About this episode
They dig into the play-within-a-play structure, ninety minutes of red herrings, and David Greene's mirror shot that points straight at Jeff Goldblum. They ask why Lynn Redgrave and Patrick Macnee are barely in a film marketed on their names, and how a story that never plays fair still earns its twist. Spoilers come late. What does a Columbo gotcha look like without Columbo?
Transcript
Automatically generated, so expect the odd misheard name.
I heard you were quite good when you went on for me last week. The audience was disappointed. I did my best but there's no comparison. No, you're being modest. Well, it doesn't much matter, does it?
I mean, you're here. That seems to surprise you. Why would I be surprised? I brought your tea back. You know, special blend of tea leaves that your grandmother whips up in her country kitchen.
Didn't you like it? I mean, it really calms me down. So you said. Takes home before opening night. Wonderful for the nerves.
It is. Yeah, maybe so. Not quite so good for the rest of the body. I don't know what you mean. Let me see if I can make myself perfectly clear.
Since you practically forced that tea on me. And since your motives are so transparent, I took some to my doctor and had him send a sample to the lab. A lab? I learned a marvelous new word. Cyclophosphamide.
It's an alkylating agent. That's an odd thing to find in your grandmother's recipe. There must be some mistake. This causes dizziness and nausea. A few sips of this and I'd be home right now and you'd know which makeup to use.
Monica. You weren't even willing to pay your dues, were you? Karen, I... Didn't know you had company. Hi, Mark.
Hi. This is private, Leo. No, come on in, Leo. The three of us should have a little talk. About what?
Oh, pick a subject. Opening nights? Doing a favor for an intimate friend? What? Huh?
Going to medical school? You did go, didn't you, for a few years? I imagine you had courses in chemistry? Well, that was a long time ago. Why?
What's this all about? She knows. About what? About that. She had it analyzed.
Oh, brother. Okay, look, we spiked your tea, but it wouldn't have harmed you. Just would have slowed you down for tonight. The question is, what are you going to do? I told you it was crazy.
You wouldn't listen. Be quiet. They put people in jail for something like this. Welcome to the Shabby Detective, yet another Columbo podcast. I'm your host, Mike Boyd.
Joining me, of course, is Mr. Chris Dashew. But Mike, where did you get that flashlight from? All of those other drawers are locked and unable to be opened. We are still between seasons of Columbo as the show is getting retooled and revamped and a decade about is passing.
We are talking about either some Peter Falk stuff or some Lincoln-Levinson stuff. And this month we are talking about a Lincoln-Levinson joint, which is how they preferred to have their films called. Predating Spike Lee, just so you know. Yep. Lincoln-Lemonson joint.
Yeah, it was crazy. Lincoln-Lemonson, they are the writers and executive producers of the TV film Rehearsal for Murder, which aired on CBS May 26th, 1982. The film stars Robert Preston as Alex Dennison. He is a playwright. Write what you know.
Lynn Redgrave is in here as Monica Wells, the star of the show. Then we've got a whole bunch of people. This is an amazing cast. We've got William Daniels showing up in here. Jeff Goldblum, second time working with Goldblum because his incredible role that he had in the one episode where he's holding a picket sign.
They said, get us that guy. That's who we need. Get us the key. He held that picket sign so good. We've got Who else is in this?
Patrick McNee, Lawrence Pressman. It's a real rogues gallery of some great character actors. Great seeing Robert Preston in here as the main character. And yeah, Chris, I want to know, what did you think of this film? You didn't mention William Russ, who so many people know as Mr.
Feeney from Boy Meets World, because. No, I believe that you're screwing him up with William Daniels. That's the guy from Boy Meets World, I think. I think they're both from Boy Meets World. Really?
Okay. I've never actually seen Boy Meets World. Oh, wait. No, you are right. He was in Boy Meets World.
What was William Daniels best known for? Well, Knight Rider, Saint Elsewhere, and Boy Meets World. Oh, my God. Boy Meets World. Boy Meets World.
Yeah, no, I am getting him confused, but William Russ and William Daniels are both in Boy Good God. Okay. Yeah. Well, what are the odds? I guess relatively low, but apparently relatively high, given that they both worked in television.
William Daniels, you just know him from his voice. I do. Because I watch this on YouTube where it's readily available, and he sits down next to Robert Preston at the bar. It's like, is that Mr. Feeney from Boy Meets World?
And then he opens his mouth, and it's that voice. And he has the mustache. It's interesting. I remember seeing Robert Preston in Victor Victoria. two years ago now, a few or three years ago, Susan Lambert had him and I talked about it. I remember really liking him in that film.
