Full episode

Kulture Meltdown: In the Mouth of Madness (1994) — "Do you read Sutter Cane?"

2 hr 36 min Explicit Full episode
Kulture Meltdown: In the Mouth of Madness (1994) — "Do you read Sutter Cane?"
The Kulturecast
0:00
2:35:37
MP3

About this episode

What if the horror isn't the monster in the book, but the discovery that you were only ever a character in it? John Carpenter's In the Mouth of Madness, written by Michael De Luca, sends Sam Neill's John Trent, a smug insurance investigator, after Sutter Cane, a vanished horror novelist whose readers are losing their minds, and into Hobb's End, a New Hampshire town that shouldn't exist. Is it Lovecraft without Lovecraft, a satire of '90s bestseller fandom, or a film about how a book becomes a religion? And is Carpenter's most personal late film also one with a third-act problem?

Movie Meltdown's Bryan Renfro joins Chris Stachiw, the Doctor of Podcasting, to talk the Apocalypse Trilogy, Wes Craven's New Nightmare, Jacob's Ladder, cosmic horror from True Detective to The Empty Man, whether great directors should keep working, and so much more.

———

The Kulturecast is a film and culture podcast from Weirding Way Media, hosted by Chris Stachiw, the Doctor of Podcasting, alongside a rotating table of guest co-hosts. Each week digs into where film and culture meet — and how each one bends the other. Now home to sub-feeds including Required Viewing: A 360° Film Study with Dr. David D. Perlmutter.

New episodes weekly.

Subscribe on Apple Podcasts → https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-kulturecast/id931361376
Spotify → https://open.spotify.com/show/5wjxip9XVYapYuY12yEaGY.
Back the show: https://www.patreon.com/cw/kulturecast

Transcript

Automatically generated, so expect the odd misheard name.

Hello, everyone, and welcome to the Culture Meltdown. I am one of your two hosts from the CultureCast. I am Chris Stashew, and I will always be Chris Stashew, no matter what anyone says. But I have a question for my co-host, the host of Movie Madness, and I think he knows what I'm going to ask him, so he better have an answer ready. Brian Renfro, do you read Sutter Cain?

I don't know how to read. What do? I feel like that would shut down most of your cult members that want to recruit me. They'd be like, oh, okay. Better question.

Do you drink Sutter Home? No. Whatever they're selling, I'm not interested in. That's me with pretty much all religions. So this is just religious nonsense to me.

I'm a bad fit for whatever cult Sutter Cain is trying to get me to join. But on this episode of The Culture Meltdown, which if you don't know what that is, that's the crossover show that Brian and I do once a week between our two movie podcasts where we talk about get this movies or TV or possibly other things. But I mean, I guess movies and TV right now are, are, are the two big things, but we, as I've said, I don't read. So that takes one of them out right there. No fucking kidding.

Yeah. Well there were odd man out on that one. Uh, but on this episode, we are talking about a John Carpenter film that is very near and dear to my heart. The lead from the film, unfortunately passed away just recently this year, uh, another actor that I know the two of us are going to spend a fair amount of this episode talking about. We're talking about.

1995's John Carpenter-directed Michael DeLuca screenplay, In the Mouth of Madness. So the film, like I mentioned, directed by John Carpenter, Michael DeLuca screenplay. It stars Sam Neill as insurance investigator John Trent, who is hired by publisher Jackson Harglo to find Sutter Cane, a best-selling horror novelist who has vanished before delivering his last book. Kane's readers are turning violent. Trent and Kane's editor, Linda Stiles, finds the fictional town of Hobbs End, New Hampshire, and guess what?

It's real. There's a whole. Lot of stuff going on in this movie. It is very much, in a lot of ways, a... Lovecraftian or Cthulhu adjacent property.

It is very much, though, a John Carpenter thing through and through. David Warner is here, John Glover, Bernie Casey, Francis Bay. Hey, Wilhelm von Homburg. Is here, a.k.a. Vigo from Ghostbusters 2, who, by the way, by all accounts, a real terrible human being.

Apparently the hell you say yeah. Uh but brian uh i'm very curious before we talk about in the mouth of madness specifically or for our friends who don't know how to speak well or good specifically thoughts on john carpenter the director and uh did amber heard ruin his career yes or no. No, because, I mean, he was on a downward slalom at that point anyway. No, because of John Carpenter's Ghost of Mars. Yeah, I mean, everything, Escape from L.A., Ghost of Mars.

I mean, I actually, oddly, I rewatched The Ward in the past couple of months, and I was like, yeah, this is fine. It's not your top tier Carpenter, but that's true of a lot of them. So I think that's what I realized. I am a huge Carpenter fan on very specific movies. And then the other stuff, I still, I always appreciate what he's done on He is amazing stylistically.

He is just he is a master when it's the right thing. And then there's plenty of other stuff he's done where he just shows up for work and it's fine. And now he's just an old, tired, cranky dude that wants to just smoke cigarettes and play video games. And I'm like, that's fine, too. Like, he should be able to do that now.

He's an old man. So there are some cigarettes, smoke weed, hang out, do nothing, cash residuals for other people making his keyboard. Yeah. I mean, good for him. You know, he's he's really living the life we all dream of, like, you know, making passive income off of merchandising from movies.

That are 40 years old. At this point that other people have made sequels to that. He's just like, well, I don't care how good or bad the sequel is. It's making money. And that's all I care about.

That's my favorite is how many times he's like, okayed this. He's like, gonna do a remake? Okay. Gonna do a sequel? Okay.

Just give me my cut, man. Keep using my theme song. I'm fine with that. Well, Nat, you know, I think for someone like John Carpenter, he's, you know, we talked about it. I just recently talked about John Carpenter, funny enough.

I talked about John Carpenter yesterday with John Carpenter's The Thing. And I think for me, I know people love Halloween, and I don't dislike Halloween. I think In the Mouth of Madness is my favorite John Carpenter movie. I think John Carpenter's best movie is The Thing. Halloween is good.

I think his trilogy of kind of apocalypse, as he calls it, should be Halloween. The Thing and In the Mouth of Madness. Prince of Darkness, like I appreciate John Carpenter likes that movie, but it's I don't know. I'm not a super big fan of Prince of Darkness. And I think that The Thing, this movie and Halloween tap into the void.

And I talked about this on The Thing episode I did for Required Viewing. It taps into the void and the ideas of nihilism that John Carpenter, I think, is imminently more interested in talking about because this movie is very nihilistic, very cynical, very meta as well, which I mean, some of it's Carpenter, some of it's DeLuca, but it is, this is very much a John Carpenter movie through and through, even if he did not write the script, which is not always the case. John Carpenter writes a lot of the things he directs. He's not one of those directors that doesn't write the things he directs. There are plenty of those directors too.

He's not one of them. Again, I've just, I've come to the Terms with the fact that there are true masterpieces that he is responsible for. And like, it kind of becomes a very specific, and that's the thing I would, it's crazy that my go-to, which should be Halloween. over the years kind of isn't. And like, don't get me wrong. Again, I love, and I do count Halloween as a masterpiece.

Like it is perfect for, you know, your intro to slashers. This is it. This is all you need. And it's so well done and it's so stylish and it's ahead of the curve of what was going on at the time. Not that he wasn't still kind of stealing from other people, but what he was doing was so amazing.

But, From the time I saw the thing the first time, I was just like, no, this is it. This is my movie, man. So that, I mean, is the true masterpiece. And I don't know that anything most directors are ever going to do can touch that. Like, I think the thing is just so damn good.

It's ridiculous. It's a perfect movie. It really is. It really is. And so is Halloween in a lot of ways, but.

I would say Halloween is a different kind of perfect movie, but I resonate more with the thing between those two. But I like In the Mouth of Madness more, even though I will 100% concede it is a lesser film than both of those films, because this is... I would not say in the mouth of madness is a perfect film. It is a film that I really like that really resonates with me. That really makes me feel a certain way about John Carpenter, but it is not a film that I would suggest to a broad audience even now, because I think it is in a lot of ways, like, and you know, I will, we'll talk about the third act of this movie when we talk about the third act of this movie, but There are problems with this movie that it cannot fix.

And that are not indefensible, but there are parts of this movie that are not great. And The Thing and Halloween don't really have those moments. If this movie was a literal perfect film throughout, I would say it... I don't know. I'm not going to say the third act is the only thing that hampers it from being a perfect movie, but it might be, I guess.

I really like this movie. I do think the problem with this movie is It's a little headier than The Thing. You know, The Thing doesn't really get into the nitty gritty of the themes and the things it could have. Which is kind of why it's so brilliant, I feel like. Right, I agree.

Because it's so everyman. It's so MacReady could give a rat's ass about any of this. Like he's just trying to save his life and he doesn't trust anybody else. And I was just like, that's what drives that movie and makes it so damn good. Well, and also, I mean, again, you know, John Carpenter, he makes changes to that source material that are so smart and well thought out.

That you know again he. And uh i forget who the i mean we talked about it just yesterday and i forgot who the writer is on that but it the decisions and choices they made i think paid dividends for that film now you know again i It's not that I don't think people have seen this movie. I think people have seen this movie and I think a lot of people saw this movie and were completely confused by it. And I'm not saying that it's not a confusing movie. I do think it is a confusing movie.

And I think similarly to another movie that I will probably bring up at least several times on this episode, but this movie reminds me a lot of Wes Craven's New Nightmare. It is trying to do something that movies at the time were not doing. I mean, this movie comes out in 1994. It is what. A year or two removed before scream comes out.

Like scream comes out after this two years after this, is that right? 96. Very close. Yeah. Surprisingly.

And, and scream, I think, you know, we always talk about how meta scream is. Scream is such a meta movie. And like, I do think John Carpenter and what he does, like he is, a deconstructionist in a way, but he is also, I think a lot more of a nihilist and a cynicist than he is who someone who works in meta all the time, because this is kind of his only meta movie. Like this isn't like, it's not like John Carpenter was only directing meta films. Like there's nothing meta about the thing.

Like the thing is played straight, which makes it such a great film. Like this film, the reason this film is so complicated is, is because that's the intention of the film is not trying to be easily decipherable by everyone. It's like, it's making you work. It's making you be an active film goer. And yeah, I'm not saying that The Thing isn't that way, but I think The Thing has suffered, and I talked about this on that episode, The Thing has suffered from, oh, who's alive at the end?

Like, who cares who's alive? Nerds just like to argue about stuff. Well, it just reminds me of Blade Runner. Like, was Deckard a replicant? Like, who gives a shit?

Like, it doesn't, my enjoyment of The Thing does not have anything to do with the way it ends. And, you know, The Sopranos are another one of those things. And so I'm much more interested as a film goer in a film that asks interesting questions throughout the film and then leaves me with not necessarily without answers, but with things to ponder. And that's for me in the mouth of madness is that film for Carpenter. Like it is his.

Kind of headier, more esoteric meta film. And I don't know, I've, Ever since I saw it, I always have resonated with it. So I put the question to you, Brian. Thoughts on In the Mouth of Madness? What's funny is I'm watching it going, this is kind of like a new Carpenter movie for me, which is weird because I have those.

There's like that 90s era that's almost like become a blind spot in my brain. Because most of them, I feel like I saw at the time, some of them in the theater at the time, and I've forgotten almost everything that went on in that era for a lot of those movies. And this was one of those, it's like, I remember the first like 10 minutes or so, I remember the asylum shot and that visual is really great. And then after that, I was like, wait, and then what happens? So as I'm going into this, I was like, most of this was gone.

And I'm just sort of immersed in this new John Carpenter movie, which is a treat, you know, you don't really get that these days. So I kind of like rediscovering it. I like kind of going through and deciding like, okay, number one, what do I think about it for a movie at the time? And then sort of reassessing it as okay. And now as the viewer now, what am I thinking about it?

So it was an interesting ride, uh, watching this and, and just kind of taking it in for the Carpenter thing that it is, which, you know, everything he does definitely has his fingerprints on it. So it is very John Carpenter. So you had never seen it before then? I had. And again, like I said, I remember the opening of it.

I had seen it, but it had been years and years to the point that I'd forgotten pretty much the entire plot. I had not gone back to rewatch it in so many years that most of it was gone. So I had seen it, but it was so long ago. It just wasn't one that I was revisiting, which some of them are. Some of them are ones I go pretty regularly and watch, but This was just not one.

So, yeah, it was kind of an interesting reintroduction to it. And, you know, for me, it's one that I watch probably once every couple years. I don't know if it's... I'm trying to think, like, is it a yearly rewatch? I would say it's probably more of a yearly rewatch.

Well, I don't know. I was going to say, well, you know, Halloween is. A yearly rewatch as well. Like, I always watch Halloween. But what's funny is.

I don't always go back to Carpenter's Halloween. Like I, I, Sometimes we'll watch Halloween Halloween. Yeah, correct. Some Halloween fix to get you through October. Yeah, exactly.

And so I don't always I don't always go back to Carpenter's Halloween, but I do watch Halloween. But I would say I probably watch this once every year, once every year or two. You know, it's it's one that I really like. And it's one that I would say it's kind of a one in one with this an event horizon, because it's kind of this event horizon and possession in terms of Sam Neill's horror things that i will watch and horror things that he's in that i like you know i i don't know i'm not running out to watch possession uh and you know if you haven't seen it maybe it's not imminently obvious as to why i'm not running out to watch possession but possession is a very intense movie and in the mouth of madness not super intense i guess i've never seen the omen 3 That's what.

I was thinking. I was like, you just want to see him as Damien. That's what you want. Well, and I've seen Daybreakers, but... I don't...

Okay. I don't know. It's fine. Event Horizon and In the Mouth of Madness, for me, are like the one-two punch of Sam Neill horror movies. Do you know what I mean?

Like, am I wrong in that respect? Yeah, I mean, I feel like, especially at this era, like, this was him. Like, anything... Because, like, the... just the punch in the face for America is Jurassic park. And then from there, it's like, okay, now you're a leading man.

Kind of. Nobody followed up after Jurassic park though. Right. Do what? Nobody followed up after Jurassic park though.

Like he's, I don't like him. I don't like, I guess my question to you, because I was a little too young in the nineties, did Jeff Goldblum and Laura Dern and Sam Neill become huge stars because of Jurassic park? I mean, Goldblum was already kind of like he was the name coming in compared to the other two. Right. Laura Dern had been working and was like amazing from the time she's a teenager.

But like she still wasn't like household name where Goldblum was already kind of like recognizable to your regular people on the street. And just from that point on, like that was it. Like it was everybody knew who Jeff Goldblum was by that time. But. Yeah, I mean, I feel like that was the introduction for a lot of people that weren't like hardcore movie people that didn't already know Sam Neill from the other roles in the earlier stuff.

