About this episode
Tony drives Meadow up to Maine to look at schools. Somewhere on the road she asks him, flat out, whether he's in the Mafia, and he gives her the most honest answer he's going to give anyone all season. Then he spots a face at a gas station. A guy who flipped, who's supposed to be long gone, living a quiet life under a new name. And suddenly the college tour has a second itinerary.
Back in Jersey, Carmela has the flu, a bottle of wine and Father Phil on the couch. Nobody does anything. Everybody almost does something. And when Tony gets home, she's got one name waiting for him.
HBO didn't want Tony killing a man in cold blood this early. Chase did it anyway, took home an Emmy for the script, and the show was never the same. The Doctor of Podcasting and Mike White of The Projection Booth get into all of it: two road trips, one confession, the wire, and the conversation in the car that Meadow and Tony both pretend never happened.
Episode five. And yeah… this is the one people mean when they say it changed TV.
What, No F**kin' Ziti? is a Sopranos recap podcast covering every episode chronologically. New episodes drop every other Sunday.
The Sopranos is a property of HBO. No copyright infringement intended.
Transcript
Automatically generated, so expect the odd misheard name.
We are the Kway Media. Hello, everyone, and welcome to what? No fucking ZD? Yet another Sopranos podcast. However, this one's not hosted by people who are on the show, at least not that I know of.
Mike may be holding out on me. It's in one of these episodes. All of a sudden, Mike's like, Chris, I have something to tell you. I was actually a background extra in the Sopranos. That would be funny, though.
I am joined by my good friend on this journey through The Sopranos chronologically. He is the host of The Projection Booth podcast, the internet's finest movie podcast. Your friend and mine, Mike White. If you don't want to work in the rain, try For the Fucking Yankees. God damn it.
Tony, man, he's got some he's got some good ones. He's got some good one liners this episode. And on this episode of What No Fuckin' ZD, we are talking about the first season's fifth episode, a pretty big episode for a whole host of reasons. That episode is innocuously titled College. So the episode synopsis, as it were, on IMDb is while visiting colleges with Meadow, Tony spots a snitch.
Carmela, meanwhile, discovers something about Dr. Melfi. Yeah, sure. IMDB. I mean, I guess that is what happens in like one scene in one phone call.
I mean, there's there's a lot bigger of a thing going on with Carmela that the synopsis doesn't even fucking hint at, frankly. What actually happens with Carmela in this episode is we are introduced to Paul Schulze as father Phil Intantola, who, yes, is. has been recast, in fact. I think rather well, though. And he comes over to, well, he wants some of Carmela Ziti. No innuendos intended.
Or are they? I'm going to kick it to you first, Mike, given that you play the role of the newbie on this show. So what did you think of, again, I think, honestly, this is one of the most important episodes of television of the last 30 years, but obviously a very important episode of The Sopranos. I thought it was a really tight episode. I mean, obviously, it's pretty much the same length as the rest of these, but Just having the two storylines, the two main storylines, and cutting back and forth between the two, I thought was very clever.
And just to see the family relationships and everything, I thought it was great. I really liked the way that this whole thing was put together. I like that we've got the mystery going on with Tony. We've got all the stuff happening with Meadow. And then, yeah, the...
And chin between Carmella and the priest. Look out. Cook an egg on that heat. Yeah, there are some very suggestive shots while she's taking communion that always crack me up. Some very close up shots of Edie Falco's mouth that are definitely suggestive as it were um obviously this episode is pretty important because this is this is the first time we see tony kill someone uh and maybe that might be underselling it this is the first time we see tony kill someone and he fucking strangles a man in cold blood rather graphically i mean again to actually strangle someone doesn't just take 30 seconds not that i would know but because there have been studies done on how long it actually takes and it takes a shockingly long time to strangle someone via you know throttling them and i mean he throttles him pretty quickly but it was a it's a turning point for this show obviously because in a lot of ways up until this moment in the show it's just been a rather basic show i mean The mafia is here and we've seen people get murdered, but the people doing the murdering haven't been our main character.
Our, you know, our hero, as it were, and heroes don't murder people unjustly. Right. Right. Right. Right.
No, not in this show. And that's the thing that makes this episode so important is we see Tony get his hands dirty in a way that completely changes the way you look at his character moving forward. Because now, you know, he is a threat and it's not just it's not all talk. He's six foot two and he'll fucking kill you. And he does.
And he does. I mean, that's the thing. Like, you know, it's the moment of the moment of murder in this episode is it takes so long to get to it. But I think it's so smart because it keeps building up this idea of like, is it going to happen? Is he going to do it?
