Season 3 · Episode 2

Rings of Power S3E2 Recap: "The Gift of Men"

48 min Explicit Full episode
Rings of Power S3E2 Recap: "The Gift of Men"
The Podcast of Power
0:00
48:21
MP3

About this episode

An assassination plot, Isildur hiding behind a hood and a new beard, and far more Númenor than anyone asked for. Mike White and the Doctor of Podcasting, Chris Stachiw, recap “The Gift of Men,” and the island’s castle intrigue does not fare well: low-rent Game of Thrones, still stuck in season two while the rest of Middle-earth has jumped five years ahead.

The good stuff lives elsewhere. Sauron rigs his own contest to keep Theo alive, then offers him a father in the fire, a pitch straight out of Palpatine’s playbook. Marnukh crunches a centipede and tells the Elves what the One Ring is really for, opening a side quest to an Elven smith held at Gundabad. Two Nazgûl take off their helmets in front of Durin, Eddie Marsan’s angle comes into focus, and Mike and Chris weigh whether anyone from the films could still turn up before the series ends.

___

The Podcast of Power is a weekly Rings of Power breakdown from Mike White and Chris Stachiw — one episode at a time, plus whatever Middle-earth tangents we can't help ourselves from taking.  

Mike is the host of The Projection Booth. Chris is the host of The Kulturecast.  

New episodes every week. Follow the show so you don't miss one: https://www.spreaker.com/show/the-podcast-of-power  

Ratings and reviews on Apple Podcasts and Spotify genuinely move the needle on who finds us — it takes a minute and it helps more than you'd think.  

The Podcast of Power is part of Weirding Way Media. https://weirdingwaymedia.com

Transcript

Automatically generated, so expect the odd misheard name.

Thank you. Welcome to the podcast of power the only lord of the rings rings of power podcast available anywhere in the world online offline any place no one's allowed to talk about it except for us i'm your host mike white joining me of course is mr chris stashu. I have a secret that could help you save middle earth do you like man flesh. It's startup a butcher shop Just hanging in the window. Oh, that'd be great.

The long pig. That is the gift of men is their flesh. That is the episode that we were talking about. The gift of men. Second episode of the third season, the 18th overall.

We've got our friend Charlotte Brandstrom back in the director's chair. She did this one, the previous one and the last episode of this season. very consistent when it comes to the writers and directors of this. There's just a handful of folks that are writing and directing these, and then just a handful of folks that are watching the show. So on this episode, we're going to talk about The Gift of Men, where we go back to Chris's favorite place in the entire world, the island of Numenor, where he likes to try to If you can't see him, you have to picture Chris having those Al Farazan eyebrows that just kind of twist up at the end. If you don't think that Chris looks evil enough with regular eyebrows, the twisting up at the end really adds a good effect.

I wish I had those eyebrows, man. I think I mentioned it when we were doing the show last season. That is that fucking actor's real eyebrows. Yeah. that's just the way, like they may be giving them a little bit of a twist on the end, but they were like, who do we know? Who do we know out there?

That's got real great eyebrows. Tristan Gravel on top of everything else. What a great name. What a, uh, overwhelmingly, uh, British or Scottish or Welsh name or Irish. One of those, I I'm assuming just, you know, with the way he looks and the way all of the Numenoreans are cast is apparently people of British or Scottish or Irish or Welsh descent.

Like that's, That is where these characters are coming into the show. I really don't like the Numenorean stuff because it is low rent Game of Thrones. And it feels like it feels like the hold over stuff from last season and the season before that, frankly, like it's I am prepared for it to be over with because everything that is going on in Numenor is broadly uninteresting, which is so disappointing because we know at some point Isildur is going to be a rather important character to the, to the probably next two seasons, if not this season of the show right now, Isildur is just fucking around in Numenor. Great. Yeah.

I didn't even really recognize Isildur when I saw him in this episode for a long time. I was just like, who's this guy? It's like, if you think that Theo changed his appearance, there's also this guy. So I'm like, Okay, yeah, all of this castle intrigue stuff in Numenor, I agree with you. It's weak sauce.