So I feel like Jurassic Park was the main thing that just sort of. put it in everyone's face and was like, no, this guy. And then at that point they were like, oh, well now he's, he's a commodity. We can actually make him, you know, sort of a leading man on these movies that aren't quite as huge as Jurassic Park. So, you know, you can get even stuff that's weird sci-fi and horror and like, you can now add Sam Neill in there and just that name now means something. I think the, the Jurassic Park of it all brought so much money and so much attention that like just having someone from that, in your movie had to bring it up, you know, considerable as far as the attention you're going to get.

Well, and wasn't, I guess, was this, this was the second time that Carpenter and Sam Neill had worked together. Isn't that right? Cause they worked together on memoirs of an invisible man. So that's, Yeah, that's right before this. Right before this.

Yeah. Which I defend that movie a lot more than most people. Not the casting choice. But the movie, I think, is a really interesting Invisible Man story. I was going to say, what are you defending?

Because I'm curious. I would say it's not a bad movie. It's bad because it's not a bad movie. It's not a good movie because Chevy Chase is in it. Yeah, he's the problem.

And again, I'm not the first person to say Chevy Chase is the problem here. I feel like a lot of offices. No, I spent a fucking entire podcast talking all about it. If you want to. Here at the Chasing Chevy Chase podcast, I spent two years of my life talking about Chevy Chase.

That sounds like your questionable decision. I went from an ardent Chevy Chase defender to... I mean, I don't know if I would even call myself a Chevy Chase fan at the end of it. Like, you know, well, what's funny is like it coincided with the end of that. The end of the podcast coincided with that documentary coming out where he kind of like further made an ass of himself.

And it's just like, I have no, I have a hard time defending him. And to go back to the memoirs of the invisible man of it all, like he made that set pretty miserable from the sounds of it. And Sam Neill was on that set. Like most sets he was on. Right.

Yeah. Like, and Sam Neill was on that set with them. So what's funny is it's almost like, it's a mea culpa, like Sam Neill and John Carpenter want to work together again without that Chevy chase guy. Without that asshole getting in the way. Which, I mean, again, you know, it would only be, what, five, you know, three, four, five years later.

Yeah, yeah. And it's also weird, you know, Michael DeLuca, who wrote this movie, is promoted to New Line president and COO. Like, what? a couple of. Years before this movie comes out. It's, there's some weird stuff with this movie, right?

That makes it like, again, it does feel like a passion project by John Carpenter because again, he's working with Sam Neill again. And this is a very, like even for Carpenter, this is a small movie, right? This feels like a smaller movie than Carpenter was doing even at the time. Like even movies he'll do in the future, like this, even smaller than Memoirs of an Invisible Man. Yeah.

Scale wise, like I feel like it is like specifically once you get to that like small town, like it all takes place there. Even the stakes of it seems like it doesn't leave the little area that they're trapped in. Like you don't know that they're going to go take over the whole world. All we're sort of concerned about is what's right in front of us, which is this town and these weird people. And that's it.

Like it doesn't have a huge scope as as these type of movies sometimes do. But I think for me, that is what makes it so interesting is it captures the tone of Lovecraft stories and cosmic horror in a way that like things in the 90s like didn't. And again, like this is not Lovecraft. It's. It's like, again, it's Lovecraft without Lovecraft is probably the best way of putting it.

Once a long time ago in A Different Life, I did an episode of another show whose name I won't mention about movies that are Lovecraft without Lovecraft. And this movie is square at the top of that. This is not Lovecraft. This is Sutter Cain. But Sutter Cain is Lovecraft.

Or Stephen King, I guess. It's... That's what I was going to say. This to me, it's a lot of different things coming together at the same time in the middle of this movie. So it's also like such a sign of the times of the completely overwhelming society, like pop writers.

You know, it's like it is Stephen King more than any of the other ones. It's also, you know, at this point, you've got your Dean Kuntz and your Michael Crichton like taking over like they had been for years. But like they kind of hit a pinnacle of all these super poppy writers just becoming like everybody was reading them. So it did kind of make sense that this story came together when it did. Like, I don't know that you could have done this story before.

At this level, even 10, 15 years before, like those even some of those same guys are writing at that point. But the the population just hadn't caught up with that yet. The weird fandom that built up around them didn't fully kick in until you get like towards the end of the 80s and then heading into the 90s. Everything sort of becomes that just pop culture wise. Yeah.

Well, and you know, what's funny is I would say this film has benefited from the uptick in cosmic horror being a thing that people are really into now. Like it is very popular now. And I think John Carpenter was right to do something that was like, and maybe not Lovecraft, but Lovecraft adjacent, because, you know, again, it may not have been the thing at the time, but it has become, I mean, Cthulhu is mainstream, right? Like it's, very much a mainstream thing now. Like so many other things that I could not have believed in the nineties would have been mainstream are now very, very mainstream.

At least known what it is. Like if you go back, even at this point, most people wouldn't know what Cthulhu is. Wouldn't probably wouldn't know even my name Lovecraft versus now. It's all just kind of become, again, it's moved into full on pop culture at this point. So people know what that is.

They know what the references are, even if they don't care about it, even if they're grossed out by it, like if they think it's evil, which people still have that kind of response to his works. So I think, yeah, for me, I think I had the other version. I don't, I've never paid that much attention to his writing. But everything I've learned about the person over the years makes me dislike the writer more and more. So I'm just like, yeah, I don't really care about Lovecraft for that reason, because he seems like a horrible human being.

Yeah. He has some, I mean, again, you know, questionable morals, but. I guess in my mind, I always have a hard time with holding anybody who makes art accountable for their morals, given that I know people that make art and they have questionable morals, whether or not it comes out on screen or what they do is, you know, some people are better at hiding it than others. And some people just, they mine that shit directly for their, uh, For their source material. You know, it's funny.

I'm with you. Like, I've read some Lovecraft, but for the most part, for me, Lovecraft is not. His. Works are, like you said, something I've appreciated through others. Not.

I'm not coming into this like, oh, I'm a huge Lovecraft guy. Like Lovecraft is my thing. And the reason that, you know, this film failed was because it wasn't enough of a Lovecraft thing. And people were expecting, you know, it's like the whole Prometheus argument. It's like, well, I went to the movie expecting alien and it wasn't called alien, but it was an alien movie.

It's like, I didn't go into in the mouth of madness going, well, if this isn't Lovecraft, I'm going to be disappointed. I couldn't frankly have fucking cared less if it was Lovecraft. Like, like you said, it's, enough without having to make me be the one who has to know things about this writer coming into it, which I appreciate. The other writer of this, specifically of this era, but the one that also I feel like took that away well completely overtook the lovecraft thing with his own version of it is again the one i didn't name is clive barker this is the era of clive barker just totally catching on and people knowing you know once again anybody that knows a writer by name like that's you've got to cross over because plenty of people are out there watching you know whatever's on tv But if you get to the point that like someone writing books becomes so pop culture that your average random person on the street knows them by name, like that's a big deal.

And that was Clive Barker at this point. And his stuff was Lovecraftian, but he had his own weird spin that he put on it. And that's something I also felt in this. I felt a lot of like, yes, it seems like they're name dropping King and they're using sort of his his impact on society at that point. But I also feel like there's a lot of Clive Barker kind of mixed in with the look and the feel of the stories that we're kind of using, maybe more so than King.

Definitely a lot of Lovecraft. But again, the 90s version of Lovecraft just became Clive Barker for me. Well, and I always joke about this whenever I go to a bookstore that actually sells horror. Books and someone will come up to me like, oh, you're looking for someone? I'm like, well, I'm looking for a horror book that's not written with a K in the last name.

And glad you guys have more than like. Well, for the longest time, it was like horror was like K and nobody else. And now that's not the case. Like. I don't know how easy it would have been to even get Lovecraftian like text or like Lovecraft, like write his stories, like compendiums of his writings.

I don't even know if that was a thing you could do in the nineties. Like I have personally no idea. I know you can now because you know, half-braced books and the internet. And I think all of those books are, I mean, all of his stuff at this point is like, it's public domain, right? It's out there.

And like, like read it on your browser of your phone, like different versions of, you know, completely compendiums of everything he's ever done. So I think, yeah, at this point there's so many people putting out his stuff just because you can. And because there's, again, now there's also such a horror fan base for anything horror that is movies, but also books and just anything horror related. I mean, just, halloween supplies at this point you know anything that's horror related people will latch on to so it's just got a fan base that is so much bigger and wider spread than anything going on even in the 90s. Well and you know we talked about i've talked about this recently on other things and i don't know maybe it was you and i that talked about it but there's just so many more people with so many more diversified tastes And the Internet really has allowed people to watch things that they like and not be, you know, beholden to the 10 channels on the fucking TV.

You know, you hear about Chris Carter and all these other creators who were creating TV shows in the 90s and the things that they were influenced by, the things that they were influenced by. They're like one of the last wave of creators that could have been influenced singularly by terrestrial TV. Like the generation of content creators after them were ones that grew up with some version of the Internet and like that directly or, you know, at least like a fledgling Internet. And that allowed them to, yeah, really tap into things that people were not aware of and were not able to see. I mean, you know, someone like Quentin Tarantino. was able to be successful because people hadn't seen the movies he was aping.

Yeah. That's it. Like if people had been able to see those movies, they would have just said, hey, you're ripping those movies off, dude. Like that's it. But again, the internet being what it was and people having access to certain things, like now you can watch In the Mouth of Madness on Tubi.

It's available for free on like Roku and Tubi. And, you know, you don't even have to pay for it to watch it. Like when it came out, the only way to see it was go to the theater and it was in the theater for probably two weeks. It wasn't huge. It was, yeah, it was mediocrely received, I guess, which is again, it wasn't poorly received.

It's like critical score has gone up since it came out, but only about like 6% on the aggregate. Like that's, not that much and yeah it's found an audience since it came out but it hasn't like you know no one's like where's the in the mouth of madness sequel like where you know where you know that's that was the thing in halloween like those were the carpenter things that people wanted more of that they got more of and i guess in some respects big trouble in little china as well but that's kind of always like the weird odd man out i don't know why but for me it always is To me, that's like the third in my trilogy. It's Halloween. It's the thing. And oddly enough, Big Trouble in Little China has...

It just continues to grow on me as time goes on. It's just a fun movie. That's the problem with it. Like it's, but it's low stakes, which is why like I always forget because it barely feels like a John Carpenter movie. But it also like it's, it's grown on me, but it's also the more I watch it, the more I'm like, actually, this is so well put together.

And like it, I think it comes off effortlessly, but the more I've watched it, I'm like, this story is like, well put. crafted and a little tighter put together. Like if you pay attention, like if you just sort of watch it, you're like, Oh, that was fun. But like the more I've watched it over the years, I'm like, this is really well written. And like, it's just, it, it has no seriousness to it because our lead is a doofus and like, he's a brilliant doofus, but like, he's just such a goofball that like, you can't take anything seriously and, So, yeah, it feels very different than every other John Carpenter movie. But I don't know.

The more I watch it, the more respect I have for it as a movie. Are you saying James Woods in Vampires is not a doofus? James Woods has become more of a doofus this time. Yeah, he's more of a doofus now than I think he's ever been in any moment up until now in his fucking career. He can turn in amazing performances, but...

He's in one of my favorite movies. Like, that's the worst part about James Woods. He's like, he's in Videodrome, which I. Yeah, I just did like a year and a half or so ago, did a whole episode on Videodrome and just. Like, it's just, which happens a lot in Videodrome.

Just a lot of gross gushing going on. A lot of, what is it? I equate the end of that movie to a General Tso's chicken buffet. It's just a lot of... When the guy's exploding it, it's so gnarly.

I love that movie, man. A lot of grossness. I loved it so much, yeah. I was just... So, yeah, that's the hard thing.

It's like, man, James Woods is so good in that because... Of being James Woods and like you get those performances early on and then the more time goes on, I'm just like, oh, look at this crazy old man. So, yeah, thankfully, we don't have to worry about him in this film. I was going to say, you know, we're we're talking about a film that we're we're at that point. We're what, one film away?

Is it one or two films away from this being John Carpenter's In the Mouth of Madness? Because it's John Carpenter's vampires. Don't forget. It's John Carpenter's Ghosts of Mars, right? He's putting his name on things here pretty quickly, which is.

And calling your shot, I guess. He's one of the few that did that. Like, he kind of called it early on when everybody was like, wait, how come this guy gets to do that? How do you feel about that, is my question. Again, if you weren't John Carpenter, I would think it's kind of a, just how full of yourself do you have to be, buddy?

But then when he comes almost out of the gate with Halloween, I'm like, all right, you're not wrong, dude. You are John Carpenter. So he just came out pretty solid, not counting Dark Star. I people love it. I don't know.

I just I couldn't I couldn't get into dark. You're going to have to leave the network now. I'm sorry. All right. I just inappropriate in.

You don't like Dark Star at all. I couldn't get into it. I get it. I get it. It's just again.

So talk about something that's so silly. I can't even like invest myself in it. And I'm like, I like goofy comedies, but like the, I just kept trying and it just kept falling flat for me. And I'm like, I see what you guys are going for here. And like, again, I like everybody involved, but it's just not hitting.

I don't know what it is. So jump ahead a few movies and he's knocking out masterpieces. I'm like, it's, it's, it's pretty, pretty quick turnaround for somebody. And that, that's why I'm like, well, I guess you can slap your name on the title then. It's a, by the way, it's, Escape from L.A., which is the first film that becomes a, quote, John Carpenter thing.

So, well, no, I mean, before that, it's it's just, you know, title of the film. They Live is not John Carpenter's They Live. It's just They Live. It's not John Carpenter's The Thing. It's just The Thing.

But from Escape from L.A. on, it's like John Carpenter's Escape from L.A. And it's like, who else's Escape from L.A. Would it be? I understood when it was vampire. I think it's in parentheses, even in Halloween.

You're like, we all know it's John Carpenter. Well... we have. To say that now because of a fucking Rob Zombie movie, but Rob Zombie's movie is called Rob Zombie's Halloween. Like, why are we, because he's copying off of him. No, we have to call it John Carpenter's Halloween because of David Gordon Green's Halloween, which is just called, which is just called fucking Halloween.

So it's dude, the fucking naming conventions of Halloween are insanity. Almost as bad as the timeline of those movies. My God. Like, Eventually, just don't worry about it. Just watch the movie in front of you at the moment and.

Go with it. And just assume that at some point they'll reboot it. We promise. We promise. At some point it'll loop back around and some of this will make sense, but probably not.

Yeah, it's always cracked me up when people are like, David Gordon Green's getting Jamie Lee Curtis for the first time in how long, though? Because this is technically the second time. Or technically the third time, yeah, depending on how you want to count. Like, it's... I mean, again, retroactively canceling all those movies, whatever, fine.

Yeah, they kept doing that. It's weird. John Carpenter is, yeah, he's a director who kind of, wandered away ignominiously like his last couple movies hit this i i mean i talked about it with with mike white on the recording we did for the thing like i don't i think this might be the movie that is kind of his last possible good question mark movie for most. I was gonna say that i was i feel like this is right at the point where he seems like he's not invested like he used to be And I don't dislike the rest of them. I've watched most of the others, but it doesn't feel like he's all in like he used to be.