And then when you see it happen, it's like, oh boy, we're never going back from this moment, are we? Yeah, I honestly thought that he was going to say, oh, you know what? I'm here with Meadow. I'm going to call Big Pussy and Pauly Walnuts and have them come up here and take care of business. And I'm going to go back to my house with my daughter.
Because I don't want her mixed up in this at all. No, no, that's not how it played out. No. And so they they they're in Maine going to visit colleges. And, you know, within the first 10 minutes, we have Meadow going, Dad, are you in the mafia?
Yeah. Which is which is one of the great it like we're only five episodes into the show, but this is one of the great scenes. like interactions between tony and meadow because though the amount of defensive he begins at versus where he ends at in the conversation is hilarious he's like no i'm in waste management okay well maybe i make some money from illegitimate and he just starts to like soften the more the conversation goes and you realize that like at some point this probably and will and has happened in these families these mafia families the you know The La Cosa Nostra families, because kids were growing up in these families and some of the parents didn't want them part of the life. And we're going to see that in this show, how Tony feels about his kids possibly getting involved and what would their involvement be, would be and how might they be involved.
But I've always gotten the sense and it's made very clear early on that Tony has no interest in his kids having the same life that he does. And he and his rejection of, you know, him kind of rankling at Meadow saying like, aren't you in the mafia? also juxtaposed against edie falco kind of openly admitting it to father phil which again in that scene it's almost the inverse of what we're seeing with meadow father phil already knows like yeah there's like the fucking way and like he knows which is why he ends up like coming up short as it were at least that's my head canon as it were as to why father phil knows better Cause it's Tony Soprano's wife, but you get the inverse where she's sitting there bearing her soul to him.
And she thinks that like, she clearly thinks that like, this is some big revealing moment for her. And he's just kind of sitting there like, I'm. Glad that, that you and I are on the same page as far as he's very look, but don't touch. Right. Yeah.
Cause I was, I was thinking at first, I was like, is he giving off these vibes? Is she giving off these vibes? I mean, as soon as she knows it's him at the door, you know, she's sick at home, but she runs up to the bathroom and fixes her hair and does all this stuff. And I'm like, oh, okay. Yeah.
You want to look good for the priest. You want to look very good for the priest. Right. And so then there, her taking communion kind of becomes this like weird kind of like corrupted version of like foreplay sex. Yeah.
Which is, which is really interesting. Cause again, like later in the show, the term, the propane and the, Oh, my God. I forget what it is, the propane and something else. But it's like it's a it's a very hard malpropism that the show kind of rests one of the episodes on. And it kind of rears its ugly head here, which is like this moment that is meant to be so like full of religious kind of like meaning is so perverse intentionally only because of the way that it's shot. but it does kind of speak to this idea of like you said, like look, but don't touch, but like get as close as you can without actually doing it.
So we're offering communion in this very, you know, suggestive way. And then he's drinking the full cup and he's like sweating the whole time. It's all very reminiscent of a sexual encounter without any of the sexual interaction. And I, I, again, I find it to be really funny. Like it's meant to be funny.
It's shot in a way that like, If you're not finding this humorous, like you're not picking up on it, but like, it's a very funny scene. I have to say Alan Coulter who directed this one, right? He does not like to keep this camera still. He is doing so many camera moves, whether it's just a, you know, push in on the phone before Christopher answers that you've got a lot. I think the actual episode starts with kind of a circling around of Tony as he's looking around at the college campus.
And then when, The priest comes in. You've got him and Carmela and the cameras constantly going around them, getting closer and closer till it has a nice frame at the end. But really very, very well directed this episode. No, I agree. And there are some really fantastic shots like when Tony is taking a drunk meadow into the hotel room.
We're seeing a lot from Febby Petrullio or Frankie Peter. It's like the worst fake name. It reminded me of the recent season of Reacher where it's like, his name is A.M. He's just using this. It's like, God, that...
I don't think that the FBI's witness protection would make it that obvious. I don't think Henry Hill's name was like Hank Hiller. I mean, Hank Hillerman would be really like it would. It wouldn't. No way.
Like there'd be no way that they would keep the initials the same, even like by accident. But I love that scene where Bebby Petrullio is like watching and you see like the first person shot of him down the barrel of his gun and then it cuts to the other couple coming into the hotel. And then you see that he's missed his chance to kill Tony. But I just love that we're seeing like this tense moment that anything is like really you feel like anything can happen. I mean, obviously, you know that this show is going to continue given that there's six more seasons but like in that moment it's like oh my god like tony like he's gonna get the drop on him and he has the drop on him but but you know happenstance right you know the universe deus ex old people as it were deus ex geriatrico so yes yeah right But I think the thing for me, again, and to go back to this idea of the character of Tony changing in the episode, that moment, like you mentioned, where he's given an out multiple times.