I'm not really invested in it. And they're going to have to do something to make the fate of Numenor tie a lot more to the fate of Middle-earth, because I don't care. I don't care that now we've got rebels and they're trying to kill El Farazier. yeah like you've got who's in on it who's not I mean this episode it gave me a little bit of whiplash with just how much stuff was going on in Numenor this whole thing of oh there's this assassination plot and here's this old lady who's a handmaiden of I mean for lack of a better term the princess but it's not the blind princess it's Is that Alphazir's daughter? No, it's Isildur's sister. Isildur's sister.

OK, thank you. Because I was just like, was she evil? But was there a daughter in the last one who is a real see you next Tuesday? I thought so. OK, yeah, because I don't see her.

I just see the sun and Alphazir. Maybe that was her. Like, they've just rejiggered the character. Like, again, that wouldn't surprise me like. Yeah, and then there's the other guy.

Like, the other guy who's hanging out with El Verzon. I'm just like, who is this dude? Yeah, who is that guy? Okay, I'm glad I'm not the only one. I'm glad, yeah.

We pick up with what we were doing last time. We get the little flashback. We know that Theo's going to be in this. We know that Numenor's going to be important. Also, a little reminder, when Sauron shows us the box full of rings that I think he picked up at Jared's, there are four rings that are gone right now.

We saw at least two of those rings last time with the one Nazgul who attacked Galadriel, the rune person, I can't remember what it is, the Kamul. Kamul! Camul, not camel, but Camul, the fairest of the Nazgul. It's Camul al-Sayed, right? I think you might be right.

Yeah, I think so. It's so funny. You're like, these guys are Middle Eastern coded, right? Guy takes his helmet off. Yes.

Absolutely. Very Middle Eastern coded. 100%. Yes. Yes.

Yes. Abdul Al-Sayed getting my vote for sure. One of the Nazgul doing great things for the Nazgul. Yep. You know, he hates blacks.

He hates Jews, but he loves the Nazgul loves orcs. Yeah. But I mean, yeah, I, I could really give a shit about all this Numenorean stuff. And, we have this assassination plot. We know it's going to be foiled.

We know that this guy is going to be sticking around for the whole thing. So he might get killed before the end of the season, but not in the second episode. No, not at all. And yeah, like it'll still do her. We're rocking the beard.

I'm just like, Oh, who is this guy? What is going on here? I'm amazed that a beard could throw me off that much. I am, yeah, I think, and I think we talked about it every time we did Numenor last season. Like, I could not care less about anything to do with Numenor.

Because, like you said, Numenor is not, I don't know, it's not that it's not interesting, it's just what... What is happening in Numenor is going to affect everything else. But I kind of just don't care because it is just I have seen it done in other shows better. And what they're doing here is not even it's not even Castle Intrigue should have some complexities. There should be, you know, like, you know, to quote one of our favorite things. there should be plans within plans.

Like that's the castle intrigue of Dune, isn't it? Like that's, you know, to speak to castle intrigue in Dune, like plans within plans and, you know, who is backstabbing who and why and what does that mean and who is benefiting and who is not benefiting? Like all of that is answered in one scene in Dune much better than it's ever been answered in all of the Numenorean cutaways in this show. And there, again, in this episode are a ton, A ton. Most of this episode is spent in Numenore.

Yeah, I have a feeling even though this episode of the Rings of Power is an hour, I think that we will probably be not speaking that much about it because of the Numenorean of it all. I mean, well, yeah, we'll recap a little bit, but I'm much more interested in the Theo stuff that's going on, which is weird for me to say. But this whole thing, you mentioned in the last episode that Theo is really giving an Anakin Skywalker vibe. I definitely see that with this episode especially. I like that Theo doesn't cheat, but Sauron cheats, which makes sense.