Those 80s wins, even the ones that aren't amazing, they're John Carpenter's. His heart and soul is in this thing, even if you think it's weird. Versus the further you go in into the 90s, it's just like, Yep. John Carpenter made a movie again. And like, they're fine sometimes, but they just do not feel like his heart is in it the way it was on the earlier stuff.

Does the John Carpenter-ness of it all seem to get in the way? Like, is he getting in the way of himself? Did it all start with body bags when he's like, I'm John Carpenter and I'm in this as John Carpenter? I'm just, I'm asking. I'm the Rod Serling of this show.

I'm asking because like fucking post body bags, man. Like most people are like, eh, really? I don't even like I know there are probably people that would say, you know, it's it's they live. And that's as far as I'll go. And like, again, I'm not sure that those people are wrong.

If you're looking for a certain kind of thing that Carpenter is doing, I would say this is still as close to classic Carpenter as he gets. Nothing else beyond this gets close to the way things were before this. I feel like it starts changing, though, and again, not after this or before this. During this movie. Oh, yeah.

No, I feel like you can see his career change by the time it gets to the third act. Because the third act is a mess. But I think even the filmmaking is different in this. Like, we get... And to me, it's like, it's also...

That's kind of what I was saying before. Not only story-wise is it of a time, but even within the filmmaking of it, I feel like it's changing because the films around it were changing. And John's like, oh, maybe I'll try that. So... Like, I don't even know that he's like specifically doing anything.

I think it's just the filmmaking at the time was becoming something different and people were doing weird, different things that I start. to see in this that I don't remember in other ones and I have a I have one that's like a watershed movie and I don't know that anybody else will agree but I think it's a weird thing that I started noticing a lot of movies changing the way that they were cutting stuff and the way that they were presenting special effects and after Jacob's Ladder, of all movies that nobody really cared about at the time, but it was doing weird visuals that were kind of different than what people were doing before that. And it was doing this weird editing style and it was doing this weird conglomeration of stuff going on real quick.

And you were just like, oh, what was that crazy nightmare scene? And like, so I feel like at least I noticed it changing after that point. And I feel like there's times in this when it'll go to one of those weird nightmare scenes or it'll do quick cuts of 10 different things going on two seconds at a time that I'm like, I feel like that's a filmmaking thing that was going on in this era in the 90s. And it's different from what Carpenter was doing before that. So again, not really good or bad.

I just noticed it being different than what he used to do. So why Jacob's Ladder? I don't know. Cause that's, that's, and I, I'm sure somebody out there knows of other stuff that was doing it. I mean, again, I can even think of stuff that was doing weird dream sequences and weird visuals before that.

But I feel like there was several different, like specific things that they were doing with these weird cuts, almost the way that they were cutting together the, the people moving really fast. And like, they would do this weird editing thing that I hadn't really noticed before that movie. And then I would see in your every horror movie that came after that would do. We're going to take a couple of, you know, a couple of shots out here or a couple of frames out of it. So it looks like this person jumped ahead a few spots and their head flipped around real weird.

And then to the point where later you like every music video at that, like it became the most run of the mill thing ever. But I don't really remember seeing it before this era when we start seeing it come into play. So, again, I think it's just filmmaking changing at the time. And that was just where I noticed it. But I'm sure it was, you know, continually changing.

This was just something that I noticed. Was Jacob's Ladder successful enough for that to have been a thing? I don't think it was financially, but I think a lot of people saw it. And I think a lot of people that were working in the industry, I think it was one of those that was it got a weird cult feeling. built around it over the next couple of years. It's one I don't think that many people saw in the theater, but a lot of people saw on VHS and on cable.

And they were like, oh yeah, that movie's kind of weird. And like, I think it started to kind of creep into the way that people were starting to do things at that time. So again, I think it was more of an impact that it had versus actually being successful originally. Jacob's Ladder is such an odd film. It is.

I remember even at the time going, I mean, I guess I liked it. I still don't know how to process. I'm like, it's it's got really interesting stuff in it. It's very unconventional and it's structuring, especially for the time. Now I've seen a ton of movies that just do that.

And I'm like, oh, they pulled a Jacob's Ladder. So like. To me, there's so many things that it ended up impacting that like at the time were different, which I don't know. Now, a lot of those things, both visually and story wise, have run of the mill. It's just what happens in movies now.

You are not a fan of It's All a Dream? I mean, not that that hasn't been going on for a long time, but that was a different take on it, I feel like. So I think that was just one of those. Yeah. Yeah.

I don't, you know, Jacob's Ladder is such an odd film. It really, I don't know. I mean, I'm not saying In the Mouth of Madness isn't an odd film, because In the Mouth of Madness is also a very odd film. It's very, you know, I would say this much, like, it's a very odd mainstream film. Yeah.

Because trying to be mainstream and to your point about like, well, Sam Neill post Jurassic Park, like, but Sam Neill post Jurassic Park was still not fucking Tom Cruise. No, definitely not. And I mean, you know, let's let's talk about who John Carpenter, I think, has worked with. I would say one of his actors he's worked with the most, if not, like I would say the most prolific in terms of his career. And you tell me if I'm wrong here, but in terms of actors he's worked with in a prolific nature, it's Kurt.

Russell, right? I mean, that's the go to for and for me. And again, because two of the three masterpieces for me star Kurt Russell and the other one is pretty damn good. It's entertaining, at least. I mean, he knocked out three right at the same time there with him as his main lead.

And I've I've always said there should be a fourth. And I think it just didn't come together because tell me they live as it meant to have Kurt Russell in it. That guy with that look is Kurt Russell. He just was probably bigger at that point and had other roles going on and he couldn't get him. And went, who else can we get?

Who else has shaggy hair? Hey, look at that wrestler guy. I swear that was written and had to be for Kurt Russell. Well, and that's the thing. I think...

I distinctly remember Carpenter didn't want Kurt Russell. He wanted someone who, I mean, here's the thing. He wanted the, an every man type, but rowdy, rowdy Piper, like it's not an every, well, that's the thing. Like he is, but he isn't, but he is like, if you're asking me as like a wrestling fan and I know you're not like, you're not like an unknown wrestling fan, but you know, like rowdy, rowdy Piper, uh, versus a Hulk Hogan is more of an every man than Hogan is like in terms of size and in terms of size and stuff, I. Guess more to your, I think what you're like, your point.

Is like less like the specific like facts of it, but like, it does seem like it would have been a logical final act for them that would have worked better than escape from LA. Cause escape from LA. I mean, good God escape from New York. What's fucking crazy. Escape from New York came out in 81.

It came out 15 years after the first one did. 15 years is, regardless of when that time is, that's a lot of time. That's a generation and a half worth of people. Escape from L.A. failed for a whole number of reasons. One of them is, who the fuck cares in 1996 about a movie that came out 15 years earlier?

That was not successful when it came out. Escape from L.A. Was, you know... It's structured so weird too, because at least New York is like its own little like streamline. Here it is.

Like, here's the thing that's going on. Whereas LA, that's why it makes no sense. It's like, it's weird that it's the same director and the same star. And like, it seems like it should be able to follow suit and be similar to that first one, but it's so segmented and it just sort of loops around on itself. And like, Each thing is its own little weird.

Here's a 10 minute snippet of a story and this thing is going to be self-contained and this character is going to leave, but he's going to come back in like 20 minutes. Don't worry. Like it just keeps doing the same weird moves over and over. And they're all just silly. Like it's so like at least Escape from New York takes itself seriously.

We're nothing serious in Escape from L.A. Well, and I feel like, I guess that was the intention, right? Like, it was meant to be more fun. I think it's purposeful, but I don't know why. Like, I don't know who he thought that was for.

It's not fun that way. Not the way that the sequel is. It's entertaining, but it's not, I don't know, it's so goofy. Once again, I get to a point, I'm like, why are we watching this again? Don't get me wrong, it has its fun moments, but it is a silly movie.

And I wouldn't say John Carpenter is a silly director. I mean, that's the other thing. No, like John Carpenter is not someone who I'm like, remember that one comedy that John Carpenter wrote? Like he's, again, like he's a pretty... nihilistic guy like he's very cynical in the movies that he works on I mean maybe the least maybe the least cynical film that he has worked on and this I think you probably agree here the least cynical film and I'm not talking TV movie because I think the least cynical TV movie or least cynical thing he's ever made it's probably that Elvis movie but the least cynical movie he's ever made like big screen film Starman right Yeah, I mean. That's pretty uplifting for him.

It's E.T., but they get to make out. Yeah, it's E.T., but with Jeff Bridges and Indiana Jones' girlfriend. Yeah. Okay. But who doesn't want those things?

I mean, 84, yeah. Yeah. But I mean, I mean, I guess, you know, technically, to be fair, Jeff Bridges of the two. I'm taking Jeff Bridges now. I mean, he's, you know, dude, I still like Karen Allen.

I don't care. I just I feel bad for right now. I feel bad for Karen Allen because she was so tacked on in that Indiana Jones movie. It's just like she needs a win in this lifetime. That isn't just like, well, you were in this thing 50 years ago.

And people people who are 50 plus years old now remember like, okay, it's such. A really love Marion. Come on. I don't know if that's sure. Sure.

Fine. Yeah. Great. Uh-huh. I don't know.

Maybe it's, you know, it's funny. Like John Carpenter, when I think about his entire filmography, his filmography, I think broadly is one that, I don't know. Like he does have a through line, but he is a, I don't know. Like when you think of John Carpenter, what do you think of as a director? Like what do you, what is your like, Oh, this is John Carpenter.

Like what's your John Carpenter thing? It's the thing for you. And that's it. Like I know the thing. Yeah.

Like, but outside of movie wise, like what is your like take on John Carpenter as a director? Like outside of like, Those specific movies he's made, like, I don't know, like, what's your read on him as a director? Now it's all just recent stories. It's just, you know, old dude with long hair being cranky and complaining about everything that goes on in movies, mostly other directors. And, like, just smoking a lot of cigarettes and, like, not really wanting to make movies anymore.

That's where he's landed now. And that's kind of what I think of when I think of him these days. Which is a shame because he's... Yeah, I don't know. He's a director of a certain generation whose films...

I mean, again, people are still remaking and doing things with and making sequels and prequels to even now, so. And it's not like you get, oh, you're too old, you can't do it. I mean, Spielberg's still doing it. Scorsese's still doing it. Clint Eastwood's still doing it.

Like, these guys are still cranking them out and they're as old or older than you, man. So, like, there's no excuse, really, except he just didn't want to do it anymore. He's just... it's too much trouble. Like, I don't want to go through all that. I'm just going to hang out at my house.

Like, I don't blame him really. But at the same time, I'm like, it's a shame because I would have still liked to have seen more John Carpenter movies. No. And, and that's, you know, that I was going to say, like, before we kind of talk some more about the movie proper, like that is the thing for me, like in the mouth of madness is a weird spot for him as a filmmaker, because I don't really like anything past this. And yeah, Everything before this, within reason, I'm a fan of the things I've seen.

And I think the things I haven't seen are maybe someone's watching me and assault on Precinct 13. And I think that might be it. I think I've seen everything else. I've seen Precinct 13, and I feel like it's a good concept. People love it, man.

I know a lot of people that really love it. Mike White, one of those people. It's weird because to me, it never addresses why... the people are so drone-like. I'm like, these are just like gang members. These are just like punks.

And yet they behave like they're zombies or they've been taken over by aliens or something. Like it's so like, and I know some people will make that part of it. It's like, no, they're just supposed to be mindless drones. And they're just, I don't know. I just feel like if you're going to make that part of the story, make it part of the story or just have them act like actual like individual characters but they kind of don't like they're just they're a placeholder they're like here's the threat coming after these people and here's the concept that we're doing the Alamo so it's like I get it I like what he's doing as a concept and I think it's still impressive especially for as early as it was But again, it's not my favorite because of that, because it's a little weird because he just doesn't bother to address why the characters act the way they do.

He focuses on the good guys, but the bad guys are just like, eh, whatever. It's just a weird move to me. Well, and I was going to say, in something like In the Mouth of Madness, some of the reasons the characters act the way they do make sense from a narrative standpoint. In this weird world, it makes sense. Yeah, why Sam Neill is the way that he is, why Julie Carman is the way that she is, are understood because they're characters in a book.

Or even the whole town. Everybody in the town also is acting weird, but I'm like, it makes sense in this story. That is part of what we're watching. Right. Well, I was going to say the other the other thing I guess I asked to you here at the opening of this conversation about In the Mouth of Madness is by your approximation, what is going on in this movie?

Because like I mentioned, I mean, it is a film that has stuff going on that is I wouldn't say unintelligible. But when we start having a conversation about meta stuff and things that are meta, it's hard to maybe distinguish what. The lines are on things. And what is actually going on and what is in a character's head or what is X or Y or Z. So best you can tell what is happening in, in the mouth of madness.

Cause I gave a, you know, a synopsis if you hadn't seen the film, which I don't know why you'd be listening to this if you hadn't, but what by your approximation is what's actually going on. Like, can you explain what's going on in the mouth of madness? Does it need to be explained? I guess. I think first I want to go into the opening of it, which led to a weird aspect of the story that I may have known a million years ago and forgot, but it also ties into something I've noticed about your classic TV shows and specifically like the heroes of these shows.

So I thought it was weird that it also tied to this movie. But again, if you're an old person and you watch me TV all the time, which is now a lot of my viewing habits, it's sad, but... There was a lot of those weird detective shows that I don't think I paid that much attention to a million years ago when they came on, but now they're rerunning them. And I'm like, that's kind of what you think of, these cool, tough detective guys, your Mannixes and your Cannons and your Barnaby Jones, and they're out there solving mysteries and stuff every week. And then now I go back and watch them, I'm like, you guys work for insurance agencies.

It's like Barnaby Jones, that's his job. He's not like a cool film noir detective that this sexy girl walks in and he takes a case. He week in, week out works for an insurance agency and he's busy trying to bust people that are trying to stick it to the man. You're not going to take money from this multi-million dollar corporation. I'll have none of it.

It's so like, dorky at this point when i'm like wait that's what this cool action show which by the way that guy's 100 so it's not much of an action show but when i watch them now i'm like this is built around a dude working for a multi-million dollar insurance agency and he's trying to keep them from losing any money That's a really weird move for your detective show, which also happens with all those other shows in the 70s and 80s. They're all detectives. And the more I go back and watch them, they're just trying to keep somebody with a lot of money from losing more money. So as we get into this movie, I'm like, this dude's just working for an insurance agency. I think that's a weird hero to have in any story.

But in this story, it's even weirder because once you get into this, the craziness of the cult-like religion behaviors and book writing and Cthulhu small town craziness. And then, yeah, it all starts with a dude working for an insurance agency. So that was my first comment was, that is a weird person to put all your money on is Yep, this dude that's really good at telling if people are lying when they're trying to stick it to the insurance agency. It is, yeah. Again, I didn't have a problem with it.

