About this episode
The 2008 financial crisis has been dramatized as a farce, a lecture and a heist, but J.C. Chandor's debut Margin Call plays it as one long night inside a single investment bank. A junior analyst, played by Zachary Quinto, finishes a model left behind by his laid-off boss, played by Stanley Tucci, and realizes the firm is sitting on assets that could sink it. What follows, up the chain from Paul Bettany and Kevin Spacey to Jeremy Irons' chief executive, is a film about who decides to sell the bad paper and what it costs the people in the room. Shot in 17 days, it earned Chandor an Oscar nomination for the screenplay.
Dr. David D. Perlmutter and Mark Stachiw join Chris Stachiw, the Doctor of Podcasting, to talk J.C. Chandor, Wall Street on film, corporate ethics, and so much more.
———
The Kulturecast is a film and culture podcast from Weirding Way Media, hosted by Chris Stachiw, the Doctor of Podcasting, alongside a rotating table of guest co-hosts. Each week digs into where film and culture meet — and how each one bends the other. Now home to sub-feeds including Required Viewing: A 360° Film Study with Dr. David D. Perlmutter.
New episodes weekly.
Subscribe on Apple Podcasts → https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-kulturecast/id931361376
Spotify → https://open.spotify.com/show/5wjxip9XVYapYuY12yEaGY.
Back the show: https://www.patreon.com/cw/kulturecast
Transcript
Automatically generated, so expect the odd misheard name.
We're in way media. Hello, everyone, and welcome to the CultureCast. I am still your host, Chris Staschew. Much to the chagrin of at least someone out there. And I'm joined by my good friends all the way from somewhere in West Texas.
He is the professor of media and communications at Texas Tech. Your friend and mine, Dr. David E. Perlmutter. Howdy, Chris.
And he had a front row to this whole thing unfolding. My dad. He is the former general counsel of Metro PCS and semi-retired corporate attorney Mark Staschew. Howdy. Howdy.
And on this episode of the CultureCast, we're taking to task the 2008 mortgage-backed security crash that put so many people out of business and so many people into financial turmoil. But we're talking about it in a dramatic sense. We're talking about it through the lens of 2011's dramatic film by J.C. Chandor, who's the son of one of those Merrill Lynch people that didn't have a great time in 2008. We're talking about Margin Call.
So the film is Directed and written by J.C. Chandor, it stars a whole host of people. Kevin Spacey, Paul Bettany, Jeremy Irons, Zachary Kinto, Penn Badgley, Simon Baker, Demi Moore, and Stanley Tucci. I have heard Stanley Tucci is an actor, though all of the Italian food that he cooks, I believe, on CNN might convince me otherwise. And the film is about the crash in 2008 that was caused by mortgage-backed securities.
This film does not focus on any one specific investment bank. It is an investment bank, a nameless investment bank, but not faceless. Most, if not all, of the people I mentioned work for the company in this film and are company either Flunkies or Yes Men or No Men or Fall Guys. So there's a lot going on. It is an ensemble cast.
And, you know, normally I open an episode by giving my thoughts, but because one of us was directly, you know, front row seats to all this, I think it would be pertinent to kick it to Mark first to A, explain what the movie's talking about, because I don't think the movie does a very good job of that. And B, also to give us an idea as to whether or not this film is accurate, and C, what did you think of the film, if it was or wasn't accurate? Thanks, Chris. So to start with, what this film is, the premise of this film is what's called mortgage-backed security. So what they did, the mortgage banks took mortgages on homes, and they packaged them into a security that they sold to the public.
And so there was various levels of what these are. So if a mortgage generally is no more than 80% or 90% of the home value when the mortgage is written. So there is some portion of that mortgage that is, you know, it would take basically a complete catastrophe for it to get less than that mortgage. So they packaged those together. And they sold them to the public, to companies, to individuals, et cetera.
And they had portions of these mortgages left over. So what they did was they packaged a bunch of those together and made a new security out of them. And because the risk was being spread over a number of mortgages, they were able to convince the rating agencies to give these a higher rating than they probably deserved. And then they sold those to the public. And then there were still things left over, pieces left over.
So they then packaged those together again. And because, again, the risk was being spread wider and wider, they could basically give a again, a very good credit rating. And many institutions, for example, and MetroPCS was one of them, had a, you know, you want to always have a AAA rating on whatever securities, bonds, debt you held. So, you know, you would buy these kinds of things because they had a AAA rating. Well, unfortunately, the They weren't really AAA rated.
They were probably closer to junk bonds, which means they have a lower rating, which means they have a higher chance of failure, especially if the market turns south. And what they were talking about in this movie, they called it MBS, MBS, MBS. What that stands for is mortgage-backed securities. And what these banks were doing was they originally created them on their books, and then they sold them to the public. And what this movie is really talking about– now, there's a couple things that are correct about it and many things that aren't.
The banks did try to get these off their books. They sold them to their customers. They sold them to individuals. They sold them to other banks. And when they realized that they were going to be a problem, they tried to move them off their books as quickly as they could.
I believe there's a famous line. by one of the banks that came out, I believe, in the public, which basically said, we're trying to move these like toasters. They just needed to get these off their books as quickly as possible, because I think they realized that these were probably not as creditworthy as what the rating agencies had put on them. And so this movie does do a good job of portraying the kind of the aha moment when banks realized there was a problem. It didn't really run through the risk department. So I think that's that's probably accurate as well.
What the movie doesn't get right is this occurred over weeks. It did not occur over one day when the music stopped. You know, there were a lot of people holding these that they had bought from the investment banks. And a lot of. These were traded on, you know, seven day, 30 day or 90 day periods.
And when the market froze, all of a sudden these things became virtually worthless. And I think what they're showing here is something that's happened many times in the past. It used to happen in the United States on a regular basis. And this happened a lot in the rural areas where someone would say, oh, my God, the bank doesn't have enough money. So they would run and take their money out.
And as more depositors took their money out, there'd be a, quote, run on the bank. And the bank would then bail because the bank had loaned the money out to other people. They didn't have cash to cover all the depositors drawing their money out. That also happened fairly recently in most people's memory, the Silicon Valley Bank disaster, where the first depositors realized that they think that Silicon Valley Bank was overextended because the interest rates were starting to rise. So they ran and took their money out.
And then as others took their money out, obviously, Silicon Valley Bank had this money in loaned out. So it didn't have the cash to cover it. So what becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy, the early guys out get out much better than the later people. And that's what this movie really is portraying, is a run on the bank. It's not a bank here.
It's a run on these kind of securities. So it happened over a much longer period than just 24 hours. Now, maybe there was a bank which realized this and was able to get this off its books in 24 hours. I doubt it. I think it took much longer to get this stuff off people's books.
I think what the movie does do well is does explain the ethical quandary of someone who realizes that there's a problem. And do they have a duty to get out or not? And do they have a duty to warn others? And I think Spacey was constantly driven by that here. But I do think that it shows a typical view of investment banks and Wall Street, which is all they care about is the money.
So it didn't matter what the ethics were. It didn't matter what anything was. We got to get this moved out, and it's all just money anyway. So the fact that small people are being harmed doesn't really– they don't really care about it. So, you know, the ethics of this, I doubt, were debated in this fashion in the banks because, again, they're trying to protect their bottom line.
