And they put way too much effort into it.

Jesus Christ. I'm just like, yeah. I was just like, I don't care. It's Wookiees and shit. Man, I'm just going to make a show and call it Life Day.

I don't think the Star Wars months are the same as ours. Is there a Star Wars 2... to our reality conversion of dates and times. Again, I've heard theories. Again, geeks have nothing but... You'll probably get lots of angry emails.

Because there's some theory that it works out the years, too, where it's like, ah, 77 is this year that the Battle of Yavin took place because it was in 1977. And then if you map that out over the years, the battles take place in this year versus... I don't know. It's way too much. That bothers me less than figuring out that Life Day's not in December.

Way too much. And I don't know why. Yeah, and that's why I don't worry about any of it. I'm a geek, but there's levels of geekdom, man, and that's... I just have life days so I can make...

Oh, you know what's coming. Wookie cookies! Oh, you made the cookies? Yes! So.

Okay, you didn't make the blue milk, but you made the cookies. Yeah, because blue milk seemed like it went to waste, but nobody wants to. Waste Wookie cookies. Are there raisins in here? Don't...

It's against the Wookiee religion. You know that. Well, I know, but I always have to ask when someone gives me a cookie. Wait, are you going to have some sort of reaction if I put them in? An unhappy reaction.

Let me get the phone. Hold on. My reaction will be a frown. Yeah. I'd hate to ruin 15 plus years of friendship over that.

I do want to say this year's Wookiee cookies were a fight. And as the Skywalker saga comes to an end, maybe I'm tired of making Wookiee cookies because they were not cooperating. Like, these are the best of the batch, and these ain't that perfect. As you know, I'm kind of picky about my cookies. How's your oven here?

It sucks, which is why I don't bake anything here. I have opted for several years to take the dough somewhere else to bake it. That's how dedicated I am to not making sucky cookies. And then this year, they still wanted to fight me, so. Maybe we'll come up with a new offshoot for Life Day in the future.

I wonder if I still have a key. Because that was the best option, actually. The place that you used to work and you might break into now was the best option when I made them. Unless the oven was going to kill you. It also tried to kill me, but it didn't make really good Wookiee cookies.

So, I don't know. And those crispy edges, I love them. Just a side note on the Wookiee cookies this year. It's a fight to get them to come out. They're still good.

These are delicious. One of the struggles of being a Wookiee, I suppose. So with that, do we want to ease our way in with any Mandalorian talk? Is anyone else on board with the. I still haven't seen it.

I want to watch it, but it pops up on my screen and I'm like. That's normally how I am with most series, but I obviously had to make an exception because it's Star Wars and I'm. Also kind of just like waiting. I don't know what it is. It's just kind of like I don't want to make the investment or the commitment or something like that.

It's like I want everyone to forget about The Mandalorian and then I'll watch it. Yeah. Surprisingly, though, I talk to people all the time who have seen it, but they don't really tell me much about it other than that they enjoyed it. Yeah, I had the first person I ran into yesterday, actually, that were like, I don't get it. I don't understand why everybody's all worked up.

So I was just like, well, you're wrong. Because I'm pretty impressed with it. One of the most recent episodes, I was questioning one of the best shows of television? Like, it was just really well put together. So that's just me.

It feels weird to be sitting there watching, let's just call it TV. episodic TV that is Star Wars that is good. And that's kind of why I want to do ease in with it because it's going to come back around by the end for me. I think that's what I like about it is that it's making use of this Star Wars universe and doing something entirely different with it. And I'm like, that I kind of want. When do you remember like 10, again, time is Meaningless to me anymore.

Remember like 10 years ago when Lucas was saying, I want to do a live action TV show, and then it didn't happen for two years, and he goes, it's too expensive to do. Which at the time, again, pre-Netflix streaming kind of stuff. Which now I kind of get, because The Mandalorian is movie quality special effects, and you're like... So this is what regular TV has become. And I'm down with it.

And sets and costumes. Everything is that level of quality, but in a TV show, which you don't always, especially in sci-fi, it's so hard to deliver really impressive sets that even pretty high-budget shows, sometimes I'm like, eh, the sets are a little shoddy, but what do you know? It is Apple or it is Disney +, so it's not quite TV. It's kind of, I don't know how to define things anymore. It's all a great version of TV.

It's premium cable. It's whatever. It's weird now when I watch a show that reminds me of primetime TV. I'm like, the pacing of this, everything is just so foreign to me now because this is like the golden age of television where every, I mean, you know, they don't have the special effects, that kind of production value, but like True Detective and Fargo, like they have that cinematic quality. Like the writing, the acting is all like top shelf.

There's a handful. Mostly I just leave the TV on because that's what I've done my entire life. But it's on in the background enough that I still see some like network TV stuff. And when I get like a standard run of the mill network sitcom, I'm just like, this is so weird. It's just so almost a bygone era now.

Like, oh, they do still make these, don't they? Like, it's weird. I've been into The Good Place, which does have that feeling. But it's self-aware about it and it's still weird enough and like bizarre enough to make up for it. I really liked it.

I love Kristen Bell. So anything she's doing, I'm on board with. But it's almost like overwhelming after a while. Because I got three seasons in and I'm just like. oh god it's coming on like it's yeah it's too much like they're so high concept they're so. Yeah that sort of concept you could really write yourself in the corner really quickly and I feel like they did and then to get out of it they had to just pile on these layers.

And continually reboot themselves within the series sometimes within the same season reboot things and do a whole different style all of a sudden and I'm just like. And I'm enjoying it but man there's a lot going. On yeah it's like that's creative which is great but it's also like it takes its toll on you i feel like like can i just watch a dumb sitcom and not think so much. It's like high energy yeah and high concept yeah it's like slamming your. Brain but it's really well written like the jokes are smart and like really kind of cool little like inside joke stuff the the fact that the supreme being loves to watch old sitcoms and makes jokes about them and like that's a nice little touch for geeks out there.

And just loves burritos. Yeah. Like again, this is like the, the weird stuff they work in is, is brilliant. And again, sometimes a little overwhelming. When I like the, um, the, the layered morality to where the system rigs itself to where even if you do something good, there's so many layers deep that leads to something bad that you're just, because to me that that's, that's the cosmic joke of everything is that, You're damned if you do, and you're damned if you don't.

So, screw it all. That is the universal truth that we've learned. So, to me, that the the idea that there is a system and the system is fundamentally broken is to me the the ultimate joke yes of it all. Yeah this is why i just try to watch less intelligent shows it's too much to think about All right, are we ready to get into this week's movie that I feel like we're going to have a lot of stuff to discuss? Get more out of life.

Go out to a movie. It's an instinct. Force brought us together. We're not alone. Good people will fight if we lead them.

People keep telling me they know me. No one does. Long have I waited. And now. Your coming together.

Is your undoing. What, uh. what are you doing there, 3PO? Taking one last look, sir. At my friends. Confronting fear.

The Force will be with you. Always. So, we have, surprisingly, gone out on the town. We went out into the world and sat with other geeks, and it was a moving experience, and For me. I don't know about the rest of you.

I go to the movies all the time. Oh, I do. But this was different. It was a different just vibe in the room. There's only a handful of movies throughout the year that I'm like, this feels different.

I go and usually sit by myself because I'm like an old man. So I like to go in the mornings when nobody else is there. It's so great to be with like three other people in the theater. I'm like, yes. It's like Saturday morning cartoons.

Yeah. Except I'm watching whatever cool movie I want to. So yeah. That's the normal way. But this way was, you know, packed in with a lot of people and we were all of the same ilk, geeks, to many levels.

So, yeah, this was a different experience. That experience was this week's Out of the Town feature, which is Star Wars Episode IX, The Rise of Skywalker. The year is obviously 2019. The director is obviously J.J. Abrams.

And the plot, according to IMDb, is minimal at best. The surviving resistance faces the First Order once more in the final chapter of the Skywalker saga. Really didn't even put effort into that. No. Remember that stuff in the other two movies?

Yeah, it's more of that. Which, they're right, but. Alright, so... Where do we want to begin? Where to begin?

I feel like there's a lot to discuss. There's the basics of the movie itself, and then the overarching... within this trilogy within the whole saga so there's a lot of stuff you're. Gonna want to go macro to micro or. I tried to at least because again i only got to see it that one time so i'm like am i gonna forget half this stuff which i probably am so i also try to get like a a basic synopsis to try to hit some of the points as the plot goes along too and then i'm sure we'll sidebar on many many issues along the way so i don't know do we just want to kind of run through the plot more or less or just the bigger picture. Of things my first thought is i enjoyed it i had a good time with this movie.

That that was my leaving the theater mode first of all as the lights came up and there were just a bunch of old people tearing up in the dark my life has been about this like it really was a little a little verklempt you know you're a little like and again not even this specific movie it's just like this This whole thing has been really kind of important in my life. I will say I did have two moments I can remember off the top of my head where I almost cried. Like genuine tears. And again, it was, I think, bigger than the specifics of this movie. It was way more weight behind everything because of the ridiculous amount of years I've, most of my life, what little brain I have has been devoted to Star Wars.

So like so much of it kind of weighed on all of that. I can also get to what I think is what, because again, I had a good experience myself. And as time's gone on, I've, as geeks do, found a million things to nitpick about. But at the time, I was like, it still kind of worked for me. And then the other moment that happened, because I sat there like a geek through the credits, and surprisingly, a few people around me did.

And one of them was this family. And there were like two little girls there. And one of them's, like, the littlest is, like, four, maybe. And her older sister's wearing a Luke Skywalker shirt. And, like, old school, like, Jedi era Luke Skywalker that I guess is reprinted.

So, like, they're heading out, and the little girl in her little, like, lispy four-year-old voice is just like, that was amazing! And I'm like, damn it. Like, it still works. Like, it still is working on countless generations now we've hit so many different levels of kid that still just get sucked in because it's star wars and i'm like i think that hit me maybe even more than the movie like the fact that it's still working and still sucking kids in like it did me i'm like that was maybe the most impressive thing right there was that little kid going that was amazing and still being excited about it and they were in the they were parked next to me too so even all the way out they were like talking about plot points and i'm like This is my whole life.

This is what kicked it off for me, and I'm obviously still doing it now. So, yeah, that was my overall view at the beginning. That's a very wholesome story. Yeah, it was fun, and I had a good time. And then later I sat and thought about stuff, and I was like, what the fuck?

What about this? Why this? And so then the geek mode kicked in. But my initial run, I had a good time. When we were walking through the theater to find our auditorium, There was, headed towards us, there was what I'm assuming, it was a little kid and what I'm assuming was his dad or uncle or he was kidnapped, whatever.

Guardian. Yeah. Legal guardian, perhaps. The little kid is like super excited and he's. Like, oh my god, that means that Ray and Kylo Ren are cousins.

And the dad was like, well, not necessarily, but for like that minute, I was like, what the fuck? What the fuck? And. Then after I watched the movie, I thought, you know, I'm going to do that. I'm just going to.

Stand outside and just spout off about how they're cousins, how. He is really a dude. Just make up wrong information to, like, spoiler it, but not real. Right. Make people feel like it's been spoiled for them.

And then mostly when they're walking out, they'll just be angry and be like, that dude lied. Like, son of a bitch. All right. Now, unless I misinterpret, like, family trees, they're not in any way cousins. Not that I can tell.

Unless there's some sort of. Just making sure that I didn't miss something. It's like the only way they're cousins is that they are descended from different families. Like Romeo and Juliet. Just making sure that my understanding of the family trees of Star Wars universe, that they aren't really cousins.

Sorry to confuse you. That's okay. Well, I mean, sometimes I miss big. Points, just making sure that, you know. Sure, I get it.

And it's the Star Wars universe, so everybody's kind of related, and that doesn't mean you don't kiss. Although, I have to admit, and again, I don't go too much into the now legends it was, the extent of it, but did anyone ever bother to mention that Palpatine had a family? That's one of the things that came up as time went on. I was like... If you're having a family, if you're a dad of any sort, why are you wasting your time with this little Anakin dude?

Why are you spending 20 years planning to take over his life when you got a son right there that you could corrupt? Obviously, everyone knows that that isn't his last name like She or something like that. I think his first name is Sheev Sheev Palpatine so everyone knows that Sheev Palpatine became the emperor so what do you think his kids were like Hey, Dad? What's up with that? Dad, do we have to move to that big fancy place where the emperor lives?

You know, do you think at Christmas things got really weird or were they not invited? I bet he's like a deadbeat dad wasn't there. That thought occurred to me too. We don't know that he didn't have a love child with one of his interns. Yeah, and was like, fuck you.

So is that family known to him? Did that family know he was their grandfather or whatever. Well, they kind of. Implied that, yeah, they know that this is the granddaughter, so that's why we're hiding her, but just barely. And also, they're disgraced or something.

To muddy the waters even more so, and back to that other point, there was a story that I can't even remember where it came from, and I'm assuming is legends now, but there was a weird story that was like, she... essentially created anakin and initially in that first you know phantom menace era we were like did he like hook up with mom and then i think as the weird legend stories go it's like it's not it's like he got together with the the sith dark side of the force to make the most concentrated evil kid that he could and it like jesus style like manifested itself into his mom which is why she had no idea how he got there and like but it was like sheaves doing and doctoring of the force that created this.

Child that was the whole dark ages yeah yeah you can create life la la la. So i'm like that does kind of make him his dad right in an unofficial blood way he created him Aren't they then cousins again? I guess so. Damn it. That kid was right.

And then my wife pointed out, she's like, which one of Ray's parents was it? Was it the mom or the dad? I think it was the dad. Which one? But they never really.

I thought they said the dad. I thought they said he had a son or something like that. Yeah. But either way. There will very shortly be a novel about all of us.

There's probably four of them already being written right now. And when did he have said son? Was it. Pre-emperor? Or was he all mummy?

I mean, it's got to be about the same time frame as Anakin because then grandkids grew up around the same age. That's the only thing that I even want to try to imagine. Anything after that is like. what she's hot you know it don't pretend I. Don't imagine Palpatine like going to some dive bar you know in his. Club just cruising yeah especially after he like takes over you know I'm the.

Emperor I'm the best pick up line ever exactly you know. I have my own palace I've got a lap dog I make him do whatever I want I burn the hell out of him and then I just put him in a. Suit now did that bother anyone that big reveal. Which the Palpatine part? That didn't bother me.

Other than when I started thinking about it later. Well, how does that work? That kind of bothered me. But I was like, no, I can handle this. That's...

If they're going to make... Because when I. Heard that they're bringing the Emperor back, that's when I was like, I don't know. But then when they gave it a connection like that, I. Was like, okay.

Bringing the Emperor back bothered me a lot more than Rey being a Palpatine. I think that's where we have to get into another layer of this too. It's like, what's going on on screen, what's the story part of it, in quotes, versus what's going on behind the scenes that's pulling these strings that now make these things happen. Because I was thinking that earlier. I was like, Star Wars... post internet is probably the most doctored with series ever because from, from attack of the clones on everything becomes so heavily influenced by fan base, by internet chatter, by people bitching that they, for some reason they should just be like, screw you.