I just thought it was funny as I got into this. I was like, oh yeah, this is like all those weird detective shows. Yeah, it's odd to me that. I don't know, like the every man this of this movie with Sam Neill. Right.

Like he he plays an every man for John Carpenter in the way that I think John Carpenter is trying to get out of Rowdy Roddy Piper. Sam Neill is really like good at just playing a guy. It works with Sam Neill. Yeah. Yeah, it really does.

And I believe him. Again, I think it's more like concept wise. Like as you get into this, you're like, oh, so again, you assume it would be more of like a cool artistic take on it. Like, oh, so he's going to be like the author of the book and he's writing this creepy book and things are happening. And then you get in there and you're like.

No, works for an insurance agency. So they really dial up the every man of like, and again, if it weren't Sam Neill, I don't know that it would work. Like, I think if he didn't get the right person in this role. from the beginning, you'd be like, what are we watching? Why am I invested in this guy? But Sam Neill's good at it.

And you do watch him bust that guy at the beginning for not only trying to burn down his own place and take the money, but also screwing around on his wife. And you're like, no, this guy is good. All right. I i see now why we're following him he's on top of things so like again i think the fact that it's sam neill is what makes it work even when it's a weird running an insurance scam so i guess my question to you is the entire story as we're seeing it is a book yeah Eventually, again, I think it's one of those that starts off like we're in the real world and then eventually we're not in the real world anymore. And by the end, it's like it loops back around and you're like, wait, so did we start in the real world?

I don't know. Maybe like I don't know that we're supposed to know 100 percent. I think it does leave it open ended enough that you can be like, well, here's what I think, which is, you know, kind of what you want for dorks that have their own podcast. Yeah. here's what I think happened in this movie. So again, I like, I like movies that leave it open to interpretation enough.

Like you have to at least pin down a few things along the way, but which this certainly does. So yeah, I like that it starts off very grounded. And by the time we get to the town that goes out the window and it just continues to get weirder and weirder. till the end when you're just like, I don't even think we're in reality anymore. I think all of this is crazy made up book stuff. And again, that that's, I feel like is what he was going for.

You know, that that's the story he's trying to tell. So I, I'm fine with it like that, but yeah, I think it is sort of a gray area. Yeah. I, I feel like we don't necessarily see anything in. The movie at all.

That's not taking place in the book that, uh, Sutter Cain is writing again, you know, it's, it's so weird. Like what the movie I feel is about is I guess like the, the process, not the process of being a horror fan, but what it, I guess I had to say, I don't know like what it means to be a horror fan or fans of horror and how to horror fans interpret the things that they're watching. Like I have a hard time understanding, I guess what this movie is about. If it's about anything at all, like it does feel like it's trying to say more about, than just like, oh, this is just an entertaining John Carpenter movie. That's the part I can't tell.

I can't tell if I'm expected to read more into this movie or not. And I guess that was the question I was getting at. Is there more going on in this movie, or am I just searching for something in a movie that's kind of asking maybe more questions than another John Carpenter film might have? I mean, I think it's throwing out a lot bigger concepts, again, maybe even than a lot of John Carpenter, probably a lot more than future John Carpenter movies. But maybe even more than some of the previous wins.

I think it, to me, that is a big thing. And maybe again, apologies for people who are very tied to their religious beliefs, but I'm like, to me, this is a lot about religion. To me, this is like, as much as it is about the, again, the, like I said before, the pop culture fandom that was taking place of of just writers in general at this point, and then horror as a whole was becoming bigger and bigger, and the fandom that surrounds that, I think it's equally as much asking the question of like, okay, what's the dividing line? At what point are you not just a pop culture figure, but you become a cult figure that you become almost a religious figure? It really is sort of...

Asking that question, blurring the line and kind of leaving it up to you of like, okay, which is it? What is this thing? And I think it is sort of like that everybody comes at religion with their own beliefs. and attaches themselves to the beliefs built within it. And like, I think that's kind of what's going on in this movie too. Like some people are going to latch onto that and see way more of the religion aspect.

And then some people are just like, Oh, look at those cool monsters. So I think it leaves it very gray area for that reason. But I think you also kind of bring that with you. That's, that's kind of what I love about, you know, like I said, dorks talking about movies. I think it, it gives you a chance as the viewer to decide what you think and how much you bring to the movie and then what you end up taking away from the movie.

And I, not every movie allows that as much as this one does. I would say most, if not, None of Carpenter's movies allow that. Not normally, no. I'm not saying Carpenter's movies don't have ambiguous things to them. I mean, fucking Halloween ends with Michael Myers getting away.

But this movie... If you ask someone who watched this movie, what happens in this movie? I feel like people be like, well, I don't have a fucking clue. You tell me like, you know, to have the film end with him watching the film version of the film we just watched is intentionally. I wouldn't say misleading because I'm not sure what direction you're supposed to be led in with that.

But it's like it's intentionally confusing, right? like it's or. Just playing it's toying with the audience right like it's like yeah where the lines are blurred intentionally like what we're doing is intentional we're not original audience you're sitting in the theater eating popcorn like sam neill like you've it's come full circle you're in the movie now essentially you're part of my experiment i'm playing with here And I like that about the movie. Like it does for as meta as the movie is, it almost feels more like the film is playing with the audience directly and not like, again, like I wouldn't say like not in a meta way, but it's in a way that I haven't seen a lot of other films do even again, to go back to the new nightmare of it all, like even new nightmare doesn't do that.

Like new nightmares playing with conventions of nightmare on Elm street. And it's like crossing into the real world. Like what if the horror you create became real kind of a thing versus this is the other way. This is like, what if you got sucked into your own creation and like, then you yourself don't even know, am I in the real world? Am I in this creation of my writing of my movie making of all of it?

Like, it seems like it's sort of addressing that question of like, what if you just became part of your own artistic creation? And what happens if you find out that you've never been real to begin with and the world that you live in is a creation of someone else's? brain question mark like. Again like that's the ultimate question at the center of this movie is Sutter Cain has done what like Sutter Cain has done what and it's he's created the entire world of this film and again the question by the end of the film doesn't become what is going on but how far does what Sutter Cain is Sutter Cain has created extend to Because, again, if you if you go off what the movie is doing, the movie is essentially saying the world that we live in is created by Sutter Cain, even because we are, again, meant to be Sam Neill, I guess, question mark.

Well, and again, I maybe it's again because I'm always looking for this, but like I also take that religious aspect of it. I'm like, so by the end, we've got this guy sitting at a typewriter just writing a book. But then again, enough to piss people off when I say, OK, isn't that just don't we have people that have looked at this book that someone wrote somewhere back and whatever day you want to go with, whatever story you want to go with, how this book came to be. But like they're now basing their lives on it. They are caught up in this book and letting it dictate everything that goes on in their life.

And essentially it was just somebody came up with some stories and now your entire life has changed because of it. And you're part of this in some way. Isn't that religion? Like, so we've got, you know, the town is falling apart even before we get to the crazy, you know, little town version of it. In the city, we've got riots going on and we've got people just attacking each other and insanity going on all based around this guy writing a book.

So it's creating once again, it's creating a cult out of it. But that cult is a fine line from a religious cult that I'm just like, and now it's so widespread. It's like everybody's kind of falling under its spell. So I don't know. That's that's where I start, like looking at it is like what it thinks it's representing or what I think it's representing.

And like, I think a lot of it to me was way more of like that end of it is like what Who's in charge of creating these stories? And are these stories so important that they change people's lives and that they change the world around us? And again, whether it's the fake movie of it all or the you're telling the story and people have turned it into something much bigger than you originally expected. Like, I don't know. I feel like that's a key element to this from the way I'm looking at it.

And I totally agree. Your read, I think, is another interesting one. It ends up, I think, for me being such a fun movie to talk about because, again, it kind of asks you to not feel a certain way coming into it, but it is kind of expecting that you're going to come into it with your expectations of what this movie is going to be and how it's going to Approach what it's doing and it plays with your expectations as an audience. Member. Like it really, I think knows maybe in like, I think in a lot of ways, like John Carpenter knows.

Why you're here. And in a lot of ways he plays with the expectations of why he knows you're here to see his film. Like this is a, relatively bloodless, kill-less affair. It is a horror movie, but in a lot of ways, it is a horror movie of the mind. It is a horror movie, and cosmic horror tends to be that.

I think of something like True Detective, which I just recently watched again, the first season. We don't see a lot in that show. A lot of it is the theater of the mind. It's audio that we hear, or people describing things that have happened, but we're not It's not like the monster, the Jeffrey Dahmer story where there's blood and people getting ripped apart on screen. It's a rather bloodless affair, but the stuff that they talk about is genuinely horrifying, like systemic and.

Institutional violence. Toxicity and that like leading to like power and people doing awful things to get powers like that's horrifying. But yeah, it's not as, you know, visually horrifying as a person being stabbed in the head or hung up on the wall by Michael Myers. Like I get it. It requires you to actually like sit and think with it as opposed to just like, Oh, I see the thing.

Like, and I'm not saying visually disgusting things can't be off putting, but there's no amount of art, the clown dismembering or disemboweling someone that could replace some of the things that are described in some of the best movies. Like, you know, for as disgusting as seven is a lot of that movie takes place off screen. Um, For as disgusting as, again, as disgusting as something like even Silence of the Lambs is. A lot of that movie takes place off screen. Like, you know, or I mean, the TV show Hannibal is more grotesque.

Than the movie ever got. And that's because I think they realized people needed that because that was part of something that people wanted and wanted. Again, I remember something like Zodiac. People were so disappointed at that movie for it not being a bloodletting in terms of the things that we saw. And it's like, well, that's never going to be the point.

Again, it's a detective story more than anything. Well, and same with this movie. This movie is a detective story. You are as blind to what's going on as Sam Neill is throughout the entirety of the movie. And I think that works to the film's benefit.

I really think that the film. one of the successes of the movie is we are figuring out what's going on, quote unquote, along with Sam Neill. Like we're not, we're not eventually right. Like we're not privy to what the fuck is actually happening in this movie at any point. Like we are, I think we are as lost. I, I don't know if Sam Neill figures out what's going on either.

Maybe until it's too late. Like I think by the time he even has a clue, he's gone crazy at that point. So it doesn't matter anymore. Yeah. Well, that's what I'm saying.

Like it's too late. Like he's, you know, that's the thing, right? With cosmic horror is, you know, horror, horror is in a lot of ways. Like what you make of it. And in this film, like a.

Lot of the horror from this film comes from the fact that like Sam Neill has gone crazy. Yeah. Like he's having what is going on in his life directly described to him by the Julie Carmen character. Like he's looking into the void and like, she is describing what he is doing. That would drive anybody crazy.

If you are anyone with autonomy, you are broken in that moment because you realize that the autonomy you thought you had has been a lie your entire life. And if that's a lie, what else is a lie? Because that's the deepest of lies. And that's, again, like you said, it comes back to, well, there are real monsters in this movie, but In the Mouth of Madness really is a stand-in in a lot of ways for religion. and people losing themselves entirely to religion, or something that they, again, give themselves over to entirely, and they maybe don't understand the ramifications of even what that means. And I think at its headier moments, that's what this film is getting at.

I think what's funny is, and you tell me how this statement lands, this is maybe not the right kind of film to be made by John Carpenter. I don't know if John Carpenter is the best director for this kind of film. I think he's having fun with this. Sure. Don't get me wrong.

Yes. Because I feel like he's always one that's making use of his role to like manipulate the audience. Like he's in Halloween or in The Thing. Like he knows what it is that's going to creep you out. He knows what it– so he's usually doing that. but he's doing it in a more subtle, like understated way in the other ones where this one, it's just right out front.

He's just like, what can I do now? That's going to mess with these people. So this one is, I think probably a very freeing version for him, especially at that point, he'd made a lot of movies by this time. So maybe this is him just kind of messing around. This is just him like This is his, you know, he's he's a music guy.

This is his jazz. He's just like throwing it out there like, yeah, let's try this for a while. Let's throw this in there. See what they don't think of this. Like it feels very free in the way that it's approaching the storytelling versus his other very structured versions of movies.

And, you know, I'm not trying to drag the movie and say, well, like, I don't because it's not as John Carpenter as some of the other John Carpenter things I've seen. I don't like it. Like I said, this is my favorite John Carpenter movie, which I think maybe speaks to how much I actually like. John Carpenter as a director. Like the one of the least John Carpenter things like a admittedly like the latest of late John Carpenter's in terms of the movies that people will actually like is the one that I like.

Like, go figure, of course. I'm not going to say I'm a contrarian, but like sometimes I am with certain things and I can't help it. Like, you know, it's, I res, I think I resonate with this because, and. This is just me. And like, I realized this as I've gotten older and like watched more, uh, things of this kind of ilk, I, for whatever reason, really resonate with cosmic horror.

And I mean, one of I mean, again, like I just mentioned, some of the things I've watched recently, Wes Craven's New Nightmare, True Detective, Midsommar, The Wicker Man, like those are all kind of of a variety, like maybe some. Are more folk horror than others. But I mean, even Midsommar and the Wicker Man are kind of trafficking in, like, we're commuting with a bigger power, whatever that bigger power is. Small town gone crazy, and it's maybe because there's some weird bigger thing going on behind the scenes than you want to realize. And by the time you figure it out, you're dead or crazy.

Right. And, like, I... Really love that idea. Like, I love the idea of there being I mean, again, like to go to like, you know, I wouldn't say I don't know, like Twin Peaks is obviously like cosmic horror adjacent. I think David Lynch, like I don't know if David Lynch would even want to say it's that because like he was such a I'm doing my own thing and I don't even want other people's things to dictate how you interpret my thing.

But it is cosmic horror adjacent. I would say Blue Velvet, in a lot of ways, is cosmic horror adjacent. The seedy underbelly, the void of that town is Dennis Hopper. And again, to go to this movie specifically, Hob's End is. Not a real place, but it is a real place because it's been conjured into existence like a tulpa by all these people reading Sutter Cain.

You know, I just recently talked about The Empty Man, which I feel like has some ideas in common with this movie. Like the ideas of Sutter Cain are being made reality. by the people reading his book. I mean, again, we just talked about Videodrome, like Videodrome, same idea. Like it's my favorite. Yeah, pretty much.

It's my favorite David Cronenberg movie and it is not, would you say it is David Cronenberg's best film? I think it's the most Cronenberg movie. There are elements of him before that that are creepy. There are elements after that that are way more polished. But it's the most like Cronenberg doing his Cronenberg thing and the body horror of it all, all just kind of coming together to gel in one big gross thing.

I think it's the most Cronenberg. The Fly might be his best, but I think Videodrome is his most Cronenberg. And it really... It really, I don't know. It really is in a lot of ways, but I would say almost for me, the most Cronenberg movie that, I don't know, like I was gonna say The Fly though.