Anyone who's carrying these securities and realized there was a problem sure as heck didn't want to hang on to them. It didn't matter what altruistic views they might have. That didn't help their shareholders. And many of the people that are in this bank are shareholders of the firm itself. So they all have an interest in getting it out.
So I think it did a good job. It obviously didn't do a good job of explaining what this problem was. It was always looking at a screen that no one ever saw. It never really explained how this came to be. But I do think the idea of this was a 24-hour period, and it's kind of showing a run on a bank, is a more modern version of what happened many times when people run the bank, trying to get things off your balance sheet, get yourself in a much better financial position, and you're running ahead of the market and everybody else.
I mean, it's like selling a stock. You think a company is going to fail, so all of a sudden, you want to get out before it goes bankrupt, kind of like Enron, right? You want to be the guy that sells before Enron falls, you don't want to be the guy hanging on to Enron when it goes into bankruptcy. So you know, that's kind of what was happening here. So I think it's good.
I don't think it probably accurately portrays what was going on here. But again, this is a movie. This is meant to be a dramatic portrayal, not meant to be a documentary. Same question posed to you, Professor. Thoughts on the film?
Thoughts on whether or not Mark just explained it better than the film? I vote yes. Mark, I mostly agree with you, but I think it has to do with what is this genre-wise. We've talked before about there's really very few business films out there. If you make a list of Hollywood movie genres, every couple of years we get a business film.
But There's just not a lot of them. And certainly there are television series set in law offices where lawyers are doing hijinks and advertising agencies. But something that focuses on financials, not as much. And part of it is, of course, the perception that watching people sit around offices and talk about spreadsheets is just not intrinsically interesting. I approach this film and I've watched it like five times now.
As a fable like this, this is a story set within our universe, but it's not necessarily 100 percent tied to any one thing happening in our universe exactly. So the big short, which I think we should do sometime, was an excellent film. That took time to explain exactly what was happening. Like this house in Florida was underwater because of what this mortgage firm was doing over here and what this investment firm. And I came away educated from the big short.
I then read the Michael Lewis book, which was a good history of what happened in 2008 and But I look at this film, Margin Call, as a listing and a projection of ethics, morality, values, philosophy that surrounded the world that created this disaster. So. Individuals, Kevin Spacey's character, Zachary Quinto's character, Jeremy Irons' character, just everybody had their role in showing the different kinds of responses to events that were like what happened. So I'm not holding this film, nor did I go into this film saying I want the historically accurate document. I feel by 2011, anyone who Who cared to be educated about what was happening would have known about it from reading the newspaper, and I didn't necessarily need it to have it explained in a film.
It is interesting, and I think part of it is also– This might be called negative criticism. The film does seem a little rough in the editing. They never explain what a margin is. It's called margin call. But I simply don't think the average person should not trade on margin.
I don't think the average person understands margin. But in the end, I appreciated that it brought up all these issues about the way people thought about That led to this disaster. And I feel especially since I'm assuming CultureCast has a younger audience as well as maybe some people in the age range that Mark and I are in. Roughly skews male 18 to 45. Yeah.
So this was almost 20 years ago. So this is. Almost like talking about World War Two during the 60s. Right. So not everybody has this memory, except I see it from my end as in universities.
What we saw 2008 doing was that the security system. of the post-war world in America, where if you went to college and you got the were in the right major and you got a job with the right company, you were set for life. And my father, as I've mentioned before, was a business professor and he studied business. And unfortunately, He passed away around the time this film came out. We never had a chance to watch the film together. I'd love to get his opinion.
But I remember him talking about how the sort of post-war certainty and security. Mark and I remember that, you know, you were a man in a gray flannel suit. You were you were a company man and you'd work for 50 years for IBM and you'd get a A dinner and a gold watch and a secure pension. And there was just this certainty that if you played the game and did your part in the game, that you would get this American dream return. And 2008 really shattered that.
And I noticed it in parents. Parents were asking questions of us. post-2008 that really hadn't been asked before. My father went to college on the GI Bill. I wouldn't say 2008 was the turning point, but it was in the era where parents suddenly were saying, what is the value of college? What is the value of majoring in this major?
Will my daughter actually get a job? All this investment, we talk about a house. House is probably the most expensive investment most people have, but your daughter's education is the most important investment That you have in terms of what you want as as a future. So I loved the speeches here. Jeremy Irons, whole amazing.
And business media, again, these are business meetings, but they're transformed into I honestly feel like Homeric or Shakespearean drama. Jeremy Irons speech, maybe because he's just a great British actor. He pulls it off like he's doing a scene from King Lear or something. And the profoundity of a lot of. The things that were said, I take away.
I have used quotes from this movie in business discussions. I've referred to this movie. So I'm agreeing with everything you said, Mark, but I'm not sure that was the– and I think you said it. This wasn't the point of the movie. Historical– lesson was not the point of the movie as much as a sort of exploration of the mentality that led to 2008.
But I'll tell you, this is a hit piece. And let me tell you why it's a hit piece. First place, it's misnamed. This is not about margin calls. This movie is not about margins.
This movie is about mortgage-backed securities. The margin calls are much more interesting. And those are individuals who took their stock portfolio borrowed money on it, and then perhaps reinvested it in the market. And what happens in a margin call is when your stock value drops below usually 80% of what it was margined at, they'll force you to sell it. You either cover it or you sell it.
The second thing I'll say is this movie talks about, it's almost isolated. It's mortgage-backed securities. The reason why 08 and your parents were talking to you as they were, David, is the stock market crashed. It wasn't– most people did not hold these mortgage-backed securities. These were usually held by institutions or highly wealthy people.
Yeah, I was talking about the general collapse of 2008. And I'm talking about parents– the parents of the kids who are coming. Yeah, I understand that. But my point is, the reason they were talking to you is not because the mortgage-backed security market collapsed. They talked to you because their portfolios collapsed, which were in stocks, largely.
Because I remember at the depths of 07, considering whether I should sell. Everything I had. And I know people who I went to parties, Christmas parties in 07, and saying, I feel good. I sold everything. I got out of the market.
The third thing I'll say, and the reason why I say it's a hit piece, is business exists for the perpetuation of the organization itself and for the employees who work there. And this is obviously much more complicated than what was portrayed here. Business, of course. Always is going to try to make sure that it protects its bottom line, and if it's a good organization, wants to protect its employees, both of which I think Jeremy Irons' character is trying to do here. He just portrayed fairly negatively about kind of what was going on here.
So what it doesn't show, this makes it look like these guys are the evil ones. The evil ones, in some respects, if you think about the mortgage-backed security disaster, one, were people who were buying homes constantly on mortgage, thinking they were always going to go up, the banks that loaned to them, which were not these banks. These banks contributed to the problem, but course, because they created these mortgage-backed securities that allowed this whole engine to kind of run. But they're taking one piece of the thing, and they're focusing on, hey, these business guys are doing all this. Bad stuff, which is a typical portrayal of business.
Having existed in business for 30 years at the senior level, I can say this is not a portrayal of exactly how businesses operate. They worry about lots of things. Of course, if the enterprise itself is being threatened, they're going to do exactly like this is. And by the way, if you. Held money in a bank and you got a note from your friend that said the bank is about to go toes up and it's not going to have money to cover all its depositors, you know what every depositor is going to do?
