Full episode

Father Malone's Weekly Roundup - Ebenezer (2026)

16 min Explicit Full episode
Father Malone's Weekly Roundup - Ebenezer (2026)
Midnight Viewing
0:00
15:42
MP3

About this episode

How many Carols does a Christmas need? Infinite! Get in the holly jolly spirit right now, damn you!

Father Malone
patreon.com/FatheMalone
linktr.ee/FatherMalone71

Transcript

Automatically generated, so expect the odd misheard name.

Thank you. Welcome back, Midnight viewers, to Father Malone's Weekly Roundup. I am Father Malone. It's been a minute. It's been a lot.

But I'm back to haunt you once again. Bond! It's Pattinson. Okay, cool. I mean, it's greedy.

Bond and Batman. And Harry Potter and Twilight. Augustus, save some room for later. Alright, Doomsday is imminent now. Is that redundant?

As such, we've got a new Von Doomfest, the final Von Doomfest, coming up soon, where HP and I will finish where we started, with Tony Stark himself. I never really liked that guy, to be honest. Not talking Robert Downey, I'm talking Stark. Smug prick. His father, though.

Now there was a guy. And I mean John Slattery and Dominic Cooper. Is this a call to action at the start of the show? You're fucking right it is. As such, check out the new button switches and consoles next week where Laura Grillo and I are smack-a-dab in the middle of a twister.

That's right, the 1996 classic. And over on the Patreon channel, you can hear Laura and I talking about the absolutely can't-be-denied fucking classic, They Live. So that's two ways to hear, but one you gotta pay for. She's worth it. We all know it.

Speaking of Laura, she turned me on to Black Doves. You like that pause? Black Doves! Why am I late to every fucking party? This is from two years ago and it's just sitting there on Netflix?

What the fuck, man? I spend too much time watching anthology shows from the fucking 70s. Keira Knightley and Ben Whishaw. Just fucking spectacular. I'm going to do a show about it eventually, so I'll keep a mum on my feelings.

Except I fucking loved it. Go Williams. Alright, that's all the nerd stuff I got for this week. I'm still busy. I'm rehearsing, everybody.

There's more of gravy than of grave about you, whatever you are. What is it about A Christmas Carol and Ebenezer Scrooge and the Cratchits and the ghosts? It's the ghosts. That's it. It's the ghosts.

Answered my own question. But truly, how many classical pieces of literature dealing with the holiday had taken the turn of ghastly-by-ghastlamp approach employed by Dickens? Nothing memorable. But why goddammit do we need so many iterations? Putting aside the genuine, full-blown theatrical feature versions there have been, and there have been many, just think about every time they used this plot for a sitcom.

Try to think of one that didn't slap it on their Christmas episode. I know It's a Wonderful Life is a strong tie for lazy primetime comedy Christmas episode, but Scrooge has got to be the king. When I was growing up, I loved this goddamn story. For the ghosts. I mentioned the ghosts, right?

And this is a ghost story. What never sat well with me was Scrooge's transformation. I was glad it happened, and I was glad he began treating his loved ones and associates like fucking human beings, and maybe realized he was one too. But it always seemed to me that it wasn't the look back or the one around him that turned his mind. It was the mockery and casual dismissal that awaited him in death that scared him straight, so to speak.

Could be as a kid in the 70s I wasn't hip to the nuance of the language, because if it's done right, Scrooge turning isn't a moment of eureka. It's a slow, gradual transformation of the man. Nevertheless, I always believed the ghost should have visited in reverse. What would he care about anything after his death, this bitter old prick? And then the present remains at the center, but it's the past that undoes him.

Because that's the truth. Most adaptations focus on his lost love, Belle. And yes, my fucking god, what a huge and transformative moment it is in losing her. But not as many even include his sister. And it's her that really works Scrooge over and sets him to rights.

