Season 10 · Episode 27

A Culture of Despair

12 min Explicit Trailer
A Culture of Despair
Movie Meltdown
0:00
12:10
MP3

About this episode

Movie Meltdown - Episode 445 (For our Patreon supporters.) This week we sit down for a simple movie discussion and suddenly we are knee deep in an examination as to whether or not we are in fact - a culture of despair? But after hammering out the finer points of Thanos' plan for the universe vs. Roddenberry's vision of the future... we quickly fix all the world's problems. And while we try to figure out just what it takes to assemble the lair of a podcasting super-villain, we also mention… Guillermo del Toro, Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri, The Hateful Eight, dragons can, in fact, be defeated, a genuinely weird movie, more concentrated death... in a more productive way, the creative and constructive power of the imagination, escapism for poor people, when your real world has crossed over into what you thought was dystopia, non-likable characters, a zero sum game, a loss of faith in ourselves and each other, escapist literature, co-creators for the new world we live in, hanging out at one of Dali's parties, French new wave, not really a clear narrative of who's supposed to be heroic, a slave to his own reductivity, AP Bio, it's because we've accepted, in a very internal way, a kind of preexisting low expectation for human beings, justifying literary endeavor, I don't have guests over to sit and take tea, you really shouldn't compare arts, a productive calculus, the poetic capacity of persons, HAL 9000, living in a fantasy world, a mis-step from a talented writer, a quote from Chesterton, we're always reflexing the universe back at itself, we're getting more fractured, misery can be beaten, Don't Be Afraid of the Dark, rose-tinting history, your natural desire for something that is inherent to you, moral un-culpability, The Shape of Water, take a stand on an abstract philosophical issue and try to defend it, the human being as artist, moral injunction and the heat-death of the universe.

Spoiler Alert: Spoilers for the epic death and destruction of Avengers: Infinity War. You have been warned!

"There must be more that your nature is reflecting about the kind of cosmos that you're supposed to be living in then the sheer misery and despair of the world." Go to: https://www.patreon.com/moviemeltdown and support the show!

Transcript

Automatically generated, so expect the odd misheard name.

We should probably let people know that this is a Patreon exclusive episode. Is it really? And I mean, it was. Was it not the greatest conversation. You've ever had?

Man, I just never realized I would one day be Patreon-exclusive content. I mean, we are all over the map, and yet somehow we tie it all together, and we never ramble on, and we're super smart about everything. Everything. Especially names. Anyway, yeah, I think you should definitely listen to ridiculous things that we say like this.

That I also feel like we're hitting almost like a point of oversaturation of not likable characters that we spend a lot of time. Like it became a thing like kind of mid 90s, I guess. It became sort of an underlying. Well, I'm like. I'm like the most pop culture version of it because I remember like midway in watching tons of Seinfeld.

Yeah. And it's only later I look back and go, these are terrible people. Oh, yeah. By the end of the series, they even acknowledge you guys are horrible people. Why are we going along with this?

I have an uncomfortable relationship with Frasier for that reason. Well, yeah. So it's like it became sort of a fashionable thing. And then as time went on and we hit like the era of Breaking Bad where it's like not only is this an unlikable character– He does deplorable things. Like you hit a point of anti-hero that became almost too much and it became.

So acceptable at that point. Thank you, Game of Thrones. Well, yeah, it became so acceptable that then suddenly like almost everything became that. So now it's so rare that I watch something and be like, you know what? I like this character.

Like it's so nice to see like a return to an old version of like This is our good guy and he does nice things and he's got an arc that like kind of is helping people or at least trying to accomplish something with his time. Is that Thanos is presented as the heroic character, you know, in that film and this has been widely commented on. It's a great move by Marvel. But the thing I would mention is that. This movie, he basically says, look, the only hope for any kind of species is this massive population control effort, you know, essentially.

Now, here's the thing. I'm not a Malthusian. I don't agree with these sort of population control theories. I think it's actually, I think it's a crack pottery sort of a thing. But the thing that was most sad about that is essentially this villain presents, okay, this is my plan.