They're going to run to the bank and try to get their money out early. So the institution here is acting no differently than individuals. It just happens to target a company on this scale. And so here is where I come in as both someone who, again, I don't talk about it very often on the show because it doesn't really have anything to do with Talking about movies, but I have a master's in business and I went to school for business and that was the academic lane that I fell into. in terms of post high school. And as someone who now, you know, co-founded this network and works with other people that do and don't have business backgrounds, you kind of realize the things you learn in business school actually do.
It's not that they don't apply, but I have taken for granted as I've gotten older, the amount of lack of business that a lot of people have. And especially the the things that I look at, I'm just like, oh, that's obvious. And it's like, well, that is not necessarily obvious. I take for granted I went to school for business. as someone who has both the, a business mind, but a very creative kind of drive. The thing that's funny about this movie is I agree.
I agree with you, Mark. It does feel like a hit piece, but at the same time, like Dr. Like, like the professor said, it is a movie. And so the, the, the expectation is to entertain. And so I feel like it's the worst thing I can say about this movie.
And I think you've both already said it is the worst thing about this movie is it's not the big short. because the big short does that thing way better. I think the thing that's better about this movie in certain ways, then the big short is this is like the professor said, this is trying to speak to something that's less about the business of it all, but more, I think like, uh, a muse, a philosophical musing on why people do what they do and what causes things to get to certain points in certain, uh, aspects of things. I mean, you could look at this as a business thing, or you can look at this as a kind of a general human emotional kind of response to things. And that's the thing. I mean, I think something like Big Short is more specifically about the 2008 crash.
I think this movie, the best thing about this movie is that it really isn't. It is at times about the crash in 2008, but at times it had also nothing to do with that at all. And the best, I think the best moments of this movie for me are the moments that on the face of it are the kind of 2008 facing things, but are in reality more the kind of, like you said, professor higher level things because the, and I think the problem is, and like you've already alluded to Mark, like it's, it's hard to make, it's hard to make a movie about business that's entertaining. And frankly, if you're going to do something like this and you know, this is my take on this at this point as someone who talks about things creatively, just make a documentary, right?
Jesus, if you want to make a thing about a real thing, just make a documentary. There's plenty of documentaries that are very entertaining, that are very well done, that are doing... what the big short or this movie is trying to do, which is be entertaining and educational in some respect. I don't think this movie is that educational. I don't think this movie is educational at all. I think the big short is trying to be educational as much as it can, because it's trying to explain to the common, quote, golden retriever, unquote, as this movie so aptly puts it, someone who doesn't understand basic business.
And I think that that That's the worst thing about this movie is that it exists in a universe where a movie like the big short. exists and is so well done. I mean, you know, we've never talked about the Big Short. Like Professor said, I think we probably should at some point. But even the Big Short didn't work the second time they tried to do it with that Dick Cheney film that is kind of, you know, leftover reheated version of the Big Short with Christian Bale in a fat suit tacked on. Like they couldn't even do that.
So it was lightning in a bottle in and of itself. And so I think that's the worst thing about this movie, just at the outset, is that it's not the big short and that it exists in a universe where the big short came out and was super successful and people got nominated and it won Academy awards and had a rather large presence. And it's being spoken about still rather kind of positively, even now all these years after it's come out. And I think for me, this movie exists in the shadow of a film that's so kind of immensely successful and still exists in the pop culture conversation that like, Oh, you know, this movie was always going to feel lesser than that just by design. But like the professor said, if you're coming into this movie expecting the big short, you are going to be disappointed.
But if you come into this movie kind of leaving it open for something else, I think it has a lot more of an interesting conversation than the big short. Because I don't think the big short really speaks to the broad human experience the way this film does. Let me add one thing that I said, you made something, you said something at the beginning that has triggered something here. So you said that the director, his father worked for Merrill Lynch, I believe. If you recall, and this is a historical moment, Merrill Lynch did not survive the 08 disaster.
It got acquired by. JP Morgan or Bank of America. It was one of those that got bought up at the pennies on the dollar. Maybe part of the premise here is the director harking back, had Merrill Lynch done what this fictional investment bank did, maybe they would have survived. Okay?
Because they didn't survive exactly because of this, right? They were very deeply extended into mortgage-backed securities. And basically, they had run. They got run on. And they couldn't survive.
So they ended up going pennies on the dollar. The other thing I'll say is, This does– I'll agree with the professor that this does portray how people perceive businesses do operate. And in some respects, it's true. In some respects, it's not. It's true in the respect of the firm and the management of the firm is most interested in the success and continuation of the firm.
No one there wants the firm to fail because they're all invested in it. And, you know, they give the window into what people are making here. And they they do a good job, I think, of trying to to portray at least the Wall Street people is all about money. OK, you know, what's he making a year? What's this guy making a year, et cetera?
And they're all making it kind of on the backs of this. So, you know, I think it's it does a good portrayal in the sense of trying to say that now being said, what are you holding it up for? What's the mirror supposed to show you? And, you know, what do you expect? And like I said, if the idea of this movie is to ask the question of yourself, if you were in the same spot, what would you do?
I'm not sure anybody would do anything differently that this firm was doing. OK, because, I mean, again, history runs on banks in the in the Old West were classic. As soon as someone thought that the bank didn't have the money, they all ran the bank. Everybody was there to get their dollar out. And when the last guy was at the line, he didn't get his money out.
He was. OK, and that's I think the other thing is you just mentioned it, that there is a time there was a time and a place in filmmaking where having a business movie was very reductive and it was exactly what this film is, which is all anyone in business cares about is money. I'm just going to point this out here as someone who spent most of the time since I graduated from college working in or around business people or quote self self-proclaimed business people. I have seen businesses do bad things and fail and has had nothing to do with money. Nothing to do with money.
Money was not the reason bad things were being done. Money was not the reason people were doing what they were doing. It was ego and all these other things. And I think what's funny is, and I know, Mark, you have not seen it. I think we would both enjoy it.
I think the professor has seen it because I've heard him maybe mentioned it offhand once or twice. I don't know if you could make margin call in a world where succession exists because now business people actually are real nuanced characters and things. And if you've seen succession, I'm assuming the way that they build the characters in that show is multidimensional, not just me like money, money, good me need more money now. now, which is very reductive. Business people are motivated by so many other things other than money. And like I said, I've seen things, and as I'm sure Mark and the professor could speak to, I've seen business things fail because of other things other than money.
Frankly, I've seen them fail because of money more often than not. And it's It's so reductive to watch a business movie and go, all it is is about money and these guys in these hedge funds were all about money and investment banks were all about money and all this was all about money. It's like, yes, but not really because some of it could not have been motivated by money because at some point you have more money than you could spend. And that's no longer the motivation. And something like Succession speaks to that.
I mean, the title of the show, I think, is a dead giveaway. This, I think, does exist in a time and place where business movies hadn't really matured yet or business kind of focused things hadn't matured yet to be like, oh, well, it's actually... nuanced in terms of the way we're presenting these characters. They're driven by ego and pride and hubris and all these other things. And I'm not saying they don't get to that in this movie. I think they do get to that more in this movie than they do something else.
But this film is more of a proto version of Succession, I think, in terms of like, it is speaking to the things that that show will probably eventually get to. But again, there is kind of that, like Mark mentioned, this undertone of like, well, money, and that's all they care about. I was like, that's not, it's not all that. Like, if you boil it down to that, maybe, but that is just, I think, boiling it down too far. You could say that about anybody, frankly.