Christopher's like, well, I'll come on the plane to Boston and I'll come deal with it. And he's like, or, you know, have Pauly come or have Big Pussy come. And it's like, no, like, this is me. He like there were people that I knew that he caused to suffer because of his actions. So Tony's like, I'm going to do it himself.
But I mean, up until that moment, like you said, like there is a more than zero percent chance that we don't see Tony do it because up until this point on TV shows, this was not a thing. Your main character murdering a man in cold blood is just not really a thing. Like it's at least again, like a guy who ostensibly murdered Did the right thing. I mean, again, I mentioned Henry Hill, not jokingly, but also like effectively he's meant murdering a Henry Hill type. Oh, yeah.
You know, like a guy who ran off to live his life elsewhere and no longer be in the mob. And, you know, he even says it like this guy goes and fucking talks on college campuses about how big man he was in the mob. And there are guys doing that now. I mean, yeah. Mickey the Bull or Sammy the Bull Gravano like that does it full time.
I mean, I read his book last year and he has he's on people's podcasts and stuff like, you know, like these guys are all doing it now. And like, it's funny because in another narrative, this guy is not the villain, as it were. He is the hero. He's the one who left the mob and, you know, trying to go straight forward. We see that he's not really going straight.
It's clear that he's like still dealing heroin, apparently, which is very Henry Hill of the narrative, because again, Henry Hill got kicked out of witness protection because he was still doing that. So, I mean, again, like it feels like kind of like a little bit of a send up of Henry Hill in a way. Yeah, I heard a great story on NPR where it was interviewing FBI agents who basically listen to all of the mob podcasts that are out there and are still connecting dots, like hearing stories and being like, oh, so that's what happened to that person and being able to like continually like dig deeper. It's like the cold case files and they get little hints from these podcasts. It's pretty amazing.
Well, and so that's, you know, the thing that we haven't really mentioned. I mean, we've kind of hinted at, obviously, like there is a movie, you know, The Many Saints of Newark. And so that's the prequel continuation of the story. Part of me wonders what The Sopranos would look. And it's never going to come back because no James Gandolfini, obviously.
But what would The Sopranos look like if it came back? And like one of those things would be like dealing with this idea of like all these mobsters now, at least the ones that are no longer in the mob or are not mobbed up or like just spilling their guts. Constantly like oh can you imagine Christopher's social media account. Right like and that's the yeah and that's the thing it's like you you get the sense the more you watch this show that like these some of these people are for serious and they're like they're no bullshit mobsters like Tony like Tony would never Tony would never take an opportunity to rat on anybody else like it's made very clear given what he does to a rat in this episode but you do see as the show goes on like that is not the case for everyone like Not only is that not the case for everyone, but the longer the show goes on, the circles start to close more and more and more because you realize that at the end of the day, the selfishness of these characters is not just within the mob.
It's more about themselves personally. And so what do you do when you're popped by the FBI is you become an informant to save your skin. And that's why Tony takes it upon himself to kill this guy because I mean, he says it when he's murdering him. He's like, you know, this is for, you know, this is for Jimmy. And he's like fucking strangling him to death.
And it's like you understand in that moment why he's doing it, because this is the moment that so many of these mobsters never get in reality. And so we're getting to see that Henry. I mean, again, the Paul Sorvino killing Henry Hill moment that the real person wishes he could have had, which is strangling a rat who put him in jail for, you know, because I mean, Tony says that he's like he was in jail and died in jail because of this guy. It's like, I'm going to fucking kill him like that. That moment feels again like if it were another show, this is not the hero.
But Tony is our hero of the show. So sure, he's going to murder a rat and the show is going to be like, yeah, he's murdering a rat. OK, yeah. He's got his means, and he knows what he needs to do, at least according to him. Right.
Well, and that's and that's the thing about the Tony Soprano character early on is you you get the sense when he talks to Dr. Melfi about all these things that he has done. But we never really he talks about it, but we never see it. And this is the first time we've ever seen him be like that man of action. And it's I mean, for you as someone who hadn't seen it and like you mentioned, like there was those moments where you thought someone else was going to come in. and and do it like was that scene with tony murdering the rat like was it as surprising as kind of the episode wanted it to be for you as as someone who'd never seen it before like does it still have that emotional like weight to it that it that it did when the episode first came out because this was a big deal like when it first came out obviously.