The fly is very polished, though. I think this was so still knee-deep in the muck of his early filmmaking that it's the dividing line, almost, because it's not much further until you get to the fly, but the fly feels so polished, comparatively, whereas you can still see the paint on the things that he's making in Videodrome, and yet it's still so effective and so weirding people out in a way that... he was probably dreaming of with his first couple of movies. Yeah. I, yeah, I, yeah. Okay.

If Elgar, sure. If that's where you're coming from, I agree. It's, you know, I guess the thing. About the fly is also the fly is not Cronenberg's thing to begin with. Like it's very much.

I would say, I don't know. It's filtered through him. Well, and, you know, you could say the same thing about John Carpenter and The Thing, but I would say in terms of The Thing, The Thing is much closer to the original story than it even is the movie. The who goes there at all. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Cause the original movie is not even like, it's such a different weird thing. It still has some basic concepts that are coming into play in the, in the, you know, the carpenter version, but just like dipping a toe in compared to what we get in the carpenter version. Yeah.

No kidding. I guess for me, John Carpenter and his take on things like I, I, I feel like he is the one to do in the mouth of madness, obviously. And like that, we obviously get that with the movie he did, but at the same time, like he's just, I don't know. His, his filmography is so, I wouldn't say all over the place, but in a lot of ways, like it is all over the place. Like he's not, I can, like, I wouldn't say like there's any one thing like we've said already with the John Carpenter of it all.

Like what makes a John Carpenter movie, a John Carpenter movie. I mean, they are very different. They are all very different. Because the ones that are big titles that I even forget are John Carpenter. There were so many times when I have to remind myself, oh yeah, Christine is John Carpenter's Christine.

And there are moments that feel Carpenter, but there's a lot of stuff that just feels like an 80s horror movie and a very King treatment of it all. But that doesn't... feel the same as like a lot of the other like Carpenter movies. And that's the more you look at his whole rundown, you're just like, I don't know. Like I don't, it's a vibe. It's again, an approach he has to the characters, to the stories, maybe at least in that seventies and eighties era.

I do feel like it changes by the time he hit the nineties. And like I said, I think it's also because he just doesn't feel as dialed in anymore. I feel like it changes his because he's just sort of probably getting tired of making movies. So it's more of a job at that point. But I think that's it more than anything is the seventies and eighties have a vibe that like tie them all together.

And it's different as, you know, assault on precinct 13 is from, you know, Halloween or escape from New York. They all feel like they sort of exist in the same universe more or less. Yeah. I guess my question to you is, because we've seen this now with other directors, is it better to just walk away. And stop making film?

Or is it better to kind of continue to make film and hope that you make something as good as things you've made before? Because I don't really think, and you can correct me if I'm wrong, But I don't really think that Scorsese has made that. Great of a film in quite some time. And we can have a discussion whenever we do a Scorsese film about when that is. But it's been quite some time.

And my opinions on certain late Scorsese films have changed in the last couple years. Because there are films of his that I used to really go to bat for that I don't even really like anymore. And I'm not even sure people talk about or think about anymore. And it's like, I don't know, man. I'm so....

Jaded anymore because sometimes i'm like maybe it is better to just stop while you're ahead and i mean john carpenter wasn't ahead when he stopped like good god he could. Have stopped several movies earlier no offense but yeah well dude i mean anytime you're and you know like look i'm i'm not saying amber heard in terms like all the johnny depp of it all like no amber heard in terms of. She's not a great actor like she's just not great and the ward being carpenter's last film is a bummer because she's not great as an actress and she's the main character in the film like it's. I can't like i said i just watched it recently it's not bad like again if it weren't john carpenter you'd be like oh yeah it's fine but it's because it's john carpenter that it brings so much weight with it at that point they're like oh this was john carpenter's last movie like versus if it was some dude you'd never heard of before you'd be like yeah movie was all right it wasn't just.

John carpenter's last movie it was john carpenter's last movie and his first movie in 10 years at that point like he had taken a step away for 10 years to come back with that and oh by the way the movie before that was the was one of the movies that again i was hearing about for the longest time before i saw it about. How bad it was with ghost of mars people love that movie Nobody knows that. It feels very. And again, as it's been a while since I've watched it, but it felt very segmented. It once again felt so much like Escape from L.A.

It's like that became his move was these. Here's these little snippets of stories that I'm just going to string together with this overarching story. oh, journey, we got to get to here. We got to do this end result thing. And then we can just drag all this stuff together into a movie. But like, it doesn't even feel cohesive like either of those movies.

So like it was just getting into bad habits by the end of the run, I feel like. And I think that's again, like that's again, the question I pose to you, like. Should this should if this had been John Carpenter's last film, would this have been a disappointment if it had been his last film? I don't think so. Like if this is what you go out on versus like, again, is anyone going to bat for anything past this in a substantive way?

Yes. I've heard people making like, Oh, escape from LA is not as bad. Like, yeah, but it's like as bad as much. No, that's a fucking like, that's faint fucking praise. Like, I'm sorry, but you know what?

Here's the thing. Why would I watch a not so great carpenter movie when I could watch a escape from New York? Like it, It's not like I live in a universe where I can't find Escape from New York if I want to watch it. Maybe I don't have it imminently available immediately, but four bucks can change that on most streaming platforms. I just bought a copy recently, so I have it at the ready right now.

And if you don't, it's on fucking YouTube or Netflix or HBO Max or something. And if you don't have one of them, you could probably... get a free trial and watch it. Like it's, you don't have to go to the goddamn library anymore. So I, I'm not saying like, why should we watch good movies and bad movies? Like, I'm not saying we shouldn't watch bad movies.

I'm just saying in this day and age, if you have limited time, I can understand why escape from LA is not your bag, but I don't think it probably shouldn't be, but I don't think anything past this movie is having a lot of people going to bat for it. But my my answer to your bigger question, not even so much the John Carpenter of it, but should anybody just walk away versus keep trying to do stuff? I will always side on. I'd rather see people just be creative and make stuff and make more stuff. Is it going to be good?

Maybe not. Is it going to be as good as your greatest thing ever? Maybe not, but like a, you don't know. And B you're what else are you doing with your life? So again, my only answer for him is if he wanted to stop, then yeah, stop.

I'm not saying force this guy to make movies, but, But I'm like, if he's happy right now doing not movies and just hanging out and playing on the synthesizer and playing video games, good for him. Do it. But of the like the other directors out there still doing it, your Scorseses and Spielbergs that are still doing it. Like if you're happy making movies, man, do it like because, you know, it gives you. it gives the world your creations that like otherwise wouldn't happen. And like somebody out there is going to like this thing that you made.

And even if they don't screw them, if you enjoyed the process of making it, that's you creating something like, I don't know. I will always push for people to be creative and put something out there into the world, regardless if it's what you want to do. So that's the only time I would say, you know, is it a good time to stop is if you don't want to do it anymore. then yeah, don't force yourself to do something you don't want to do. But if you're still liking the process of creating, then I say keep putting it out there. Even if I look at some of these aging directors and don't respond to their stuff as much anymore, I'd still rather have them putting stuff out there.

I'd rather have them creating another movie that might, you know, give us one more masterpiece before they're done for all we know. But even if they don't, They're interesting, usually, like I can watch any of those and still find something that that I think this person has something to say. And I think you get directors that sometimes have something very different to say the further they are in their life and in their career that like you wouldn't get if you just stop when you're 30 or 40. So I don't know. I would encourage, you know, filmmakers to keep making stuff if it's a possibility and they want to do that.

I think, you know, again, like I've seen The Irishman. I've seen Hugo. Like I'm not going to beat up on Scorsese specifically because we're talking about John Carpenter and we're sitting here and having, you know, discussion about his things that he worked on later in his career. But I do struggle with some of my favorite directors later films because they're not– They're not as good as the things that they came out with before. And like you said, it's a shame, but it shouldn't stop them from making things.

I do think we should stop making things when our heart's not in it, to your point. Yeah, I think so. out and be good. There's nothing saying it can't, but I don't know. Like then I, then I look at facts based, uh, logic, right. And like, not, not feelings based.

And, you know, that's the part where it's, I have to kind of divorce myself from things. And yeah, I struggle with directors who have made things later in their careers and whether or not those things are very good, because a lot of them are not. And I'm not trying to be a dickhead like I'm just like, did anyone go see The Irishman and go, man, this is as good as this is so good. Like, I'm so glad we waited 20 plus years for this film. And part of it is that right.

Like part of it is the the weight of. some of these directors only work like every five to 10 years. Some of these directors aren't working all the time. I mean, David Lynch, what the last thing David Lynch did before he passed away was twin peaks three. That was it. Like, and that was what, 10 years.

Before he passed away, much stuff he put out. We, I'm so glad they let him do that. Cause I'm like, if he would have just one done one two hour movie, but like now look how many hours of him doing his, His thing that we got late in his life that I'm like, once again, I'm like, he was driven to do it. Somebody gave him the money to do it. And like now a whole new group of Twin Peaks fans have found them, you know, because of this entry point.

And from what I've heard, like there's a ton of younger people that have gotten into the original series because of that push at the end that might have never found it because of that. So I don't know. I still say keep working. And if you get something good, that's great. If not, maybe it's a window to the old masterpieces that they wouldn't get to otherwise.

One, I mean, that that is for me the obvious thing. Not unintended consequence, but it is the thing that is the, well, benefit. Of this that you'll get, right? People will kind of interact with things that are not this. I mean, I would say anybody who's worth half their salt as an executive over at Walt Disney slash Star Wars slash Marvel is hoping that anyone who resonates with the current things are going and spending money on all of the other things that have come before it, because there is a large catalog of things that have come before it.

And that is, that is how you make money. Now you don't make money on all these other, not weird things, but there used to be like, Oh, it's Nielsen ratings or, Oh, it's the box office. Now it's like, it's streaming and merchandising. It's like, it's residuals. It's all these things that are harder to put your finger on because it's so much It's so diversified now.

And that's not a bad thing. Having all these opportunities to see movies. For all the opportunities we have to see movies, that means all these studios are making the opportunity for us to see the movies. You can go illegally download pretty much anything. But that's not what I'm talking about.

I'm talking about engaging with this in a... in a legal way, there are so many more ways to do it now. Like there have never been more ways to buy, uh, escape from New York than there are now, like, or any of these movies, like it's, you know, even if it's not just buying it as much as just watching it, like there are ways to watch these things. And so, yeah, I, I agree with you because, you know, like you said, things will find an audience eventually, but at the same time, like I, I hate that so many of these directors like Carpenter worked further than they needed to on things that were not befitting of their talents. And like we've already said, and like you said with David Lynch, They gave David Lynch the opportunity to make a full season of Twin Peaks great.

Awesome. I'm glad, and I'm right there with you, and I'm all for it. But there's no universe where they weren't ever going to let someone of David Lynch's caliber do something. That's the other thing. I don't know.

Look at all those things he fought with in the middle there. I know, but he wanted to make things that they wouldn't let him, and they kept taking the budget away from him. I'm talking about when we finally got to 2014, when that show came out, like when it became a legacy thing. Do you know what I mean? Like, it's I don't know, like John, I bet people have asked John Carpenter in the last 16 years to do stuff.

Right. But that's I think it's unreasonable to think they haven't. And I genuinely think there will always be a spot in Hollywood for John Carpenter if he ever wanted to work. Same with David Lynch. Like, I think David Lynch was done.

I don't think the, I don't think it was like, well, we're not giving money to David Lynch. Do you know what I mean? I think David Lynch was just done. And that's the thing, like with John Carpenter, Carpenter's just done. Like it doesn't, you know, like.

I think he has been because from what I heard. There's no amount of money they could give him is what I mean. Like he's done. His heart wasn't in it because the last thing I remember hearing about that he even directed was one of the, It might have been one of those last Masters of Horror, but like something for TV. And he was doing it from his house.

They'd rigged up a camera so he could sit at home and smoke. And like they were beaming in what the guys on the set were shooting. And he was then kind of telling them what to do without bothering to come to set. I'm like, dude, that's when your heart's not in it. Like, that's when I say not just don't even bother at that point.

Just give it up completely. Yeah. It's like if you want to go make an album, you know, sit at home and play with your synthesizer and make an album. But like you do what you're passionate about. You phoning it in literally from your house is not passion, man.

So just that's when I say stop. But like if he was. full on, like, you know, ready to come out and make a movie now and geared up to do it, I say do it. Like, again, we might get something amazing out of them. Even if we don't, it's the same argument I have for the remakes. You know, people are, oh, they want to complain about a remake or complain about some new legacy sequel.

And I'm like, it doesn't change the other one. So if, if Carpenter comes out of retirement and makes some garbage, does it take away from the thing? Can you not still go watch Halloween? Like, I feel like they're still there. Like even if he does lesser movies further into his career, like it doesn't take away from the masterpieces that he did.

And maybe something will be good if it doesn't, maybe it's at least interesting and gives people something to talk about, which again is what we, what all of this is for us anyway. And that was, again, that's, I guess, where I come in as well. Like, I'm with you. Like, if your heart stops being in it, stop doing it. But at the same time, like, know that if you make something, it may tarnish the things you've done before, like, irrevocably.

Like, I'm not saying, like, oh, everything John Carpenter worked on has been forever laid bare because he made the ward, but sometimes it's better to just go out on your own terms. And he did go out on his own terms eventually, right? but even at the end there, like you said, like, even then it's like, well, dude, like, don't. Don't come on. Like, don't even like, what's the point? Like it's, what's crazy is to think about it.

It's, it's so much work. You have to go and do a thing somewhere else and do all these things. Like it's the coordination of all of this is a job in and of itself. That's why producers exist. Like that's literally the job of the producer.

So it's, Think about the worst job you've ever had and then imagine doing it elsewhere for four to six weeks. And that is what being on a film set could possibly be. Like it's, you know, because again, there's no guarantee it's going to be great. Like, but there is a guarantee that it could be bad. And so just think about doing that elsewhere.

Like, why the fuck would people sign up for that if their heart's not in it? It's not like going to an office. It's really not like I mean, you know, people that have worked on sets as well as I do, like outside of just the people we talk to and listen to in the industry. But it's a lot of work to just be a fucking director of an episode of TV, let alone a movie, let alone a movie that shoots anywhere international. Like I just it's it's so much work that, yeah, like you said, if your heart's not in it, fuck it, don't do it.

But what you know, perfect example of that, I mean, really is John Waters. He did it for years. He loved it when he was young. And he got to that point later on in life that he was like, and he said it, I've heard him say it. It was too much trouble.

Like it was just, it was not worth the effort for the money they're going to give me for the budget that they're going to give me to make a movie. It was more work than it was to do it. And then he found other things he was passionate about. He's like, I can go write a book and make more money that way and be glad I did it. I can go on a tour and just stand up and talk to people and still tell my stories without all the bullshit that goes into making a movie.