Like, that's not a business person thing. Like Mark mentioned, if someone tomorrow said, all of the money in Bank of America is running out of money, I would be in line to get my money out. Like, I'm not, who wouldn't be? Like, it's not, even in 2026, it's, if you hear that, that's a horrifying thing to hear. So, yeah, it's, I don't know, like it's it's, you know, condemning, you know, self-condemnation without being willing to, like Mark said, look at oneself through the through a mirror is like, OK, what is the point?
I feel like. I watched a slightly different movie than both of you did, which is fine, because I always tell my students, you never watch the same film twice and nobody is watching the same movie. You're all bringing sort of different. Opinions, attitudes, histories, cultural references, maybe expectations. I didn't go into this the way that I would for other films that are historically natured.
And I have to say, it's interesting because I'm typically– I'm the cranky guy who's saying, especially like my favorite genre of war film, I will be the guy who says like, wait a minute, you know, that the F-1B fighter wasn't flying until 1946. Why are they having it in England in 1944? You know, like I love historical accuracy, but I think that that was completely irrelevant historically. to what this movie set out to do. And of course, that's one of the things I argue is that to criticize a film, you have to say, what did it intend to be? I could sit here and I could say everything wrong with the Minecraft movie, but I'm not the audience.
10-year-old boys were the audience. And so I have to criticize... I appreciate maybe the Minecraft movie from the point of view of like what would it try to do to reach 10 year old boys? To me, this was an attempt to tell this Shakespearean Homeric fable in one compacted in one day. I mean, I agree on Succession, which, by the way, is an amazing television series.
And You can go back to Rod Serling wrote a script in the 19 late 1950s called Patterns about a business in New York, you know, where there's a sort of fight in the management there. And my dad always said he thought it was one of the best business movies ever written. And this is like 1950 something. But to me, let's just take going back to Jeremy Irons character. I did not see him in any way as a villain.
I thought I mean, I agree with you. Actually, 100 percent. There's this whole thing about, you know, villains who kind of have a point. He is given the script and the time. And of course, it's Jeremy Irons, you know, this this the peak British acting commanding the room.
We've talked about how some actors, you know, are good voice actors and then other actors, their whole body actors. Not if you just turned off the sound in that main meeting there where he gives the this is it speech and the music playing. And I don't cheat speech. If you just look at his body language, like I've always thought there should be an Academy Award for body language separate from from the speak, you know, the total totality of speaking. But he makes some really incisive points that lead to this question, which I have asked myself and certainly in the 5,000 conversations I've had with alumni who are in all sorts of businesses from financial services to oil to whatever, is that you find yourself in situations where, yeah, the money is not– as relevant as the fact that we are all people.
So let me just take one quick example here. Again, this is just a 24-hour snapshot. But at least, I think, two and a half times, it's clearly alluded that the Stanley Tucci character Eric Dale had warned the Kevin Spacey character Rogers had warned the firm, Hey, you know, this is happening. Like this is, there's something going on here. And yeah, it's shown that that particular day after the layoffs at the beginning, this film starts out, people haven't seen it.
I don't think we're giving it away because it's the first scene. There's a bunch of layoffs and Stanley Tucci's character, is laid off. And it's so corporate. I mean, I thought that was a beautiful scene there of these corporate hirees who come in to tell you you're fired, and this is your 24-hour offer. And if you don't accept it, then it'll be rescinded.
And they have their memorized, wow, we honor your service. I mean, that was so corporate. I have talked to hundreds of people who have been fired that way. But there were warnings. So then you have to ask, just like, I mean, this does allude to 2008.
2008 was not a meteor that came in out of nowhere. It was the stupidity, the bad planning, and most of all, people ignoring the warning signs. I mean, no disaster has ever happened without some level of red flags. And it shows how that happens. Because this company was making, as Zachary Quinto's character says, you may have noticed that we're making considerable profit.
And I love how Jeremy Irons, the CEO there says, I have noticed that we've made huge profits with these MBS Trans builders. But they ignored it. Well, why? Because that's a very corporate thing to ignore naysayers, ignore somebody raising their hand and saying, I have a problem with this. I've heard this story hundreds of times of when there was a problem in a company to the point of a company going out of business.
And they were warned. I mean, there's a whole history of this. You know, I go into a classroom and we talk about innovation in media. And I tell my students, I think I've told the story to you, Mark, before is like. My first car was an Oldsmobile.
I took pictures with a Kodak camera. My parents shopped at Sears. My first job was at Blockbuster. I guess I'm a curse on industry. All of those companies were not run by greedy idiots.
Or BlackBerry, the film that we just watched. These are often very, very intelligent people. But there is this corporate mechanism of ignoring it. Warning signs. And I thought that to me, that's the point of this movie is it raises like four or five of these interesting issues about the nature of corporations and the nature of corporate think.
And that's true. And by the way, corporate think is everywhere. It's not just I think it's in the military. But I felt the movie strengths were there. And usually I'm the guy to say like, oh, you know, it's not historically accurate.
I know you're not saying that's the only way to look at a movie, but I just felt these philosophical and sort of human questions were just so much more interesting than whether it's a template. Yeah, I want to be clear on a couple things. One, it doesn't have to be historically accurate. What my concern is, it doesn't explain why they were having a problem. It's kind of like timeline, right?
They don't explain how the machine works or anything else, right? It's just all of a sudden just magic. I mean, take a movie where it's just wizardry. I'm okay with that. But if it's trying to be something that is trying to portray something that is a relevant event, I'd like to have them explain more around their life.
It doesn't have to be historically accurate. Obviously, for cinematic and dramatic purposes, having it play out in 24 hours makes sense as opposed to being what happened here for weeks. That was very similar to a film that the professor and I watched earlier in the year, Jobs, where it was like none of what happened was like taking place in the moments before the thing. But it's like, again, for dramatic purposes, we have to do it because it's not as exciting to have him sit and sit at the computer for as long. You got to just streamline it.
Yeah, I agree with that. A couple other things. I also agree with you, Professor, that. It does. I mean, the movie starts with layoffs.
I could tell you I've been in companies that have gone through layoffs. The company layoffs we went through weren't like those. This is more of an Enron kind of layoff where I heard about Enron. They put them all into a big, you know, auditorium and they basically say, don't go back to your desk. Because you no longer your passes no longer work.
Right. Um, and I would, I mean, this kind of like, I believe it's, uh, up in the air, I believe is the movie about, you know, the guy that goes in and help people get laid off. I mean, it has that vibe. Okay. Associated with, so starting from where it did and then laying off the guy that's in the risk management does seem kind of stupid.
The one thing I'll say about having been in business and sat at the, at the table that those people were at, you always have threats. You always have risks. And as a business, your job is to try to evaluate those risks and figure out which ones are real, which ones you're going to act on. I mean, it's no different than after every catastrophe, there's always someone who raises their hand and said, I told you so. Now, if you listen to every, it's kind of like threat prevention, right?
You know, there is so many threats to whatever you want to call it, business threats to the United States, et cetera, hundreds of thousands of them a day. One of them will be true. Ninety percent of them will be false. So trying to separate the real from the from the false is really, really hard. OK, but the other thing that I will say and.
We don't have this from the film. And this would have been helpful to understand, to buttress your point that this is about the human hubris and not about whatever the business economics are. The fact that they had a risk doesn't explain whether that risk was explained as a catastrophe. Or it was just a risk. Of course, if you have mortgage-backed securities and the housing prices fall, those mortgage-backed securities are not going to be.