He is the Lord of Lies after all, but that he cheats in his own contest and murders the Southlander that is about to murder Theo just because he sees the mark on Theo's arm. and it's yeah you're not the best you're not the strongest you are of the last two people the second of two but i'm still going to rig this game in order to find out what's going on with that mark on your arm and then this whole like oh yeah my father left me this gift and then it's like oh yeah you want to meet your father i can show you your father it kind of reminds me of like uh uh blade you know where it's like oh yeah your mother yeah she's still around like yeah she's my whore upstairs and instead it's your dad is a talking pile of rocks i guess it's a fire it's a very serious black showing up and talking with harry potter out of the fireplace kind of stuff i'm just like i'm not sure exactly what you're doing yet soran i don't imagine you're telling the truth because you are a dastardly villain but uh okay there is something that is interesting you in theo enough to have gotten you off your ass to stab that other guy not that it takes a lot for Sauron to be motivated to murder someone.

No. And, you know, that's the thing I, you know, I think if we have Theo as a Nazgul at any point in the show, like it will. it will be partially because of his own downfall, but also because of Sauron's machinations, which for me, I think is the right way to play it, right? Like to play it where you have the villain being directly involved in it and it not just being, oh, you know, the character is turning on their own. Like, no, we're having the character like further manipulated by the villain. It allows us to further hate the villain in this show.

Like Sauron is just, he is that awful. And I kind of love it. Like, I love that Charlie Vickers is just playing this character, full throated villain. Like, and it's not like you said, like in that first season of the show, like they don't hold back. Like, you know, Middle Earth is getting destroyed fucking outright in the first season of this show.

Like there are broad changes that happen. You know, we mentioned in the last episode that this this third season is kind of a soft reboot of the show. Almost every season of the show has been a soft reboot of the show, because last season it was all about Caleb Brimbor, who was barely a part of the first season. Like this show has kind of navigated throughout its own kind of storylines and given certain storylines more importance than others. And that makes it feel very different as a show because yes, Game of Thrones would cut away to other stories, but they would still like for the most part, come back to them like this show.

They're also saying like possibly some of the storylines are out of the show completely, which I mean, again, would also be kind of strange like that. The idea that the show has to follow a certain preordained way of doing things, I think, in the day of streaming is unnecessary as well. The stuff in Numenor and the stuff that is not Sauron related, I think in this episode specifically, broadly uninteresting. And I wish I knew what to do about the, I wish they knew what to do about the Numenor stuff. I can't do a goddamn thing about it.

I wish they knew how to better suit the Numenor storyline because there is interesting stuff going on. It's literally a race of giant men who think that they are due the immortality that the elves have. They've barely even treaded into that fucking ground. Like that's, that is the issue with what Numenor wants. Like they have, Farazan makes that somewhat clear.

But I mean, again, like me saying it right here, like that is his character motivation. They want to live forever. they think that they are deserved the ability to live forever because they are the last true men of middle earth, you know? Yeah. Something that would be important to know because right now there is no motivation for these guys. They're just kind of hanging out and like, yeah, fuck the mainlanders.

It's like, that's your motivation is just being a prick. So yeah, have something going on where it's like you said, we want this. I mean, and we've seen, I think the orcs are basically twisted versions of elves, right? It's like you pour the evil into it. Here we have this brand new crop of orcs, including Shadrag, I guess.

Not the same Shadrag that we have in the Lord of the Rings, but this is the guy with the big metal horns almost coming off of him. Last season, we had the guy who I kept thinking had a mustache. I like to call him the Bob Belcher of orcs. This time we have this guy with this crazy get-up going on. And poor Sauron has to be pretty lonely because he doesn't have that many humans to talk with.

It's all orcs. And I think this season is going to prove to us that orcs really aren't great conversationalists. It's like, I'm kind of reminded of evil from Time Bandits and just how he's surrounded by a bunch of nincompoops. I guess if you're trying to be impressive, you just surround yourself with a bunch of sycophants, a bunch of low-life creeps, and they just won't stop talking about, I don't know, closing borders and testosterone. Who are these weirdos?