And I couldn't, for the life of me, place where he was from today until I went and crawled through his IMDb and I was like, oh, Victoria, that's what I said. Obviously, yeah, like you mentioned, this is a very theater-centric episode, TV movie, what have you. Again, it's very funny to me. My girlfriend and I keep watching these together and she's like, what's this for? And I'm like, it's for the Columbo show I'm doing.
I'm like, and you can tell because a lot of times the men who are cast in these lead roles are just like Columbo adjacents. Like the Columbo adjacency. Hal Holbrook kind of looked like Peter Falk. Robert Preston kind of looked like Peter Falk from behind any. When you see him in front, they don't.
But you have an older man solving a mystery. okay, like I see what you're doing. I appreciate it. And I think it's well done. But it is very funny that it's like, we have all these things that are just like seemingly could have been Columbo scripts, I guess, that are just being bandied about and turned into these kind of television movies. And in a lot of cases, at least this one and the last one, like they work as well as some of the best Columbo episodes.
And this, I think for me is even better than, the last one we watched with Hal Holbrook, because the twist in this is it's really good. And they wait until the last possible moment, like several times to like pull up or divert or go left and right. And I really appreciate that because this is one of those things where I tend to not look these things up ahead of time, because I would like to actually be surprised by what's going on and be able to like solve it along with the character. And this is one of those ones where like you, theoretically could, I guess, but it is playing a little unfair with the audience, which I appreciate. It's not like it does or doesn't acknowledge it, but this is one of those Columbo adjacent things that ends up being as good as the best episodes of this show.
I would. What about you? Yeah, this was the first time watch for me. This was one that I had heard about and just kind of knew about from doing our research on the show. looking at all the Lincoln-Levinson properties and just being like, okay, yeah, it's so funny. It's that same phenomenon as, you know, when I was working at the video store and like Sizzle Beach came in and it's got Kevin Costner huge on the box.
And I think he's in there for just a little bit or like Cutting Class or whatever the one with Brad Pitt. And here's Brad Pitt on the cover really big. Supermortar starring Jeff Goldblum. We promise. He is in here, folks.
He's somewhere in here. But yeah, it's funny to see him at this point in his career before he really is like Jeff Goldblum. He was doing a lot of work at this time, and this was one of those. I did try to get him for this episode. Nope.
He did send me back a reply. He loves to do that. He loves to use emojis. So he did the thank you hands, plus a heart, plus I think like a sideways fist. Yeah, oh yeah, absolutely.
He will respond whenever I send him emails, but he usually responds with three emojis. So it's literally him, yes. No, that's the email address I used to set up our talk that we had years ago. When he thought you were the other Mike White. Well, that's still my theory, that he thinks I was the other.
Yeah. I would like to think that he thought I was a different guy. I mean, why is Mike White from School of Rock going to call up this guy and talk about monster movies and stuff? I don't know. Maybe that's like the secret handshake in Hollywood we don't know about.
Hey, you want to talk about monster movies with me, Jeff? Right. And what would you like on your pizza? Thank you. Yeah.
Good God. Wow. The reach of reaches. We got there, folks. If you know what we're talking about, God bless.
That's funny. What's funny is I was going to mention this to you because, again, the place, the easiest place you can find this right now is on YouTube. And one of the images on YouTube is Patrick McNee and Lynn Redgrave, who, again, talk about two people that are like kind of barely in this, really. And then the other one is Jeff Goldblum. Talk about someone who's kind of barely in this.
And the image that they have for Jeff Goldblum is fucking weird on top of everything else. It's like his head is shaved. Yeah, what the hell? When did he ever look like that? Yeah, no, I'm so immensely confused as to... what they're trying to advertise this as post this coming out.
What's funny is I guess this was a DVD double feature at one point and they use like a reverse shot of like him as Jeff Goldblum. Like a shot of Jeff Goldblum looking at a like a brontosaurus and it's like, rehearsal for murder, a front row seat to murder. Like it is weird because it is one of those things that feels like it's being advertised incorrectly because this is a Robert Preston thing. First and foremost, I think before more than anybody else and Goldblum and Redgrave and McNee are in there, but they're by bit players. It is a Robert Preston thing.
More or less. I would say like in terms of it being like, driven by someone, it's 100% driven by Robert Preston. Yeah, the image that I saw quite a bit was Goldblum's face with this kind of red sheen over it, and there's script pages that are ripped in two, and he's between the two ripped pages, and it's like, okay, very, very 90s, very... What was that? He was in one where it was the...
Almost like, well, I know he played the devil in Mr. Frost, but there was like a serial killer Jeff Goldblum movie. It felt more along those lines. Yes, very 90s, very like, we got to get this product out here and people aren't going to know what this is. And we're just going to market it as this secret Jeff Goldblum movie.