I don't think it it really hit me as hard as maybe it would have because for me i'm just like okay yeah it makes sense that he would kill this guy you know i just kept thinking well maybe he won't maybe you know he goes and he spies on the guy and he sees that he's got a little girl and he's got a wife and i'm like okay well you know maybe the little girl that'll appeal but yeah when it doesn't when he goes through with it i'm just like yeah it kind of makes sense so it wasn't like oh my god i can't believe that tony's killing this guy i'm like yeah he definitely gets his hands dirty. Right but but i mean again like this is that first moment and like again like for so many people at that time it was like oh my god like our our our main character in this show is getting his hands dirty and murdering someone and again like murder in so much television like especially like the cop stuff that we watch like we see people get shot and killed all the time all the time and like it's not like no big deal is made out of it like in plenty of barney miller we've had people like shot at, shot people in the show being threatened with guns and other things.
But here is like just a cold blooded murder. Tony just kills this guy, strangles him and then just ostensibly leaves his body in the middle of a dirt like field. So it's not that it's not justified. I mean, by the character of Tony Soprano, it's more than justified. But we as the audience theoretically should be aghast at what he's doing, because, again, he's chasing down someone who is going straight and Tony is never going to go straight.
Right. Oh yeah, definitely not. And I do like all the cross-cutting because I mentioned the two main storylines, but you also have once Fred, quote unquote, figures out that he's being followed, he then starts to investigate back and say, okay, have you seen this guy around? He's going around asking questions. He might even go to the same bar that Meadows is in.
I can't recognize which bar he goes into. And then you got Tony looking around, going through the whole phone book and finding the travel office and the bust of Reagan with the big lips. And that's the thing that seals the deal because of the whole, was it Frank Sinatra bust that was in somebody's living room that this carved? You got to work on the lips. He looks like Shaquille O'Neal.
And I love that. I love that in that shot, we see the lips of Reagan and then we just hear Tony go, got you, rat. so nice but I you know and like you mentioned like that moment is it's not shocking in that moment but man you get to see that like and again like as someone who's seen the show like this is that first the first inkling of it but James Gandolfini is a fucking force of nature as a actor and I mean like this is that first moment where you get to see the physicality of him because he's a big guy but man just that scene where he's just sweating and choking that guy out and he's just I mean he's going for it it's like a good minute and a half two minutes of him strangling this guy and he's Right.
Do you remember what they show on screen after he murders Febby Petrullio? And Tony looks up into the sky and he sees something. Oh, it's the fucking ducks. Right. Yeah.
I have my own headcanon as to what the show is going for, but I'm curious, like with you right now, as someone who hasn't seen the show past this episode, like, like what are you, what is your thoughts on the ducks? Cause like, I don't remember how much the ducks come back, but when they show up, like it's, they're getting at something and I have my own ideas as to what they're getting at, but I'm curious kind of what your thoughts are and like the usage of the ducks. Cause they keep coming back to the ducks throughout this first season. Well, the ducks for me are almost what could have been or his hopes and dreams. And they just keep flying away and they'll never be able to catch them.
Right. That's kind of what they seem like to me. My kind of read on it is like Tony in this moment, like this is an inflection point. Right. And there is a version of Tony that here's what this man has to say and says, like, I didn't kill you because you had a daughter.
And like, he's expecting that same, you know, from him. And he's like, well, fuck you, you fucking rat. And in a lot of ways, I wonder, like, if Tony had not done that, would anything that happens from here until the end of the show happen? Would those things have been different? Would Tony have been able to, you know, again, keep that family unit together, keep his family safe, provide for his family?
But I mean, again, I think the show makes it very clear, like, and there go the ducks once again, like just flying off into the distance. And you get that great shot of Tony seeing the ducks. And then you see the shot of the ducks point of view, seeing Tony moving away. Yes. And it's so it's so fantastic because, again, like I'm not doing the show's work for it.
The show is giving us this and asking us, what do we think? And again, like that was the big thing early on with this show. I mean, if you go and like read anything about the show in the early seasons, like the ducks are a big gag. I mean, I literally have a Funko Pop sitting on my shelf that it's Tony Soprano with a duck that it came with a little duck like that was a thing. That is so kind of associated, at least with the early show.
Like it again, I don't really remember how much it shows up throughout the rest of the show because it's such a first season thing to the point that it's in the first episode and then it shows up here. But I like the imagery of the ducks reappearing here and kind of this big, this big, important moment. And again, I think it further reinforces how important this moment is. to the character of Tony. And it's, I think it's a little on the meta side again, like some, somehow the show acknowledging that like things are going to start changing and your perception of the character is going to start to change, which is fine. I mean, I don't feel like it's handing something to me and being like, Oh, look at this.
Whoa. You know, it's not like lost or something where I'm just like, Oh boy, what does this mean? It feels very organic to the episode. Right. And that's the thing about this show that I've always appreciated is like it doesn't.
And I mean, again, if you don't know what the ending of this show is, and I know, you know, because again, like, how could you have lived at a certain time and place in our culture, be a certain age and not have heard of the ending and the way the show ended like you heard as well as I heard. And we were different thing where he gets attacked by ducks is just mind blowing. One giant duck. Honey Soprano gets stepped on by a giant duck at the end of the show. Is that what you think happens?