This is my art. I'm doing what I want. Especially when Lucas was doing it, he should have been. Cause that's why Phantom Menace is so isolated and like insulated and, it's its own weird little movie because nobody complained about it yet. Like it was, he'd worked for 20 years to come up with this concept.

He made it out of pocket and threw it out to the world. And then people just lost their mind. And from that point on, every Star Wars has been like, oh, well, okay, they don't like, okay, we have to do this. And like rewrites and recastings and firing directors keeps happening every time just because people like, Complain about stuff. And then they're still not happy.

And they're still not happy. And they never will be because they're geeks. But I think you can see that, especially in this movie, like massively in this movie. Like you see the backpedaling and you see so many changes being made that I'm like, there's no way in hell when you wrote Force Awakens, any of this stuff was going to happen. Because well they've even admitted they had no when they wrote uh force awakens they had no idea what was going to happen and i and.

That was like the game that that jj was playing at that time is like i'm gonna set this up i'm mr mystery box i'm gonna set this up and i'm gonna leave all these loose threads i'm gonna hand it off to two other directors and then one and then not one and it changed hands so many times after that but It's like he specifically, that was kind of the game, was just like, and then you do what you want with it. And then people lost their minds. And he's like, oh, shit, I guess I have to reel it back in and do the basic thing that I did the first time, which was kind of reboot the idea and take things we already are familiar with and we kind of like already and not stray too far from that. And that's what I feel like is happening here.

It's like, had it just been written all at once, years ago before any of this happened and they followed through with that plan, I think we'd have a totally different movie. Oh yeah. This is like, you can feel like this is why the emperor gets thrown back in. This is why, because I feel like last movie, Ray's parents were nobody. And like, that really is the way Rian Johnson wanted it to be.

He was just like, he put that scene in. And at the time I even said, he could just be messing with her or he doesn't know what's going on, which was the actual story. But I'm like, I assumed he was just like making her feel even more useless and then he could sway her over to the dark side which could have worked but instead now i see the real world coming in going oh people hated that idea i better make her somebody's daughter because that's what we do in star wars everybody's got to be related to somebody and they go with what is the easiest option which is oh she's related to somebody uh ben kenobi uh palpatine fuck i don't know i'll just throw somebody in there That's. Exactly the way that I read it.

It was like, I actually, like, I know a lot of people didn't like Episode 7, but I really did. And it kind of, like, reintroduced and recaptured some of that Star Wars magic. It did. And, like, it asked a lot of new questions. It was opening all these new doors.

And it was making you, you know, it was making you think, like, who's this Rey person? Where did they come from? And it was like, oh, all these questions. And then Episode 8 was like, no. I'm going to close all those doors.

Yeah. You're going to get what you get, and it's going to be what you know. And then I felt like this one was trying to be like, no, open those. Try to open those doors back up a little bit. No, no, it's too late.

Oh, crap. But it didn't even do that, really, because he really did just kind of come back and reset everything like he left. Like, everything that got thrown out there is like, this is probably going to be a thing we're going to follow through with. JJ comes back. He's like, nope.

Like, parents, still somebody's kid. Rose, pfft. who's Rose? Like he just, everything else that got thrown out there. Rose is a good example of what you're talking about with the fan reaction, which I was kind of upset about because I have no problem with that character. I think the actress who plays her is, is amazing at it.

I think it's a good sort of, but not really comic relief. And we had like five minutes of screen time, screen time with her where she really wouldn't have mattered if she was there or not. Yeah. And that's what I think is you can see so much of the real world coming into play. That's one of many examples of that.

Well, that's where I get mad at Star Wars fans all the. Time because of what they bitch about. And now we've got a character that they've completely ruined because they harassed her so bad that she thought about giving up on acting entirely. Yeah. And then to the point where they just pretty much wrote her out of what could have been a really interesting character.

They wrote her out of the series. Yeah, that was my issue last time. I think she, as an actress, is fine. I think they really gave her nothing to do. Even though she's got tons of screens time, I think all of that sidetracking stuff with her and Finn is kind of useless.

And then by the end, I'm just like, wait, why did we spend all this time with these characters when we didn't really get anywhere? Well, and they basically. like what was the guy from lord of the rings who suddenly shows up i was. Thinking that i was like crossover. He had more lines and more screen time oh yeah rose did yet rose was sort of being set up as finn's love interest but then they introduce another character who is also an ex-stormtrooper as his love interest sort of and i'm like so you just throw this one out throw two new people in i kind. Of saw like at the i guess kind of close to the beginning of the film when she's on the screen for the first time and finn kind of just like gives her like a little like shoulder thing and i'm like oh.

They broke up it's like yeah there's like that awkwardness because he also like it wasn't it wasn't a personal connection at all it was just like a very yay hopeful rebel kind of shoulder yeah it was kind of a go team sort of a very pc thing that i'm just like that's not a relationship either not that they were really there that is another one of those points i wanted to hit along the way of one of the more frustrating things just because because i don't think everything needs to be about relationships and i don't think every male and female character has to turn into some weird relationship angle but because they focus so much on this Finn relationship arc that like from the very first movie, I stand and everyone wants to argue what his motivation is.

But I mean, like to me, that first movie, he is so puppy dog in love with, with Ray. He just, that comes through to me. And like, so that's part of that arc. And Ray kind of seems like you're cool. We're friends anyway.

Like she doesn't really go down that road, but she likes him as a person. It's all good. So you think, okay, we're coming in with two, they're going to try to counterbalance that with giving him someone new to be interested in. But they really don't develop that relationship at all. She just randomly blurts stuff out at the end of the movie, and you're like, why weren't we building this relationship the whole rest of this movie instead of just running around with wild horses and shit?

But instead, she just sort of blurts it out, and I'm like, okay, so now it's going to be this, what is Finn going to do, because he really likes her, but now he's got this girl that's actually interested in him, so it becomes sort of a, Dilemma for him to deal with. No, no. We come to the new movie. Not only have we kind of blown off Rose, we've rekindled this I've got something to tell you thing that we string along for the whole damn movie. And then by the end, we also introduce a new potential love interest maybe that also goes nowhere.

I'm like, why do we keep setting up all these crazy relationship angles for Finn if we're going nowhere with every single one of them? Finn deserves love too. I mean, again, the fan base out there still wants to put him together with Poe, from what I hear. Oh, yeah. I was waiting for that.

Go searching for that fan fiction. But even then, I'm sure that's going to come up in this. Actually, it did, now that I think about it. At the celebration, did we not see two women... Full on kiss?

Yes. And I was like, alright, see, they're already planting that seed. It's cool in the Star Wars universe. We're okay with it. I feel like that was testing the water.

It better be. Have you seen the internet? Like, Jesus. All they do is lose their mind over stupid things. People are still freaked out that Tom's a black stormtrooper.

Yeah, yeah. I mean, that was disturbing to me, is how much backlash that got when that first trailer came out. When that came out, people were saying that that proved that Star Wars was anti-white, which makes... zero sense to me no matter how you do the math on it. Which just kind of proves that no great art is going to be made if you listen to fans. If you're compromising all the time.

Why I don't understand why they keep doing that. I'm just like, just make your thing. Just make it and if people hate it, tough. It's freaking Star Wars. People are still going to go see it.

It is. And again, eventually you're going to get better product out of it and I feel like the fans that appreciate that are going to be the ones that come back. And if the other people don't like it, then they'll fall off and go find something else. Your job is to make this movie that's going to make them feel differently and see things differently, not the other way around. Which is what it's become, again, since Phantom Menace, essentially.

Every movie since then has been, and not just a few times. I mean, even look at just the most recent. Solo, we had to switch directors midway in because of their weird behind-the-scenes stuff of like, everything has just been such a mess on the production end of it that i'm surprised we've gotten the decent movies that we have out of it over the years because it's just a fight every step of the way of switching out directors and rewriting they almost switched the lead actor too yeah because people just wanted to complain and i'm like he's he's fine like nobody's gonna be harrison ford deal with it we're gonna have more stories about this character he's a huge character they're gonna keep writing books they're gonna keep making stories so just make peace with It's going to be another actor eventually.

I know this is like a blasphemous to say because it's Star Wars, but it's a movie. It's entertainment. Last night, I got into a weird, again, not even recording, I got into a good hour-long argument over Star Wars. I know everyone's shocked, but that was one of my things. I was like, I am a geek, and I will, again, as I said earlier, I've devoted so much of my life to Star Wars, but I'm still not that far gone that i can't go but at the end of the day it's a movie and there's way more important things in the world that you need to be focused on than nitpicking and whining and complaining about whatever the hell went on in this new movie that by the way you didn't make you didn't have anything to do with it's just entertainment for you you're supposed to like it or not but the fact that people get so up in arms over it.

It's out of control which one in uh gladiator um the What's his name? Commodus was the. Commodus. No, Commodus was Russell Crowe. Oh, he was Marcus Aurelius.

Commodus was the Caesar. Yes. Like, that's what they're like right now. Joaquin is what you're saying. Just like, yes, Joaquin.

The Joaquin of this movie. They're sitting back like, I am not entertained. You know, I haven't... I think the... I think Disney's in an unenviable position in that they basically bought the biggest franchise in the world, but yet they don't know how to handle the fandom of the biggest franchise in the world.

But that was pre-existing because you watched Lucas go through the same stuff and change his movies two and three to match what fans on the internet were complaining about. Well, I guess he didn't like, hey, Disney, here's what you're getting yourself into. Yeah, they should have known, really. Which is surprising that, again, Marvel has arguably created the biggest fandom in the world, and they seem to handle it pretty well. That's what I was going to say.

And I think part of it is they're like, this is where we're going. Take it or leave it. We don't care. That's what I think is what's missing, is you had a Kevin Feige that was there in maybe not the first couple movies, but pretty early on, before we even got to that first Avengers, they were like, here's what we're doing 10 years out. This is the plan.

We're sticking to it. We'll make some minor changes along the way. We lost a director along the way. But for the most part, like, they stuck to their guns and it's like, this is the arc. This is what we're telling.

If we need to lose characters, if we need to, like, you know, they found a lot of weird stuff along the way that should have rubbed people the wrong way. But they stuck to the game plan and, like, it kind of works. Well, but even with the fandom, they're like. Oh, you don't like the movie where we have a main black character? You know, we don't care.

There's going to be like two white people in the movie and they're going to be bad. You know, you don't like, you're upset they were giving Black Widow a movie? We don't care. You don't like Catherine Bravo? We don't care.

Yeah. It's like, we're going. We're going to put millions of dollars behind it because we want to. And that's, yeah, that shows you what a great production game plan is. makes such a difference. It's like they needed that.

That's why I don't understand why, because I was thinking that as I was sitting there yesterday. I'm like, why didn't JJ just sign on? Like, I know he kind of took a lot of heat coming into it anyway, but he proved himself for at least a certain amount of the fans. And then I'm like, okay, just finish it out. Because, again, that's what worked.

That's what worked about Seven was he rekindled all those old feelings and he stuck to... enough stuff but still opened up these new avenues that we could go follow new characters add new plot points but for the most part he didn't stray too far from what we knew Star Wars to be in the original three movies and then it just yeah trying to hand it off once or twice depending on which version just seems like a bad idea. Yeah. I think you should go back and just make another eight and nine just to, because there were so many, like, like he like had this like silver platter with seven where he was just like, all right, here is a ball to dunk. Like I've left all. Of these avenues.

You can do whatever you want. And then it was like, oh, and then we get this. But the thing is, I don't, I don't even mind where it went necessarily, but I just feel like. There was so many opportunities. Yeah.

Yeah. That's what I said about that last one is like it, It had potential that it didn't follow through on. Along the way, it did some great stuff. Because I do think he's a really talented filmmaker. I also think it's funny that his movie is playing next to this one.

Because Knives Out is awesome. I was really impressed by that. I still need to see that. It is really good. And that's what I think is interesting.

It's really well written. It's really well put together with all these characters. And that's what I feel like is suffering. I don't have problems with a lot of the stuff that people do out of the last movie. it was the basic character interactions and development and like weird side arcs. And like, that's what doesn't make any sense in that last one.

I think, I think the worst about, and I, so I came out of the last Jedi really liking it because of certain, because of some of the things it did, like you're nobody yet here you are one of the most powerful. I like the idea. I was fine with that. The Force is open to everybody and have at it. That's how it originally started.

That's the way I liked it. So I'm good to be back on board with it. But as I've consumed The Last Jedi four or five times, I'm like, the fault is in the plot and the pacing of this movie. It really is. Not so much the ideas.

Well, I said even when I saw the first one, I was like, if they'd taken... Two, maybe three more shots at the script overall, we would have had a much tighter, much more cohesive, much more enjoyable movie. The first of the new trilogy or the last one? No, no, on Last Jedi. Last Jedi, okay.

Yeah, I kind of agree. I feel like there's so many points where, as we always do on this show, I'm like, If you like, I come up with my idea that I'm like, I think this would have worked a lot better. And I'm like, I know you don't give a shit, but I'm like, if I can find what I think works better as a plot and you're the screenwriter, like there's a problem there. Like, I don't know. I think a big problem too is, and we've talked about this before.

There's for a while, there's too much star Wars. There's too many. And they've gone from with these in the, I guess what would be the main part of star Wars to, I don't think, because I think they only had like a year to work on each one, whereas with Jedi and Empire, they had like two or three years between them. And they had committees on those. With these new ones, I think they're getting like a year and they don't have as many people contributing.

It's just the internet. Because even with the original movies, you had a ton of people saying, George, I don't think that's such a good idea. And that's why they're better than the prequels. Right. Because he still had people telling him no.

By that prequel time, not only did he have nothing but yes-men around him, but he was funding out of pocket. Those three movies are basic, especially that first one. He paid for it. Really hard to tell the guy who's paying for it, no. At that point, you're like, sure, George, that's a great idea.

And you get a whole bunch of nonsense. I still remember there's a scene, one of the behind-the-scenes things, where it's them in a personal movie theater, and we're watching the final cut of Phantom Menace, and the lights come up, And George is in the middle, and everyone's around him, and I swear, and maybe I'm just pushing my emotions on them. Everyone's like, oh, my God, this is a pile of crap. And everyone kind of looks to George, and George goes, I loved it. And you see everyone just go, oh, thank God.

All right, then. Let's start the promotion. It's like everyone there is like. oh my god this is horrible but as long as george likes it we're i'm safe yeah and again maybe i'm projecting onto that but it looked to me like those guys were in terror if you're in that position. It's like you know you're thinking about your paycheck yeah i mean. I don't blame them really you can't i mean professionally i don't blame them but artistically i'm like somebody need to go no no no no george what are you doing like I think that with a lot of really well-respected directors, I'm like, you still kind of need a producer or a writer or somebody there to counterbalance you and go, no, no, no, no, wait a minute.