Remember Mazes and Monsters? That movie had Tom Hanks in it. Yeah, we know. It was that same thing. Yeah.
Yeah, like, oh, oops, like, oops, he's in it. I mean, you can legally advertise that he's in it, sure. This comes out one year before Adventures of Buckaroo Banzai across the. Which, again, he's not nearly in it. He should be in there so much more, but.
I mean, I have the poster in my office, and he is on it, and it's the Mondo poster, but I think he's on the poster the representative amount that he's in the movie. Like, he should be in it more... and he's kind of the outsider brought in, but the fact that it's like, we're going to advertise this on the backs of Jeff Goldblum feels very nice. Rehearsal for Murder being advertised as a Patrick McNeil, Lynn Redgrave thing feels very late 80s. Like, Right. Like when it like maybe even when it came out.
But Patrick McNee is like barely even in this. Lynn, you know, Lynn Redgrave's barely even in this. To speak of the one who's really not in this that much. Lynn Redgrave is the one who highest, you know, second highest billing, but is in this maybe the almost the least. Her character obviously has a big impact on what's going on.
And her murder is the one that's at the center of everything. But she's in it for maybe 10. Right. Right. Sorry, someone has to get murdered in all this.
And, you know, often a woman, especially when it's this, like, kind of pseudo-Columbo-adjacent male protagonist. So I really liked it. I appreciated that it did have all these great actors in it, and it is being advertised weirdly. But they're missing the point. Like, Robert Preston is so good in it.
He's, like, so melancholic without feeling, like, too... too much, which can be a thing. He feels the right amount of sad. And also you can tell that he's like very driven to get done and figure out what is going on and really put kind of put things straight with the, these people that he knows. And I really, I appreciated that. Like I said, it's just, it's a really all, it's always weird to see things like this being advertised because this lives in a gray area.
It was a TV movie. Like you can watch it for free on YouTube. YouTube movies and TV free, like not like some, I mean, there are a couple of pirated streams out there, but they look about as good as the YouTube stream does. It's about one to one. So this is not exactly something that anyone is like champing at the bit to rewatch or they're doing any, like, it's just kind of hanging out.
So it is interesting to see how they were advertising it at some point is kind of Jeff Goldblum thing, which it's not, or a Lynn Redgrave, Patrick McNathing, which it's not. It's technically those things, but it's not only them. That's. So. I was kind of kidding around 44 year old movie.
I think we're okay to spoil this. I want to save the twist and the very last twist until we're about done talking about this movie. I like the structure of this. You know, we get about five minutes into the movie. We see Preston at first in this empty theater and he's setting up these chairs and you've got that striking image of these chairs set up on an empty stage and and the stagehand is there, and he's just like, oh, I'm going to go get some food, what can I get you?
And at one point, Preston's like, it's okay, I'm done, get out of here, kind of thing, and you're like, what's going on with this guy? What's happening with Preston that he's a little bit testy with this person? You feel maybe he's a suspect, almost right off the bat, because of the way that things are happening. Then he has a little bit of a flashback, and We get to see that he's this playwright, that he's going to be married to Lynn Redgrave. Lynn, right?
Not Vanessa. Yeah, okay. Going to get married to Lynn Redgrave. She's a little upset because the story has broken to the papers already. She asks him a couple odd questions that we're going to get back to later on in the whole proceedings.
And then he's away when the murder happens. So it's like, well, maybe he didn't murder her. What's going on? We're not sure exactly what happened. And then eventually we get back to the present and it's, oh, hey, guys, we're doing this whole play thing here.
I've got this new play. I want you to read this and I want you to all act out these parts. And you pretty much immediately lock into this. He's kind of a vindictive asshole, and he's got all of these actors there, and he suspects every single one of these actors. And he's got this policeman that's there kind of hiding in the shadows in the theater, and he's going to basically be there to catch whoever this criminal is.
And of course, I think it takes like 70, 80 minutes before they even mention Hamlet and the place, the thing to catch the king kind of thing, but it's like you just know pretty much off the bat like, oh, this is what's happening. He is trying to do this, and he's going through each one of these characters and casting all this doubt on them. It's like, well, McNee, you had this problem, and you did that, and you were a spurned lover, you made passes at her, and you're just like, wow, he's not pulling any punches. He's really going for the guts with every single one of these people, and just giving you suspect after suspect. And I really like how they take this idea and just kind of build up that tension by all of these, basically, it's like, this movie is I don't want to say it's flashback crazy because that makes it seem like it's a bad thing, but the structure of it is such that you constantly are going back and seeing how things played out in the past and how it reflects in the present, which is this rehearsal for murder.