Transgender people? Yeah, he's just surrounding himself with a bunch of weirdos. It's like, all right. It's so weird to see that in this show because I've never seen that happen in real life. It is funny, I think, wasn't it in the last episode, Celebrimbor was like, I think that the orcs are beginning to pity you.

It's like, holy shit. Like that, I think, you know, to speak to Sauron, right? Because Sauron as a character is very interesting. Because again, we've talked about this before last season, like they're, up until this point in Lord of the Rings, Sauron has been ever present, but un- corporeal. And that was, I mean, kind of honestly, one of the weakest parts of Lord of the Rings is that it's a proxy war that Sauron is fighting through his like, you know, many, many men, his, you know, the, the Southlanders or the men of rune or the orcs or whomever.

And the, the best part of this show is Charlie Vickers has Sauron period. And it's because we finally get to see scenes where we see Sauron's motivation. And we get to understand who Sauron is as a character. And like you said, he is the world's loneliest man. And I love that they, the writers of this show understand that, that this kind of pursuit is a lonely one and one that is not, you do not surround yourself with great people if you are doing this.

And again, like the orcs are, It's interesting because the orcs are a little bit more complex of characters in this than they ever were in the Lord of the Rings movies. In the Lord of the Rings movies, they're not really given any autonomy on their own. Here they are, and it's very interesting because as characters that are given their own autonomy... we get to see a character like Marnuk go off and do the Gollum thing where he's like, I'm going to lead you to, I'm assuming Gundabad to, to find the, I guess it's the Elven Smith that they have there that they didn't know they've had. And there's just been sitting there. And again, you know, they talk about it in the Hobbit where it's like, you know, well, you're a dwarf.

I'm an elf. I can just wait you out. You'll die eventually. And I'll never die. Like, In reverse, it works the same way.

You can jail an elf forever. And, you know, so an elven smith being jailed at Gundabad, you know, that they don't know about makes sense. But it's interesting that we have an orc with agency. Because orcs have not been given agency up until this point. Because Gollum's not an orc.

Gollum is just a kind of perverted human-esque thing. Like, we've never seen an orc with agency, period. Absolutely. I mean, the most we get... is some of the orc high in, especially in, uh, the two towers and then like little things like, what about their legs? Like that guy, you know, but that's about it.

Like, yeah, like barely anything. And when it comes to like the goblins in the Hobbit movie, other than the goblin King, none of them really have lines. I mean, they don't even look that humanoid in, uh, in that movie. and I know goblins and orcs are two different species. Yes. I'm not being specious.

Then I know orci and orcs are also two different species, but I have to say that there's a wide variety, very wide variety. I mean, it is, uh, it's like, you know, uh, a melting pot when it comes to how different orcs can look, you know, they all look very, very different. I've never seen two orcs that look exactly the same. I mean, you get some of those really interesting orcs, like the, uh, The guy who's leading the troops in Return of the King, who looks very Harvey Weinstein-esque, you know. But yeah, this guy.

And yeah, like as soon as I see him in this episode eating this massive centipede, I'm just like, OK, yeah, he's the golem of the group. And, you know, it's almost like, you know, you expect him to, you know, shout off from the sidelines like, hey, I found this huge sandwich over here. You got to eat that. Yeah. Oh, I'm sorry.

I spilt my my gruel all over the plate. You know, like he just says it seems like he's going to be comic relief almost, but not quite. And I hope he doesn't become comic relief. Well, I was going to say the same thing. I hope he doesn't become comic relief either, but I also genuinely hope that they don't lean on this for too long because I don't, that's the thing.

Like as much as I appreciate that the show is kind of doing some things that we've already seen before, like, you know, Elrond and kind of, elrond and gim and well i would say elrond and gimli but elrond and durin kind of doing the gimli legolas thing or you know gandalf in those first two seasons doing the kind of gandalf and the hobbit thing from those you know from the fellowship and then from the hobbit like all of those all of those things that they were doing were again very nail on the head and i know why they're doing it now because now they're trying to make sure that they have again like they have the right audience here. Like they need, they need the audience here that is going to stick with the show for the next two seasons.