I would hate to ruin it if that's what you think. I think about the duck is playing a journey song and it fades to black and then you hear a quack at the end, I think. Quack, quack. That would be it. It just cuts to black and then you hear the door open and quack, quack.
What? I mean, that would that would be the true ending of the show. That would be great. But I mean, you know where the show is going. So you already know that the show is not going to hold your hand through a lot of this.
And I think for me, like, again, now we really live in a time and a place where like nuanced storytelling is, I think, almost expected. Frankly, like it, you know, we run into this problem when we talk about something like Barney Miller, right? Or a Columbo where it's like, oh, look, Robert Cope is playing two, three, four different characters. Look, you know, so many of these actors like Ralph Manza is playing like five different characters on Barney Miller. And there was a time and a place where that wasn't a thing that anybody cared about.
And now it's probably like, Not only is it the fucking inverse, it's like so far inverse at this point where like every single why? Why? I mean, again, I mentioned I think we're I don't remember what we were recording, but the Evan Peters thing in WandaVision like that in and of itself was like the worst example that I can think of of like people nitpicking the shit out of something and then the show just like. raising its middle finger in, in defiance, like fuck you internet fans. But when this show came out, there was none of that. And like, and like, as the show got to the end, people were more conditioned to kind of, you know, like, write dissertations about the last 30 seconds of the Sopranos because I've seen like a 40 page document of like, this is what happened at the end.
And like, let me tell you how the, and it's like, for fuck's sake, like it's in a lot of ways, like we're already seeing that the show is doing what it wants to do. And it's storytelling devices are in a lot of ways, looking at something that you expect and doing not necessarily the opposite, but it's doing something different. Like, Oh, the father comes over and this is you expect that this is going to be this kind of like tryst between Tony's wife and this kind of not lecherous father. But I mean, he's, you know, he's verging on it. but it doesn't happen. Like the show intentionally subverts your expectation.
And then at the end, it even subverts it even more. And I love that scene at the end when Tony comes home and Carmela's like, I just want you to know Father Phil was here all night. And he just laughs. He just laughs in her face like over and over and over again. He's like, what did you guys do?
Like name the Pope? But the expectation is that he's going to come home and be, you know, angry and like scream at her. And you've seen that. And like, but again, like Tony is so wrapped up in himself that he couldn't even believe his wife would do that anyways. And it's like, that's the benefit of this show is like so much of this show really is told through Tony's like through the way Tony is seeing the situation.
And like he is always himself almost to a fault. I love this whole thing, too. I mentioned Christopher and the phone and everything, and you've got Carmela and Tony connect via the phone. But I love that everybody is on the phone. You've got many conversations between Tony and Christopher.
You've got, gosh, there's a phone call with Dr. Melfi coming in. It's like anybody who isn't part of the show is available via phone, and they just keep getting phoned into... The whole shebang, which is pretty cool that, you know, they are carrying forward some of the other narrative threads, but it's all via these phone calls. So let's talk about what apparently the IMDb synopsis thinks is a big moment in this episode.
Carmela finding out Dr. Melfi is a woman is their interaction is so strange. Oh, yeah. Well, she thinks that Melfi is one of Tony's side pieces. Oh, and that was the other thing was the side piece that.
Oh, Irina. Yeah. Yeah, gets the phone call from her and the whole thing about her sister with the fake leg and stuff. I can neither confirm nor deny whether you will eventually see the one-legged sister in this show. But I was like, oh, right.
They introduced Svetlana, her one-legged sister, one-legged cousin, like fifth episode of this show. What's interesting about like, because the character of Irina has been in the show since the first episode, I believe, or like the second episode. You're right, yeah. She's it's interesting. Cause like you get the sense that Tony wants to leave his wife for her, or at least that's what like the overtures are.
And it's clear that that's never going to happen. It's never going to happen. And yeah, it's just stringing her along this entire time. Right. Right.
Which I mean, again, like this character shows up for quite a while throughout the show. So I just really didn't remember like so much of this gets like laid out early. Uh, I have a feeling she's going to at some point threaten to come forward and to tell Carmela, even though Carmela probably is very well aware that Tony is banging other chicks. But I think that that might be the end of her. That's my guess.
Interesting. Interesting. I will say that Tony's relationship with female characters in this show is interesting because he's so paternal with Meadow. but like but then even in that moment where she's like dad I have to tell you something and she like is honest with him about taking speed and he like lips on a die oh yeah and it's like and again like again it's hard to imagine what it would be like for this person to be your father knowing that again there is a more than zero percent chance that he has killed people and you know you notice she doesn't ask him that she doesn't ask the question that i think any one of us would ask our parents if they were in the mafia is like have you ever killed someone And she doesn't ask that.