It's this whole rehearsal of him with this new play and all of these actors. And that was the thing about it that I appreciated is it is play within a play. We have kind of Robert Preston character saying, okay, look, all of these people ostensibly don't know why we're getting together. I'm getting together with them in the hopes that we're going to solve murder. And I know that the, you know, the murderer is in this room with us now.
I like that aspect of it. I will say to your point, like not to get to the twist, but to say there is kind of an over arching twist here with all the, I, I, you never know with a thing like this, if they're going to do that thing, because again, like there have been plenty of these things I've seen that they don't where it is just like, it is one of these people in the room and it is technically one of these people in the room. But I think the thing that I appreciate is this goes with the bit for about as long as you could take up until the last five minutes, maybe like one, it's effectively a commercial break is what we get. Like the last, like, 10 minutes of it is, like, host to the big twist.
I like that it kept my attention for that initial 86, and I wasn't, like, questioning as to whether or not, like, gotta be another twist, it's gotta be another twist. What it was presenting to me, I believed was reasonable enough that if that was the way it had resolved itself, and it had been one of the, you know, the Patrick McNee, or the William Ross, or the Jeff Goldblum, or the Madeline Smith, like, any of those characters, even the William Daniels one, like, If it had been any of those, I would have been like, okay, understood. Obviously, that ends up not being the case, and we're not there yet, but I like that it does so much in terms of making sure that we are entertained while it is kind of building that head of steam that we maybe just don't realize initially.
Because again, it does a really good job at not playing its hand early. It holds back, which I appreciate. It needed Oh, gosh, I don't remember exactly how far into this is, but it's one of those like you're talking about commercial breaks. You really feel the breaks, the commercial breaks here. I want to say it's like an hour into it.
So it's probably what would that be? The midpoint of the second act for a film like this and or probably towards the end of the second act where McNee. kind of rushes into the room because they've taken a little bit of a break you know this is pretty upsetting because they have all of these people reading this and just being really manipulated by Preston you get to realize just what a son of a bitch this guy is to Constantly be like, okay, now it's your turn to read these lines and then reenact all of these horrible things that you've done to Lynn Redgrave. And here's why you suck and here's why you're a suspect. He doesn't go so far as to keep reenacting the murder scene and recasting it with different people.
But he just kind of leads you up to that edge time and time again. And so at one point, they're taking a little bit of a break. and McNee comes in, and he's just like, hey, guess what? This cop isn't who he says he is. And you're just like, oh man, what the hell's going on here? Because we've seen this cop, the cop was the one in the shadows, he's obviously a friend of Robert Preston's, and then when you find out that he's actually not a cop, that he's an out-of-work actor, and it's like, oh shit, what the hell's going on with this guy?
This is this new twist, and it's like, I think. It's only, you know, obviously there are other writers that do this, but Lincoln Levinson have been honing their craft for so many years and they just know the exact right time to do this and to give us all of these twists as we're going one after another. And then that's like a real big like, oh, wow. OK, so he doesn't even have the cops on his side. He's doing this kind of, again, very vindictively, and he's trying to solve this murder himself.
And like you said, I'm getting Columbo vibes through this the whole time. At first, I thought when he came in and said this guy wasn't who he says he was, I thought for sure he's a private detective or something. But I'm just like, okay. You don't see Lynn Redgrave murdered. All of her parts, now that you're saying this, all of her parts are flashback because...
It's a flashback that we see of the night of her murder. It's a flashback that we see of him with her, of Preston with her. All of the stuff that we get with her and McNee and Goldblum and all of these characters, Daniels, all flashbacks again. And then you're just like, all right. So we don't ever see her in the present again.
And other than not seeing how she died, this feels totally like a Columbo episode. This becomes the whodunit instead of the how-catch-em, but really the how-catch-em is kind of the engine that's still driving this whole thing forward. And I like that about it. I mean, again, it does feel so Columbo. Not Columbo-adjacent, but it does just feel like Lincoln Levinson, when they wanted to do something like this, they could just break it out. at a moment's notice.
And I'm not saying like, well, this is very easy for them. They make it look easy. They make it look easy, yeah. And I think that's the sign of someone who's truly gifted is like, I know how hard this is. This is plans within plans.
This is interlocking mechanisms working, the dialogue interlocking mechanisms. And then you have the script itself with what the characters are doing even. I think for me, When I think of the things that Columbo has done really well, this is right in that wheelhouse because it checks so many boxes of, like you said, great lead actor, great supporting cast, great setup, great payoff, different enough feeling where it's not just the usual whodunit murder. There's a little bit more to it, but it's not pressing you super hard in terms of expectations. So I.