This isn't working. Like, you need somebody to check you when you're getting a little out of control. And, like, sometimes they do that. I feel that, like, Disney needs to mature a little and understand that the most vocal people of your fan base actually constitute about 5% of your fan base. Yeah.

And if you lose those, you still got 95% of the people. See, I don't even know if I blame Disney only because I don't feel like anything else that goes on in their company is like that. There may just be a weird subdivision of Star Wars things that people are just like, I don't know, because every other aspect of their company is like titanium. Like, Everything runs perfectly bulletproof. It's just like the theme park works fine.

Nobody messes with the theme park. We know how to run it. We do it like every aspect of like their freaking store in the mall. They know how to run it like everything works. the Disney way, and nobody questions it because they're right. Because they've made tons of money, they've become super successful, like, they know what they're doing.

Star Wars was just such a weird thing that they picked up along the way that I think it just, because they haven't integrated it. Yeah, it's like, they don't know how to work it into the Disney way officially yet, but yet Star Wars is running on its own craziness that Lucas left behind, because again, even his were out of control, so. Well, isn't Kevin Feige moving over from Marvel to Star Wars? He needs to. I think that he may not be the head of.

I think when they finished out the Avengers, that 10-year run, I think that was like, he's just like, I want to be done. I want to go out in style. I don't want to hang around and do another couple of years. I want to finish my arc and walk away. So, if he wants to move to Star Wars.

I think that maybe what's happening behind the scenes... I could be wrong. I just heard it one time and it didn't fall through. But I think that he is now the overlord of Star Wars. Which, again, isn't the worst idea I've ever heard.

No, I mean, again, you need someone who kind of has a 10-year vision of your things. Because I think that, you know, Disney got the property and were like, movie, movie, movie. And just threw movies at everyone and ideas. And then you get... I liked Rogue One.

It's not perfect, but I liked it. I liked all of them. I think all of them have been enjoyable. I think there's flaws in different ones for different reasons, but I think they're all pretty well made. Some of them I enjoy like a Marvel movie.

I enjoy it because it entertains me, because it's flashy, and it's like fast food. Which is good. And not necessarily the Star Wars aspects of it. But it does still... But not Rogue One.

I really liked Rogue One. Again, I have issues with that one too. I mean, I have issues with it. Yeah, yeah. Well, what I found interesting about Rogue One was there is a mountain of stuff that they shot that you saw in trailers and stuff that wasn't in the final movie because they basically went in with a skeleton of a plot and basically said, let's just film whatever we think is interesting at the time.

And then they cut it down and made a movie for it. Now, that also gave us one of the most awesome scenes from Rogue One, which is that that vader scene was unplanned until someone says what if we did this and they went let's go we. Kind of need because vader has become more sad the more they elaborate on his story i'm like can we just see him be a badass for one minute in the universe but. But that's that same style of filming failed in so many spots but then gave you this gem of a scene at the same time but you know you've got to You really can't rely that you're going to luck your way into awesomeness. You kind of have to have a plan.

Especially for something like Star Wars. I mean, there's so many other movies. Like, you can't even plan to have a sequel. Because, again, studio involvement will be like, you made how much? Not enough.

Sorry. You don't even get another movie out of it. Star Wars is such a huge franchise. Like, you know something else is coming. So... somebody needed to be sitting down to be like, okay, where are we going with all of these?

I feel like somebody needs to be in control of the whole thing because now that it's, as we referenced earlier, they have a TV series. So somebody needs to be like, okay, how does this fit into the world? How does this fit into our business plan? How does this fit into the story of it all? Like you've got to have somebody pulling the strings on everything from video games to the now new canon novels.

And like all of this has to be like, held together and like it still feels like they're kind of need a project manager yeah they still like are scrambling to piece things together because they were firing everything out so quickly that like they need to just they've had an extra like almost a year plus now to kind of like slow down a little bit like they need to get a game plan together moving forward so we don't have to throw everything out there which is part of what i think is going on I don't know. That's what I took away. Again, my thinking after the fact. Again, initially I feel like there's so much fun going on there. As just a general fun movie.

Even for Star Wars fans. It's one of the few times we get hey, the gang's back together again. Like we finally, because that's your issue with even original Star Wars. It's like immediately from the first movie we split everybody up by empire. We don't get that and we get a little of it towards the tail end of Jedi.

But it's like That first movie is just so much fun because it's them running around the Death Star making smart-ass comments to each other. Like, it's the gang hanging out together. Yeah. And the comedy relief in this movie worked again. Yeah.

It didn't work as well in 8. Yeah, it was a little off the last round. But yeah, this one I feel like... Seemed a lot more natural. Well, I feel like it was almost, again, that's what I almost feel like the real world coming in and going, this is what people want.

So that scene of like, no, we're all coming on this trip. It's like, we're telling you, audience, we know this is what you want. We're all coming on this trip, damn it. So... again i feel like lando lando kind of hit the nail on the head where he was like well we made it work because we were all we had and i feel like that was a commentary on the last two movies you didn't have. That yeah we didn't have that grouping we didn't know what we were doing either like we didn't know we were gonna succeed and we kind of made it work and so yeah that's kind of where they are again but i feel like there are so many there's so much going on and even just this latest movie that does feel kind of crammed in there i did feel like it was after setting the 35 minutes of trailers it really was i did feel that There was too much in this movie.

And probably my biggest complaint of this movie was the finale. Felt like it went on too long. And there's too many, we're winning. Now they're winning. Now we're winning.

Now they're winning. And then, and we're winning. It just felt like, okay, cut one of those out. Pick one. Who's winning?

Because, and I'm going to jump to the very end here. When the fleet shows up, That should have been the end. I mean, that was amazing. That is one of those moments I was. Like, holy shit.

I was like, this is amazing. But then it went, and now there's a lightning storm and everyone's getting blah, blah, blah. Yeah, that was not really necessary. I was like, that was, again, it was like the Lord of the Rings ending of, and we're here and we're here. And I just, at that point, How long was the movie?

Like three hours? It was pretty long, yeah. At two and a half hours, I'm like, I kind of don't want to be push and pulled one way. I want the ta-da. And that was a great ta-da.

It was. And scene. Yeah. Especially when the first 30 or so minutes of the movie... was like the pacing was so fast where it was like the setup of a scene would be like two seconds it would be like oh here we oh action action action action action like there was no breathing in any any of like the first 30 minutes and then to see the last 30 minutes be so drawn out i was like wait there's a compromise. Here i like that about the beginning.

Though because i was like oh we're getting right into the. Action and it's and it is getting back to what we yeah And it's getting back to what we love because action slows down a little bit more action. And like a lot of the, the classic moments of star Wars isn't because of the bigger picture, but it's almost like you get these individual vignettes going through like the, where the millennium Falcon goes. In the giant worm on the whole, you know, on the asteroid, that sort of stuff. So I was like, okay, cool.

We're getting back into that. But then, yeah, like you say, the ending, it's like, oh, this should. Have been over 20 minutes ago. And, I should be in the car right now. There was like a specific scene that bothered me like a lot.

And it was like Ray was reading that book with all the ancient coordinates and whatever in it. And she was like looking at it for like one second. You just see her looking at the book for like one second. And then there's all this hullabaloo and she goes down there. She's like, I think I know where it is because of something that I read 10 seconds ago.

It's like, whoa. In a language I don't even understand. It's like there is no setup for this. Ray is really good. Yeah, that's I see.

I didn't even feel that it was like going on too long at the end. I went the other way of like, I feel like we're trying to hurry up and end story arcs and threads from 20 different things. And we got 15 minutes to do it. So hurry up, get this, get this, get this. And I'm like, this needed to be, hell, its own movie or a whole nother scene.

Like the thing that really felt like almost forced to me is we get the little interaction at the earlier half of the movie there with Poe and the person from his past. And so that's kind of like a weird little like Lando moment of like, here's somebody that knows your backstory. We come in, there's already a little bit of bad blood, but you kind of make up and you're like, all right, we'll be friends and we'll help each other. So it's like, then we have to counterbalance that with that at the end. But there's this whole, again, it's like giving Poe a potential love interest, but we don't really have time to work on it.

So we're just going to throw it out. And then he'll be like, yeah. And she'll go, nope. And I'll be like, all right. Plot averted.

I had assumed that she died when they blew up the planet. I was like, oh, yeah. But I mean, that's another thing is like what Brian says again and again and again is that there's no freaking stakes and nobody ever dies. Chewie didn't die. C-3PO got his memory back.

Like, Chewie didn't die. First of all, I was really happy that Chewie did not die. Because when the ship exploded... You were alone in that. Everyone wanted Chewie to die.

At first, when the ship exploded, I was like, oh, cool, she made the ship explode. Then my wife was like, Chewie was on there. And then that's when, like, I'm gonna cry. Shut up, he was not. And then five minutes later, they were like, oh, he's safe.

Fake out. Well, and see, I don't necessarily feel that, like, One of the biggest issues I had with Joss Whedon in, like, the second Avengers movie was the... Someone's got... For there to be stakes, someone has to die. And I don't necessarily believe that.

You know, so... But he likes doing that in Jim. No, but. He really likes... Well, but that's his M.O., but I don't think that that...

To have stakes does not mean death. Yeah. But somebody... It's a war. Like, some...

That's why I liked Rogue One. I was like. Everybody dies. Finally, people die. I love all these characters.

I can't wait to see what they're up to now. At the same point, you know... I'm also not going to a movie to see the people I like die because it's a movie. And if I want to have that, I'll just stay home and listen to the news. I get that.

But I think the part that's annoyed me more, and this was, I've complained many times in the Marvel run, was like, if you're going to kill him, kill him. If you're not, just let everybody go on and kick ass and be happy. But it's the fake out that got annoyed. Yeah. After we pretend to kill Coulson, but then we give him his own fucking TV series.

Mm-hmm. Then we pretend to kill fury but then oh not within the same movie fake out haha he's not like they did that three or four times in a row in a couple of movies and i'm just like you can't keep playing that card you can do it once in the whole series maybe and then like they they just reveal. That you let breathe that you let people think that they're dead for more than three seconds like just that it's like so quick to be like oh she's not dead it's like come on, let me like grieve it for like 20 minutes and really think that there's some tragedy here. And then it's like, oh my God, the elation that Chewie's not dead. If there's a reason to even play that card.

Because again, in this new series, it's not like we're not killing characters we love. They're all gone. Each movie we've offed one of them. I have no problem with Luke being dead or Leia or Han. And I was kind of, much as i love the character i was kind of like oh let's see how lando gets killed which of course doesn't happen billy d will never die but then when they made me think chewy was dead i was like i want my money back for not just this movie but all of them.

I mean even at that moment i was like that's a weird move like don't i mean don't get me wrong i mean like they're they're burning bridges like they're finishing stuff off here but that's a weird move. If they killed chewy like legitimately killed him in the third act I would have been okay with that. I've heard that as, as fans were coming up with theories that like in this movie, we were going to end up killing Chewie. We were going to like, end up like just dive bombing the Millennium Falcon and it's going to be gone out of the series, which we did several times wreck it, but they still, I'm sure it'll be back. No problem.

So yeah, I mean, I've heard many ways of them going out and they didn't do a lot of those, but like, I think if you gave him a big, I think that's what rubbed me the wrong way. It was a random explosion. I'm like, well, At least give him a big triumphant ending. Yeah, a big hero moment. And he saved everyone, and that's how we lost Chewie.

But, like, you know, that was just so. Like handcuffed in the back of a cruiser. Yeah, I was like, that's the worst, most sad way to go out. Someone explain to me how they captured Chewie alive. Yeah, kind of.

That doesn't make any sense. Because he ripped people's arms out of their suckers. They showed him in handcuffs and I'm like, wait, that's not the Chewbacca we know. Chewbacca we know would have gone down swinging. He's mellowed in his old age.

He's not nearly. Yeah, but still. Well, I guess, you know, besides that, the thing that I found really weird, so he's captured, he's on the flagship, And a random ship just comes in with a code. No one visually wonders what the hell is that ship. Well, the Empire has fallen for that several times.

It's an old code, but it sucks up. In a movie that's three hours long, that little interlude could have been removed and then Chewie doesn't get supposedly killed in the transports. But again i also feel like that's the trying to fix the problems part because i feel like that is the thing that seems the most like trying to raid the death star and get leia like it's that same little maneuver and i'm like yeah i mean it kind of works it's a fun little part but it's probably not necessary but it feels very reminiscent of the original movie And I think he was trying so hard to bring that back because we lost so much when people got pissed off last time. He's like, no, no, let's do stuff people liked from the old movie.

So I feel like it's, let's throw scenes like that in there. And that's totally what that felt like to me. It was just the detention block all over again. But I feel like that led to a pretty interesting scene where she's talking to Kylo Ren and he pulls the mask through, however he does that little trick, which was neat. I've liked that anyway.

That's the thing that I think is the most solid out of Last Jedi. That whole interaction between... I think that's the one arc that works all the way through this little... new trilogy is the dynamic between them. They're hostile and they don't like each other except there's something there and there's some underlying thing. And as they spend more time talking to each other through time and space, they do build this relationship that you start to buy...

And you start to see both of them might turn. It's like they might change their mind. Because there are moments, even in that second one, where I'm like, Ray might just join him. And I don't know that that's the worst move, because neither the Jedi or the Sith know what the hell they're doing. All the way up to the last 20 minutes, I was like, she could turn.

And I know that the way movies work, and people want the good guy to win, it's like, I know they're going to turn Kylo Ren, but she could still possibly, at any second, go. you know why not yeah and i wasn't sure i wanted him to turn i was okay with the way it came out he really did sort of as much as you can redeem this person but it was rather quick yeah. Well but honestly that's probably my biggest critique of star wars and the whole jedi sit thing is five minutes of experiencing a bad emotion turns you evil five minutes of experiencing a good Emotion turns you good. It's just whoop. It makes sense when Vader comes back to the light side because it's he's watching his son get tortured tortured and even though he hasn't known his son his entire life there's still that.

You've also felt that again they keep talking about that conflict in him that whole like from the end of Empire all the way through Jedi it's like you kind of see him starting to question and especially like as we get into the prequel end of it I'm like he had a horrible run like The way that he was mentally abused by Palpatine. Well, like you mentioned earlier, Vader's existence, the more you think about it, is just sad. It is really sad. It's depressing. I can't imagine having to live a life like that.

Kylo Ren wasn't that deep of a character, though. Yeah. But I also feel like he played it because he sells it so much as, especially that first one, he's still coming off like, Granted, he's in his 20s easily, but he's an angsty teenager. He's just pissed and yet really powerful. And if you give somebody that much power and they already kind of have a short fuse, I think he balanced those out pretty well that I kind of bought him as that character.

Oh, yeah. Yeah, the one thing I would say that I'm kind of shocked made it through all three films was his arc felt the best of me and felt the most consistent even though he went Director A, Director B, back to Director A. I was like, this is actually, this is good. I like that. I think that's the actor.