And I think that that's an interesting omission from all the things that she asks, because in a lot of ways, like if I were in that position, I'm not sure that I would want to know either. No, no, I probably wouldn't want to know if my old man was a murderer. Right. But like there is that like sinking feeling that you wonder, like, which is like, is that the next question that she wants to ask? And she just stops herself because she sees again, because Tony begins to get visibly irate with her about like, you know, stop grilling me about this.
Like it's a waste management thing. or whatever it's not waste management tony but. Fine but fine um yeah and i was just i kept wondering is she gonna mention christopher's name is she gonna rat out christopher And I don't think she does. No, she does not. She does not. Because he asks her where she got it from.
She's like, well, now that you've reacted that way, I'm not going to tell you. It's probably a good call. But I do want to mention because we talked a little bit about Paul Schultz and Edie Falco. I really love that storyline with the two of them, because, yeah, he is kind of like. slaying he again like we're not sure we're kind of assuming what's going on with him is that he's trying to like you know show up and schmooze and you know oh i'm just here for the ziti i love how the mozzarella gets nice and chewy it's like shut the fuck up dude like we know why you're here but then like again you don't get the sense if nothing happens because he's drunk Or if because like subconsciously he's like after she takes communion and it like ish is is Carmela trying to push him away by taking communion and confessing?
Or does he stop himself? And again, I think to the credit of the show's writing, it's not made clear. It could be both of those things at the same time. But the writing of the show is so smart that we kind of yes to both. Yeah, exactly.
Doesn't he get sick, too, and run to the bathroom at some point? Right. But then he clearly has come out at another point because you see him on the couch later the next morning. But you kind of like that's kind of that final moment. But then you think like, oh, he's in the bathroom the rest of the night.
But then you see him on the couch in the morning. So it's just it's very interesting because like there will be a couple other characters where Carmela has these similar kind of like close calls with. And I won't say who, but like this is the first time that we see it. And what's interesting is we're already seeing this idea of like Carmela maybe is not for all of her kind of like problems with Tony's indiscretions. She's also maybe having her own kind of like as close as she feels like she can get without doing it because we all know what would happen should Tony find out.
And that's the thing. Again, it's the question comes back to is like, is Father Intantola, he's again, he's aware as to who Tony is. So like, why is he even putting himself in this position to begin with? Is like the real question here? Because like, if you know which he does, this is a bad idea any way you cut it.
Yeah, well, you know, just once as ZD. It's so important we named the show after it. No fucking ZD for me. He gets all the ZD. Yeah.
And that's the thing. Again, he never really makes the move, but you could consider what they're doing through that taking of communion kind of like, the closest she gets to like foreplay with him. But it's like, I just love the way that entire scene is shot. And then she's like, I'm leaving. And she's like, well, I got a DVD player.
Let's watch a movie. And it's like, oh my God, like. they're enabling this back and forth. And it's almost like they're playing chicken with one another. And then like they get to that moment and then he's like, oh, I'm sick. I have to go.
And it's like, is this, is he actually sick? Is it, what is he sick from? Is he sick from like, like this? Or is he actually just like thinking to himself, if I go through with this, like there's a, again, Tony Soprano will more than likely kill me should he ever find out. The thing, Edie Falco is not going to kill the women that Tony is sleeping with.
She'll just leave Tony. There's no physical threat from her to them. But Tony, the other way around, it's like there again, like Tony will just murder you. It's fine. Yeah.
Oh, definitely. Yeah. And then that makes me wonder, like, so, you know, he has just drank the blood of Christ. If he goes into the bathroom and throws it up, does it when does it not become the blood of Christ anymore? Is he committing some sort of like weird? catholic ritual when he when he throws up is that still the blood of christ or has it changed back into wine at that point oh.
And substantiation you're right instead of trans oh my god i mean I think probably when you flush it, that's when you like tacitly agree it doesn't matter anymore. And then it just leaves. And then it just, all of the water in sewage becomes the blood of Christ. That's what it is. Okay, yeah.
Well, that works. Yeah, right. I do like the scene in the morning when he wakes up and she's just like, pays him no mind at all. It's like, and again, it's like, okay, like what was going on? Like, and, and you, and again, when she says like, of all the Fanuc priests, why does mine have to be straight?
And it's like that moment, like that moment you understand, like in another universe, Carmela and this guy are together. Oh yeah. But then the question becomes, because again, like when she's, when she's talking about her relationship with Tony in that scene, she knows what Tony does. She makes no bones about it. And this is one of, I think, two or three of these kinds of scenes in the show where she like openly admits and acknowledges that like her entire lifestyle is based on more than likely the blood and bones and like sadness of other people, be it literally, figuratively, financially, emotionally.