And so they're trying to give people something that they recognize, which is a Gollum-esque character leading to other characters on a quest. Like it, it makes sense. He seems like an interesting character, but it is on the, you know, it is derivative obviously, but not in a bad way. It's just, you're kind of playing to the tropes of Lord of the Rings, which is, OK, good tropes. They're solid tropes.

Yeah. Yeah. I mean, it's, you know, can't really blame them. It's worked before. And I mean, we know how dangerous Gollum ultimately was.

I mean, that those are some of the best scenes, right? The Gollum Schmiegel scenes, especially when he's having the self debate. I mean, that's probably probably one of the best moments in. The film for me two towers so much the two towers is the best of those three movies I mean the first one I think is the best one the second one is my favorite because of all the Smeagol Gollum stuff because Andy Serkis's role as Gollum is it had to be as good as it is and it is still as good as it was then now like genuinely like you go watch it now And that performance is still just as fantastic now as it was then. And that's the thing I will applaud them for in this is this is not CGI.

No, no. They're all practical makeup, which looks really good. Right. Which I applaud the show for because even Peter Jackson didn't do that. I mean, I don't think he could with Gollum, I guess.

Right, right. The other guy that we're talking about is Lord Belzagar, played by Will Keane. And I imagine if we went back, not that we're going to, but if we went back to the previous seasons, maybe in like a scene where a giant bird shows up and says. Oh, this is the king. He's probably hanging out somewhere around there, but he's really elevated in this episode.

And okay, great. Cool. And yeah, I've already talked about pretty much everything I'm going to talk about when it comes to Numenor, at least at this point. We get the guy who... is in on the plot, and then we get the revelation that Isildur's sister is part of this whole thing. Okay, great.

She offers to help him with his sufferings in private, and then he ends up getting killed. Okay, yeah. I really just want to stick to the other stuff, so let's get through this stuff and get back to The elves and the dwarves. I mean, it is a good shot cut when we have the old lady hanging in the city square. I mean, you know, I'm all for bringing back public executions.

I think that's really what unites a country. Me too. I, the Isildur, Maxim Baldry in this episode, with the beard, for whatever reason, he reminds me of John Krasinski when Krasinski's got the beard. Yeah, I could see that. I do.

I do like that. He's just cloak faced most of the episode as well. He just has the, the cloak three quarters on his face. So you just see like the little bit, you know, it's like, Oh, I really don't remember who this is now because half of the characters in the show are just bearded white or white adjacent men. So I, you know, with the character of Ari and the, the sealed or a sister, like what I don't, I want to say like, what a waste, but just what a.

It's basically just for the listening audience who know that we spoil these episodes because this is a post show. She shows up and she like I barely remember her from any of the previous seasons. That's why I was asking, who is this person? She shows up really prominently in this episode. And by the end of the episode, before the credits roll, she's dead.

Of her own hand. She kills herself because, you know, again, what is the most obvious thing? someone is in on a plot trope to have. If someone is in a room and someone else is in a room and they don't see them, but when they leave the room after the other person leaves, the other person was in fact hiding around a corner to see them leaving. Like, oh my God, how, like you could do a fucking, a hyper cut of all of those scenes together. Like it's, I don't understand, like for a show that is not phoning it in everywhere else, it is beyond phoning it in with Numenor.

To the point where I'm like, do we even need cutaways to this? Do we need to know what's going on in Numenor? To the point where, because it hasn't affected anything else so far. The closest these two worlds have gotten so far is Theo... working for the Numenoreans and going off to fuck off with Sauron. That's it.