I think he really did zero in on what he wanted to do with this character and he followed through with all three movies. I had written down some notes about after he does turn back to Ben. Oh, I did write something. It's like, Kylo Ren only comes back to Ben after something happens to him. Like, he can see everybody else going through hell and he's like, yeah, whatever.

But I was like, oh, somebody showed a little bit of kindness to me. Oh, have to like no empathy have an ass but then I was like after he turns back to Ben the way that Adam Driver is able to portray that he is no longer Kylo Ren with only saying one word which is ouch like but even the way he was like running was like a little bit more human. Yeah just the look on his face and the scar when Rey healed him the scar on his face healed too which I thought was a neat little touch yeah. I also, in that turn, I think, because I remember posing this question as we elaborated on the potential stories down the line on the earlier movies. It's like, okay, even then we were questioning, is he going to turn back?

Is that going to be the way they wrap it up? And I remember at the time going... Can he? Specifically for the fan base, you lightsabered through the middle of Han Solo. Can anyone let you come back?

And I think that's the only way, again, as a story arc, as a screenwriting thing, is the audience is never going to forgive him unless Han Solo himself shows up and says, you know what, son? It's okay. I know you made a mistake. That little discussion with whatever Han Solo was is the only, again, in the real world, I think is the only way we as the audience could be like, all right, he can turn back to Ben. We'll let it happen.

You talk about tearing up. I think that was the part where I'm like, that's actually really sad. That got me. And Adam Driver's sad boy face. Just real tearjerker.

But I am glad that they killed him off. Only because from a storytelling... Yeah, how do you... What do you do with that character? What do you do with that guy?

Because. He's gonna heal each other back to life, like, endlessly. But it's like, is he gonna go show up with the resistance and they're all gonna be like, oh, it's that guy that. Killed all of our friends. He goes to trial for war crimes.

What happens if he stays alive? That would actually make a... well it'd be a boring movie it'd be like well it would be interesting if we do go down the line if we've got like a Kylo Ren rotting away in space prison somewhere storyline that comes up later that like everybody's like yeah well he kind of deserves it you know so it's like that that could lead to an interesting end I don't know how you do more with the plot after that but it could be an interesting little like way to wrap things up that he actually did pay for all his crimes in some capacity But that is another one of those that was kind of weird, too, is even at the beginning of this movie. Like, we're watching him just massacre those people.

First of all, I don't know who they are. I'm kind of okay that they just cold open with this, like, battle of him just taking out whatever these weird alien creatures are. But I'm like, who the hell were they? And is it okay that you just killed all... Since you're going to be a good guy by the end of this movie, is it okay that we just watched you murder all these people?

Well, and again, I think that's my biggest problem with, again, the five-minute morality of Star Wars is that. And don't get me wrong, I know it can happen in real life, but just typically most people don't jump into evil. They kind of inch their way into evil, and people don't just... I think the opposite is more true. Sometimes you jump into being good when you finally are faced with the horror of their things.

But I think still, you don't just jump and then forget how to be evil or good. You jump and then you're like, oh, I've got to do baby steps to get better. Or worse, you know? But it's Star Wars and it's magic and it's whatever, you know. Dreadlord Sinister, here is your coffee, sir.

What? I didn't order any coffee. Ah, yes, you did, sir. Three days ago. Three days?

Good lord, man, what took you so long? Well, sir, you only wanted coffee from the Southwest Quadrant. Ah, yes. Julio does make it just the way I like it. The Dread Cruiser is 1,200 miles across.

It's the size of a planet. Julio's is literally on the other end of the ship. It's... It's night there. Oh, you know what would go great with this?

Some of those little crumbly pastries Julio makes. That makes me think of a particular coffee shop in town because we're. Not advertising, right? Oh, it depends. Is it Heine Brothers?

It's Heine Brothers. Because... Of the few good things that have happened in life ever, we're now sponsored by Heine Brothers Coffee. Oh, my God. Thank God, because I am sponsored by Heine Brothers Coffee in general.

Well, we all should be because Heine Brothers is awesome. It actually really is. I'm drinking Heine Brothers Coffee right now. I am right now. We're drinking Heine Brothers Coffee.

That's all we drink in this house. This is another caffeinated movie geek. This is a Heine Brothers House Coffee. Once again, you should go right now. Go get yourself a bag.

You can have it shipped directly to your house. And that meltdown code is going to get you a little discount. Just saying. You got a code? What?

We got a code. I want to tell you about the Heine Brothers coffee subscription. Wherever you are, home, work, or out on the road, you deserve great coffee. And the Heine Brothers subscription plan gives you top quality, organic, fair trade coffee delivered right to your home or office automatically. You select the frequency, the quantity, and the variety of coffee, and Heine Brothers will take care of the rest, shipping included.

So just order online at hineybrotherscoffee.com slash subscription and use the offer code MELTDOWN for $ 5 off any gift subscription. And if you're not familiar with Hiney Brothers Coffee or the spelling or any of that that might make it a little harder, just go to moviemeltdown.com and look on the right-hand side of the page and you'll find a link to take you right to hineybrotherscoffee.com. That's right, the Meltdown Caffeinated Movie Geeks are hooking you up, so get your subscription started today. Tell you what, go get me a coffee and a pastry from Julio. Bring them back here and we'll call it even.

There's a light side and a dark side in all of us. These two forces are always fighting in the final battle between light and dark. You can be a master of both. New LEGO Star Wars play sets. The choice is yours.

For me I'm living in Hey, Jacqueline. Hi. Guess what? What? We're broke.

Yeah, we definitely, I'm pulling up, turning my pockets out right now. Nothing. That's what I'm saying. I do that every week. And yet I'm trying to produce this show.

For you guys listening right now. Yeah. Freeloaders. I'm just saying, you know, if you want to keep this thing rolling, it'd be kind of awesome if you go to our Patreon page and like kick in like, seriously, like two bucks. I mean, you're going to do like Netflix for like $ 9.

99 and you get And you're probably not going to watch it all month like I do. Yeah, you need our commentary to figure out what to watch on Netflix. I think so. It's like a companion piece to all your Amazons and Netflixes and all of these things. So just think how much you don't make use of your other streaming services.

But every week we're loading up a whole new episode of us going in-depth, more than you may want, about whatever movie we've decided or bringing in some awesome guests. So I'm just saying... Two bucks. It's not so bad. Two dollars.

You won't even notice it. And you'll look at your bank statement and be like, two dollars. Oh yeah. Oh yeah. I'm supporting an artist that I like.

That's all I ask for. Trying to keep this thing rolling. And all we need is your assistance. So go to patreon.com slash movie meltdown. Or if you can't remember all that, go to movie meltdown.com.

The link is right there at the top of the homepage. That's all you need to do. I contribute more than two dollars a month. Because you're awesome like that. I don't remember.

Why don't you be awesome like Jacqueline? I'm just saying. I mean, really, though. I mean, you can't be that awesome, obviously. But you can get closer.

You can climb the ladder a little bit. Just saying. Patreon, go support us. All I do, all day long, fall down on my knees and pray she come back home for me. Why is our fellow born on me?

But I quip, and he doesn't use shaving foam. A wood for Christmas when he already owns a cone. Hello, this is Peter Mayhew, listening to Movie Mountain Down. What can you get? A wood for Christmas when he already owns a cone.

What can you get in a hurry for a furry kind of friend like that to take home? What's part of your problem? You know, you haven't seen enough movies. All of life's riddles are answered in the movies. Now, on with the show.

I need someone. I need someone to show me my place in all this. But I was going into Tosche, Tosche Station. It's just a fair Tosche, Tosche Station. I'm never going to get out of here.

I was going into Tosche, Tosche Station. Oh, my God. Tosche, Tosche Station. It's going to take up some power converters. but that's always been my biggest problem because and again that as a fan me casting my beliefs into it i really wanted at the end one thing that bothered. Me at the end was when.

Palpatine's like, you can't kill me. If you kill me, that's anger, and then all of the Sith in me goes in you. I'm like, you're like the most evil person in the universe. Killing you isn't killing you out of anger or hate. It's just saving the universe.

From all this stuff. So why does it have to work that way? Well, and they never explain most of what goes on in this other reality that they go to. Because, again, it's like, why is every time a Jedi dies, it's like, if you strike me down, I will become more powerful. And they go into this massive, you know, world of Jedis that protect everything.

But, like, Sif, just die. Like, does that not happen? I mean, is there not a super... Again, we saw the weird, like, robed characters there. Is that the... equivalent of like the sith but did they not really have any power because they didn't do anything but disappear so like did they not a lot yeah they threw a lot of chanting which was which was cool the chanting was kind of kind of creepy i do like that that last like 20 minutes had a lot of like hammer horror vibes it really like i was like i kind of like this weird dark horror movie we got going on in the middle of our sci-fi well.

I think i mean I look at a lot of concept art and stuff anyway. So the look of when he got to the planet at the beginning and just the look and feel of that, I'm like, this is, this is dark. And I like it, you know, probably those moments were probably the darkest out of the whole. And then just the, the, the, the, the inverted wedge thing and the little floating above. And I was like, this is, this is atmospherically really cool.

And again, as, as, I still think that bringing Palpatine back is a lazy move at best. But at the same time, number one, that hanging cadaver maneuver was creepy and weird. And I was just like, I like that they went that dark with him. And the weird screech of the lightning strikes. I'm like, I like this.

This is cool. But again, as much as I thought when I saw that last trailer, I was like, of course they're bringing Palpatine back. But the more I thought about it, I was like, But at the same time, that's the entirety of this arc. I mean, if we're making these nine movies, like, four of them are, like, the bulk of it revolves around Palpatine. So I'm like, he really, like, it's weird that all of a sudden the last three have nothing to do with him when, like, the first three are his story, essentially.

Like, Anakin's just kind of a side thing. It's all his ridiculous, long, drawn-out plan of of taking over a government. That's what those first three movies are. Well, when those prequels came out, George Lucas said that this is where we're going to see that Star Wars is actually about Darth Vader and not Luke Skywalker. And now with this one, I'm starting to think maybe the story is actually about Palpatine.

The whole arc is kind of about Palpatine. Really? It's like we take a few off. But I mean, in the bulk of it, it's like the first three are by five, they're already talking about his big plan. Six is nothing but him.

So it's like, it was okay. Like it bookended it. Okay. Like, but there was like no mention or foreshadowing or anything about him in seven and eight. And that's the only kind of thing I was like, and you know, it's like a big reveal.

It's the plot twist. Third one. Cool. But well, and then 10, 11, 12 will be the super, super secret Sith planet where, where the super secret guy who is controlling Snoke and Palpatine lives. It's, There's always this, you peel back that onion and there's another bad guy who's above everyone else.

And then once again, we get every movie, if we're going to nitpick about Star Wars, this is not a minor win that every movie has to have a Death Star at the end. Well, this time, instead of all Death Star, we have an armada of Death Stars. Instead of going bigger, we went more. And there's only one navigational system for all of them. That was ridiculous.

All the star cruisers, or whatever they were called, I was okay with that, but I remember saying to my wife as I walked into the theater, I know the Emperor's coming back, if we get another fucking Death Star. And then they're like, well, not only that, but we get the Death Star. And I was like, well, at least it's the ruins. I was okay with the wreckage of it. That was fun.

I was like, I can handle that. Yeah. Well, I have to give credit to the bad guys. So they went from a moon-sized planet killer to a. Full-size planet, eventually.

Well, they had a full-size, but then in 8, they had the, they miniaturized it to where it was a big thing, and they could bust a bunker buster, and then it's just a turret. So, at some point, there's going to be handheld Death Stars. It's like phones. You just stick your hand out the window of a spaceship. You're like, I don't like your planet at all.

That was another one of those that has come up since then, that I'm like, alright. Again, like, it's so, we just need this stuff. We just slap it together, and we don't worry about the questions. Because then, as the geeks sit around, like, who the hell built all those ships? Right.

Like, who the hell is running all this? Who the hell? Apparently, the Emperor has, I'm assuming, an army of clones. Well, I asked that, I mean, even with the First Order. I was just like, where did all these guys come from?

When they lost the war 20 years ago, we'd been building a regular, like, republic, more or less, again. And then all of a sudden, they have this massive amount of troops and ships that And everyone, and I'm like, well, where did that come from? So you're telling me in addition to that, there's a whole other hidden version of that that's even bigger with more people running it and building. Who the hell's building all those ships? Where's the money coming from?

Now, they did say that they needed basically... the the people the army from the first order to go there to pilot the ships and then they had to conscript a whole bunch of more kids so i give them that but i agree still where's the secret factory on that world that made and why'd you bury him why'd you bury him in the ice to have the giant reveal if just have them sitting there on the ground. I mean, they're floating in the air or something. I mean. And think about how much... Again, just, like, practical things.

Like, think about how much money it would cost to build one of those ships. One. Think of how many there are. And, like, where... I mean, yeah, you were emperor.

But, like, where is that kind of funding coming from? Apparently, he'd been siphoning off a lot of money. I think he's skimming a little off the top over the years. But still, like, I mean, like, that's just practical questions of, like, how the... magically, all of a sudden, all these ships appear. I'm saying conservatively, one of those probably takes five years to construct.

You would think. I mean, it took him like 20 to build that first damn Death Star. He's had 40 years, so that gives him eight ships. Well, unless he built them in parallel. Unless he built one and then stopped and did If you did them all at the same time.

I think they're like Mercedes Benz. They do them one at a time. It's handcrafted Corinthian leather. Actually, he's such a long-term guy. Do you think like Phantom Menace era, he's like skimming money and start building my ships.

Skimming money. So like this 30, 40 year run, he's like suddenly built all these ships. That's the reality of why you don't really have evil masterminds in the real world because... No one noticed all of the steel and concrete being shipped to this volcano? Well, I mean, that's, again, going back to the prequels, the building of the entire clone army.

And I'm like, nobody's questioning where this funding came from and who put this order in and why we're building all these people. Yeah, at some point you would have an accountant go, these numbers just do not make sense. So you're telling me that yesterday's lunch cost 15 quintillion space credits. It's just, yeah, there's so... It's best to not overthink these things.

Yeah. They do not make any sense. I've said that many times. You start nitpicking at Star Wars, the whole thing unravels. It just falls apart.

And you're like, what have I been doing with my life? Yeah. Yeah. And then what was the thing where... He's like, I made Snoke, and then they had the cut-up Snoke in the vat.

They showed him in a jar, which is interesting. Again, I think that he's basically cloning Snokes. Yeah. So I think that was maybe the one that worked, that we cut in half. And then this was a whole bunch of failed Snokes.

I don't know. And again, that scene was weird enough that I just was like, I'm okay with that. Well, and again, super dark. There's a tank full of half people. It was just like a Hellraiser kind of thing.

Yeah, but it was so worth it. I'm like, I'm okay with this. Just go. Well, and again, just feeling like them just scrambling at story. Just like, I don't know, we killed him already.