I think what's interesting for me the most is as it goes on and as kind of more of it unravels and unravels, the stakes feel, like you mentioned, the stakes keep ratcheting up. Initially it's, oh, the cops are in on it and then the cops aren't in on it and they're impersonating a dead cop. And then it's just like, it just keeps building. And there is not a moment where the tension really lets off up until the end. And I really appreciate that.
Like I am the kind of watcher of kinds of things where i would prefer it like build to that moment of tension and then like really let it go and this this i think does that in a way that is reminiscent of the best colombo episodes because the best colombo episodes really build that head of tension up until like the last possible moment and then sometimes it even does a pivot right then in that moment i mean some of the episodes i think of from those like first two or three seasons really like they kind of hard pivot two or three times right at the end. Yeah, I think it's really interesting how much mileage they get out of the initial setup and then how much more mileage they get out of each of these little twists that kind of unravel within the kind of main narrative as it goes along.
I mean, the Preston character kind of reminds me of somebody that Jack Cassidy would have played, like even going back to Murder by the Book, because... He's so sure of himself and he knows that he's a really good writer and he's not afraid to tell people that he's a really good writer. And then also he's so smart to be putting all of these threads together and saying like, hey, listen, other female actress from the play, sorry, I don't remember her name, but you tried to give Lynn Redgrave some stuff that was going to fuck her up before the performance. Here comes the whole understudy, sweeping in and taking over the role. Here comes the showgirls moment of it all, the all-about-Eve type.
Great. He has found all this stuff out, has pieced all of this together, so he's basically telling everybody there, I'm smarter than you are. I have already pieced all these things together. And again, that feels very Agatha Christie, like, hey, I am the one that can... find all of these threads and tie them for you and show you that I can tie these for you. I mean, at one point he actually pulls out a fucking gun and is holding a gun on these people to make them continue with the play, which is insane.
And just like, this is how driven this guy is. He does not want to stop whatsoever. There's a, a guy who's coming in and like giving a delivery and Preston's got the gun and he's like, kind of almost twirling it around on his finger. And he gives the gun to the delivery guy and the delivery guy holds it while he's signing for the package or whatever. And it's just like, what a fucking cock, man.
This guy is like so full of himself that he's just so lackadaisical with this gun that he's holding on these people and just handing it over to the delivery guy. Like, you know, it's, it's a funny moment, but at the same time, you're just like, this guy's really twisted. Yeah. Well, and that's what I think I appreciate so much is that it really sells you on the idea that, like, Preston is kind of, it's that Barney Miller, like, paranoids with proof thing that we've always talked about. Like, Robert Preston's right.
His wife was murdered. And he ends up, like, proving that to be the case. And it takes a while to get to that point with the audience because, like you said, we early on are just, like, maybe a little unhinged. And That ends up not being the case, and I really love that, like you mentioned, it is so engaged and invested, misleading the audience in a way that, again, these kind of things end up doing really well because they need you to kind of believe the lie along with everybody else for as long as possible because that's part of it. It's like Robert Preston is in control of the situation at all times, and we are supposed to believe at times he is not. and that it is out of control, but that is all manufactured within the narrative intentionally.
Not to talk about something I've been watching recently, but there are moments that remind me of, there are moments in Westworld where there's twists that they're trying to do here, where it's like, I know what's going on within this, and I've created all this, and this is all working as I intended, even if it doesn't look like, I'm still in control. And I like that about this, because that kind of misdirection when done well, especially by Levinson and Link, they've done it several times, as we've talked about, like, it just, it works like gangbust. And I like that, yeah, we are led to believe the Robert Preston character is this kind of, it's not flippant, but he's just kind of an ass. But you know that he's right.
Instinctually, you know that he's right. And I like that they spend almost an hour and a half for this thing proving like, yeah, without a shadow of a doubt, he is right. We just don't realize everybody else in the room already knows that, which I think again, like they do such a good job of not letting that cat out of the bag. Exactly. That is the big twist of this whole thing is that everything being done is being done for an audience of one.
And that audience of one is that fake cop, that actor, And everything, all of the stuff that we have just talked about for the last half hour is a complete fabrication. The flashback to Lynn Redgrave at the beginning. 100% true. Her murder. 100% true.
All of the stuff that we see with McNee and Redgrave, with Goldbloom and Redgrave, with Daniels and Redgrave, et cetera, et cetera, I believe it's all 100% fabricated and it's all there just to... build attention, and really put on a performance for this guy who is the actual murderer. This fake cop, fake actor, well, I think he's a real actor, but he's also a cab driver. He's the lowlife that is the one that murdered her, and he's doing all of this stuff. Preston is doing all of this stuff in order to catch this guy. And that's where I think that this is fucking brilliant.