Worth as much. That's obvious. That's a risk. I suspect everybody knew what that risk was. The question was, and they talk about this in the movie, the Tucci character, he can't make his model work.
He can't explain the magnitude of the risk. All he knows is he thinks there is a risk. I mean, could the risk be, you know, okay, we lose 10% or we lose 100%? And I'll give you an example. And it's important to understand the catastrophe.
So one of the companies I was with, we were shifting from a– and this happened to– this is kind of let's call it back into the BlackBerry era. We were shifting from going from terrestrial-based systems to satellite-based systems. And I was involved in the negotiations of the contract, et cetera. And I raised the question. I said, hey, wait a minute.
I said, what happens if we go to right now we have thousands of terrestrially based facilities and we go to a single satellite? What happens if the satellite fails? OK. And I was told, oh, the satellite never failed. There's a backup.
No problem. Everything's good. Guess what happened? Again, most of the listeners to this podcast may not even been aware of what happened. But there was a time when two or three weeks, the entire.
He's going to have a problem. So tell me about your backup system. Tell me about your triple redundancy. So they had backup systems. They had all that.
But again, most of the listeners to this probably will not remember. There was a period of two weeks where no pagers worked for the most part because everybody had gone to satellite. And they were going basically the same satellite. Okay. Now, the technology didn't fail.
Somebody keyed a command into the satellite and it changed position. Okay. And, you know, there was a backup satellite. Sure. And they could get it in place.
Yep. The problem was someone had to go repoint all of the satellite dishes. So therefore, I remember for two weeks, we were scrambling 24 hours. People were, you know, there was salespeople driving engineers out to sell sites because they had to get them repointed, had to get repointed, you know, working 24 hours. Okay.
So in terms of the way to think about this is, There's lots of risks in business. I mean, every time you make a decision, there's a risk. Every time you enter into a contract with a counterparty, there's a risk. The question is, what's the magnitude of the risk? What happens if the world goes to poo, okay?
And Cucci couldn't explain it. So in fact, this is, again, like many other things, oh, there's going to be a threat. There's a terrorist threat. OK, there's 10,000 of them that just got reported today. Which one is the real one?
Which one is the one that's actually going to cause a problem? And if you can't tell the magnitude of the risk, It becomes almost meaningless because there's so many– I mean, first place, we're not entirely sure what the risk is that Tucci was speaking to. I mean, they never really talked about it, and I'm not sure they needed to, but they didn't really talk about what it was. But it was clear that he never articulated the magnitude because he couldn't figure it out. Only when the kid figured it out did the business react.
And quite frankly, they did exactly. What they should. As soon as the risk was understood and the magnitude of it was understood, they acted on it. You just can't act on every risk you hear without knowing the magnitude. Now, should they have let the Tucci character go?
They don't explain why they let him go. The implication is because he reported the risk is why they let him go. Maybe so. But the lady that gets let go did tell the senior management that there was a risk. She says that.
She says that I did tell you guys about this. And again, trying to defend her position that, you know, I didn't hide the ball here. But again, did she know the magnitude of the risk? Probably not. If Tucci didn't, she sure as heck didn't.
I think it's, you know, and I watched something recently, you know, in the light of 9-11, you know, there's always the conversation you just had, Mark, about all these organizations knew and they were all talking about things, but none of them could get their story straight. And 9-11 was more of a, Inter-government agency failing, less people not knowing what was going on and not respecting the warning signs. And the thing in 2008, by the approximation of the movie, it has kind of a take on, you know, again, people did know, but ignored it. And, you know, like you said, maybe that was the case. And who knows?
There were enough people. in enough industries, having enough conversations that somebody probably had the conversation at some point about what was going on accurately to exactly what was going on. I always, you know, and I don't host this show anymore, but on Scary Stories We Tell, I used to always say, somebody at some point in the last 70 years, if you don't believe that JFK was shot by Lee Harvey Oswald, in the last 70 years, somebody at some point somewhere has had a conversation about what accurately happened to JFK. If he was not, in fact, killed by Lee Harvey Oswald. Someone had the conversation. Someone has said it verbally to someone else with or without realizing that that is what happened.
But without any confirmation of anything, how would anyone ever know that that's the case? And it's like what you just said, Mark. Someone at some point before 2008 probably said exactly what was going to happen and warned someone about it and whether or not someone believed them. was going to always hinge on whether or not they could prove it or show to what extent or show to what magnitude. And that is, again, in business, the things that I have seen ends up being the question of magnitude, ends up being the question of, okay, this is now not a moralistically, diametrically opposed conversation, but I feel differently about risk than you do. And that's the thing that the Stanley Tucci character would be, you could have an entire movie about just his character and talking about risk in business because risk in business is hard to describe to someone who hasn't worked in business because risk is not, risk is not something that's measurable on a scale until it is.
I mean, you, have someone who does risk management and risk analysis, but people still go do things. And even in the face of risk, people still do things. And again, Jeremy Irons' character speaks to that in the film. He's like, you know what? businesses will continue to do this even after this happens because it has to because it this can't be the end every time someone thinks it's the end it's not the end because someone is going to be there to pick up the risk because there are just and this is the part of the movie where it's like again it's hard for me to have a conversation about this in some respects because you know you want to look back on this and demonize all these people but at the same time You can't sell products or securities that people aren't buying.
Yes, it's not being done in good faith, and obviously that's part of the question here, but people still bought. And again, some of those companies don't exist, sure, but plenty of them still do. But there are two things I'll say. One, all of business is risk. And the better businesses are ones that manage risk better than the ones that don't.
And I agree with you, Professor. That one shouldn't demonize the Jeremy Irons character or in fact what they did. Once they understood the magnitude of the risk, they wanted to protect the enterprise. They did exactly what I would expect anyone in their position to do. Actually, Mark, let me just stop there for a second and ask you that specific question because we have this– you as our resource here.
You're in that meeting. Remember when when Jeremy Irons walks in the room and it's a little tiny one off where he stops and shakes the hand of somebody and hello, John, you know, and then walks to the end of that. And we never find out who John is, but obviously John was important enough that he was the only person in the room. that Jeremy Irons, the CEO, the big honcho, stops to say hello to. Everybody else, he's just sort of moving past. So you're John, who said nothing at the meeting, by the way.
But you're at that meeting with all the information that you've just been given at that meeting. I'm really curious, and I'm not trying to put you on the spot, but you were at meetings of this kind. What would you have said at that meeting? Because they actually had a character there who was from the general counsel's office. And I assume at that executive committee meeting, maybe John was the executive general counsel of the senior general vice president, general counsel of the firm.
What would you have said at that? You know, the first place as lawyers, we're not we're we're we're trained. To give advice, not to take that, not to take the answer. OK, the fact is, the fact is. The continuation of the enterprise is the most important aspect of what management needs to do.
Because if the enterprise doesn't continue, none of the shareholders will have value and none of the employees will have jobs. So at the end of the day, if you realize that the magnitude of the risk is that the business is going to fail, unless you do something, you do what you need to. Now, the one thing that I do think was they said a lot about it. I don't know. We haven't focused on it in discussing here.