And it's more financially successful and people are equally as happy and I'm invested in it. So it's like he found a better way to do these things and still be creative and still be vital to all his fans, right? without turning out a movie that even he wasn't interested in making so again that that became a great example of somebody who just decided it wasn't worth it anymore but didn't just give up and sit at home like he's been doing stuff consistently since he stopped making movies he just didn't want to deal with the bullshit of making movies Which is understandable. And it, you know, I also assume and, you know, this is now, you know, we were joking. I don't know if we were joking about this before we started recording.

I guess I was probably talking about it during the recording. But the idea of like, yeah, I would probably fucking do nothing as well if I could make all that Halloween money. It's why wouldn't you like Jesus Christ? Like I've heard about how much David Gordon Grimm. Green's residual check was because I know someone who knows someone who was there when he opened his first residual check from the Halloween movie he directed.

And his first residual check was a million dollars. Like fucking come on. Like John Carpenter. I'll take it. Okay.

Right. Like John Carpenter didn't get no money from all of his Halloween films. Like he's been making money. Like he, he has. And so, yeah, like he doesn't have to do anything.

And there was probably going to come a point in his career where he didn't have to do anything. Anyways, is my point. Like it's, you know, once Halloween became the legacy franchise that it has become, and it's become kind of one of the. Big boys in terms of branding. And he didn't have to do anything.

I'm assuming he gets part of that residual. I guess I'm assuming he gets part of it. He would have to. Specifically on the remakes of his stuff, he would have to get a cut, I would assume. The original who knows, but yeah, I assume there was going to come a time where Carpenter was just going to be done anyways.

Like it's, you know, it's, I don't know, like Carpenter is just, it's a, it's a weird situation because I do wish and wonder if he had not stopped what we could have seen and the people he could have worked with like that, you know, it's always, it's like the pro wrestling thing, right? Like it's, it's a shame that X wasn't around when Y was working because it would have been interesting to see the two of them wrestle. Like I say the same thing about film directors and actors. Like it's a shame that John Carpenter is not working now or has not been working in the last 10 years because there were plenty of actors that I would love to have seen him work with, but I guess he could not be bothered to work with them either.

And that's the shame of it all. It's like, I don't know if John Carpenter just is done because of, legitimate reasons or he's done because of personal reasons or he's done just because he's done. But it's a shame either way, because the things I think of him doing with actors, I can only imagine. And the things that he might have done may have been even better than the things I could imagine. But I know either way.

His kind of voice and the things that he brought to film, it is a shame that he is no longer working because he did have a. Seminal and unique voice. And I think in the mouth of madness is one of those, like a film that yes, he did not write the script, but his fingerprints. Are all over it. Definitely.

Yeah. I w I will say, do you want to discuss the thing that may be the most weird and disturbing in this whole movie and all this weird, crazy stuff going on and, looping around as to what's real and what's not and literal monsters. But to me, the creepiest thing right off the bat, John Glover. he is just way too cheery. I don't know what is going on when we enter into the asylum and John Glover is waiting for us there with that creepy smile on his face. And I'm like, I don't know what's going on with this guy, but I don't like it.

So that was maybe the most disturbing thing in the whole movie. I love John Glover. I first saw John Glover in Gremlins 2 where he plays fake Donald Trump. He plays Clint. Daniel Clamp.

Which is just, I don't know, like it's so on the nose. I know. Gremlins 2 is one of the better, I don't know, like I'm going to just say this outright, like I don't really like Gremlins. I love Gremlins 2 though. Like I love, I've seen Gremlins 2 so many more times that the amount of times I've seen Gremlins 2 would be exponential to the amount of times I've seen gremlins.

Like I've seen gremlins maybe twice, three times. Maybe I've seen gremlins too. So many times that I bought one of the Mondo posters that they did for it. And it's not, it's not one of the better ones, but it is one of the ones that they did. And I bought it because I absolutely love gremlins too.

But it's like Dante and I would say like, would you say Mick Garris as well? Like it's a lot of the, well, maybe not. I don't know. Like who, who are John Carpenter's contemporaries? Like, like a Joe Dante, like what names am I missing?

I mean, yeah, I mean, they all started at that time. So it's just depending on what else they were doing. And I think again, those other, examples lead to guys who just found other stuff they wanted to do. Even if it's, and again, our area hanging out, talking about movies, which, you know, granted, that's kind of what both of them been doing, but definitely Mick Garris, like from the beginning, that's how he got into it before he was even a director was hanging out with people talking about, you know, Hey, how did you make this movie? What is, what happened behind the scenes here?

Like Joe Dante just wanted to do that because he was just such a film fan from the get go. So I, I, Those are good examples of like guys that have gone on and aren't working as much as a director anymore. but are still invested in the industry. And like, they have as much fun talking about filmmaking as the rest of the geeks out there. You know, it's like, those are the, that, those are the ones I don't feel bad. They're like, Oh, it's a shame.

They're not making movies. I'm like, I think they're having more fun doing what they're doing now than probably again, turning in movies that they weren't being handed the budget. They wanted to do what they wanted anyway. Like, I think they have more fun doing the stuff they're doing now talking about movies. I mean, the question is, why don't we have John Carpenter directing a Marvel movie, right?

I mean, that's the real. I mean, that's the question that the world has always asked, is what would John Carpenter direct? I mean, fuck, dude, we actually got a Sam Raimi Marvel movie. I mean, we did. And it's very Sam Raimi.

Four of them, frankly, which is even more fucking insane. Definitely, that last one was very Sam Raimi. It is very much, in a lot of ways... I don't know. Like, yeah, I guess I don't I don't wonder what movies Carpenter would have made.

But I worked with and when his contemporaries like you said, like Joe Dante hasn't really made shit in a long time either. Like, no, none of those dudes have really like, yes, Spielberg still making stuff. But even a lot of Spielberg's contemporaries aren't making movies anymore. Like it. It's kind of like a rarefied air of like the older generation working anymore.

Like I would say in a lot of ways, like even, even someone like Ridley Scott is. Surprising that he's working. You know, we were joking about it because we were talking about possibly covering blade runner, the TV show. And it's like from executive producer, Ridley Scott, like that doesn't mean what it used to even anymore. Like, But that's I guess that's I guess that is the outlier case that proves what I'm getting at, which is like at some point you could fucking sour your reputation so badly that you should have stopped.

And Ridley Scott is one of those directors. Like he even came back for a film that people wanted with Gladiator 2. And nobody wanted it. And nobody wanted it. And he even was like, fucking Paul Mezcal is a sissy boy.

And I don't like that he's bringing emotionality to the role. And it's like, fucking, have you seen a movie Paul Mezcal is in? Like, he's not Russell Crowe. I'm not saying Russell Crowe doesn't have any emotional range, but his range and Paul Mezcal's range are very different. And Ridley, yeah, Ridley Scott is, in my opinion, one of those directors that's like soured his reputation by continuing to work to the point where, it being a Ridley Scott thing is like, well, I'm not even sure I want to watch something he's been involved with, even when it is things that he popularized like Blade Runner and Alien.

I mean, he's another one that just kept working. And like, that's, I think it's just a different approach from different directors. I think some of them just would do, it might be five or six years between movies and they'd get around to doing another one or they'd put a lot of prep work into it or something. But like Ridley Scott never had that. Ridley Scott's been knocking them out one after the other year after year since the first movie.

And like, that's just... again, to work ethic, I guess I'm impressed with that. I mean, who puts out for movies specifically something that takes that much time and energy? Who puts them out that constant? Like, it's almost overwhelming to think about, especially at his age now. So, I don't know.

Like, I guess it's impressive. Not the movies sometimes, a lot of times lately, but I don't know. Like, it's it's just depends on how you approach it. Like if you're willing to keep showing up and doing the clocking in part of the job, it's sitting there in the director's chair day in and day out for movies that not everybody's thrilled about sometimes. I don't know.

Well, you know, I, I guess, I guess I can always hope, you know, maybe John Carpenter will make something else. I, I, you know, maybe a girl can always dream, but I, I think, I think I'm okay with, uh, him being done. Because again, like, like we've said with something like in the mouth of madness, like if, if you stop here, this is a pretty good movie to stop with. Like, and, and, you know, I would say it's funny in a, in a lot of ways, you know, to, to talk about another director that I've mentioned one of his works. In a lot of ways, I feel kind of similarly about Wes Craven and New Nightmare, where I'm like, I.

Don't really vibe with a lot of Wes Craven's. Yes, I like Scream, but Scream kind of is good, but it's its own thing. Like it's, I appreciate that it's Wes Craven, but like, I think Wes Craven and like, it has been somewhat shown that you can make a successful scream movie without Wes Craven. Like, I will say like, maybe not the most successful scream movies, but like Wes Craven, I guess like scream is probably like in my mind where Wes Craven's career for a lot of people, like that's the secondary high point. But like, Man, John Carpenter never had that second moment of like hitting another high.

Like at least Wes Craven kind of had that a little bit and then kind. Of, you know, stuck around. I mean, Scream 4, however you feel about Scream 4. But John Carpenter never had that like second moment of like, well, he put out that one last thing. It's like kind of just limped along to the end, which I mean, again, like it is what it is.

My question is, where is John Carpenter's music of the heart? Dear Jesus. God, where is John Carpenter's silence? Where is John Carpenter's for the love of the game, damn it. Yeah, where is John Carpenter's bug?

Like Friedkin with bug. Remember how many people were like, I love Willie Friedkin's bug. It's, I don't know. There's somebody out there saying that. So you just got to keep cranking them out.

And there's one weirdo somewhere that's going to be like, man, I love music of the heart. And you'd be like, all right, well, there you go. Somebody liked what I did. Damn it. Yeah, I guess I can't.

Yeah, there is. Yeah. Look, at the end of the day, I think when we talk about where Carpenter has been and the things he's worked on, like his his influence is still around. Like there are so many people, you know, we've seen the reboot. Of the thing come out or the remake or prequel or whatever you wanna call it, they remastered the video game to the thing and they added a John Carpenter cameo.

Again, like you said, we've had Halloween come out with reboots, both Zombie and David Gordon Green get a full trilogy and Zombie almost got a trilogy. John Carpenter's presence has been felt even if he stopped making films. Because he was still making films when other people were rebooting his movies. Again, Zombie and him worked together for... Worked at the same time for, what, two years?

Because the first Zombie movie came out in 2007. So Carpenter's last film came out in 2010. So they were even contemporaries. And he's always still kind of attached. He'll still be some sort of executive producer, associate producer.

Making the music for the David Gordon Green movie. He will still come in and make the music. That's what I was just saying. The last one, he... redid a new version of the song because he can like he's just hanging around the house why not so again that's what I think he should do like just put out albums or something like find something else you are interested in putting that energy behind if he wants to, I don't care. Like I said, if he wants to hang around the house and do nothing, do nothing.

But like, if you still are creative enough that you want to get something out there, like, yeah, do the weird John Carpenter jazz album. And like, who cares? Like I just find something cool to do and be glad that you're doing it. Yeah, no, I, I, I agree. So let's, so I, I, again, you know, John Carpenter specifically kind of in the, in the rear view, I want to talk about the Sam, the Sam Neill of it all and the effects of it all, because I think obviously, you know, Sam Neill, a huge part of this movie, the lead of this movie, one of the better parts of this movie, but also I would say similarly, the effects.

Are really good. I don't, again, you know, what we see of the creatures, I think it's very odd how little we see of the creatures, almost like they didn't trust the, creature effects that they had even though it's being done by k and b so you know i mean when you do see it they look interesting and weird and unlike i would say the closest we see is maybe that weird floating thing from hellraiser and one of the creatures looks very similar to that thing that ashley lawrence runs into in the in the back hallways of the the centibite world but It's weird that for as good as Sam Neill is, we see as little of the creatures, if that makes sense. The creatures are very underused in a film where we are told how bizarre and weird and monstrous the creatures look.

And I guess it does make sense because, again, cosmic horror, it is the thought and idea of it less what we're seeing. But don't tease me with a good time when I know KNB is working on the practical Lovecraftian inspired effects. Yeah. It is one of those that ease their way in. Like at first there's just, you know, the real world stuff and him reading the books and like sort of nothing weird and crazy metaphysical craziness is going on.

But like the further we get into it, we get to the town and then you get like the weird painting on the wall. But again, that's like a practical, oh, look now it's different. Like it's just... easing our way in with little touches of look at these weird lovecraftian creatures and then like there's there's basic stuff but even then it's just like here's some regular dogs like they're scary right like so it really isn't until you get to well into the halfway point of the movie if not the last third before they're just like okay here's some monsters but like I don't know if it was just because it's still kind of minimal budget for this type of movie. Like, I don't feel like you see tons and tons of effects money on the screen until you get to the end.

And then like, they do give you a wall of monsters at some point, but like, I don't know if it was, if it was budget restraints or if it was just, they didn't want to show too much before the end, they wanted to make it the grand finale and here's the monsters. So yeah, I don't know. But yeah, it is very understated through the first half of this movie. And does... I guess, again, to go back to the John Carpenter of it all, does that. betray the movie because i mean in big trouble in little china and in the thing like there's none of that so i wonder like is that deluca and carpenter playing with your expectations as a filmgoer for his kinds of movies because i mean in the thing you see the thing a lot again having just watched pretty early on yeah yeah you're not they're not holding back in that and i i I mean, this is coming out post that this is coming out in the wake of that.

So my question to you is like, I, does that betray the film? Cause I feel like part of the reason the third act of the movie does not work for me. And like the halfway through the second act and the third act doesn't work because it just, it doesn't pull the trigger enough. Like I, it, It's still talking about things as if we're not allowed to see them. And I don't know why we're not allowed to see them because it's clear that they did the work.

They did the legwork. I don't know why we're not allowed to see what's going on for real. Like it, you know, they, we go all the way to the edge and then they pull us back and it's, it's a very odd choice. I feel like they also didn't know how to finish it. Like, I feel like they almost knew the roundabout way of the meta end of it, him watching the movie, like what even is real kind of wrap up of it.

They didn't know how to get there. But the in-between, like when you get to the third act- It's like, OK, and then I don't know, some monsters or something like it. It felt like even in those moments, they were just like, I don't know, something here. We'll get to that later. And then at the end, he's watching the movie.

Like, I feel like they they did a good job easing their way in the beginning. They knew where they were going to wrap it up at the end. But that third act. kind of feels unfocused. Like it feels like the best we've got is, is having Sutter Cain writing the book and him like spelling it out for you, I think was the best they could come up with is like, what if he just shows up and explains what he's working on as much as you can explain what's going on in this movie. So like, I feel like that was the stand in for having a full and, you know, vision of what the third act of this was going to be.

It felt more like just, I don't know, have him explain it and then we'll throw some monsters and then we'll do that part at the end. Like it did feel a little unfocused once we got to that third act. And it, it does not, I'm not going to say it doesn't help a film that's already kind of asking you as an audience member to identify with headier. Themes, but it doesn't help. Like it, it, If there's not even creatures to see on screen, there are going to be people who were already kind of halfway checking out are checking out.