So I would like to mention William Russ, the actor that we both were getting confused as being on Boy Meets World, plays the main character's father. So him and the actor who played Mr. Feeney, I guess they were just like, hey, how are you doing? Long time no see, huh? Like, how weird is that?
It's... Well, when did that show come out? Because that was that. Yeah, William Russ actually is in an episode of The Sopranos. Way further.
I... I didn't see the twist coming and it's not because it doesn't kind of, it, it's not out of left field because there is this kind of dodginess of this, you know, Oh, the fake cop. It's like, once you realize that cop is in on it, there's like, well, there's another variable in plane that he might be part of this as well. And it's like a niggling thought at the back of your mind. But again, like kind of put it out of your mind because, Lincoln Levinson don't really belabor the point.
It's just like, you know, they just keep the ball rolling. And because they keep the ball rolling, there's not any moment where you're able to like kind of readjust and like retake stock and thing. And the fact that we have this moment of like, get the gun, I'm leaving. No, shoot him. And then you, I didn't understand what the fuck was going on.
All of a sudden it's just get the light. So where's the flashlight? And then they point the flashlight at Patrick McNee and he's just standing there. And I'm like, what? is going on and that's like oh okay this guy is the one that they're doing all of this for this guy is singular reason that this is happening and they until the last 10 minutes i mean i'm like literally. That's the gotcha moment.
That's that classic Lincoln Levinson Columbo gotcha moment. That's Columbo holding those gloved hands up. That's when he finds the fucking contact in the back of the vehicle. All of those little things. And it's really what...
This is fucking... Dick Van Dyke going over and finding that camera. And Columbo going, were you a witness to that? Were you a witness to that? Because he's the only one who knew where that flashlight was.
And that's what sends this guy up the river. And the other thing I really like that you're talking about is not only, yeah, they don't give it a lot of lip service that this guy is not the real cop. And eventually the real cop does show up, which is yet another twist. That's like an 11th hour twist for this whole thing, which is amazing. But since that guy is an actor, he's one of them.
He fits the ranks of all these people. So they're just like, oh, okay, you're an actor. Yes, we all know how it is to be a struggling actor. Okay, we understand why you took this part. you're just doing this for Robert Preston, he's proudly pressed gang new into this, just like how he's holding a fucking gun on us to make us do this play now. Yeah, it's brilliant.
I really love it. And I have to say, David Green's direction on this, we haven't mentioned him at all, I think is really effective. There's one moment where they, I believe they take all of the furniture, and I don't remember if it's the furniture from her dressing room or from, okay, and they put it out on stage, and it's this kind of almost like a Dogville kind of like, here's a recreation of the room with all of these things there. And there's an amazing shot where she's got a vanity mirror and Preston walks up to it. And eventually Green doesn't show us.
I don't think he shows us Preston anymore. I think he just sticks with the reflections. And this thing has probably like four reflections in it. And there's this beautiful shot that it's got Preston in two panes of this mirror and So he's reversed from one side to the other. The line of the mirror is straight down the center of the screen.
You've got the female actress over one shoulder in one mirror. You've got Daniels over the other shoulder in the other mirror. And then all the way in the back, you've got this very faint gold bloom coming out of the shadows. And it's just this beautiful shot. And you're just like, okay, like telling us so much visually of what's going on with this narrative where you've got this fractured Robert Preston character where he's just conflicted.
He's trying to solve the murder of his almost wife, his fiance. You've got all of these suspects. And it really, for me, I was just like, oh my God, Goldblum has to be the guy just from that framing. And it's yet another red herring. And I'm just like, this guy...
Lincoln-Levinson and Green are feeding us red herrings for 90 minutes. It's delicious. And I appreciate that every time they do it, it doesn't feel as forced as someone who contrasts this against some of the Columbo episodes that we, you know... They can still do this when they want. They put the show in the hands of other people, and those people are not nearly as talented as they are in terms of creating... worthwhile twists and these kinds of moments every week.
And look, I understand as well as you do. Effectively, Columbo is an anthology show. It is an anthology show with the same character every week, but it is an anthology show, which means by design, there will be episodes of the show that just aren't as good as the other episodes. And I mean, I'm not saying that that's not the case on the serialized show, but anthologies just, I've watched enough anthology TV shows as you have you to know at this point, like there are some of these that are just atrocious and In a lot of ways, my girlfriend was like, have you ever seen Black Mirror? And I was like, no, but I've watched enough anthology shows to know what it's about.