And like she acknowledges it here very early on and she's going to acknowledge it a couple other times through the show. But to me, it's kind of surprising because, again, like this is not the kind of scene that we see in these kinds of things for the most part. For the most part, nobody ever acknowledges it. They're like in Goodfellas. They're just like all very happy and like all taking like.
You know, we would travel together. We would eat together. I mean, you know, that whole Lorraine Bracco monologue about like, you know, we would travel together and we were all family and like, but what is the reality of that? It's like all these people are making money off of the backs and sadness and like at the expense of other people. And rarely do we see characters acknowledge that in the way that Edie Falco does here in this episode.
And it's, again, it's kind of refreshing because most of the time it's the male characters admitting it. And in this, it's like a female character, the wife of our main character, ostensibly one of the show's main characters saying like, I know where this comes from. I know how we're living the lifestyle. This extravagant lifestyle that we're living is on the backs of other people. Yeah, no, it's a pretty great moment.
And it's very, very telling the way that it plays out. And I, I really she's just amazing. She is so good and such a, you know, such a performance we get from her every single episode. I know she's fantastic. And again, you know, we've talked about on other things, you know, like child actors and like younger actors.
But Jamie Lynn Sigler as Meadow is fantastic, right? Oh, yeah. You can read so much on her face when she's listening to Tony. It's so good. And then she also like calls him on his shit throughout the entire episode.
I mean, after he murders Febby, you see like he's got dirt on his shoes, his hands are bleeding. And she's like, where were you? What were you doing? Like, don't lie to me. You're being honest with me, right?
And he's like, no, he's he's doing the Michael Corleone thing. to her right then and there he's like no oh yeah nope like I'm honest with you like I'm being honest with you and she's like we have that kind of relationship right where we're honest with each other and he's like yep we do and it's like you're lying to her face and you're telling her you're being honest like you're a you're a sociopath like There you go. Like, again, like if you want an idea of who Tony Soprano is, this this episode gives you a pretty clear like line to follow of like this guy is adulterous. He's a murderer. And not only that, but he lies to his family constantly. Even when he's claiming he's telling the truth, he's still lying to them.
And the question is, why is he lying? Because what he's doing is reprehensible and he knows it. And he doesn't. But but then again, the question becomes, why is he lying? Because he doesn't want them to know because he wants them to have the ability to deny it.
Should anyone else ask? Like, again, everybody knows who he is. Like, nobody makes any bones about it. And, you know, we'll see in later episodes like AJ will confront him. AJ will confront him about it at some point.
And you'll see the same thing play out of like, how does a adult in the mafia deal with someone in their family confronting them about it? in a way that doesn't feel like, you know, again, it's a, it's right. It's trying to be a put on. It's trying, they're trying to do it in a way that feels somewhat real. At least. Yeah.
We always talk about the movies, the mobster movies when we're talking about this. And I love when she brings up the question about whether he's in the mafia that he says, like, like the godfather. And she's like, no, more like casino, you know, Sharon Stone and stuff. And I'm like, oh, okay. Yeah.
The, Different generation. He's from the Godfather generation. She's from the Casino generation. Christopher's probably from the Goodfellas generation. Well, the last time we saw Father Phil, I believe he asked, didn't he ask Carmela, he's like, which Godfather does Tony like?
And he's like, how does Tony feel about Godfather? And she's like, I think he likes one, two, but not three. like again like you wouldn't ask someone that if you didn't like know like and again like even though it's a recast character like that moment gives you an idea that like this guy already knows he's mobbed up and it's not again like in with this show coming you know out in 1999 right at that moment where the internet is just beginning to take hold plausibly you can deny some of this but like now as the show continues and progresses and people start to get cell phones and technology becomes more pervasive, we'll be able to see that like it's harder and harder to deny what's going on and who is doing these things and why these things are happening.
But early on in this first season, like there's still a little bit of like, who is your dad again? I mean, again, I think we saw it what in the last episode where AJ doesn't end up having to fight that kid because his dad is Tony Soprano. And, you know, like you you see that the manifestation of that there, and this is again, a similar manifestation of like, what does it mean for your dad to be in the mob? And like, and again, like all of a sudden we're somewhere where he recognizes someone now he has to go kill them. Like, of course, of course, just a happenstance, of course.
Yeah, and what a happenstance that is. What an episode. I'm so glad, because you were kind of teasing this one, and regardless of Tony killing somebody or not, this is just such a solid episode. I'm glad you liked it. Like I said, it really is, for me, the first great episode of this show.