This is what I'm doing. This is why. None of the heroes actually objected to it aside from the fact that it was essentially genocide. But that is, in my view, kind of a technicality. None of them said, no, what you want is wrong because blah, blah, blah.

No, in fact, pretty much the film bent over backwards to demonstrate that Thanos was likely right. That's what I said on our episode. I was just like, that's the sad thing is he's got a point. And you want to not be on his side because- It's horrible. He's killing so many people and people that we love and not just characters we love, but like everyone else out there.

And like, it's hard by the end of it to not look at the statistics part of it, like the mental part of it, not the emotional part, but the mental part and go, damn, he's got a point. But anyway, yeah, no, I think that's actually one of the fundamental differences, though, between the core Roddenberry vision and some other versions of Star Trek and other sci-fi shows is that question of what is human nature and how does it... Roddenberry had what I think is actually a laudable, if debatable, view on human nature, where human beings actually possess the potential to improve and get better, so that we get to a place where actually... What was it? Will Riker...

Friend of the show. Yeah. Jonathan Frakes. Great guy. He likes to tell the story in interviews, which I was always fond of, where he says that Gene Roddenberry.

So if you want to hear that kind of really intelligent comments on movies and music and. random other things. That came about. Or future interviews with random people such as myself. You should definitely go to our Patreon page. Again, if you don't know how to spell Patreon.

That's fine. Go to moviemouthdown.com. I'm sure you're there all the time. Which you should be looking for new content. Which is awesome.

How often did you say it was updated? I'd say once a week. Once a week. You get a brand new episode. That's really exciting.

We used to do other stuff, but nobody paid any attention. So if you want to write stuff for the website, you can do that too. But nobody wants to do that. So, That's why I focused on the audio, and we do that every week. It's where you belong, Brian.

I feel that. As time's gone on, I've realized this is my calling. It took me a long time to find it, but this is why I'm still, this many years in, still doing it. Well, the truth is it actually didn't take you any time to find it. You've been doing it for years.

It does explain why I had that little mini cassette recorder that I used to carry around. As a kid. We were just talking about crappy jobs before we started. We were talking about crappy jobs. And the thing is, and I think this is true for a lot of adults, it's not true for me yet, but that's because I'm a failed adult, is for a lot of our, well, a little bit.

I mean, the 30s is the age of coming to terms with things, I think. Yikes. But, yeah, look forward to that, kids. But I think that many of us find ourselves, like, we're like, oh, man, what am I supposed to be doing? What am I supposed to be doing?

And then you kind of look around and realize, wait a minute. I've been doing this for 10 years. I barely think about it, but it is the thing that I want to do all the time. Well, with me, I also was doing it well before that. Yeah.

And they're just, most of the time, aside from that little recorder, a lot of the time when I was doing it with other people, I wasn't recording it. But I spent so much time working around other people who were movie geeks. sometimes surrounded by movies. Shades of Tarantino there. And we would sit there and have these same discussions that we're having now, sometimes with the same people that are on the show now, because I'll dig them up and be like. Look, we need to bring him back.

We need to go back to where we used to be. And, like, just start with new movies and new conversations. And so, like, you really do, like, sometimes realize, oh, what I need to be doing is what I've been doing all along. I just need to find a more useful, more productive way to do it. And that's what this show has become.

Well, I know I never thought to myself I would have a theater career. And yet here you are, superstar of the stage. Well, and yet here I am. Well, luckily I still don't have a theater career because that's the nature of having a theater career. That was coming to terms.

Yeah, yeah, yeah. So remember those things you had called dreams, kids? Well, it's better if you just cut those right on out. But no, seriously, like, yeah, no, it's true. You kind of look back and you realize, oh, wow, this is actually the thing that I've kind of always been doing anyway.