I made Snoke. I made him. It's just grasping at straws here. What can we do? Just throw out there to make people, okay, just again, geeks are going to question things.

We got to have an answer. Doesn't have to be a well thought out one. Just, I made him. Nobody mentioned me because I was dead. So I made this other guy to be my puppet to do everything.

But he's kind of a jerk for a puppet. He's pretty cocky for a clone. So what about all the new force powers? I mean, so force can heal, force can teleport items. I was okay with all of it.

Again, people like to complain about all of that stuff, because we certainly had a lot of that in the last movie, but I'm just like, it's also a continually progressing thing, and it always has been. Now, again, some of it from, like, a screenwriting standpoint, and some of it's just, like, I also feel like Rey and Kylo are, like, super pushing the envelope. Like, everything else was structured in their dumb little religious order, so, like, they stuck to it, but, like, from day one, like, Kylo has been like, what can I do? Can I freeze a bolt in midair because it looks cool and I can show off how powerful I am? I feel like he was always like, what can I do that's different from what everybody else has been doing because I can, because I'm super powerful.

And Rey from the beginning is like, I don't have anybody really training me, so let's just figure shit out. So I'm okay with all of that. About a week ago, I wondered, can anyone else shoot lightning bolts besides the Emperor? Apparently they can't. Once it got to the ship, that's like when he sort of alluded to the your parents thing, and then when she stopped the ship and lightning bolts came, I was like, well, we've already answered the question of where you're going with this.

She just shot lightning out of her hand, but that or Yoda. Wasn't he the only, didn't he have green lightning in their battle? No, I think he just deflected it. Or did he just catch it and force it back at him? But yeah, Emperor is kind of.

I mean, it's space magic, so I mean, you know, I accept it. I prefer there not to be limits on what the Force can do. It's really all about the person and how they're harnessing it and what they're able to do with it. If there weren't limits, Kylo Ren wouldn't be able to pull stuff from one area at And I know he's not doing it on purpose, but I thought that was pretty kick-ass. That's just a weird thing between them, it seems like, too.

Yeah, like they're cosmically linked. But if you're not putting limits on what they can and can't do, then from a storytelling point, you're wide open. Yeah. And that can be good, and it can also be bad, but I think so far they've managed to keep it decent. Yeah, don't do, like, time travel shit.

Yeah. Well, yeah, the minute, to me, time travel is. When you're out of story ideas and way to nip your things is when you start going, well, we'll use time travel because we are dead inside and we have no idea. There is time travel in Star Wars. Not in the movies.

Yeah, no. It's coming. Don't worry. But no, I mean, that's sort of like within the plot progression of The Force Power is But also just within the screenwriting, it's like I think they also just didn't plan that far ahead from day one, from Lucasair. And this is one I never thought about at the time, but it was brought up in the fan base.

And I was like, huh, that is totally true. Go back 1977, that first movie. What are the Force powers? Other than being able to like suggest something to someone. Kind of see by feeling nothing like you can detect when little robots are shooting yeah you gotta sense.

But there's no proton missiles there's no and even then i like when i was a kid i assumed he just got a good shot in there like only later did people go no he was using the force to put i'm like oh okay if you say so like i thought he was a good shot like in beggar's canyon back home like i mean something like i don't even think that has to be force-powered so then i heard this theory so see what you think because this is fun assume there is no force the only movie that exists is 77 star wars and ben kenobi is just a drunk old man yeah so there is no because you never there's no like telekinetic powers in the first star i never really thought about it's empire when he starts picking up the the lightsaber we never see any of that the best you get is like ben makes that weird noise with his hand but again maybe he's just a ventriloquist hell i don't know so like how.

Many times it took me watching that freaking movie before i even caught on that yeah. It's so minor and that's why i'm like it's it was so like understated in that first movie because george probably hadn't thought of that yet but like there's no real powers to the force it's all like even then i. Mean that's kind of telekinetic so. Yeah or the power of suggestion. I'm gonna choke I'm going to make you choke yourself.

And look how scary my costume is. You're going to do what I say, right? And he's right. One of the highlights of the last show to me was how the lightsaber battles became better, more visceral. Yeah.

How if you had something that could cut through anything, you don't fight like it's a sword. Yeah. You know, you fight like it is. You find new ways to use it. Right.

You know. Whereas, again, the prequels, of course, the 4, 5, and 6, he didn't know where he was going with this stuff, contrary to what he says. And in 1, 2, and 3, it was just all so structured. But I like the visceralness of 7, 8, and 9 with the fights and the stuff. And you could sort of reckon it as these are untrained people who are learning things on their own, so they're not constrained by the training.

Rules of sword fighting. Yeah, the only thing that doesn't make sense, specifically, and again, it's the argument of what order you watch them in, but if you watch 1, 2, and 3, and then go to 4, these old men are the most boring fight I've ever seen. They're like flipping around and doing stuff in the prequels, and these guys are just like... In Ben's defense, he hasn't been in a lightsaber battle in 20 years. In Vader's defense, he doesn't really need to.

That's kind of true across the board in this whole universe. If you're not going back in time when there were all these Jedi, but I'm like, that's another one of those things I hadn't thought about is when we get to Kylo in the first movie there, and he's having a lightsaber battle at the end of the movie, it's probably the first time he'd ever had. There were no other Jedi. They were all dead. So I guess maybe he made the Knights of Ren get those cool sticks and hit them with them or practice.

Well, he obviously got some training in the academy. I guess. But for the most part, there weren't any. By the time he turned evil, particularly, there's nobody to fight with. So it probably was a little bit like, finally, I get to use this thing.

So mentioning that, what do you think? That's another one of those of like, I'm picking up the movie that I started moments The fact that we magically have the Knights of Ren back, who completely disappeared last movie. Yeah. What? Well, I figure that was the fans.

It's JJ being like, no, I wrote this. I like this part. Yeah. And then I kind of liked how they were like, hey, it's the Knights of Ren. Cool.

Well, the other people were visually scared. Like, what are these ghouls doing here? I kind of like that. Like, these guys have a. Yeah.

Have a... A. Reputation. They have a reputation that these are the freaks that get called out when shit needs to get done. As the movie's going along, I'm sitting there thinking about the Knights of Ren and how obviously they're badass because they were trained by him, but then I really start to think about it.

It's like, they're probably super badass because they probably had to kill other guys who were training to be knights to get to that level. Is it in the canon to. Did Kylo Ren make them and train them? See, I thought I'd heard it was the other way. That, like, it was a pre-existing thing and he, like, the arrogant bastard that he is, named himself Ren when he turned.

So he's named after Ren. I sort of figured, like, you know, just like it's Darth whatever, that maybe the Knights of Ren and then you join it and you become Johnny Ren. Philip Ren. I like that. Yeah.

But I don't know if that's been told yet. I'm not standing behind that. I just heard that thrown out there that he gave himself that name when he turned. Could be. Because it already existed.

It made it look like no matter what, they were following him. Yeah. Which is why I was kind of hoping that at least one of those guys would be like, I'm loyal to you, so whichever way you're going, that's how I'm going. Yeah. Which is why I think, I mean, it's weird when they show up at the beginning because it's like, oh, I guess they're just back.

But it's even weirder by the end when they immediately want to fight him. And I'm like, why are you, you don't even know that he's turned, do you? Like they just, as soon as he comes in, they're all ready to take him out. And I'm like, is it? He not only on your side, but your leader?

I think the force keeps a roster. I guess. And everyone kind of knows. We just lost one. That's your answer for everything.

We just lost one. Damn it. All right. Got to kill him next time we see him, guys. It's got to be balanced.

Now it's 97. Who changed? Must have been them. I just got an alert on my phone, guys. We lost a Sith.

Next time you see that guy, just kill him. Just go ahead. Why couldn't he power of suggestion them into being like, I'm still the boss, you know? You want to follow me and go kick that old guy's ass over there. I was curious about that, too.

Were they trained in the ways of the Force, but not necessarily Sith, like Jedi or. And I'd even heard that they were the other guys that left with him when the whole Luke fight happened. They killed all the other ones except for these five guys, and then they became the Knights of Ren and went off. But again, I've heard so many different variations on this story that I don't know. At this point, just make up your favorite part.

Don't worry, there'll be a novel. Oh, there's, again, several out there, I'm sure. So I was trying to hit the other things... 3PO still just amuses the hell out of me yeah he really I'm sorry like his delivery is so damn funny I know sometimes and the more I was sitting there I'm like is it weird that the person who used him the worst is George Lucas because I feel like he's pretty funny in the first three movies but again you're handing it off by the second one so like his better moments in Empire are a different director by then anyway The time that he's the most hammy and ridiculous and cartoony is in the prequels. And that's all Lucas.

And then you give him to, like, J.J. in even the last movie. I'm just like, he's really funny. Like, I feel like other people know how to make use of creepy. He's the straight man. I mean, he's the one that, you know.

But in the prequels, I mean, he was just. He's a cartoon. It was too funny. Yeah. You know.

And it needs to not be overused. Well, in this movie, when he sacrifices himself, that was the other moment where I was like. And I think I was more upset by. Felt genuine emotion toward that than I did when I thought Chewbacca was dead. Because I was like, he's been through all of this.

He is key to where they are. And he's just going to say goodbye to everybody. Yeah. And including us, you know. I do feel like it was, again, a cheat that immediately, 20 minutes later, he magically has his full memory back and everything's cool again.

I was like, eh. Yeah, but I like. How they're like, well, doesn't R2 have a backup of your memory? And he's like, I wouldn't. Well, I mean, that's the thing.

They made a big deal out of it in this movie of wiping his memory. I was like, well, he's already had it happen once in these movies. Like the only one that really has been there the whole time and remembers everything is R2. Like R2' s been there every step of the way. Which is really the other thing that kind of annoys me in these movies is he is totally sidelined.

Yeah. Like, R2 has completely been replaced by BB-8. And, like, he was asleep the whole first movie. And then this movie, it's like, you stay here with Leia. You know that chick that's gonna die?

You hang out here with her. And then who's rolling next to him the whole time is BB-8. He's just totally been replaced. How do you feel about, was it Dio? Dio.

I like Dio. Awesome name. Like, it's fun. I did, but. I felt like they could have used him a little more.

I mean, he basically said, sad. Yeah. Happy. I like that we get a droid that speaks. No, thank you.

That's not, you know, 3PO. Like, everybody else just makes beeps. It was kind of fun. I mean, no, you're wrong. Cute as hell.

And I liked it. But it was also sort of, well, let's jam another thing. Another cute robot in there. Well, I feel like of all the droids that look like, garbage that somebody put together this guy really. The most he looked like he came out of the brave little poster yeah well it's like somebody take a flower pot we'll get one of those mutes they stick in a.

Trumpet here's the thing here's the thing that's awesome because i saw it yesterday after i left the movie in the store there's already a lamp that is and i'm like well his head is a lamp i mean like yeah they just took the little pixar robot and like Here he is. So you can now go buy one that looks, I mean, it's almost the exact right size. I'm like, well, shit, now I'm going to have to buy this lamp because it looks like a robot. I like that a droid that has boundaries. No, thank you.

No. Well, I do like from the beginning, he's like, please stay away. I'm like, ah, issues. I like this. This robot's got backstories.

I don't think this droid was treated very well. I'm like, oh, I got to feel guilty about. A droid being abused. Stop slapping yourself around, damn it. But that was a little moment of like that is sort of a theme running through at least this movie.

Again, I don't think anybody plans ahead enough to be more than that. But that like giving yourself for somebody else, that transferring power literally and figuratively, because you also get that with BB-8. Because Dio had been down since she got kidnapped, I guess. And within a second, he like converts power and like totally powers him up again and like brings him back to life. which is what we see later, but is even like the 3PO sacrificing himself to save everybody else. Like it's kind of a little running theme.

If there's much going on that's a running theme in this movie, that was sort of like an underlying thing that they keep returning to is like, I'm going to give my life force for you, even if you're a big weird serpent in the cave. I thought that Samorin was going to come back out at some point and help Rey. Yeah. Like go home. It's like a big, powerful, scary sandworm.

The giant snake thing. On 3PO, did anybody else think he looked weird in this movie? The chest looked weird. Something was just off. Like it was literally the guy in a costume with a black undershirt and he put some wires across it.

Like it didn't look. Yeah, it kind of always looked weird. There are times when I'm like, that definitely looks like... Well, since I've gone to Blu-ray, you can definitely tell. Oh, I think.

Yeah, that's just some loose wires. You've seen a drag queen in HD. It's also, I mean, you know, dude's getting to be an old man now. There's probably only so long he can cram. I mean, they're still crediting him, so I don't know if they've...

I thought I'd heard he's got somebody doing some of the physical stuff. He was the only one... Yeah, he was the only one in the credits, but I mean... I'm sure they've got a second unit guy that does some of the stuff. I did like when his eyes turned red when he was creepy.

Because I was like, is he going to murder everybody now? That would be. Well, that was when the commercial dropped that showed that there's a whole comic book series of Dr. Aphra and she's got two killer bots. One that's a black sea thief girl with red eyes that just loves.

To murder everybody. And everyone's like, holy shit, it's the murder bot. Because the thought to me of, oh, they've reprogrammed Or just reading this has reprogrammed C-3PO and now he's evil. I'm like, man, that's a whole other story that we could explore. If this was a movie that was taking those kind of chances, that would be cool.

Yeah. We know that it's not this movie. This movie plays it as safe as you can get on each of these beats. But that would be a cool... I mean, again, if you're going to like the off and... chewy kind of thing if you're going to take our beloved 3po who's been in every movie with us and by the end make him evil and like they have to like destroy him to keep him from killing everybody in the room like that's a hell of a way to go out.

Because at that point in the movie they're talking he's talking about how well yeah we as droids we can't translate this i'm thinking okay that's a good way to keep the synth information from spreading but then when his eyes turned red i'm like no they're trying to keep droids who they don't really trust in the universe anyway they're trying to keep them from becoming evil and that's a whole other concept. It is weird that he can decode it but he's not allowed to tell you about it like why wouldn't you just. Not let him decode that like program him that way why didn't he just write it down But is it almost because we really don't get into a lot of the is that as close as we get to like. An Asimov rules for robots kind of thing in the Star Wars?

Usually there are no rules in the Star Wars universe, but like that's as close as we get to. Oh, my programming won't allow me to do this, which is going to harm humans. What I'm guessing that since he was made in the core systems that maybe that's in there and he was. You could make your own robot that can do fuck all with whatever language. What if he was made by a Sith Lord?

Huh. Wait a minute. Wasn't he? Conveniently, wasn't he? Not just a slave child with no education in anything.

But one that would grow up to kill many people. What I always thought it was, you know, Vader's got to remember that he made that And on four, five, six, he's like, holy crap, it's C-3PO. What's he doing there? Again, I was thinking that like in the. Never once does he high five C-3PO.

Or Pat R2-D2 on the dome. Remember when we used to hang out? We were in the back of my ship for like two movies, dude. So what are the droids we're looking for? Wait a minute.