Her essence continues in her son Fred, who I maintain is the greatest character in that story. Maybe better than his mom. Where's his movie? Oh well, here's Ebenezer. Mr.

Scrooge. Scrooge. Scrooge? Mr. Scrooge, we raise funds for the poor.

What shall I put you down for? Nothing. You wish to be left anonymous? I wish to be left alone. Good day.

Oh, good day. Good day. Ebenezer. Three spirits. Perhaps I could just meet with them all at once and have it.

Over and done with. Walk with me into your past. I shall not leave this bed! Hmm. No, no, no, no, no, no!

Let go of me, bitch! You're late. Spice the appetite you have, innit? Ebenezer! What was she to you?

Everything. You're welcome to take your chances out there. I've had the lot. You can't see who you've become, Ebenezer. You go after her, you will regret this moment for the rest of your miserable life!

I'm not the man I was! Ah! Forgive me, I do not know where that sound came from. Your nightmare has just begun. Oi!

I'm alive! I'm alive! I don't know what to do! Ah! Merry Christmas.

I genuinely couldn't have cared less when I heard A New Christmas Carol was on the way. The horrible memory of that waxworks nightmare from Robert Zemeckis is still fresh in my mind. Anyone else remember that? With Jim Carrey as all the ghosts? And he's doing this wispy voice.

Oh, God. When did Zemeckis decide he never wanted to deal with humans again? Did Bob Gale drive him to the brink of insanity with pitches for Back to the Future 4 and 5? And then... They said Johnny Depp was in it.

And I remember thinking, hey, remember when Sir Patrick Stewart performed A Christmas Carol on stage and he did every fucking part? YouTube that. It's amazing. And then they said Ty West was directing it, and I said, okay, hold on now. Ty West, you say?

I'm unabashedly a fan of that guy. I think he's always an interesting filmmaker. The look, the camera moves, the style, and he has a genuine sense of pacing and story. Everyone loved those Maxine movies and Pearl and You know what, I appreciate them, but I cannot stand Mia Goth. She's very talented, but not for me.

Now, The House of the Devil. God damn, man. Talk about style. If I'd been handed a videotape of that, and had been told it had been from 1987, I would have totally believed it. Not many period films feel like they're actually from the period that hardcore.

It was widely hailed for being a slow burn thriller, and it is, god damn it, but it's also 90 minutes. I marvel at that film. Even more so, the innkeepers. People say it's boring. People can piss up a rope.

The guys figured out dread. Dread, motherfuckers. Two years later, he sprinkled everything with a healthy dose of anxious panic with his Jim Jones riff, The Sacrament. That panic is real. It reminded me of that Attica Prison Riot movie by John Frankenheimer, Against the Wall, with Kyle MacLachlan and Samuel Jackson.

Fuck. I went on an Attica tear about five years ago. Read everything. Watched every documentary. That's a great film.

Against the Wall. Talk about dread, man. So Ty West intrigued me, but then it's just fucking Christmas Carol again, and Depp hasn't really been known for acting much lately. I wasn't much interested in helping him revive his career, neither. Not since Willy Wonka.

The fuck? Still bitter. And the fact that it's from Paramount, which is run by the next sad excuse for a Bond film this world seems to produce, Peter Ellison, Doesn't exactly sweeten the pot of me wanting to partake at all. But it's Thai West. And ghosts.

And it might have a chance to be actually fucking creepy. And it is. I can happily say that. This is easily the most atmospheric and supernaturally savvy of any version I've seen. These are fucking ghosts, man.

Andrea Risborough, who just seems to be in fucking everything now, is a delight as the ghost of Christmas passed. By that, I mean she's a dirty, white, almost translucent ghoul with equally milky eyes who seems as disinterested in Scrooge as he is in with the poor. That's a theme that carries across all the Ghostly Visitors. and I loved it. Another fucking awesome thing is that Marley isn't the only tormented soul we see. There are dozens of them, maybe hundreds.