And it seems like I guess I am good at it or i should but serviceable yeah well it doesn't matter i was having i was i'm actually having a conversation with a friend of mine who's a new york times best-selling author brag brag uh but she was talking about a recent novel that she wrote she but here's the deal is that she got a degree from georgetown in law and she's uh i'm sure was headed to be a very competent lawyer she's a very intelligent woman uh when i knew her in college and uh but that didn't really pan out. And instead she wound up because she had this time on her hands while she was working crappy internships and really didn't have a whole lot of things on her plate. Uh, she wound up writing this book and it became enormously successful.

And, uh, I'm really proud of her. Uh, but the point is, is that, is that she was talking about how weirdly ashamed we were both sharing this cause I'm a writer as well. And, and, and there, this weird shame that we feel cause we all know if you're a writer and, you know people who are better writers than you. And chances are, like, they're like your friends and your cousins. You know, like Alma, like, in other words, you...

You don't want to admit it, but secretly to yourself. Well, it's not even that. It's just that you know, it's like you're thinking, you go through this massive... By the way, the life of a writer is a life of fear, children. Yeah.

It's a life of fear and insecurity that you will never escape from. I think that's an artist of any sort. True, true. Absolutely true. But that's just it.

Because the thing is, you know these people, these other people, who, yeah, no, they're not artists. They're something else. They're like a doctor or something. And you know what? They do the thing that you think is special about you better than you will ever do it.

And they do it in their spare time when they feel like it. It's really annoying when you see that. It really is. But the thing about that, though, is that that's not the justification for doing art. Talent is not itself the justification for doing anything.

Look at Ed Wood, one of the century's greatest filmmakers. It's great. No, no, no. Don't need to cut a thing. But no, seriously, though, the thing is what makes you worthy of doing something is the fact that you're setting out to do it.

You're setting out to put yourself on the line and make this your livelihood or your at least your hobby or whatever. This is your investment. This is your time. you don't need a better justification than that so what if if your cousin is a better writer than you are uh the very fact that you're the one sitting down and you're like man i'm gonna write novels that's a thing i'm gonna do that is your justification for being a writer not the fact that oh man well i entered this writing competition i won all the awards back in fifth grade like that is not the justification for anything right don't don't let your talent or lack of talent or any of that stuff define what you think you need to be doing with your life, because ultimately it's whatever it is that you are doing with your life.

You know, that's that's the circular answer for that one. So, hey, man, I'm just saying there may be better podcasts out there. I don't believe it. But yours is the only one I want to be on. Mine is the only one that I give my time and soul to produce.

Yeah. And that's why I try to reach out to people and be like, if you believe in any of this nonsense that I do, and there's a handful of people that do, I realize there's a lot of people that just don't care. And I've come to terms with that over the years. But I'm like, if there's anyone out there that hasn't signed on but is like, no, I at least... respect what you're trying to do and respect that you're still at it this far in just kick in a couple of bucks. And it, it, it does give me faith.

The fact that the handful of people that have so far, I'm like, you know, at least this group of people is like, you know, I appreciate the effort you put in. I like how much work you put into like booking guests or, or, or can, Again, just getting you guys to sit down with me. That's why sometimes it goes as far as years go by, and I'm like, oh, I haven't sat down with Sterling in a long time. It's just coordinating people to sit down and talk about something is such an ordeal. But hey, beyond all that work that you do and everything else, which you do work very hard, and we appreciate that.

I will say it's really remarkable that you've been able to put together under your own steam such a fine and excellent quality podcast from week to week. I will give you that credit. I say that, but if you say that, I appreciate it. Believe me, I say it partly because speaking as a man for whom half of my friends are imaginary and the other half are on podcasts, yours is one of my favorite. Well, that's kind of awesome.

So thank you. Absolutely, man. If you guys feel that way, yeah, go to moviemeltdown.com. The Patreon link is right there on the side. Help keep this dream alive.

And buy Heineberg's coffee. Damn the man. Save the meltdown. Where I stole it from. Yeah.

Download the transcript file

More from Movie Meltdown

Transcript

Loading the transcript…