There were two things going on here in that meeting. On the one side is, oh my goodness, if we don't do anything, we're basically going to fail because we got all these on our books and it's going to go turn worthless. And you have, you know, Kevin Spacey, who's sitting there saying, wait a minute, you know, if we do this, we will not, we'll be pariahs in the market. So they are doing exactly what a business would do. They've got both risks up on the table and they're trying to evaluate which risk is the one they're willing to take.
Okay. And I think, okay, set aside all the moralistic aspects of this. I think they took the right path because if they, if the truly the model worked and they kept saying, is this model correct? Is this model correct? If the model is correct, and that's about what's going to happen.
The question is 100% certainty, or let's call 90% certainty that your firm's going to fail because you're carrying worthless paper. Or you sell this to other people, and you have a 70% chance that you're a pariah in the market. You take the 70% chance over the 90% chance. So the idea is we're going to be a pariah in the market for a while, and then everybody's going to trade with us again, and it's going to fix. If we hold this paper, we won't be around to be trading with anybody.
OK, so I think it's I think they're taking the right path. You know, morally, it doesn't feel right. But again, neither does the people standing in line, you know, that are they're taking a run on the bank at the beginning of the line who are getting all their money out. So the people in the back don't get it. But that's what everybody does.
So that's what they're doing here. You know, it's bad. It's unfortunate, but that's, I think, a realistic thing here. I do think they did the right choice because of the risk. And by the way, one other thing I'll say, and anybody who gets any financial news, there's always someone predicting a major correction of 30% or 40% in the stock market.
You know what? Every day, I get that in my email. Oh, there's a 40% correction coming. Get out of the market. Get out of the market.
Occasionally, those are true. Sometimes they're not. And so that's the kind of information these people are faced with. We got risk. All of a sudden, this world's going to turn to poo.
Is it? What's your proof? Only when they had proof did they act. I don't think that's unreasonable. I don't think you just work on...
I don't think you should make decisions based on rumor, innuendo, or anecdotal evidence. When they had the actual evidence, they actually acted. In the movie, yeah. I mean. In the real world stock market, you know, you- Oh, they were doing the same thing.
They were doing the same thing. I mean, I believe one of them, and I don't remember which investment bank, you know, had a public statement. I mean, it came out in litigation, I think, with things with the government, which is, you know, we're selling them like toasters. We just got to get them off our books. They were doing- Some of them were doing- They understood enough to understand they didn't want to have these on their books.
Okay? Yeah. So I think my point is that- I appreciated. This is a movie that we actually teach business communication in our college. We have an arrangement that I put together with the dean of business, business colleges for part of their accreditation.
They have to have students take a certain number of communications classes. And we have a deal with the very excellent business college here that their students take two courses in business communication. for us. And I would, I, if I were teaching that class, I teach a module in that class every once in a while called how to have lunch, like how to have a business lunch, because I think that's part of the education of students in communication is how to have lunch with a client or, you know, with your boss or something like that. But I would show this movie and say, Hey, let's talk about some of the themes and ideas and characters. And what would you do?
And I think it would be really good. I wouldn't, I mean, I would say if I was teaching a course of 2008 and what happened in like a business finance class, I'm not sure that this movie would be the only movie that I would show. But I think it does something that a lot of Hollywood movies, especially modern ones, are unable to do, which is raise philosophical, moral, ethical questions without hammering home what the filmmakers want you to think like and by the way this is the good guy and headline this is the bad guy because i i did watch this and i was wrapped up in the ceo's speeches and i and i came away going like yeah he's mostly right and The part that you pointed out about them selling to their own customers, that was not part of this, right?
So it actually looked like a more virtuous thing that the company did. They were selling to other banks, and they were preserving stock value for their customers. So that was, I guess you could say it's morally interesting. By the way, I looked it up. This film was shot in like 17 days, I believe.
That's how they got most of the actors. That's how the level of actors that were involved in this film. Which I mean, you know, I mean, like, yeah, like, wow, for a first time film, getting all of these actors shooting it in 17 days, I looked it up. The offices were at one Penn Plaza and they were offices which were vacant and Because an investment firm, this sort of a complicated history, they changed their name a couple of times, but they dissolved in 2014. And I couldn't get the exact story about how much 2000 used them.
But like there's a little– I do want to say I love the corporate atmosphere, the glass, the steel. Did you notice the little logo for the company is this rectangle with a, like an off center, beautiful tree, you know, on a, on a field it's, it's, it's so beautifully vaguely corporate, you know, and, and I just, those little details and people at their cubicle desks and then other people in their open glass office desks. And I'm old enough to remember the, Again, talking to alumni, say, in the 80s and 90s, and them going like, what the hell? They're starting to have this thing called the open office, and I'm supposed to have glass instead of walls. That's the worst thing I can possibly imagine.
Now, of course, it's everywhere I go. There's very few offices that are completely enclosed without glass. But I just felt it captured this hamsters in an enclosure atmosphere and the corporate look so very well. And I appreciated that. And I agree with you.
Yes, absolutely. Absolutely. I mean, in terms of believability that you were looking at a business that was operating in this kind of Wall Street firm, absolutely. I mean, that's exactly the way the Wall Street firms were, which is, you know, you got the big bullpen, you got the manager sitting out in the bullpen and, you know, there's conference rooms around the edges and maybe a manager. Has a glass office.
So I'll agree with you that it did not, none of that took away from the authenticity feel of of what you were looking at. It wasn't, you know, something that you say, oh, that is not right. That doesn't look right. Have either of you seen Glengarry Glen Ross? I'm assuming the professor has.
Mark, have you? So I, I think, and this is me again, coming at this from kind of the, the, the, you know, the, the guy who watches a lot of movies angle, as I know you both do, but it's, you know, overwhelming in terms of my life. Glenn, Gary Glenn Ross is a film that I love immensely. And it is, again, it's a film that I think you want to call it a business movie. Sure.
But I think it's like calling this movie. I think the worst thing this movie does is tie itself to 2008 specifically, because I think the best thing about this movie is all of the stuff that is more specifically about the business, business people, the ethics of business, the morality of high finance. What is the purpose of a business? What is the purpose of the people in charge of a business? I think it's better in that terms than it is trying to be a 2008 thing.
They probably should have used something that was not in market. There's enough of these that they could say it's not mortgage-backed. I think that's why they use MBS. because they never explain it, never what it is. I think they never say what company it is. It's never said like, this is, you know, this is Merrill Lynch.
This is whomever. It's just, this is nameless, faceless company. And like I said, it's like Glenn, Gary, Glenn Ross and that it's not, they're not speaking to a specific thing. They're speaking broadly. And I, I get why they're doing it here because 2008 is, you know, at the time in 2011, it's the thing that just happened.
It's like, could you really make a terrorism movie post 2001 in the years after 2001 and not mention the, an airplane flying into a tower. Like I would find that hard to believe or that the terrorists are from the middle East. Like I would find that hard to believe because it's, it's, it becomes so part of just the daily conversation and life and culture. Like it's hard to avoid. And post 2008, uh, People were thinking about the market failing because of the housing market.
Like this could have been about anything. You know, it's funny, Professor, you and I talked about Jaws recently. And this movie, you could have had this movie about this could have nothing to do with finance. And it could have been about a town being open or closed during the holiday season because of a shark and weighing the risk of that. I mean, you know, a film that I would love to talk about with with y'all, because I think it would be.
I mean, yeah. You know, the mayor. We always talk about the mayor in Jaws and how. He's not wrong. He's a villain, but he he has this point.