I know both of these guys. What are the odds of that? I built that one shit. He really should be in the Bespin room in the middle of the drama going, 3PO? Yeah, everybody questions why Ben never picked up on, because.

Ben even says, I don't remember owning a droid. And it's like, well, clearly you've known these two guys for 30 years. No one ever says, why doesn't Vader go, hey. I do like there was the, again, geek theories are my favorite, that at the moment when Boba Fett goes to blast and he stops him, it's because he didn't want 3PO to get hit. Nice.

Secretly, he was like, that's my droid. Gotta take care of that guy. That's my boy. That's my booze. I made you.

How you doing, kid? If anyone's gonna kill my booze, it's gonna be me. It's gonna be me, and I'll melt him down like I do. Alright. General Hux.

I like him going out like the weasel that he was. Yeah. It is weird to be as demoted as he was, because he was back to being just a dude sitting around the table in this movie. But. I do.

Again, I like that he's the spy. He's stabbing Kylo in the back once again. I love that he literally says, I don't care if you guys win. I just don't want Kylo Ren. I just don't like that Kylo guy.

I love that he got shot in the leg to keep up appearances and then still got shot. Immediately, that guy's like, you are the fucking traitor. And I like that the other guy, if only he could have been in 4, 5, and 6 as a background general. I was kind of wondering, could they not find a weird old British actor? Yeah, because... i serve you now as anybody like yeah that's deep instead they found a recognizable act right but like it would have been cool to go back and find one of those guys it's.

Probably doing conventions somewhere could use the money and be like dude make him the guy in charge now. But i also like when they're sitting around the table and kylo ren's like well here's the plan with the emperor and the one guy's like wait what's he want in return and because i was thinking that too and then kylo ren's just like no you die. Now Well, again, it's like the feel of the old one, but they've got to one-up it. Instead of just choking you, why don't I throw you into the ceiling? Because I'm a little extreme compared to Vader.

But that's why chaotic evil always fails, because your underlings ask a completely legitimate question. To the success of your overall organization and you just choke him out and kill him. It's like this old dude is not just going to give us these ships for shits and giggles. Yeah, there's got to be a prize for that. What do we owe him?

Don't you ask that. I like that they were like, no, we totally are comfortable with your helmet. Vader, Coke or Pepsi? Poor Kylo Renpuk. Kylo's got the cool red pinstriping action going on there.

It's all good. But again, that's another one of those things of like, No, I put him with the helmet on. Damn it. Don't take his helmet off that whole last movie. I'm putting it back on.

I'm giving it some stripes. It just seems so petty. The stripes. Oh, yeah. All this JJ of like.

It looked like a hockey goalie's helmet. How they like spray paint it and like try to make it look all cool. Well, yeah. He's trying to be cool. Racing stripes or flames.

He's trying to be cool. And then, again, I forget the guy's name, the hobbit, says, well, why don't we do another holdover maneuver? That's a one in a million thing. I'm like, oh, Jesus Christ. Damn it.

You know, it's just. That line did not need to be in that movie delivered by that character. That character didn't need to be in that movie. I was just like, what are you doing? All you're doing is taking me out of this movie.

That's your only purpose here. I think it's just because he seemed like he noticed the camera more than everyone else. Every time, wasn't he kind of looking at it? Hey guys, remember me? I was in that other movie.

I think every project he's in, he's like, that's right, I get to do this for a living. cool but uh yeah i didn't even think of him as the hobbit guy i thought it was the guy from lost yeah that's what i thought of him from okay it's a guy from lost it's adorable. That's half of the cast. In this no i'm not paying attention anymore shit. As long as we kill snap i was so glad he died he just uh i don't know which one was that the greg what's his face the other guy from lost or no the The one that's best friends with JJ. He's in everything.

He's in everything. Yeah, but which character was he in? The heavy set rebel guy? I didn't know that. With dark hair?

I wanted him to be a little less annoying. Well, and that's the other thing. I think there's been some weird side story that the whole reason they get found out in that first one is that he was on a mission and they traced him back to where the rebels were. Or their rebellion or whatever they are at this point. So yeah, he's the reason they got busted early on.

So now I'm like, why is this guy hanging around? Now, the one cameo I did like was Wedge Antilles at the very end. I'm like, nice. Especially because I thought he didn't want anything. I thought the actor himself was like, no thanks, I'm done.

So it's interesting that they lured him back in. This is the last ride. The celebration movie where everyone comes back. I like Billy Dee. As people were turning they were just gonna shove him in there but the first scene that he's in I'm like okay this sounds reasonable.

I do like that whole like them showing up there just at the time that it's having this weird festival this is another time when I'm like cause they're doing like the whole production there and like people are like dancing around I'm like thank god this isn't Lucas Ron cause you know there'd be a musical number right here yes and like it was so low key and like it is another one of those moments. This is one of the like running things that's really cool with, with Ray's character is she's still in awe of so much of this universe that like she lived on this planet in the middle of a wreckage and like scrapping. And like, so that every time she gets somewhere new, she's like, Whoa, like trees, water, like everything is just amazing to her.

Like she gets in the middle of this festival and like, You can tell. Again, this is just solid acting of the fact that she has never experienced anything like this in her life. Where everybody else is just like, I've got to walk through all these people. Poe and Finn, they've traveled their whole lives, probably. Yeah, certainly Poe.

Finn still seems like he's fish out of water until they need him not to be. Where this movie, he's gotten over all of that. Even as a stormtrooper, though, he was out traveling in space. But yeah, you can definitely see that. Well, he used to mop the. but yeah I mean I don't.

Know we've not really addressed a lot of Rey stuff so what is your take on her as a whole in this movie I guess and all of it because I like that we come in with her training I do like that again she's not just magically oh look now I have all these powers like she really has been again like Kylo she's been kind of pushing the envelope like what can I do Because when you see her put the blast helmet on, again, a nod to our fourth movie, but her doing it kind of puts Luke to shame as she's blindfolded, crossing a log, and catching the blast in the middle of it. I'm like, yeah, she's kind of a badass. Well, and wasn't Kylo controlling it during part of it to where it kept shooting her like she was missing because I think he was interfering?

Well, he was, yeah, at least distracting her enough that she was not focusing and getting blasted the whole. Time there's no limits to force powers they extend everywhere. Even with the blast it's like superman if you ride him into a corner you're just like oh by the way he can do this guess what else. He can do i mean honestly i think that the the ray and the kylo arcs were probably the most solid throughout the whole thing you. Know And again, they have the most screen time they really need to be to even make this work at all.

So, you know, and again, I was actually happy with her being no one. because I think that makes the force more expansive and everywhere yeah but the but the change at the end I'm like I'm still okay with that the. Change at the end at least like again it's almost like telling fanboys to shut up it's like how come she's so magically powerful I'm like well she's the emperor's daughter how about that how about the most powerful person in the entire galaxy is her grandfather so you know whatever like. But then, like, even with making her a Palpatine, they kept insinuating that Finn was very Force-sensitive and said, oh, I've got a feeling, you know, like, and just, like, little things sprinkled in there that he was Force-sensitive.

Especially at the end there. So it kind of, like, did still have the, okay, so the Force is still open to everybody, even if she is a Palpatine. Yeah. Because he did have that moment, and I was like, are we going somewhere with this down the line? How about the Leia's lightsaber aspect of it?

I thought that was a little weird. That training scene I thought was a little weird. Well, I guess we need it. Cause I wondered that all along. I'm like, once she realized, okay, I am, I am, I at least open to these Jedi powers.

I often wondered like, did she start training? Did she do that? Yeah. And then by the time we get to her as general Leia, it's like, why wasn't she like, she's definitely force sensitive still. But she's not massively using the Force to do things like all the other Jedi seem to do.

So it was one of those weird things, and this at least gives us an answer. It's a convenient answer, but it's an answer. Yeah. Sometimes, though, that's okay. Yeah.

Because they didn't dwell on it. They were just like, oh, here you go. And I also got the feeling, too, because she was talking about how she foresaw... her own son's death i felt like that was her way of saying i don't want anything to. Do with this force nonsense and pretty true of the force as we know it it gives them weird visions of the future and of their loved ones and whatever so like that that's not that out of. The realm maybe i mean this could be completely just like a random theory but that leia like using the force to like it takes like life from her like if she's not like super reinforced like a palpatine like it is the reason that she died was like reaching out so like maybe that's why she doesn't use the force so much is that she's just like this is gonna i'm taking.

His toll yeah i felt like that was a good way too to end her character because i figured they're gonna have to address that at some point with you know carrie fisher not. Kind of surprised it was as functional as it was that first time yeah because i was just like because they i think they didn't even use like the other stuff that they shot in the last movie, they were just pulling from weird archive stuff from that first movie, I think. So the fact that it works as well as it does, I'm like, that's kind of, I really impressed. I do want, that's another one of those real world questions where I'm like, what was the third movie going to be? Because it was supposed to focus heavily on the Leia part of it, because this was again, like the first one's Han movie.

The second one's Luke's movie. This one was supposed to be built around her. And then they couldn't do that. So like, I do kind of wonder what was that story originally that focused so much on her and did it again, did it tie into her being more of the, cause I really do like her training, especially knowing the story as it unfolds, the fact that she's still training her, knowing that she's Palpatine's daughter. Like that again is, is like one of the few underlying themes going on that like you aren't Your parents.

Right. You are your actions. You aren't your hereditary. It's the same thing that Kylo's going through. Because look at her, who her dad is.

She is not her dad. Yeah. Luke was certainly not their dad. Yeah. And the same with Kylo.

Like Kylo should have been the greatest person and he turned really evil. So it's like, you aren't your parents. You are your choices. You are your choices that you make. So even Kylo's like, oh, you're right.

And then he kind of redeems himself with that thinking. So, Again, I do like that it has some sort of underlying good idea going on there. Your actions are who you are. The thing I always find weird is when, and it's sort of a real life pet peeve of mine, if you know something, just tell the person. There's never a convenient time to tell the person.

And so I felt like if Leah knew that she was a Palpatine, why did she tell Finn? Why did he know that she was? And I guess, did they hint that Luke knew too? I thought they said Luke and Leia both knew. Which I get them.

I get them feeling it. Even though if it's, I would have liked to, of course, I would like to weird look from Luke at some point in the second movie or whatnot. But why did Finn know? And why was Finn going to? gonna tell her that, oh, by the way, you're a granddaughter to the most evil bastard. In the universe.

Was that what he kept trying to tell her? I assume that's what it was. I didn't read it that way. I thought he found that out after that. Yeah, I thought that was more of his weird, sappy love for her that he was gonna blurt it out at the last moment.

There's no reason that if he thinks he's gonna die, be like, hey, by the way, just to ruin your last moments. Whereas you would be like, I've always wanted to tell you, I really love you. Like that is something you would blurt out as the plane's going down, you know? I put my finger in Poe's butt. You said you weren't going to tell!

Shut up or don't! It's a whole nother fan fiction you just did. But back to Leia though, I really liked the way Chewie handled the scene. Yeah. When he found out because it's, yeah, this is his last, friend for.

All these years that's what i felt like was more than anything it's like it wasn't because i it is i've heard many theories over the years that like chewy and leah didn't really because like he's he's the he's the loser guy that hangs out with your husband that's always taking him out drinking and you're like he's the reason i was a cow always crashing on the cows clogging up the shower smells like a wet dog on your sofa like yeah good day all these yeah all these things that would make sense probably that she was a little annoyed with him But it does make sense that everything that Chewie's been through, this was the core group of friends, and now they're all gone. He is the only one in some droids.

And Lando. Lando disappears and wears his cool pimp outfit. That jacket at the beginning was badass. Oh, yeah. What about Chewie getting the medal at the end?

If ever there was fan service in this movie, that is the most blatant, hammy... But, I mean, it worked. I was just like, finally he gets a medal. Well, what's funny about that is, because my wife does not care for the original series. She's seen each of the movies one time.

She loves the... She sort of loves the new series, loved Rogue One. Prequels? Has she watched it? No, no, no.

I'm talking about the... Well, no, I'm asking. What's her thoughts on the prequels? I haven't shown her... You haven't inflicted them on.

She saw about 15 minutes of, I think, whatever the second one was. Attack of the Clones? Yes. And she was like... She was like, why is the acting in this so wooden?

And I was... Thank you! I blame George Lucas. Anyway. No, so they hand Chewie the...

Mask of the Desert. Yeah. I can never remember that character's name, but she hands him the medal... And I kind of laughed. I was like, okay.

And then my wife was like, what is that? And I was like, be quiet, because the movie was still going. I will kill you in the parking lot. But yeah, after the movie was over, she was like, so what was that big deal about. That thing that she handed Chewie?

And I explained to her about the medal ceremony. I was like, yeah, she gave one to Luke and she gave one to Han. And right away my wife was like, Why not Chewy? Exactly! That's what fans have been asking for 42 years.

Why not Chewy? And of all the things that George Lucas is going to go back and. Fix, why not that? I mean, that hero dog just got a medal. I saw it on the news.

Why doesn't Chewy get a medal? Chewy is just as important to all of this. All of this. If it weren't for Chewy, they all would have been slaughtered on Endor. Well, it's not like Chewie was hiding in the Millennium Falcon while they were, like, trouncing around the Death Star.

He's there with them. They're right next to him. You know? And Han was the... Han swoops in at the end.

Well, he got a medal. Why didn't his co-pilot, you know? As my Marine uncle would say, Chewie was in the shit. Literally in the. Trash compactor scene.

Yeah, trash compactor. So speaking of the indoor, how about the little shout out to the Ewoks at the end? Another fan service moment. Again, walking into the theater, I was like, oh, how many callbacks to the older movies did we get? And then they showed the Ewoks, and I was like.

Well, there's... At least there wasn't singing. And at least it was What's-His-Name. Wicket gets to make his appearance again. I guess he leads the tribe now.

I'd like to think he got paid a lot of money to just show up for two seconds. I mean, that's his job. I hope so. They're making another Star Wars or some other weird Harry Potter movie. I got to show up and give my...

What is that guy's name? Warwick Davis. Thank you. Because normally it's like right there, but now I'm like... Let's see.

Lando, 3P, returning. Returning to Tatooine. at the end yeah that was again a sort of full circle thing well that. Ending shot that's what I like about the original movie is the cinematography is just beautiful so that ending shot I felt was gorgeous with the Tucson going down. Yeah I'm okay again like I do and especially because the like burying the Luke and Leia like I kind of like that that's a nice again we don't get to bury the bodies because they all disappear what is that bitch doing out there in the middle of nowhere and who cleaned up the moisture farm Because I remember it being charred and pieces gone. They rebuilt it.

They tried to sublet it. Or the nosy neighbor. It was bringing down the property value, so she kind of cleaned it up, scrubbed off the plaster. She was trying to turn it into condos, but they couldn't sell that property. Gentrifying the neighborhood.

It was a coffee shop for a little while. It's hard to sell anything when you have a double homicide on it. It's a rough resale on that one. But I do like that moment of seeing, because she got rid of him. I'm like, well, what the hell?