Like these two worlds have barely ever, if crossed at all, like Isildur and his dad are like, they were, they were in middle earth for like a moment. And then they went back. Like it's, there's most of the Numenore stuff has been contained to Numenore. Like it's, I really wonder, if you were watching this show, the stuff with Numenor would put me off. If I wasn't a fan of Lord of the Rings the way that I am right now, the stuff with Numenor would be putting me off because it is not interesting at all.

Absolutely. Here I am praising the last episode about showing us a map. We get a map of Numenor, finally, after all this time. Now I actually get a mental picture of where the big city is, where Ilseuldur has fucked off to because he's kind of on the outs right now. So we actually get to see like, okay, here's the havens of the faithful and here's this little city.

And it's like, all right, there's more than one town on Numenor and there's different areas of Numenor. Cause I'm frankly was like, I don't know how big or little this, thing is is it just an island state or is there more well now we get to find out a little bit more we get to see the bay of elros which is the secret faithful refuge i don't care with you and your rebel alliance just yeah i didn't like we're gonna use the palantir to talk to dad by the end of this episode and Who cares? I mean, don't use a Palantir. I mean, it's an open line. Anybody can be listening in on these things.

Yeah, I love that the Palantir keeps showing up as this like, well, don't use it. And it's like, then don't use it. Stop using this thing that has been described so many times as a bad choice of ways to communicate. Like maybe it's better if dad just doesn't know what's going on. Exactly.

Yeah. Yeah. We don't have to call and check in on that. I mean, he's a fucking carrier pigeon. You know, they got they got to have pigeons and Middle Earth, right?

No, I guess they only communicate via Palantir or in person or via maybe Giant Eagle. Like, it's it's so funny. Like, you know, if you want me to care about Numenor, give the characters in Numenor some space. standing with somebody else in the world, have them interact with somebody else, have them interact with anybody else other than themselves. Like I, I am, I am wagering what's going to happen is once Numenor falls, those characters that have escaped Numenor and the fall of Numenor are going to be integrated into the rest of the story. They're pretending like a, if you're watching the show, you don't know that Numenor is falling, which I guess to be fair, I don't know.

When we talked about it before, you did not know that. And you were a big fan of Lord of the Rings. Yeah, but also at the same time, we see her having visions way back in, I think, season one. So it's like, we haven't seen one of those in a while. So yeah, you might've forgotten that it's gonna fall.

Right, and I think it's just one of these things where we probably should have had these characters introduced earlier in the third season. Like, okay, now, cause like, and be, let's, let's like, let's be honest here. Nothing that has happened to Numenor up until this point has been fucking important. Like Farazan has taken over, but that's it. Like even now, like he's just taken over.

Like Muriel is still around. She's still trying to have him killed. Like she's still a presence in the world. So where we left at the end of season two is still the same place we're at at the beginning of season three. Yikes.

Like other stuff has changed in the world more so than in Numenor. It's just, it's weird. Like everything that's been going on in Numenor feels very stuck in time. And the fact that this episode, which is Numenor centric feels very much like an episode from the last season of the show is is indicative of the quality of the Numenor storyline. We've fast forwarded five years on Middle Earth, but Numenor is stuck in season two.

You're absolutely right about that. Yeah. If this feels like a season two episode, I mean, the response to it, the reaction, I went and read some kind of reviews of like AV Club, people that were covering it, and the drop off between the first and second episode is like, first episode's great, second episode, not so much. Like, Yeah. And killing off a character that we barely have any time with is not going to move the needle for me one bit.

Like there's a lot of stuff going on in Numenor that's just if I was engaged, I would care. But because what's been going on is so unengaging and uninteresting, I don't care. And therefore it makes me. want them to feature this even less. Like just feature it as little as possible. Like if and when this show is over, like a super cut just without the Numenor stuff, like, you know, can we, you know, I wonder how many seasons it'll take until the Numenoreans actually start interacting with other people in a substantive way.

I haven't looked for a fan edit of seasons one and two, but I imagine they exist. And yeah, I bet you that's the thing. Cause yeah, I mean, there are fan edits of even the original, you know, the, the sacred text. There are fan edits of that. There are fan edits of the Hobbit, which are actually pretty good.