If you're here for monsters and mayhem and gore and John Carpenter adjacent style stuff, it does not satisfy in some regards. But again, I wonder if that was. the point in a lot of ways. Like, I, I mean, I don't know. Exorcist crab walking lady. So, you know, we kind of, Oh, bad.

Oh, it looks like those dogs with human faces from, uh, what is it? Nightmare on Elm street too. I mean, my God, it looks, it looked, the reason they cut that out of the original exorcist was obvious. Let's put it that way. The effects weren't quite there yet.

I'm sure if you CG'd it now, it would look great, but. No, it would look terrible because CG now looks terrible as well. It'd be a different terrible. I'd rather at least have, you know, K & B doing it because at least then they put somebody to work and did some weird practical thing with a contortionist. We even have a young Hayden Christensen in this movie.

I mean, my God. he's not even recognizable. Like I went back to look like I saw that and went, wait, that was the paper boy kid. Like, and I went back and looked at him. I was like, I mean, if I stare long enough, maybe I could see it, but like, he's so different looking. It's weird.

Yeah. He, and you know, it's, it's odd because it's, very clearly a symptom of shooting the film in Canada. We only have so many kids here. Just pick one. That's right.

That's right. It's this or Mike Myers. What do you want? I really love this movie and the Lovecraftian kind of adjacency of it. I mean, like I said, I've, I've resonated so much with Lovecraft adjacent stuff that in the last several years.

And this, I feel like this is kind of the start of that love in a way. Like it is really, for me, one of the earlier, more mainstream Lovecraft adjacent things. Like it, it was, I mean, for the longest time, it was kind of the only Lovecraft adjacent thing only in the last, 10 to 15 years have we gotten other things like the void or uh what is the what's that nick cage one color color and shape i mean. It's just you know color of space or whatever that was yeah. Something like that yeah we've gotten other things but this i mean this again king related the mist is very lovecraftian yeah it yeah it is without being lovecraft so yeah it's certainly the movie version of it becomes very Lovecraftian.

But I think for me, this sets the bar pretty high. Like even my issues with the third act, I, I really, you know, again, to go back to the Sam Neill of it all, I really love Sam Neill in this movie. He is such a good leading man for this kind of movie where he has to act kind of, I. Wouldn't say confused, but out of sorts the entire movie. Well, Well, he starts off just being kind of a jerk.

Like he's very full of himself. And like I said, he's busting that guy in the beginning. But even when he starts dealing with her, he's just like, yeah, I don't need you tagging along on this. Like he seems very self-assured and like he can pull that off. He's already a seasoned enough actor by the time we get to this movie that he can do that.

And then you get to the town and he starts seeing things and you get more of the paranoid version, which he also can do. And then by the end, he can do crazy, too. So like he does again, like I said earlier, if it went to a different actor, a lesser actor, perhaps I don't know that this movie would hold together the way that it does. No, and I can't really think of another actor that John Carpenter had worked with that fills the shoes of Sam Neill's character in this film, of Trent, the way that, again, Sam Neill just, it's so effortless. I know that Carpenter says, well, when I was thinking about this film and thinking about working on this film and making this film, he's the character, he was who I thought of for Trent.

And I can kind of see that, because it does just feel like I don't know, I love Sam Neill in everything I've seen, but this is my favorite Sam Neill role, period. I love him in everything else that I have seen him in. He's great in Event Horizon. He's great in Jurassic Park. He's even great in that film about, what is it, Sheep Herders in New Zealand, The Dish.

He's one of the better parts of those Jurassic Park, those later sequels. He's not bad in three. I actually, Jurassic Park three in retrospect, I think is way, look, It's at least better than two. Well, I look, I like two. I like three.

I like parts of two. Do you don't like the end, right? No, I. I like the scenes that feel like Spielberg was actually directing, and then there's a whole lot of other stuff that I'm like, yeah, he wasn't even on set that day. Yeah, that's valid.

You don't feel that in that first movie. You feel that in that second movie. Yeah, and the third movie is not even trying to be a Spielberg thing, which is why I kind of appreciate it. It's just Joe Johnston. Which, you know, I love Joe Johnston, so there is that.

And, you know, those later Jurassic World and things, they really just... Abysmal. Even Sam Neill is not able to... I was going to say, I like Sam Neill in the later Jurassic Park movies, a.k.a. 3.

Beyond that, he's not even really able to salvage those. Well, that last one, there's so much going on in that. Throwing those three original actors back in just... was over the top like it's just there's already so much going on by the time you get to that third one then i'm like sure whatever throw. Them in there too like at this point locusts and cloning and like it can't make sense yeah it can't make sense why not human being crossed with dinosaurs like you did all this other dumb shit before you did the one thing that they've been talking about for fucking ever. Like, I mean, it can't get worse putting Laura Dern in it, no matter what the movie is.

So go ahead, throw her in there. She was in three. It's a good idea. She was in three with Sam Neill, the proper amount for a, for like a, for a, for a cameo. Well, pre cameo, a cameo in a pre cameo of a certain kind world.

Like it's, it's, it's treating Laura Dern like a legacy sequel character in a pre legacy sequels being a thing. legacy sequel like an early very early legacy sequel like it's jurassic i don't dislike jurassic park 3 and jurassic park 3 also has one of the funniest out of context moments in any film where a velociraptor goes alan so i mean it is very funny like and it's one of those things where it's you know we talked about it we talked about godzilla minus zero like It is literally that Godzilla fucking up New York scene from that movie. Like, oh, it's in a fucking dream sequence. Like, OK, well, that explains why it has no bearing on anything. And I got excited kind of for no reason, unfortunately, like whatever.

It's it's that thing. But, you know, I would take that. Trailer for Jurassic Park three over having to watch any of those Chris Pratt. Jurassic Park movies. That became my issue was the Chris Pratt of it all.

Oh, fuck, dude. Sometimes the dinosaur stuff I really liked, and I'm like, ah, I wish you could get rid of this Chris Pratt part. There was a time where people liked him, and then the world slowly shifted. I was one of those people, if you go back far enough. I was as well.

Wouldn't shut up. Just stop talking about your life, man, and go back to being that weird, funny dude like that. At least people paid attention to you then. There was a time where I. would have defended Chris Pratt as the replacement for Harrison Ford. In Indiana Jones, and I'm ashamed of myself.

Yeah, I mean, you watch right at that point. Coming off of Guardians into Jurassic World, he was at that point. You could have handed him the new, like, okay, we need a new Indiana Jones movie. You could have then, and some people might not have lost their shit. Most people still would have because it's Harrison Ford, but... he was right poised at that point.

And had he not been a weirdo in the real world, like I feel like his career might've come out. Okay. And instead now he just phones in the electric state or whatever, no right wing content. Like it's like whatever other dumb, like straight to Netflix action movie he did. Oh brother.

I haven't even seen most of it. It's not even Netflix. It's like fucking prime video, man. Like it's, it's not even Reacher. Like at least Reacher's good.

Like it's like someone was like, Hey, Chris Pratt, are you doing anything anymore? Cause if you're not, we'll just give you money to be in like, cause you're, cause yeah, he's like, well, he's a fucking known quantity, right? Like that's, you know, that's to go to something that it will seem like a reach, but it's not. I genuinely believe the reason we have Robert Pattinson as James Bond is because Robert Pattinson is one of the most known quantity actors in in the world right now. And there was a time where Sam Neill screen tested for James Bond.

Yeah, I've seen that footage. He's pretty good. He's pretty good, but he's not James Bond. He's not James Bond, but you see the performance and I'm like, that's a guy who knows how to act. He's a weird choice for Bond at that point, but then again, they've made some weird choices for Bond over the years.

So what are you going to do? Well, and that's, I was going to say, that is the thing about James Bond is, if you think about the character of James Bond, like he's the, one of the more notable male character roles that a male actor can play. It's like protected, unlike any other role really is. And it's such a big deal that they like, it gets its own kind of like mention, like there are other things that do, but this is different. And I, you can't help but convinced me that we have him as James Bond because he's a known quantity.

And Sam Neill was not cast as James Bond because he wasn't as known of a quantity. Like, but think about how known of a quantity Sam Neill must've been at the time to even have that floated. Like it's, Sam Neill, I think, is one of those actors who was so good in everything that you put him in your films. I mean, he was even in an MCU movie. It was in a one-off jokey role, but he was at least in one.

He got some Marvel money. It may not have been a lot, but it was more than nothing. And he made a huge impact on a lot of people's childhoods because of Jurassic Park. They may not have seen him in a single fucking thing afterwards, but. I would.

Say it's one of those things that was like to have been in Jurassic Park, most actors would have killed to have been that role in Jurassic Park. Yeah. You know, let alone all the only thing you ever did right let alone the things before. And after it yeah but he didn't just bank on that he was a good actor before that and he continued like he could have just been like well that's it i've made my big movie now but like from this point on like he's still continuing to do good work the rest of his career so And it is a shame that he passed away. I mean, he passed away this, you know, this past year.

And I hope the Academy doesn't forget him in memoriam. I don't know why they tend to forget actors. They'll get in trouble no matter what they do at this point. No kidding. They're going to forget somebody.

I just assume that because, yeah, everybody is going to be mad about somebody. It's true. It's true. And rightfully so, because, you know, if someone's not. mentioned in the in memoriam at the oscars did they ever really act were you ever really an actor if the academy doesn't acknowledge your passing i mean in memoriam. Too many people think how many people a year die like they should just take it out of the show so they can quit getting yelled at really just be like and go to our website and there's a list of everybody that died this year there you go we covered our bases that way and now nobody's yelling at us and this show is already four hours long so they should just take it.

Out But they won't because they have better things to do. Like you said, just continue to piss people off. It is a. Shame that Sam Neill is gone. But like I said, he has a lot of his body of work.

He did not pull a carpenter. He kept working and was prolific. I'm pretty sure there may be at least one or two. roles of his that are still not out i didn't was it you that mentioned one that's something that's coming out relatively soon that's like sam neill's one of the main characters in it even now and he's passed away at least like several months ago now. I don't think i've seen anything lately so maybe it wasn't me but it wouldn't surprise me because you know but that's a good example like Aren't you glad he kept working? Like, that's my thing with any of these.

I'm like, who knows what great performance these guys still have in them. And we've got. So many people that are still out there working, and as long as your heart's in it, man, keep doing it. Well, it was us, Brian, because he's one of the main characters in the fucking Godzilla movie that comes out next year. Oh, yeah, that new Godzilla movie.

Yeah, yeah, Godzilla X Supernova, right? Where half of the characters, I guess, are gone now, because like I said on that episode last time, it was like, yeah, they're replacing the little girl with her sister, so she's gone, Sam Neill's gone, like... Yeah, no cap. The cast isn't around anymore, but we're still putting out this movie, damn it. Well, it's going to make money, so.

Oh, it'll make money. Yeah, I you know, for me, for In the Mouth of Madness, like I appreciate that when people were seeing it, when it came out, it was not maybe the the the kind of again, the horror films that were coming out at the time. were not Scream. They were not that meta horror. And so this came a little early. I don't know if it had come out post Scream, if this movie would have been successful.

I think that this movie is not mainstream enough to be as successful as Scream. No, I think it's too weird to be mainstream. It is too fucking weird. Like even New Nightmare was too weird. Like, you know, Wes Craven's attempt at doing the meta thing like was too weird for people.

And I would say New Nightmare is less weird than this movie. I can more or less follow along with New Nightmare. Like this movie is it's pretty specific of what's going on. Yeah. Yeah.

The other thing that's very of the moment in this movie that, like, I don't think about until I see something that's at least this far back in time. There's so much smoking in this movie that you just don't see anymore. Sam Neill smokes a lot. He has a cigarette in his mouth half the time of this run time of the movie. There's just light one off the other in this movie, man.

There's so many cigarettes in this movie. Well, it's very 90s, right? Yeah, I forget. It feels very 90s. people used to, I mean, not that they're not now they're just vaping all day long, but you know, they're still going on, but it's a different approach. But yeah, I forget how much specifically in movies and stuff.

Yeah. It was a lot of smoking in the nineties. Yeah. Sam Neill was doing a lot of it. Apparently.

Good Lord. He's smoking a lot in this movie. Like it's the first half after they get to the town, he's like distracted and like, They're looking at that awesome black church and they're distracted by that, which that thing is pretty damn cool, I have to say. Yeah, the church is pretty great. It's pretty awesome.

Yeah, the church might be the best, like one of the better like settings of this movie because some of this is just like indistinct town. Like, but that's part of it. You get to the black metal church. You're like, oh, hell yeah. Yeah.

Yeah, this place is great. Like every you know, everything else is kind of all over the place. I love the nondescript alley that Sam Neill is wandering around outside of his apartment. With the creepy cop hanging out. The world's worst representation of New York City.

Like, my God, the good Lord in heaven. He's John Carpenter's. New York is apparently not too far from the New York of John Carpenter's escape from New York. Which is a really weird version. Even then, I was talking about that on an episode not that long ago because I just rewatched it.

And it's like it's such a weird like. calm story once you get there like it's all build up in that first 25 minutes or so just like okay here's the here's the overall plan here's what we're doing with you here's how you get in here here's how you get to this first place and then from that point on he's just like wandering around and it's just like some random punks running by but like it's i keep thinking it's gonna be weird big set pieces and it's just kind of not it's very low stakes once he gets in there It is. And that's that's why I was saying earlier, like it is a weird movie like Escape from New York is it's weird that that movie is as popular as it. Is to me. Again, I like it in my head more than like every time I watch it, I'm like, oh, yeah, like I have to remind myself every time I rewatch it like, oh, yeah, this is how it goes.

Like I just know Snake is cool. And like I remember the premise of it more than anything. I always forget how it goes once he gets to New York. And I'm like, oh, yeah. Then he's in like a wrestling ring at some point, fighting the big shirtless dude.

OK, wait, what is this? It's a weird movie, too. You know, it is. And it's you know, it has Donald Pleasance and it has oh, my God, it has Isaac Hayes as well. Like, it's just I. it is a John Carpenter movie through and through.

Like it is. It definitely is. Yeah. It's just, it's so weird the way it's laid out. I think in my head, I remember it being more specific and it's like plot and focused and like, it's more of a, just sort of wandering around the streets of New York in a kind of barren version of New York.

You know, it's, it's, it's again, you think of it as more of a big, crazy town, but like, I guess because the police stayed, it's just a bunch of random punks running around. Yeah. No kidding. It's, I don't know. I guess the poster for that movie makes it look more exciting than it is in a lot of ways.

Like it's, it's more of a John Carpenter vibe movie than a lot of his other movies are. So it is the vibe though. Once again, it fits right in with that era of John Carpenter perfectly, but it's a weird plot once you get in there. Yeah. No, I'm, I'm glad we've done this episode on the, on in the mouth of madness.

I, I do realize that it has been kind of re appraised in the years, even since I started podcasting, I think like more people have kind of gotten into the film. You know, I think they did like a pretty big like physical media release of it a couple of years ago with like a vinyl and like maybe like a repro of the book, even like it was, I remember seeing, I used to be friends with some people that were like really like kind of cringe into the physical media. And it was like, okay, like I'm not going to spend $ 300 on this. Like I'm, sorry if you have a little pricey. I will.