And in fact, he's giving sort of. The Jeremy Irons speech about. He is the Jeremy Irons character. It's like if we close, if we close the island for the summer, you will all go out of business and then you'll all be angry at me. It's just like three days of the condor professor.
I was thinking about that because that was the episode that just came out on the feed. You know, if the oil starts running out, they're not going to ask us to take the oil. They're just going to want the oil. They're not going to ask us. And, you know, it's funny, a film that I just watched in theaters that's been railroaded into the ground, Digger actually talks about the themes of this movie and the themes of Three Days of the Condor and Jaws.
There is sometimes no benefit to being right. Sometimes being right is the worst thing that's possible because you in being right again in this film, you know, Zachary Kinto. Sure, he gets a promotion, but everyone at this business and they again, they kind of allude to it and they I don't think they belabor the point. But everybody at this business is going to be a pariah for a very long time in the industry. Until they're not until one day, it's just not the case anymore.
But they talk about it. Kevin Spacey, like, tries to not belabor the point. But that is a huge thing about what ended up happening. And, you know, like you both already talked about. The real ethics of what was going on was much worse than what the movie is showing, because if the film showed what was actually going on, you would not like any of the characters in this film, because none of the characters in this film are meant to be likable, I don't think.
I personally don't find them to be likable. I don't think that's the intention of the filmmakers to make them likable. It's to make them accurate or kind of elevated accurate. And I don't think. Yeah.
I just don't, I don't find any moment in this movie again, like what the movie is trying to do, I think is so much different than what the expectation of what you would want from a film like this to do. And I think the film is trying to navigate something that's, Again, it's hard to be successful at this because this is not a thing that, like the professor said, we see very often. But when we do see it, it's hard to not equate this to other things that are, quote, more successful, unquote, when I don't think that this is really necessarily comparative to any of the things that we've seen. I would have liked the movie a lot more had they not tied it to the mortgage-backed securities and just tied it to some existential risk that is associated with the securities they're selling.
Because then you're not trying to frame it in terms of reality. Then it's just, you know, a meteor's coming. What do we do about it? And that's what I was going to say. The film that I would love to cover with y'all at some point, I was hoping to do it for October for Halloween season, but it's going to pass.
But I think y'all would both bring a very interesting perspective is Shin Godzilla, which is a film that is literally... what happens when a government is so like strung up by bureaucracy that they can't make a decision about what to do about a giant monster walking through the countryside, destroying the, the countryside. And you have essentially a Godzilla film cross cut with people sitting in business, in a, in a business setting, yelling at one another about the ethics of trying to blow up a monster that's destroying the country. And it reminds me of Jaws and Margin Call. It's like, what is the risk? What is the expectation?
Because in that movie, they go like, well, he's not going to evolve. There's nothing that he will. It will never get any worse than this. He's just a little tadpole. There's no way it gets worse.
And then by the end of the film, you have Godzilla massive just as not a spoiler. Godzilla's massive destroying cities. And it's like, oh, so the person who is Cassandra at some point is right. Not every time, though. That's the problem.
Again, you can't. if you believe every threat is world ending, then no threat is world ending. That is how that works. So everything has to be given a level of mag, like we've said magnitude. And that's, I don't know, like, I feel like that should have been the point that the film belabored because that's the point that I think is the more interesting thing that this film is having a conversation that I've not seen a lot of films trying to have this conversation, frankly. I would have liked them to– because I think it would have helped a lot in terms of moving the pod along had they explained that the risk that Tucci was getting to was never quantified.
It's implied because the other character actually is able to get his model to work, right? But, I mean, they didn't really make a huge point of it because that's really– That's really, I think, the point of this. What happens when you have risks that are unquantified and they become quantified? What do you do once the information changes? And I think that's where, Professor, you are, which is, you know, Jeremy Irons is doing exactly what you do.
Once you know the magnitude and the quantity of the risk, how do we deal with it? Well, I deal with it because I'm trying to preserve the organization, preserve the jobs of everybody, trying to preserve what we built. And that's, again, to go back to the jaws of it all, it's It's hard because in that film, that character is characterized as the villain. But I think if given five more minutes in Jaws, you could actually have an interesting conversation about what does it mean to be the person in charge who has to make the decision, the hard decision of, we're going to stay open even though we know the risk of a shark possibly attacking people. But the reality of closing is to.
Financially destructive to even comprehend. think there, I think someone is going to make a COVID film, a COVID adjacent film or a, you know, X as COVID, because that's like the most recent thing you can think of in terms of things closing and things being open. And what does that mean? I mean, again, no one has made it yet. Someone will make it eventually. We are only in the first couple, you know, Just like this film, the post years of that happening where people are still kind of sorting out their thoughts and working on those ideas.
But I guarantee you, we see something in the next couple of years that's similar to that, where it's, again, having the conversation about what is the what is the difficult reality versus the. intangible or tangible risk that's facing me. And how do I make that decision? And who is the unenviable person in the position to have to make the decision to shoulder the blame? Should it go one way or the other? And, you know, I would say for me, and I know that we're all animal lovers here, the dog was the economy all along, which is the funniest part of this entire movie.
I mean, not funny, but it's wild to me that at the end of the film, it's like the dog was the economy the whole time. That's what my, I, my takeaway was because by the end, Kevin Spacey is burying his dog. And it's just like, again, there's a through line to the movie about Kevin Spacey with his dog, but there it is, professor. That's what you have. Your, your students, right.
Is have them write the paper of what is the dog mean in margin call? Because again, like there's an intentionality to it. Yeah. It's a college paper. So compare and contrast the dog and margin call to the cat and digger.
That's right. Yeah. Wow. Holy cow. You're not joking.
That's perfect. Everything you've read about the metaphor and symbolism and– That's right. Yeah. I guess my other takeaway is that I did appreciate this movie not for everything it did but for– some of the things it raised, which made it visually and narratively interesting, but also like I've taken away. I watched this movie, I don't think in the theater, I thought I've watched this movie like a couple years after it came out on my cable.
I've been thinking about this movie for 15 years or so. And I keep referring to it. I quote from this movie. So I do think that it had success in some of the things he was trying to do. As I said, it was uneven.
You know, it's funny. I looked up JC Chandor and not a lot of films until Craven the Hunter. I know, which is so insane, by the way, I was going to mention what that's, this is not the only JC Chandor film I've talked about Craven the Hunter, uh, a film that I saw in theaters, which, uh, it's not. I have not seen it. Would you, would you just watching Craven, the hunter and margin call?
No, the same person had directed the two, but are there, are there like Jeremy told characters? Yeah. Did someone mention MBS, you know, in the dragons or something? I was going to say that to me is the craziest part. Like Craven, the hunter is such a far step from margin call, like a complete one 80.
I mean, to speak to the Glenn, Gary, Glenn Ross, like this is a, Margin Call is a one-room stage play, and Kraven the Hunter is a multi-million dollar spectacle. No, they are as diametrically opposed as humanly possible. I actually wonder whether they put the MBS in here just to try to shortcut what was going on as opposed to actually trying to– I don't know whether this was added just to give context. Because otherwise, if you don't have it– then it's just some sort of risk that's unnamed, unknown, just kind of big and bad. So I don't know if they were trying to just tie it to something to kind of give cultural context or whether it was actually the original framing of the movie.
I don't know. I do feel that this film, especially for students, because we face this real challenge with our students. And as I said before, I'm now– started my career in academia in 1989. So I've seen quite a number of generations of students. And I've talked to a lot of parents.