Taking six hours down to four hours, taking Alfred the fuck out of there. It's like, okay, yeah, this works. Yeah. The most important part of this episode is like, here we are, here we've got Durin and his brother, and these two Nazgul show up, take off their masks, which is pretty cool to see a Nazgul taking off his mask. I think one of them is the white one, Paul Hickey.

I think he was the same one from the last episode, the first Nazgul that we ever see. The other guy is not showing up. I like how This is a weird feature, but I like the whole thing of, what do you call that, on Amazon Prime where you can pause and it will show you. Yes, X-Ray. I do like X-Ray for that, but it's not always that great because right now they show the one Nazgul.

Oh, there we go, finally. The other one is Harrod Nazgul. The white one is Losoth Nazgul. Yeah, so good to see these guys. We get to see this whole play out of, again, everybody has seen this episode, I hope, so I'm not going to be spoiling things.

We get to see this whole farce that, I almost said Gimli Durin's brother pulls off here in front of these two Nazgul. And then we find out later on, oh, he's in Cahoots. And he's basically like, I told you motherfuckers not to show up and start showing your ass around here. You have to really play this a lot smarter. Don't do it this way.

So yeah, we get the elimination of one person who was helping out stuff with the Numenor things, who gives a shit. But then we find out that Eddie Marzen is a traitor and is working with these Nazguls. So it's like, okay, what has he been promised? Are they going to do their machinations and try to make him king? That's what I feel is going to happen.

I assume that that's what he's angling for, that he's, you know, I will promise you X if you make me king. It is trippy to see the Nazgul without their face helmets on. Yeah. It's weird. It's, it's very, it's, it's, it's actually, and you'll laugh, like it's very unintimidating.

I would say like, it looks a little goofy. Um, but I, I'm really glad that Eddie Marson is again, he's a villain. He, he's a great character actor. He's playing a great, like, again, a villainous role, like a, and you know, now it's, I didn't think he wasn't villainous in the last episode. Like, it's like, come on, like you're introducing him for this like show.

Like he's, unless he's going to be a, a mainstay, like Jamie Campbell Bowers, who I'm assuming is just going to be in the show from here on out, it's going to be a, like a, a big, bad, you know, one-off season villain. And, you know, maybe Eddie Marston sticks around for a while, but he does kind of strike me as like, this is the big, this is the big bad of Duren's storyline, which we finally get. Like we finally get that. Like, cause we know that the Balrog ain't going anywhere. Yeah. anytime soon.

So there has to be like threats that can be managed and handled and dealt with in between now and kind of the, the bigger, the bigger threats. And so having him have a brother who has been alluded to up into this point and now is showing up, like makes sense. Like, you know, it kind of reminds me of, you know, we're in between season three and four of the Sopranos, but in season four of the Sopranos characters will be introduced that they've talked about up in, you know, in the first three seasons of the show. And it's like, That's a really smart way to build the world is to mention characters and then actually have those characters show up. It actually feels like the world building is kind of existing within itself.

And it's very smart to have Eddie Marson playing Durin's brother who wants the throne for himself, like clearly. And, you know, is that a trope we've seen before? Yes. But is it one that we've seen in Lord of the Rings? Not really.

No, no, actually not really. I mean, I think the closest we get to is the steward of Gondor who doesn't want to give up power. Right. And just wants to eat tomatoes all day. I mean, who wouldn't, right?

Especially if it's Walter Noble. If I had my brothers. Yeah, well, he was Walter and Fringe. Is he going to show up at any point in the show? I'm wondering if anyone will show up from the movies in the show.

I'm assuming not. right? I'm assuming that as well. Yeah. But you never know that final episode of the show, they have a 5,000 years in the future cutaway to Frodo again. They just keep carting Elijah Wood out for the fucking shit, man.