Black silhouettes against grimy Victorian architecture lurching around like zombies and pinning Scrooge in every time he tries to flee. It is so fucking good. By the way, Do you know that the image of Marley in those chains came from a trip to the Western Penitentiary in Pittsburgh that Dickens made in 1842? Marley's ghostly self is based on good old American recidivism. And like I said, it's Ty West, and he's got style, subtly I should note, to burn.

And the look of the film is so fucking good. He always knows where the camera should be, and he can maintain his own sensibility while adapting to a different time and place. I might be gushing a little, probably. The titles alone are worth the price of admission. And backing them up is a pretty fucking great score by Tyler Bates, weaving traditional Christmas hymns into a dark tapestry.

I really loved it. I mentioned Riseboro, but the other ghosts are Sir Ian McKellen as Marley, Tramiel Tillman from Severance is the ghost of Christmas present, Ron Weasley as Bob Cratchit, and Sam Claflin, who was in one of those Pirates movies with Depp, is nephew Freddy. And Daisy Ridley, in the slimmest of parts, is Clara, Freddy's wife. Oh, and Ellie Bamber as Belle, Scrooge's lost love. Fucking great.

All of them. Every single one. No joke. Which brings us to Depp. Greco.

Greco. Depp. Johnny Depp. Scandals noted, everybody. Okay?

It's a great performance. Totally committed. I know he's got a weird shaped head lately, but it works here. With the addition of some really refined old age makeup. That's a hallmark of a lot of Ty West's films.

The practical makeup effects are always on point. He isn't some caricature of the money-hungry miser, either. He makes him as Dickens intended, a bitter old man twisted by his own greed. And then he does something pretty remarkable. He actually gives that slow, gradual transformation I mentioned.

This Scrooge isn't scared of his death or his legacy. He just needs a final kick to let him know that there's still time. Still time for all of us. Which is all kind of a drag, because where this movie falls down, and the more I think about it, the harder it falls, is in its presentation of not necessarily the poor, but those swirling around them. The script has a particular vendetta for charities.

The two men who come to solicit a donation from Scrooge in the book, and basically every adaptation since, are there to show the depths of Scrooge's disdain for anything perceived as a handout. We get that here too, but we also get two crooks who are using the charity money to live large in fancy clothes. Feels a bit like a note from a billionaire, say like Peter Ellison, don't you think? Can't you make Scrooge at least write about competing financial institutions? I would have thought the movie was making some cynical joke, but those fellows come back in the future as conspirators with a lawyer who's produced a fake will for Ebenezer's fortune. thus fleecing nephew Freddy and lining their own pockets.

And then, and then, when all is said and done, Scrooge offers Cratchit a partnership, and Cratchit shrugs it off because he's a proud man that doesn't accept charity. Can you understand how frustrating that this dunderheaded, complete misread of the source material, this complete misread of being a fucking human being is? When this becomes available, I'm going to cut that bullshit out. They're three brief moments in what is otherwise my favorite cinematic adaptation of A Christmas Carol. It looks great.

When it's hewing toward the actual text, it sings. The performances are nuanced, the spookiness is fucking palpable, and it had me absolutely fucking bawling in places. Now, that may be owing to me being rather emotionally raw lately, but the scenes of young Ebenezer and his sister just knock me flat. And then Fred. Oh, God.

Fred is so good, man. Fred gets it. If you can ignore the high turbine sound of Charles Dickens spinning in his grave over the egregious fucking changes to the text, I think there's a hell of a lot to recommend this film. I can't believe I'm saying any of this, by the way. I was ready to shred this goddamn thing.

And then it ends up making me kind of look forward to Christmas. For the first time in a long time. Plus, if you hate it, you know, there's always Muppet Christmas Carol to watch. So, happy Christmas. I love you, baby.

I can see a better time when all our dreams come true. Try to enjoy the daylight, everybody. Thank you.

Download the transcript file

Transcript

Loading the transcript…