It has two concurrent, two A and B storylines that kind of tie into each other thematically. And then again, there are some stakes with, like you mentioned, the rat character looking for Tony and doing his own thing. So there's a little bit of a ticking clock there. And then you also have a little bit of kind of a ticking clock with is Carmela actually going to do the deed with the father or what's happening there? Like it's I mean, it for me, I think I want to say in terms of like the list of the 20 best episodes of this show, I want to say this episode shows up a lot of the time.
I mean, again, there are really no terrible episodes of this show for the most part, aside from like one or two. But this one is always mentioned in conversations as one of the great episodes of this show, even outside of, like you mentioned, the whole Tony murders someone and kind of how big of a deal that was for just the narrative at the time. But it is such a great episode that does kind of change the way the conversation is being had about this show. It changes the way that Tony is kind of presented and perceived because up until this point, Tony has been a very likable character. Like really, like he really has, like he's been a rather personable guy, like someone that you'd like, oh yeah, I'd love to like get a beer with Tony Soprano as long as he doesn't try to like exploit me monetarily, which would be like a 0% chance of that happening because he's a literal sociopath.
But- But, you know, my point is like up until this point, there's been like he's been not presented in a way that like most people would find to be off putting. But now it's like this guy has murdered someone. So but again, we're following him from here until the end of the show. So there you go like that. The show just says and just fucking deal with it is what it feels like.
And I love that about this show. Like, this really helps change the conversation about what do you expect from the lead in your TV show? And we get a Breaking Bad. We get all these other shows, The Wire, The Shield, about, you know, again, flawed characters that aren't just the white meat hero that has no, you know, no complexity to them. There's nothing about them that's a problem.
And this show says not only is that not something that we want to do, but... we think that the audience can accept that there might be some complexity to our main character. Yeah, you know, it's a reason why people still talk about this show. It really delivers. Yeah. And I mean, again, back, back to the, the, the man at the center of it, like James Gandolfini, every episode, man, just like knocks it out of the park.
Just every time he's so, he's so good. Like you just want to spend all this time with him. Cause Tony is such already five episodes in, he's already such a fully realized character. And, James Gandolfini, just the longer the show goes on, the more you see him kind of settle into the character. But he already has like such a grasp on where where and what this man wants and how he goes about it.
But yeah, like I I'm still every time I sit down to watch the show, I end up watching like two or three episodes because I'm like, I just love this show so much. And I love the performances and what every everybody is operating at peak. Like the writing is great. The performances are great. Like nobody is turning in. a bad performance in this first season.
Like everything has been really tight and fantastic. And this episode is just another episode in that first season of just like great, great TV. Anything else? No. What do I have to look forward to next month, Chris?
So on the next episode of what? No fucking ZD. We're going to be talking about PAX Soprano, which I don't remember a whole lot. Some of the first season episodes, I don't necessarily remember everything. I know that, uh, There's more John Heard.
Okay. Which I'm not going to complain about. No, no, I love some John Heard. And maybe some more Vincent Pastore, who's been kind of absent from the last couple episodes. Yeah, he has.
I miss my big pussy. Yeah, yeah. He's a man, got a big pussy. And no Nancy Marchand in this last episode either. No, not even a phone call.
Much brighter episode for it. Thank you. Right? Yeah, yeah. She kind of brings the whole world down.
Yeah, she's the dark storm cloud, as it were. Mm-hmm. But yeah, no, on the next episode of What No Fuckin' ZD, we'll be talking about the sixth episode of the first season of the show titled Pack Soprano. And yeah, I want to say we're coming up after the next episode. We will be at the halfway point of the first season.
So making our way through that first season. So until then, Mike, where can people find you and the things that you work on? As always, you can find everything that I do over at weirdingwaymedia.com. It is the one stop shop for all things Mike White. How about you, Chris?
Weirdingwaymedia.com is where you can find all the things that I work on, including this show, the CultureCast, a whole bunch of things. We've talked about some of them on this show, even. So, yeah, you can find all of that over at weirdingwaymedia.com. As for this show, like, rate, and review wherever you get it. More than likely iTunes.
And, yeah, make sure to check in next month when we talk about the next episode of The Sopranos. The Sopranos
More from What, No F**kin' Ziti?
Similar episodes across the network
Matched by shared keywords.
-
Kulture Meltdown: Godzilla Minus Zero (2026)
3 shared keywords: chris_stachiw, mike_white, weirding_way_media
-
Kulture Meltdown: Crystal Lake (2026), Episodes 7–8 — "These woods are ours now."
3 shared keywords: chris_stachiw, doctor_of_podcasting, weirding_way_media
-
Kulture Meltdown: Crystal Lake (2026), Episodes 5–6 — "Kill them, Mommy."
3 shared keywords: chris_stachiw, doctor_of_podcasting, weirding_way_media