It's like, I'm sorry if you have that kind of expendable income for bullshit. Yeah. Me, I like me either. And I, you know, like even when I was in a better financial state than I am now, I didn't have the kind of money to just blow on like a fucking bullshit. Blu-ray with like some, but.

Like, like it is cool, but like it is ultimately like the reason I stopped buying special edition versions. Of video games. Like I have a shelf of shit from video games that just sit there. Like, cool, I guess. Like at some point, at some point you got to say enough, enough with the shelves of shit.

And so like in the mouth of madness has gotten one of those versions, I think even in the last couple of years. And it's like, okay, like I think the version of the movie that I saw, even when I saw it for the first time, you know, 20 plus years ago, like that's not the way people are watching this movie anymore. Like I think. People watch this movie, genuinely enjoy it. I think it's found its audience, which is, It's kind of always the hope.

If you do what we do, like the hope is that more people watch the things that you like. And this is a movie that I really like. And it's hard to talk about movies I really like because it's not that I don't want to drag them. And I mean, I think I've drugged this movie as much as I can in terms of it being something I really like. But it's not a perfect movie.

I would never defend it as such. But it is my favorite. John Carpenter movie by a long miles worth of distance. Like I would say this is far and away my favorite Carpenter movie, which I think says a lot about me as a film watcher, given that it's in a At the same time, it's a very Carpenter movie, but very un-Carpenter. Movie as well.

Again, I think it is that turning point for him. It's him starting to do things differently. even maybe right before this and definitely by the time he hits this point. And I think at this point he's still invested though. I do feel like he's wanting to try different things and wanting to do this. Like the, the toying with the audience is seemingly kind of knowingly like, so I think it's before he gets to the point that he doesn't feel as invested.

So this is maybe that, that last era of him still being really into the concept of what he's trying to do here, which is, You know, I'm. Glad he was still here for this. You know, Mike brought up when we did the thing, he brought up Village of the Damned, which I mean, look, it's been a really I watched that a really long time ago and I don't really remember much about it. I think Mike put it very aptly. Christopher Reeves makes a lot of weird faces in that movie.

See, that's that's how I know it was getting bad towards the end of the run, because there were a couple towards the end that I didn't even see for years. So I knew of that one. I remember when it came out. I remember seeing the poster when it came out and just didn't get around to it, which seems crazy that there was a John Carpenter movie in the theaters and I didn't run out and see it. So that tells you he was falling off at that point.

So yeah, just in the last couple of years, I finally sat down and watched it and went, oh, huh. Yeah. Yeah, that's a movie. It's a movie, all right. Yeah, it's...

Look, I get that, you know, it is a it is a film that is made because I think Carpenter clearly loved the original. I'm assuming. You don't make a remake of a movie like that unless you have some feeling towards the original. Right. Like it.

And he loved his old movies. I mean, you can see from Joe Dante and all these other guys. Yeah. I mean, this movie, when he's watching Robot Monster, like he loves his old movies and you can see it in the movies like he is invested in just film as a whole. So, like, again, that's something I appreciate about him.

And I I'm with you like he's. similarly to Joe Dante and others. And, you know, I would even say like, you know, a contemporary of his, we haven't mentioned George Romero. Like they, you know, they really, they, they were students of the game and not every filmmaker is a student of the game. Like that's not a guarantee that they're going to be a student of the game. And I really love that John Carpenter, like George Romero, like all these other kind of directors, horror directors of a certain time, we're all very much like, we love film. and we are filmmakers because we grew up with film and certain kinds of film.

We were exposed to certain kinds of things. And like, I love that about them as filmmakers. And that's why I don't know. Like, that's why filmmakers who are making films are, like David Gordon Green and Eli Roth and all these other directors, Mike Flanagan, they're all influenced by Romero and Carpenter and, you know, people like Stephen King and all these other directors, like they're influenced by them. Like their influences are very obvious, you know?

And, and I mean, even someone like Ari Aster, like they, they're all, I mean, fucking Ari Aster directly references them. In Midsommar, in a movie that makes no sense why you'd. Be referencing Halloween, but yet it is a horror movie and Ari Aster clearly loves horror movies. So it's one of those things where now John Carpenter is spoken as that kind of secret handshake language the way he was making things like he had seen when he was a kid or a teenager. And That is a pretty stunning full circle moment to be scoring a remake of your film by a director who was, again, influenced by your film enough to want to reboot it. or remake it with David Gordon Green.

Like David Gordon Green's a weird choice because he's less of a horror director than John Carpenter. Like John Carpenter is considered a horror maestro. I feel like David Gordon Green, not so much like he does all kinds of things. So it's weird that he's the guy who did it. But at the same time, by having John Carpenter directly involved, it adds so much credibility to David Gordon Green that like no amount of Rob Zombie and John Carpenter having one conversation about Halloween could ever do.

And that's kind of John Carpenter at this point, like his involvement means something. And when you get to that point, like that's a pretty big. Deal in the industry. Yeah. He's again, like he, he, I feel like he earned his name, like his name being as important as it is. means something.

And like, he really did deliver a lot of impressive movies early on. So I think, I don't know. I think he should have the legend built around him. So yeah, it's just, it's you decide what your carpenter movie is that you're that invested in, but there's definitely something for everybody in his crazy weird, all over the place, you know, list of movies. No, I, I, I totally agree.

I totally agree. Like he does span the gamut so much that you I feel like you can come in at a lot of different spots with John Carpenter and and have something that will resonate with you on some level. I mean, even that. Elvis movie is very good and it's very I mean, talk about something that's different from pretty much everything he worked on. But. you know, it's Kurt Russell and John Carpenter doing an Elvis movie.

Like, again, it still feels like him, like the weird vibe in all of his having Kurt Russell there maybe makes it even more so. But it's still he feels like, again, he's a musician. How is he not influenced by Elvis? So, yeah, it's like it still feels like Carpenter, even as weird as that one is. Yeah.

Anything else we want to say about In the Mouth of Madness? My only other comment, and I guess the only way to make sense of it is if you're believing that all of this is crazy fiction going on in a book and none of it really happened. Because otherwise, like I said in the beginning, the main thing I remembered was that visual at the asylum and like the crazy crosses everywhere on the wall, on him, on everything. But then I got to watching it this time and I'm like, he asked for a single black crayon and that came from it. That seems a little fishy.

So that maybe is the dead giveaway that none of this ever really happened, because I think you need more than one crayon to do all that. Boy, I would not have wanted to be the set designer in charge of that room. Like that was the thing I thought at this time. It really is like it's all over his clothes. It's on his face.

It's on the walls everywhere. It's on the bedspread, you know, on the mattress, on the floor like it's it's everywhere. So, yeah, production design, you know, bonus points for the black crayon treatment. Yeah. No kidding.

It is. That scene alone is shocking. The amount of work that they had to do to make that, like just on his clothes alone, let alone all of the walls of the padded room. It's just, I, yeah, this time I watched it. I was like, my God, the amount of work someone had to do for this is just, it's a lot.

And you know what? It's, it is, it is, I think iconic imagery, Sam Neill with those crosses all over his face. I want to say the physical media version of the film that came out, like it's, it has him on it with like that. Like, yeah, I think I remember seeing it. You know what I'm talking about?

Yeah. Like, like an artistic version of him with the crosses or something. Like I said, that's the main thing I remembered. Everything else became a blur, but that image. So I'm wondering if that's like what he started with in this concept.

Like he had that image before he even like got the rest of the story together, you know, as again, he's being handed the story, but like, when taking this on, like when that, if that was what locked him into, yes, I want to make this movie because he already had this concept because it's so well planned and well visualized that like, that's the iconic shot from this movie and it opens the movie. And it closes the movie as well, to be fair. So, I mean, he doesn't have the, the black on him, but he is still in the kind of hospital garb get up. Yeah. It's, it's not Michael Myers and it's not the thing, but you know, I can't help, but feel like this is in Carpenter's top five movies.

Like it's, it is a great movie. It is very weird for Carpenter, but it also has a lot of, like you said, all the notes of John Carpenter in a way that work with him doing a Lovecraft adjacent thing without it having to be like right on the fucking nose. Like it's not. And I'm glad it's not. Cause it didn't need to be like it.

I don't know if John Carpenter doing a Lovecraft thing would have worked. I'm sure it would have. But I like that this is the way he decided to do it. Like and again, to be ahead of everybody else doing Lovecraft, like Lovecraft is a thing now. 1993, not so much.

And most of the things that are trying really hard to be direct Lovecraft seem like they fail. miserably. So maybe that's what saved this and makes it as much fun as it is, is like he's just like, no, I get it. Like we're going to have the again, the overall thing going on with Lovecraft, but we're going to give it my John Carpenter vibe version of it. And like so you put the two together and it comes out OK versus So many of those treatments of Lovecraft trying so hard to be Lovecraft just like fail miserably most of the time. You mean that version of The Mountains of Madness with Tom Cruise by Guillermo del Toro's never come out?

Yeah, remember how many times they've made that and then remade it? Fucking four. Yeah, it's so popular. The amount of Lovecraft things that have not come out are... It's probably for the best, really.

Well, I was going to say, I couldn't tell you how many things have not come out, but I can tell you how many things have. The list of things that have is very short. Direct things, the amount of... things inspired by lovecraft is very different like there's a ton of like lovecraft board game stuff because i'm really big into board games there's like you know mansions of madness and call it cthulhu and like because it's public domain you can fucking throw cthulhu into anything now and people do frankly like use it way too much but at the same time like there are riffs on it that are more interesting because they're actually using cthulhu than if they were just unable to but man like lovecraft in cinema woefully under adapted but but has been adapted sideways in terms of like the feel of but not the direct like story of like you know which is fine.

I guess yeah i mean it is kind of everywhere because no joke like this past weekend i went to a short film fest and like it was like 10 or 12 different short films from like independent filmmakers And one of them was literally a Lovecraftian story. But they even like they did, they talked to the directors afterwards and they were like, they said almost word for word what you said. They said, well, it's sort of based on this one story, but also it's public domain. You can do whatever you want with it. So it's very minimally based on that story.

So like, yeah, even like up and coming guys are still doing this kind of stuff now and just kind of, doing whatever they want with it because it's been around so long. It's free reign. Do what you want. So it's out there. Well, and I was going to say that's the other thing, like because it is open to the public broadly like that, that makes it Yeah, it's, you know, at some point, maybe Stephen King's stuff will get there.

At some point, other people's stuff will get there. But Lovecraft's is the stuff that's there now. And it is adapted as such. Like you said, anybody can do anything with it. There's no stop.

So a million bad metal bands are putting together an album right now based around every lyric is based on a story from Lovecraft. I mean, you're not wrong. I'm not wrong. I've heard some of them. It's not always good.

Well, I was going to say, I don't even know how many of them are good, frankly. It's a Lovecraft concept album. OK, great. Who cares? Like I even remember, was it?

Oh, God, who's the I'm going to get railed for this. Who's the guy who did Watchmen? Like the movie? The book, the comic book, the graphic novel. Alan Moore, right?

Even he did like a Lovecraft thing and it was kind of not great. Like it's, just because you know what you're doing doesn't mean Lovecraft, like I don't know, Lovecraft is just, it's such a specific tone. Like even someone like Nick Pizzolatto with True Detective, like he's had to be like, no, no, no, there wasn't actually like a Yellow King in Carcosa. Like I was just like, I was like alluding to it, but not directly. It's like, you have to do that because like Lovecraft stuff is so kind of, it's a feel not specifically a thing like i know people.

There's so many nerds that nitpick that stuff they'll be like but no in this story so like you have to you have to distance yourself from the specifics or they'll start getting weird about it so you have to be like no no it's just lovecraftian that makes it okay i can do whatever i want like Exactly. Uh, yeah, that's, that is exactly like, it's adjacent. It's similar to, but it's like, but it's not directly. And that's the point. And yeah, I, I have a hard time with Lovecraft directly adapted.

So I'm more of a fan of like just cosmic horror broadly and, you know, Annihilation and True Detective and The Wicker Man and Midsommar to some extent, like and you know, the void and the color space, like all those things, like very much exist in that world, but are not like beating you over the head with it. And that's kind of where I want to be. And then, you know, in the mouth of madness, the same way, like even the name evokes the mansions of madness, like the mountains of madness, like things that are Lovecraft adjacent, like, and, or Lovecraft specifically. And like, that's good enough for me. And, you know, Carpenter giving it his kind of flavor, I think is better than, Anything else I could have hoped for, including but not limited to him directly adapting a Lovecraft story.

Which, again, he probably didn't want to because he does everything his own way. So like, why would he want to be tied to that specific thing when he could just do his version of it and just kind of make it whatever he wants to do and also tie in Stephen King? Exactly. Exactly. So anything else?

Anything else you have? I think we've hit most of the the overall points, maybe more than the specifics. But again, I feel like with with something like that, that's kind of what you take on a big concept like this. And a huge director like Carpenter, like you end up talking in much broader strokes than you even do with a lot of other movies. I know I completely I completely agree.

So. Um, when Brian and I are not here talking on culture meltdown, you can find us over at weirdingwaymedia.com where this show and my show, the culture cast can be found. Mike White show, the projection booth, Brian's show, movie meltdown, and so many other great shows can be found. But, uh, yeah, weirdingwaymedia.com is where you can go. So longer speak your website.

It's a full fledged website. So don't go to their website. It's not great. Our website's way better because we actually made it. Human beings made it.

And theirs is, I think, made by robots. I don't know. The design functionality of their website leaves a lot to be desired. I think Cthulhu. Cthulhu is working on theirs.

So don't trust them. They are some sort of ancient ones putting that nonsense together. Just go to weirdingwaymedia.com. That's all you need. Yeah, and like, rate, and review this show, my show, Brian's show over on iTunes, then Spotify.

That's where it helps out the most. And patreon.com slash culturecast, patreon.com slash projectionbooth is where you can go to kick a couple dollars our way. Every little bit helps. But, you know, helping us out on iTunes and Spotify is more important than money. But if you want to hear Never Tell Me the Odds, a Harrison Ford podcast, one month early and ad free, that's where you can go to do it.

And yeah, come on back for the next episode where Brian and I are talking about something that's not Sam Neill related. We promise.

Download the transcript file

More from The Kulturecast

Similar episodes across the network

Matched by shared keywords.

  • Bollywood Cinema Club · Jan 17, 2024

    Mahakaal (1993)

    3 shared keywords: film_review, horror, weirding_way_media

  • Bollywood Cinema Club · Oct 31, 2023

    It Lives Inside (2023)

    3 shared keywords: film_review, horror, weirding_way_media

  • Bollywood Cinema Club · Mar 15, 2023

    Tumbbad (2018)

    3 shared keywords: film_review, horror, weirding_way_media

Transcript

Loading the transcript…