I know the basic gist of it. And these shows really end up being predicated on a twist or a reveal or something in these kind of shortened narratives that is a payoff for you as the audience that you can kind of get this quicker dopamine fix in an hour than you would by watching an hour and a half, two hour movie. And I like with this one, you know, Lincoln-Levinson, again, they're not playing fair per se, but the fact that they spend the entire time not playing fair and then by the end of it, I'm not disappointed that they don't play fair is, I think, a bigger success than, well... by the end of it, okay, they got, they're like, no, they were there the entire time, not playing fair, which I appreciate a lot more than, oh, me just feeling kind of put out that by the end of it, none of this really adds up.
Like, that's the other thing. All of this adds up. They have thought all these things through entirely, all the way, and it's not just, oh, and then, you know, well, we're going to have the twist at the end. Like, no, there's none of that. Like, they have thought this through entirely.
Yeah. And, Even at the end, when we get to see the reveal, we get to see that final flashback. And I love when they cut back to the stage. And it's like the killer is looking down at where she would have been because that furniture is there. And it's like he's talking to her and explaining himself at the same time.
And then he even does this very actorly thing of picking up the dead body and pretending that he has it. And then at one point he... takes those empty hands and puts them both on his face. And I'm just, just the little performance things that's going on. And you're just made more aware for me anyway, made more aware of this because this is all taking place on a stage. And then you get these great, like 12 angry men kind of shots where it's like the actor alone doing this whole confessional type thing.
And then cut to all of the rest of the cast, all framed very beautifully in the reverse shot. I'm just like, This is so nice. You've just isolated this character on screen and from everybody else that's there that's just watching this guy finally talk about what the truth was. I enjoyed that the reveal is, oh, this character who we were under the impression was... had nothing to do with... This is all actually for him and Jeff Goldblum's in on it.
Everybody's in on it. I like that. I could see how someone... watching this might go, well, it's a little bit of a cheat, and they're not really playing fair, but it doesn't bother me with something like this, because the intentionality is to not necessarily play fair. And I like that by the end of it, movies, the best kinds of films and art are emotionally manipulative, but if they do it really well, you don't mind that they're emotionally manipulative. And this is one of these things where by the end of it, I'm like, okay, it doesn't bother me that this emotionally and mentally manipulated me into a certain way of thinking than just dash all of that.
It didn't bother me because the twist works so well. And it is so well thought. out. And it is out of left field. Like, oh, Lynn Redgrave was just pissed off at Robert Preston. So she invited this guy in and then she didn't do anything, but it doesn't really matter because he thinks that he's owed something.
I mean, the William Rest character is just kind of a dickhead. I guess the thing that's nice is we don't really, the cat's not out of the bag long enough for us to get a sense of him as a character other than this guy's just an asshole. Like, just like, by and by. Like, because the flashback gives us enough to understand, and you know, oh, I killed her by accident. Like, well, you know, if that's even the truth, really.
Because, again, you can't really trust someone like that anyways. But, you know, I like that because, I mean, again, like you see all these people. There are plenty of real life murderers who murder someone and then claim after the fact, like, well, it was their fault. You know, it's like I was an accident or something like that. Well, sure, maybe if it was great.
But you murdered her. And I guess the thing that I really enjoyed was like, oh, by the way, here's the actual cop that we said was dead. That was my favorite payoff of the entire thing. Because they're like, wait a second, you said that cop was dead. And it's like, I lied and my incredulity helped.
Like, God, Patrick, come on, man. I loved that moment, too, because again, like all of it, those even those small moments feel so earned in kind of the scope and scheme of what the narrative is showing us and frankly not showing. Yeah, no, I felt good being lied to in this way and having to realize that everything that I thought was true is completely not true anymore i i really appreciated that i thought it was nice it reminded me a little bit death trap which was a play in a movie as well last week we talked about or sorry let me say that again last month we talked about what the fuck was the name of that thing murder murder by death murder by natural causes and how i talked about how that became a play this one also became a play which really makes a lot of sense The moment at the end, I mean, so much of this is play like, but also, you know, handled in a way that I didn't feel like this was just a filmed play.
It felt like this had been written for the screen. But that moment of, like, you're talking about how the lights go off and then the flashlight comes on, I don't remember if that's the mousetrap, but it just felt like such an Agatha Christie kind of a thing to do. Like, the lights go off and then they come back on, and there's a dead body on the ground, Clue style, or whatever happened. But having the lights go off and come back on in some way is such a play thing for me. And having this all in this theater and everything, I was like, this is really nice.
And I like the way that they use... the doors of the theater to introduce all of the actors coming in. And then you've got the whole thing of at the end when they're all leaving and they're just like, oh, wait, we should turn this into a real thing. And everybody's leaving and going to get drinks or whatever, which is another after the play kind of celebration thing that you do. And then there's Robert Preston up on stage. And you just really realize at that moment, you're like, he lost somebody that he really loved.