Oh, she made her own. She's completed her training. Was it yellow? I couldn't. I thought it was yellow.

It's old school Luke action figure. It's yellow. So I do like seeing that she made her own and we get to the next phase. I like that color too. Like she's from like a desert planet.

I don't know. It's just good to work some in. It was weird that we had nothing but blue. We never even got the return of the green with Luke. It was just a whole.

Lot of blue. I thought Leia's was green in the flashback sequence. And then later on, when shows were using both of them, they were both clearly blue. Didn't even pay attention to that. But I think you're right.

I think they were different colors in the flashback. Yeah, they were both blue. At the end. Because I thought this... I was like, oh, a green one.

Yay. Well, but so... luke's got broken see i kind of wondered so did they rebuild it. At the yeah in the middle of the battle. There yeah because it got split in half that was the whole kaboom so right when i was kind of thinking that in the middle of the movie and i'm like i don't have time to think about it's too much too much backtracking i'm trying to focus on the movie but i was like didn't that explode like but if it got if it was luke's always blue and then was it blue's blue in the flashback and hers was green or because if his was green flashback when it was blue. Okay And Leia's was green, I think.

That was over 24 hours ago. Warwick Davis. Yeah. But I like that she got her own. And Leia's looked kind of cool.

I like the... Yeah. It was definitely a different look. And then hers is really different. I like that.

I just learned, as a side note, I learned that Samuel L. Jackson's had the words bad motherfucker engraved on it. The props department did that for him. And I like that he's specifically like, if I'm coming on, it's going to be purple. Well, apparently he wanted purple so that he could find himself in the big battle scene.

He's like, if I'm doing this, it's going to be purple. It's like, man, the more I learn about that guy, the more. I love him. It's probably really hard in person to say no to Samuel L. Jackson when he says, I want this.

You're probably like, okay. That's so funny that Sam Jackson is like, I want the purple so I can see myself when I. Watch it back. And Adam Driver's like, I'm never going to watch this in my whole life. Yeah.

I think they were doing an interview with Samuel L. Jackson. They were like, do you watch him? And he's like, yeah, I watch my movie. He's like, I watch all of them.

They're good movies. He was just so regular guy about it. I'm like, hell yeah, I watch my movie. I think he even said something about playing with his action figure. Probably.

I mean, that's got to be the coolest thing ever to like Here's me. Here's a little me. I'd be like, yeah, this is great. I'm in Star Wars, but I'm also an action figure. Right.

I definitely feel like we all need our own action figures. Actually, you can get custom made action figures. That's what I thought. Hella ridiculously expensive. I looked into it.

Yeah, but how cool would it be? We need them tie in for the show. Collect all the weird characters on this show. Flip over the back. I can never find this one.

And it was weird, at the end of the movie, I was like, Star Wars don't do end credit stuff, so we're okay to leave. I was still kind of recovering at that point. It was just so much crammed in there. I was just like, I'm just going to sit here for a little while, guys. Now, the one thing I did hear, so apparently J.J.

Abrams was talking with someone, and they said they're a big Ahsoka Tano fan, which is one of my favorite arcs in the early stuff. He's like, oh, you need to watch and you're going to really love my movie. Being there's a ton of records. And all it is, is her voice. They did get the voice of the whole.

We're all in you. She was in there. I'm like, yeah. I had to guess that one of the women speaking was like, I'm like, that's not a reference. That's not like watch my movie.

You're going to see something awesome. That's just, I guess. They did go out of their way to work everybody in, though. Like, they really did get, like, Qui-Gon came back and recorded, and Hayden Christensen, which I kind of wondered if they were going to, like, force Ghost in, something with him. I would kind of like to see him, like, redeem himself in the Star Wars universe.

I would like to have seen... them do something with him like yeah i mean he just and i don't think he's bad i did i did not care for i think it's handled badly i don't think it's his fault somebody i. Can't remember what the whole reference was but somebody pointed out him being pissy actually does reflect darth because there's something darth vader does at some point it's perfect it actually does make sense that he was such a little bitch yeah. Well and it's sort of like you know When I read the Harry Potter stories, you know, it was throughout the whole fifth book. I'm like, stop being a little whiny kid. Go talk to the adults.

And then I'm like, well, no. He is a kid. I'm like, you are a kid. That's perfectly. So as I'm watching it, I'm like, stop being a whiny kid.

But he is a whiny kid. It's the same thing as Kylo, though. You're also a whiny kid who has ridiculous power. That, like, you put those two together, like, you're gonna lead to something horrible, specifically if you don't have somebody good taking care of you and teaching you. And, by the way, that's the only thing it reinforces in those prequels.

Yoda sucks as a teacher yeah ben dropped the ball because it's all going on around him he's just like what huh like at the end he's surprised i'm like dude you're right there pay attention to what's going on like so yeah it's like there's no wonder that he goes as evil as he does because you. Guys all suck well to me that's that was probably one of the greatest faults of the prequel movies is the arc is there you just completely completely mishandled the arc it's there it is so obvious you had this father-son mentorship you barely touch on that the dialogue between everyone sucks the whole it's just it's it's there in your hands and you just messed it up. You know well the thing about the. Ben into a liar everything he tells luke is a total lie drunk old man and then well yeah and then number two everything that happens from episode four on is ben's fault because if he would have just killed anakin on this before none of this would.

Have happened I mean, I've done ranting. Yeah, that's kind of, that's how like every war happens. I know, but that's, that's my super Star Wars geek rant. I mean, as all of them go on, like that, that's the thing. As much as I, and I think I've gone on this before, but like as magic as it made everything in those first ones, the prequels hammered out all the details so that I don't like anyone.

Like, the fact that I really am just genuinely annoyed at Yoda through all of those. Because, again, it's somebody, like, he comes to you. He's like, I'm really going through some stuff, man. And he's just like, nah, just push your feelings down. Don't feel anything.

It's okay. And I'm like, yeah, what do you think is going to happen, idiot? So, it's really, that's why I love that it kind of redeemed Yoda that last movie. Like, he's back. He's a puppet again.

He's fun. I was like, okay, good. I can like Yoda again. Because the prequels, Yoda sucks. Yoda drops the ball.

If the Padawans had a therapy course they had to go through. Because, I mean, you stole them as children. Yes. You're essentially, I mean, how is it any different than what they're doing with stormtroopers? You're stealing them as children and essentially turning them into slave labor for your weird religious cult.

They're told they're not allowed to love other people. What do you think is going to happen? Like, of course. They're told they can't be angry, which. Anger is a normal human emotion.

I mean, they can't have any of it. You can't love. You can't be angry. Like, what the hell do you do? Like, yeah.

And again, I got to a point, I'm like, I don't really like the Jedis anymore either. They have all these stupid rules. And that's what I like so much about Angry Luke in Last Jedi was he's like, we're screwed up. The way we do this is messed up. We're done.

You know, and I was like, Yes, you are messed up. You're right. This is a terrible system. I was like, however, fix it. Don't just throw it away.

Because the bad guys are going to go, well, the Jedi's are done, so we're done. And he kind of did after the fact. Because it's funny that she does the exact same thing. As soon as she sees the potential of her evil, she's like, nope, going to an island, sitting by myself for the rest of my life. The thing that she just called him out for, she immediately does the same thing.

Because it just scared the hell out of her. That's it, I'm done, I'm out. What I really wanted in that scene with Luke was... This is the way it is. You can't run from the worry of I'm going to turn evil.

You've got to face it. Learn. from my mistakes I wasted the last half of my life sitting on this rock don't do what I did that's where I really wanted that conversation to go. Of see this is where it falls apart you've got to you can't run from anger from hate you've got to deal with it Otherwise, the minute you do feel it, dark side. You've got to face that stuff. Got to get Mr.

Rogers in there. Get kids to deal with their emotions. Exactly. Both of these. Sith kids, Jedi kids, they're all messed up, man.

They need some therapy. I was kind of hoping, too, that we'd have a shot with Ghost Luke where he's like, got my hand back. Well, that was brought up, too, is like, there seem to be no rules and it gets worse with the force ghost when they do their doctoring of the old footage, because why does Anakin come back in the doctor redone footage as young Hayden version, but we see old Luke and Leia. Like, why didn't we get like episode four, Luke and Leia? Like, Do you just get to pick your presentation in this other world?

I've experienced my dissatisfaction with the Hayden Christians and the Force Ghosts many times. Well, and then I had that question with Han, too. I'm like, so... I mean, they even throw out that it's just a memory, but I'm like, is it? Or is it...

Is it some sort of proof that there's other, like, are regular people allowed in this other world that the Jedi's go to? Because Han's definitely been suggested that he's at least Force-sensitive. Well, I assume since he wasn't glowy. Yeah, they shot it differently. That it is a memory.

This is me having an internal realization. Dealing with myself. Yeah. But. You can't, that doesn't sell well on film, so you've got the show.

And honestly, to me, that was one of my favorite parts of that movie. Because I didn't expect, I didn't expect. I thought he was out. I was like, wow. I thought he, okay, he got what he wanted.

And again, I think it's the only thing that fixes that scenario. You couldn't forgive him otherwise. Did anyone else notice, though, that when Ghost Luke stood in front of Rey, you couldn't see her? I mean, it's a small technical problem, I know. But you couldn't see her, but you could see what was behind her.

You don't know how ghosts work. And then as soon as he moved, you could see her again. And I was like, I'll let it slide. I mean, I've always had those. Did you stand up and yell in the theater?

Wait a minute. No. This is bullshit. But I was really surprised no one else did either because there were some... there were some nerds. There yeah well this is i mean that is one of those i've always like from the time they started throwing out these fours i'm like what are the rules of this like what do they do the whole rest of the time or is there an entirely other like life going on on this other side and they just come to visit us or well they make it just spiritually hanging out all day like what goes on.

Which was the third one in the prequels was it revenge revenge yeah They make it sound like it's something that Qui-Gon had to learn how to do. Yeah. And then these other guys are just showing up, not like, man, you better listen, because this was hard. This was really hard to figure out how to do this. Again, there's so many weird aspects to that that I don't know how you're ever going to nail it down, but they never really clarify.

And again, is it just a Jedi thing, or does everyone go to this spirit world, but only Jedis are trained enough to come back? In some of the comic stuff, there are Sith versions of this. And that was my question earlier, too. Except he didn't die, but why wasn't there a Darth Maul that came back in ghost form, except he didn't die? And I even think in the Clone Wars cartoon, in one of the episodes, they go to an old Sith planet, and there's like a, A Sith ghost of somebody there.

See, that's a very scary thought because the Jedi are supposed to be more powerful when they're dead. And that was my question earlier. So why aren't the Sith just running around? Well, in the beginning, they may just be able to haunt places and not interact, you know, spooky, scary. I mean, if you were that evil, though, you should take that evil to the other side.

But Ben is influencing Luke from the other side, so why wouldn't anybody? Why wouldn't an evil Sith from the past be there, like, guiding little Kylo along instead of this fake clone guy? That's going to keep me up for days. So do you think this was a good wrap up to this trilogy? And then the bigger question, do you think it's a good wrap up to the entire nine movie arc?

I think it was a good wrap up to this trilogy. I don't feel like the new trilogy is a good wrap up to the whole series, though. I don't think it needed to wrap up the original series necessarily. I feel like it wrapped itself up, really. Yeah.

With Jedi. Well, again, this is almost a repeat. Like, the end is just the end of Jedi. Expanded, more or less. Because we skip the same celebration scene.

We cut to the same Ewoks. Like, it really is like its own little tribute to Jedi again. So, my other question is, do we think this is really the end of these new characters? We've killed off all the old ones, but... No way, there's still money to be made.

Well, and I think they've done so much with them because I really love what they've done with Rey in general. And it's like, I want to see more with her. I want to see more Rey. I want to see more Finn. Poe and Finn are cool, but Rey is like a legitimately great character that they've developed.

And she's, again, had this great story arc. And has kind of proven herself as a solid character. I feel like those two are good supporting characters to that character. Yeah, I like both of them. But again, I think they only work because she's such a solid lead that they can be there to kind of feed off of her.

Whereas, I mean, you could kind of do a whole Poe series. And just because he's a sort of knockoff Han Solo anyway. So you could have him having crazy Han Solo kind of adventures as his own thing. And then maybe people wouldn't nitpick as much because it's not Han Solo. So maybe that's the way to fix that.

That's the way to fix that Han Solo scenario from earlier. But I don't know. That's like, I kind of don't want it to be the end of these characters. I do want it to be the end of that weird arc and having to constantly feed back to the old stuff. Yeah.

I want entire... And that was my go-to here is like, at the end, I was like, I want it to be the end of this Skywalker arc and finish off the Luke and Leia and all of that. They have a whole freaking galaxy. Yeah. There's so many.

But I love these Star Wars... universe, the feel of, and I was trying to pinpoint this in my argument last night, because they were just like, well, what makes it Star Wars? Anything can be a Star Wars story. I'm like, yeah, that's the point. Like, if you get the look and feel of the universe, if the costumes and the sets and the sound effects and the music all feels right, it becomes Star Wars. And then you can tell any story.

Well, and that's what, I mean, Mandalorian is... And that was where I was going. I was like, the Mandalorian is that. It's delivering on this idea of like, it's drawing from all these things that we've built in the Star Wars universe, but it's not hitting every single one. He's not Boba Fett.

It's not Baby Yoda. But we're playing on the things that we know he's a badass because we all like Boba Fett, but we get to see another guy in this uniform and he gets to kind of do the cool things that Boba Fett never got to do because he just continually was fumbling and getting himself into trouble. Well, I had a feeling that Mandalorian is the result of the Boba Fett movie not going forward. Not happening. Which is, I mean, kind of good.

I'm okay with that. Yeah, I'm okay with that too. Again, we've told the same characters. Of course, I don't, unlike a lot of people, I don't really, I was never enamored with Boba Fett because he has 10 minutes of screen time. And he does nothing.

But Boba Fett as an image is fantastic. As an image, he is. And you also get to see, that's what I like a lot of what's going on. And in the holiday special, the animated set, he is a badass. And that's what I think is cool.

They are so hardcore about it that he's using the weapon from the holiday special. And it's like it legitimately is part of what he uses day in and day out. And I'm like, that's awesome. Way to really solidify the canon that is the holiday special. But see, that's a good point, though, because I'm all for Let's have something familiar so that the people who aren't super versed in it can still be like, oh, I get that.

I see where this is Star Wars. But yeah, branch out, because I am tired of hearing about Luke Skywalker. I'm tired about Princess Leia. These connections to death, though. That's the thing.

Everybody's got to be somebody's... That's another side note. Do we think the Stormtrooper girl is Lando's daughter? Is that what they were setting up? At first I thought he was just hitting on her.

And then when he made that comment about where you came from, I was like, oh, is this setting up a side story of like we find out. Because there was, again, I read there was some weird story about after Jedi, Lando tried to start a family and the daughter got kidnapped or something. So this is kidnapped to go be an empire. Yeah. Like having familiar characters.