And I feel that at colleges and universities, we have this balance that no one should take away hope from a 20-year-old. And this is something I discussed with alumni is I, you know, I would say, please don't come in to the class and say, yeah, it's hopeless out there. It's dog eat dog. And, you know, everybody's scurrying everybody. And it's just horrible because it isn't.
There are many places because I've talked to a lot of alumni where they're very happy at their work and they they love the the culture of their job. They love their job. They go in every day. So so it is wrong to portray that. any industry. I have never been satisfied in my entire life at the portrayal of professors in TV and movies.
No professor recently has as much power as Kingsfield. We talked about that movie, The Paper Chase. But I do feel. In terms of giving people something to talk about, about corporate situations. And one of the cases I do make to students is that you should think about all the situations that you're going to face.
And that's why you should listen to alumni, among other things, is they're going to tell you about situations they face, scenarios they faced. And you should make up your mind, what are your standards? What are your ethics? What will you are you willing to do? What are you not willing to do?
I can't make those choices for you. But I think that this movie does a really good job. And one last little detail. If you ask most Americans, you mentioned succession. Absolutely.
Probably one of the most important portrayals of. I don't I'm not sure whether it was a portrayal of business as much as. power struggles, like even like one level above business. Game of Thrones without the dragons, really, right? Yeah. I mean, but if you ask people what their picture of work was, Mad Men and the sitcom, The Office, are probably pretty high up there.
And it's interesting to me talking about ethics is if you just look at the floor there, People you I could not imagine the ridiculous hijinks of. I mean, I know there's a there's a time factor, generational factor here. And I've talked about this with older and younger alumni. But like I bet the H.R. department at this business was pretty powerful in the council's office. And you couldn't get away with Michael Scott antics.
At this company, you couldn't get away with madmen type of harassment at this company. I'm willing to bet that they were super serious about their corporate image and people went to work and did their job. And yeah, afterwards, the younger people went and they went to a bar and hung out or. Something like that. But it's interesting how the actual business is so much more tame than the exaggerated portrayals that we see in some of the other portrayals.
I'll say two things kind of in closing. One, although you have a character running around with a bottle of liquor during most of this movie. After hours. But he's going to meetings, he's leaving the bottle behind, but he's clearly lit. And I think, again, it's a stab at the culture of drinking and all that on there.
The other thing I'll say, and this is It is an interesting thing. I remember when I was in law school, we had a case where they were talking about the use of seatbelts. And this is in the 80s. And the fact that if you didn't wear a seatbelt and you got injured, that it was considered negligence. On the other hand, there was some significant percentage, 60%, 70% of people weren't using seatbelts.
Okay. And so you sit there and you say, well, that seems kind. Of interesting, right? So as a jury, you're going to find someone who wasn't using a seatbelt to be negligent and therefore wouldn't recover on their damages. But you yourself, when you get out of the jury room, are not going to use the seatbelt when you drive home, okay?
And I think that's what's interesting about this movie is they're holding up the mirror and saying, oh, look at these guys. Look what they were doing. They were selling this stuff and they were doing all this stuff. But turn the mirror around and realize if you were in the same spot and it was your money that was about to vaporize out of the bank, what are you going to do? You're going to run to the bank and get your money out before everybody else.
And it's one of these things– it's kind of an undertow here, which is holding other people to a higher standard than you yourself will hold yourself to. Because clearly, you were, I think, meant to kind of leave this movie with, man, these guys weren't really doing what they should have done. Now, again, if they had talked about selling to their customers, it would have really gilded the lily on this. But that's kind of the way this feels, is that you're trying to hold them to a standard because the way the film portrays them. different than what you, if you were in the same position, would do yourself, right? And maybe that's the purpose of it, is to try to show that, you know, we do want to hold people to higher ethics than we ourselves are wanting to hold ourselves to.
Well, and that's, I think, you know, like you've both said, like, I think for me, that's where I land on this movie. I did, you know, to answer the question that I normally ask at the beginning, I saw this movie pre this episode, but post when it came out on, you know, physical media, I didn't see it in theaters, but I remember when I watched it, not appreciating it or understanding it or having as much to think about it as I do now. And I think that a lot of that has come with time and distance and obviously, you know, history and, you know, actually working in the business world and having a master's and, you know, being around other business minded people or people that are, you know, at least wanting to have a business mind, which is, I think why you go to business school if you're not, Interested in business, you go to business school to have a better idea of how to do business in a more efficient and... purposeful and intentional way.
Because again, I know people that are business people that do not make good decisions that have gone to school for business. So it's not a guarantee that because you went to business school, you're a good business person. I think that that would apply for anything. And to speak to what I think the professor already said about, I've never seen a good movie with a professor in it that's a reasonable character. Say the same thing about now as a podcaster.
I haven't seen anything that portrays podcasters in a pretty positive light. I don't think that's a thing, which is unfortunate. Where we're portrayed as people that are turned into walruses or are murdered by Michael Myers or conspiracy theorists in Godzilla movies, I think, is another one. Or I think Woody Harrelson played a podcaster in 2012. Yeah, the podcasters are kind of given short shrift, which is fine.
That kind of comes with the territory. But I... appreciate this movie more now having seen it and having worked in the business world. And as someone who, you know, co-founded the network with Mike and are, you know, trying to run this as a business, but also trying to be, you know, creative people, creatively minded, doing creative things. It is, it's a, the, the movie has a different feel to it now. And I think that that to the professor's point and to your point as well, Mark, I think that that's the other thing about this movie is, it is better suited as a film that is speaking high level about human emotions and ideas and reasons for doing things and less specifically about something that is better suited to either a documentary or a film like The Big Short that is based on one of the better books about this topic.
And I think it works better when it is just a high level human piece about the nature of humanity and especially in the face of certain kinds of risk or threat or risk assessment kind of situations and less a, this is about 2008 and the financial crisis. Like, okay, great. Like it doesn't, it does, that doesn't, that honestly, in some respects kind of hampers my ability to enjoy the film in a less specific way. And that's not even speak to the Kevin Spacey of it all, which we barely even talked about, which ain't great. But hey, that's a that's a story for another time.
So speaking of that other time, when you want to hear the professor and I and Mark talking about other films like Timeline, head on over to weirdingwaymedia.com where this show and so many other great shows can be found, like Required Viewing, which the professor and I do once a week where we talk about. Why a film is required viewing from a 360 degree perspective. We've done a whole lot of interesting episodes and we're going to continue to do interesting episodes. So you can find that and so many other shows over at weirdingwaymedia.com. Like, rate, and review the show on iTunes, then Spotify.
In that order, that order is the one that helps the most. Patreon.com slash culturecast is where you go to kick a couple dollars my way. But yeah, liking and rating the show on iTunes helps the algorithm more than a dollar does. So do both, but do one over the other. Like I said, just liking and rating the show is more helpful.
Professor and Mark, thank you both so much for joining me. And as always, we'll catch you on the next episode.
Similar episodes across the network
Matched by shared keywords.
-
S1E5 — College
2 shared keywords: chris_stachiw, weirding_way_media
-
Episode 0 — Never Tell Me the Odds
2 shared keywords: chris_stachiw, weirding_way_media
-
S1E4 — Meadowlands
2 shared keywords: chris_stachiw, weirding_way_media