And he now. Has caught the guy who did that murder. And yeah, to your point, we don't know if we trust that flashback or not because we've just been lied to for the previous 90 minutes. So do you believe a flashback now when almost all of these other flashbacks are lied? Do you just believe the first one and the last one?
Was anything else true? So again, really smart. And you just see him up there. Now he's the stage manager turning off all the lights and everything and just like, putting everything to bed. I just thought it was such a nice way to end this.
I was so shocked at how much I really enjoyed this. And I have to say that talking with you has made me enjoy this even more. The way it ends, it could have felt melancholic or really... again, emotionally manipulative, but I think it really worked. I'm with you, like having Robert Preston kind of turning out the lights on this moment in time in his life. And again, I assume that the cops believed him.
We don't know if the cops did or didn't believe him. I don't know if that's true or not. I don't get the sense of that because again, like we know that the cop isn't dead, but we don't know if the cop did or didn't believe that Lynn Redgrave had been murdered. I'd like to believe that it wouldn't have taken, it looked like a year to get this handled effect for Robert Preston to figure that out. So my assumption is like, no, in fact, that cops probably didn't believe.
And, you know, well, you made a believer out of me today, I think is maybe what the McElroy says. But again, like I don't, because this is not playing fair, I don't know how much of this is for real and how much of this is a dodge that is just for someone else's benefit in the hopes that they own up to what happened. But, I, like you said, by the end of it, that it comes back to Robert Preston and the journey that his character went on. It's more about his character and coming to terms with the new reality that he lives within as opposed to continuing to fight what isn't, again, this kind of concocted story that we've seen for decades. almost two hours. And then we finally see what the reality is by the end of it.
And yeah, I appreciated that moment a lot. I think it's a well-earned moment and I don't, for me, I think that there are the best versions of these Columbo style episodes. They really lean into like the character of it all, like genuinely giving us something to chew on with the characters. And Robert Preston, I think his character is complex and interesting enough with enough nuance that he is, One of the better Columbo adjacents, if not saying he could have done what Peter Falk did. He kind of does in this movie, so I'm going to say he could.
Same with Hal Holbrook. Not to be like, oh, let's recast Columbo. But if they had wanted to take Columbo in a different direction, here's another actor that they could have done it with. Peter Falk didn't want to come back. Well, next week we're going to see, or sorry, keep saying next week, next month, maybe we're going to see Anthony Hopkins try his hand at that type of role.
We're continuing with our journey between these Columbo episodes, and we're going to be talking about Guilty Conscience from 1985. If folks are looking for that, it is available on Amazon Prime. It's a real shitty copy, but it's probably about as good as the free copy that you're also going to see on YouTube. So maybe we can find a better one along the way. But we're going to have a return of another veteran of Columbo.
We're going to have Blythe Danner. Maybe she can make it past the first commercial break on this one and won't be killed by John Kasvetis. So you never know. Anthony Hopkins, this is a few years before Hannibal Lecter, of course, so we'll see if he's playing a good guy or a bad guy in this. Another one that I have no idea what this one is.
Hopefully, I will be as pleasantly surprised as I was for Rehearsal for Murder. But in the meantime, Chris, what are we working on these days, sir? Well, you can find the things that we work on over at weirdingwaymedia.com, where this show and your show, The Projection Booth, and my show, The Culture Cast, and a whole host of other things that we have nothing to do with in terms of hosting the show, like the ladies, the documentary, or the feminine antique can be found. So you would want to head on over to weirdingwaymedia.com, or if you want to engage with us in a financial capacity, a couple dollars our way, and get to hear a... In some cases, a show that is nowhere else in Rankin on Bond, which you can find on mine and Mike's feed, or a show that is available elsewhere but a month early, which is Never Tell Me the Odds, which is our Harrison Ford podcast.
That can be found at your Patreon, which is patreon.com. Or at my Patreon, which is patreon.com. Or Richard Haddam, give me five bucks, Richard Haddam's Patreon, which is patreon.com. So that's where you can find the things that we do. and the ways to engage with us that are the most helpful. Well, I want to thank John Walker for our opening theme and Colin Gallagher for our closing theme.
And I want to thank all of you for listening. Come on back for the next Shabby Detective and hear us talk about some more Lincoln-Levinson. And in the meantime, don't do any crimes. Thank you.
More from The Shabby Detective: Yet Another Columbo Podcast
Similar episodes across the network
Matched by shared keywords.
-
Special Report: Heartland (2026)
2 shared keywords: mystery, thriller
-
The Dry
2 shared keywords: mystery, thriller
-
Episode 827: The Avengers (1998)
1 shared keyword: patrick macnee