It could be like Rey or Poe or Finn or all three of them. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Has the same kind of humor like like the the kookiness of the cultures um the look and feel of it but they don't know anybody there yeah there are no other like characters besides them that you know and just.

That and that's what i think is working on the mandalorian is because we are like he keeps going to different worlds we keep seeing different places but we're not seeing the same old characters. And not the hand and fist tributes over and over again. We're seeing resembling the fact that that droid that comes in in the beginning is essentially an IG-88 model, but it's a different droid. It's like it's doing a different thing, but it's kind of hitting that little, oh, that's the scratch in the Star Wars place that I needed. Again, in a universe, there's going to be similarities.

So what I really like about The Mandalorian is it's set after... Return of the Jedi, so. And what they did in the EU was when the Empire fell, it's not like it just disappeared. You know? So you've got the remnants of stormtroopers who are suddenly probably out of work and not getting paid, so what are they going to do?

They're going to find other jobs doing hitman stuff or being strong arms. So you've got... And plus the Empire just doesn't disappear, so you've still got local fiefdoms and stuff. So it. It doesn't have to involve it, but by having a stormtrooper helmet over here and by having a familiar-looking robot here, by having a gonk droid and a mouse droid, you're in the universe because robots are probably everywhere.

Things look the same, but you don't have to be a Skywalker or a Palpatine, which is why I was happy when they're like, Rey, you're nobody. I'm like, yes, because I don't want her to be. a Skywalker or a Kenobi or whatever. But again, knee deep in the same nine movie arc, I guess it's fine. Again, that's why I'm like, all right, fine Palpatine. I don't, well, because we're in the middle of this, I guess it's fine.

But moving forward, I'm like, leave all that behind. And there's so much fodder. It's like, oh, the fall of an empire. Guess what happens in real life? Exactly.

How it struggles. Right, exactly. Well, and now we get, especially because we're dealing with so many bad guys, it's like now you get tons of little corrupt sub-bosses that just take over and make their own little area. And like, you don't have an empire running everything anymore. You've got a whole bunch of people with power and money and like they do whatever they want and nobody's keeping them in check.

So you can tell really cool stories spiraling off that. So, and again, the, the idea of, so what, besides the look of Boba Fett, what made Boba Fett interesting was he was a bounty hunter. So, so there is a bounty hunter guild that you hire out and that, that opens up everything. Bounty hunters can get hired to do good stuff. Bounty hunters can get hired to do bad stuff.

Well, and this is one of the few things, and again, not to go too far into the series, but like we're also seeing, this is a pretty well thought out character because we're also seeing a character with morality, which we have not seen in a lot of, like they're so simplified that we don't even, they're just good guys or bad guys or whatever. We see him have to deal with like, is this the right thing that I'm doing? And you don't see people questioning that a whole lot in the Star Wars universe. And they go back to his childhood, which goes even further back in the history of Star Wars because you see Separatist droids in his flashbacks as a kid, which fits in with the overall Star Wars timeline. Yeah, if you're a 35, 40-year-old guy.

You remember the Empire, and then as a kid, you remember the Clone War, and you could have been on a planet that was caught up in the Clone War between clone troopers and other guys fighting. So that's what's interesting. Again, you don't have to name names or be on special planets that you've seen before. It's just somewhere. It's all part of the same story without being so, again, ham-fisted about it.

I also heard it described that this is the first time we're seeing essentially a good dad. and i'm like we see a lot of bad fathers in the star wars universe but this adopted dad is doing a pretty damn good job comparatively so again that was that was kind of why i wanted to come back around on it because in asking that question it's already answering itself in a different media at this point we're getting a series that's doing all the things i've kind of been asking him to do all along anyway so i think that's oh man to hit this reference there's hope. One and that's where again um My biggest complaints about Solo was that Solo was so ham-fisted about... Threading every connection. He gets his name, he meets Chewie, he gives Chewie his nickname, he gets his gun, he gets his last name.

It's like... Why does the ship look like that? How does it make the Kessel Run? Yeah, the Kessel Run, his next job is Jabba. It's like. it's like calm down just tell.

A story have sex with robots we get that it's han you know you don't have to convince us we saw the title. You know you didn't need to condense 25 years of the guy's backstory into into yeah two weeks of stuff that he did that was what i feel like they've been doing wrong for a lot of this right and so again i've always said the fun thing about star wars is it's a universe, it's a galaxy. Play, play other places in it because if you make a creature, someone's not going to go, well, that wasn't in the original Star Wars. Yeah. You see how many freaking ships showed up at the end?

How many different worlds did they come from? Like, Who knows what kind of weird creatures are flying those ships. Yeah, you know, it's not just X-Wings, Corellian freighters, and Star Destroyers. I mean, there's a bazillion other ships. But that's a good.

Point, though. I've always seen, sorry to interrupt, but I've always seen the Empire employ our humanoid characters. I assume, especially as the Empire, I assume they're super, like, close-minded about that. I do like, it gets impressive how, in this new world, how many women there are in the Empire. Mm-hmm.

And rebels, like there were a ton of rebel pilots this time that were, that were, and I was. Like, they have sort of made some hints that the, the empire is very human centric. yeah like they are. You don't see any other but the rebels don't care like we'll take what we need yeah i guess that would very. You know yeah that would play into the whole oh this whole thing was ripped off the nazi. It's basically fascist they're space fascists.

Right but i like that within the humans they're fine with it again they're they're welcoming women in the lady sitting at the table is black so i mean we've got all the as long as you're human it's cool you can be whatever But these other races, we don't like them. We don't like any of these other creatures out there they seem super close-minded to. So I guess that's the next level of them. Speaking of women, I was disappointed to see that Fantoma did not return. I was waiting for it.

I was hoping, even though it made no sense, I was like, I don't care. I want her to be the Jason of this story. I want her to just keep coming back no matter how many times he kills her. You technically don't see her die. No, she just disappears into fire.

Same with Chewie. You don't actually see him die, so that gives him room to come back, and he did. Phantom, I thought, could have been an amazing character, but now we'll never know. Well, again, she's the one that the look was so awesome. Yeah.

And you're like, boy, you just underutilized her. She's the new both. She looks awesome and has nothing to do. Fantastic. Her arc in Game of Thrones was hands down one of the best.

It was an actor whose name I recognize, but I can't. I apologize. But again, it's one of those things where... If she's listening, I apologize. I think we're okay.

So again, when they showed, like, we're going to have this character called. Poorly. Phasma, I didn't care for the name, but I'm like, that character looks bad. Was it Phasma or Phantama? Phasma.

Phasma. Captain Phasma. I knew it was Ph-uh-something. I was like, Phantama? Who's that?

Phasma. I really was, again, because they went... The silver lady stormtrooper. Because they went out of their way to bring her back in that last one, I was like, I would like that as like a... And specifically like her to seek...

Because when they went back on the ship, I was waiting... As they were running around and kept getting like running into stormtroopers, I kept waiting for her to come around the corner and be like... Like FN-2187. Yeah, I wanted her to specifically find Finn and be like, oh... Look who it is.

Yeah. Like there to be a big battle between those two and finally like have some big payoff. But they really, again, JJ, that would have been another 10 minutes too. That's true. It would have slowed it down.

They can only like tie so many bows. But we tied a bunch of them I could care less about. That one would have been kind of awesome. So, yeah. Well, I wonder, I wonder how, how petty directors are to each other.

So like, so like in the second movie was Rian Johnson like I'm gonna kill off Phasma screw you I'll kill off Snoke screw you and then Jay's. Like well okay I'll do all this to you again he specifically handed it off though it's like you came up with this whole concept and you I thought he was involved in picking Rian Johnson as the next guy to come along so I'm like why are you two being cause then he like I'm gonna change everything you did in this one and then he comes back and he's like I'm changing it all back so there and I'm like what It'd be different if they were like handed. It came about in different ways, but you were both kind of involved in this whole process. Why? I think it's a collaboration that maybe Abrams just thought was going to be more like magical and awesome than it was.

Well, I think it's also him trying to fix everything because I guess so many people got angry that he like. Took it as his responsibility to bring it back to what it was because everybody kind of liked his version. And I don't know. It felt like a lot of like, oh, I'll make it right again. I think he felt like he was handed a mess. yeah and in some ways yeah but maybe not as big of a mess as.

He thought it wasn't I don't think he probably went too far with some of the fixes and and Again, I think just took the safest way on every step of this. It just was the most basic. But again, the basic version that would make me happy. And in the end, I'm like, everything wraps up the way you kind of want it to, and it still works. It's still making kids say it's amazing.

So it worked. Did it get super creative along the way? No. But what can you do? You're going to lose people if you get that creative.

That's kind of what I wanted the non-year Star Wars movies and the other stuff to be. It's like, okay, have your tent poles, have them be what everybody wants. But the other stuff, get a little more edgy with it. Get a little more creative, a little more unusual, because that's... And.

They acted like they were going to, and then they both hammered themselves right in the middle of the other stuff so tightly that you couldn't stray and do anything weird. Like everything had to lead right up to four. Everything had to fit in right into the Han Solo arc that I'm like, we never really had the freedom to do anything else because they were so tied to the timeline and the story and these characters. And I'm like, that's why you get away from all that stuff. Well, and that's why it being at Disney, I'm like, Man, I hope they just don't start shoveling out the same stuff every time.

Because Disney doesn't want to ruin the brand. But I want weird, interesting stuff. Which is why, again, I'm sure in a couple years I'm going to look back at Mandalorian and go, it's not as great as it was when I watched it because. It doesn't stray far enough, but the fact that it is straying in good territory at all, I'm like, this is great. Yeah.

I think it's a big step in the right direction. The fact that people are responding to it, I think, is good because it's going to give Disney a real, oh, this is what people want. Like, I'm sure they're a little apprehensive with straying anywhere. Again, the only time they did, people lost their minds, so. They probably were a little guarded about moving forward on that.

But the fact that people do like what they're doing, I think is promising. So, hope. And I do have this. So, I did read where they could not have any toys or merchandise for Baby Yoda. Otherwise, it would have spoiled the surprise.

So, the fact that they were willing to go. But they lost out. I thought that. As soon as I saw the response and the memes and all of it, I was just like, They better be getting ready for Christmas. But they couldn't because it takes like four months.

And if they would have done anything, that would have been leaked immediately. And they're being surprised. So I have to give it to Disney for like. they ate Christmas sales by keeping that secret. And I'm like, that was a brave, brave move. That's a bold move.

Especially for them. Because that baby Yoda is the cutest thing ever. Even Heartless Me, I saw that and went, oh man, that is some cute stuff. Well, I mean, I still haven't seen the show, but I was like, yeah, I'll probably watch it at some point. And then I saw the baby goat.

I'm sorry, did I just spoil that for you? No, no, no. I think the internet has spoiled it. And that's like the one spoiler that I'm like, I don't even care. It's so adorable.

I mean, it really is. And I've seen the footage of him eating the frog. It is everything. And apparently that's an animatronic puppet. Really, yeah.

It is a physical thing. Which apparently we owe to Werner Herzog because apparently... They were doing two shots. They were going to do the animatronic and then pull it out and do a CGI. And he's like, you're a coward.

You're a coward. He called his employers cowards. I love that crazy fact. And again, it's Werner Herzog. He can do whatever he wants.

He's Werner Herzog. All right, but I'm like, the cranky old man gave you the truth you needed. Well, and the fact that the cranky old man was like, I love that cute little thing. You better put this in here. Yeah.

And he was right, though. He is. Yeah, I know. He's always right. Yeah.

He knows he's always right. He's Werner. But again, that is the... And every little scene that he's in, the little squeaks and moans and. But the fact that he's a functional character is good too.

It's not just cutesy. They keep finding ways to actually use him as part of the plot. And you do see kind of like progression of who he's going to be and the relationship between them. And yes, I think it's functional. I've heard he can already use the Force.

He's trying. Sort of. He's a baby he's trying and i think i think that's also a pretty brave mood you know they have announced the mandalorian show um they have danced around yoda and then and. The horrible yaddle that they introduced earlier on thankfully we don't get yaddle in this. Um but but that's a pretty again that's a novel way to bring in something from left field that.

Again, recognizable, but not connected officially. Right. And again, the fact that they're 900 years old, it's. Like, well, okay. And it leaves you wondering, well, where does this species come from?

Why is there a 50-year-old child? And it also makes sense that, well, yes, if something like that existed, the Empire might want to get their hands on it. So all these things tied together, you just got to think outside of the box. Yeah. I think that, again, I think that's the most promising thing moving forward.

So we'll wrap up on that. Go watch Mandalorian. And it's short. It's like 35, 40 minutes. They're quick episodes.

Yeah. They go by real quick. Yeah. It actually, which honestly I think it's a hard thing because I want more. Yeah.

But it's a good thing because I'm like, I'd rather end it wanting more. Well, that's smart though on Disney's part because if they keep you wanting more. Yeah. Again, not to overdo it too quickly. Again, learning things as they go.

Let's pace ourselves. It is a product for them. They want to make money off of it. Alright. I think we've covered a few Star Wars topics.

Otherwise, that about does it. We will return next time. Same geek feed. Thanks for listening. A severed universe We've had to fight for far too long What is right and what is wrong?

We've been called Bigger than all of us All the. Pieces played their part What is light and what is dark? Will you stand with me? You could stand with me You are not alone No, you're not alone. We are the storm and still flame to inspire.

We are the few that fight for the rest. We are this force and light to the fire. But I don't know my path. No, I don't know my path. Show me what I am.

Yeah, it's awakening I'm not sure of what this is There's a power deep within Broken past It's been chasing me Seeking answers of my. Own While these forces soldier on Will you stand with me? You could stand with me You are not alone. No, you're not alone. We are this storm and still.

Flame to inspire. We are the rain, the. Seas, and the sand. We are this force and light. To the fire.

But I don't know my path. No, I don't know my path. Show me what I am. Show me what I am. We'll win this war by saving what we love.

You are not alone. No, you're not alone. We are the few that fight for the rest. We are this force and light to the fire. But I don't know my path.

No, I don't know my path. We are this storm. And still flame to inspire. We are the rain, the seas, and the sand. We are this voice and light to the fire.

Is that what we were talking about? I thought we were talking about beverages and snacks. Oh, well, that's our spinoff show. If you guys like it, subscribe to that. That should have been the Patreon episode.

It can be. Kylo Kola. If you guys want a separate episode, a separate show, really, that is just nothing but us talking about sodas and cookies, that can be arranged, and or we've got the pilot episode already waiting, so just write in now. This episode is a production of Movie Meltdown, produced and edited by the Auditude Studios, with the opening music performed by the Empires. For more on how to sponsor or support the show, email producer at moviemeltdown.com.

Talk hard! This program is a proud member of the Battleship Pretension Fleet.

Download the transcript file

More from Movie Meltdown

Transcript

Loading the transcript…