Like, cause he went, what it was, it wasn't at him and Ian Homer, the only, and Gandalf, I guess were the three that came back for those Hobbit movies, but it was really Elijah Wood. That's still the one I'm just like. Are you forgetting Legolas and how important Legolas was to those Hobbit movies? Yes, I am forgetting intentionally. Thank God.

Oh God, that was so bad. I mean, Legolas is bad, but Frodo is the one that's just like unneeded. The Legolas one, at least they try to like work him into the story. Like Frodo, it's like we're trying to make this tie directly into the first movie. So you can have your all day marathon and just go right from one to the next.

That's what I'm saying. That's what they need to give us at the end of this show. They need to make it where this is now part of the full rewatch of Lord of the Rings. You can't just watch the six movies. You have to watch the fucking five seasons and the six movies.

Like, We're going to see those dwarves rolling out of the Misty Mountains and heading heading towards the Shire. So, yeah, I don't think that they would do that. But at the same time, this is a direct tie in into the movies. And a lot of the actors from the movies are. You know what?

OK, I'm going to float to you the one person it could be. OK, and I think you would agree with me that the one person it could be would be in McAllen. Yeah. Or Andy Serkis. Or third option, Cate Blanchett.

But I think that's as far as you could go, right? Hugo Weaving doesn't do anything anymore. Hugo Weaving's like, I don't want to work in Hollywood. I don't want to work for Marvel. And I don't want to work for, I will work for nobody.

That's what I'm working for. Let my niece, Samara Weaving, do all the acting that I no longer do. I would see, I could see Ian McKellen being in this at the end, like as like a bookend. Because, again, like of all the characters on the show that resemble the characters in the movies, Gandalf, for as much as we were joking about not Gandalf, Gandalf, question mark. He is still the one that resembles a character from the movies the most.

I agree. I agree. I was just thinking maybe we end this with the ring being found by young Schmeagle. Or actually, Deagle is the one that finds the ring. Maybe Deagle is the guy that shows up in this.

Well, I was going to say, or does this show end with... the final scene is just a, a shot of, yeah, I guess it, is it, is it of Deagle finding the ring or is it the ring being cast into Mount doom? Cause like, I think, I think you're going to have to address the end of the movies at the end of the show, because I think so in some capacity, because again, like it's, It's going. To be a redo of the battle that begins the Lord of the Rings. And it's going to be this Il Sildur's heir saying no when this Elrond says cast it into the fire. I guess that's the question I have for you is like, do they recreate that in this show?

Like maybe, maybe. Well, that's the thing, right? Because what we don't know is how much of what happens after Sauron gets defeated do we see? Because that's the question, right? And that's been the question this whole time with that five-year jump is like, how much of this are we going to see played out in real time?

And there could be another time jump at the end of this season. It could be hundreds of years. If it wanted to. Because they have enough room to play. Yeah, they've got slack.

Yeah, they do. And I don't know where this show ultimately ends up in terms of the narrative it's telling. I just want it to stay far away from Numenor moving forward. And I hope that this season is when Numenor falls so that we don't have to see any more of the Numenorean stuff. Because once...

I guarantee once the Numenorean characters are integrated into the elves and the dwarves and other things, it won't be an issue. But because they're all kind of situated on Game of Thrones Island together, and again, Game of Thrones only worked because the people who were writing that show understood how to make castle intrigue interesting. It could have been good, but it's not. And it's not because it's very hard to do. I don't think those characters will struggle to be interesting. when they're paired up or with or against the characters that we have come to be invested in in the show, like Galadriel, like Erandir, like Elrond. like Theo, like Sauron.

Once they're actually able to interact with them directly, I think it'll be much more interesting than them all being on their island fucking around together. And it ultimately, I mean, again, if you have never had exposure to Lord of the Rings and you're just watching this show for the first time, you would have no earthly fucking idea what the Numenoreans even part of this is. Still, it has not been made clear what they are going to factor into everything or how. And- If I were watching this show as the uninitiated, I would probably find the Numenorean parts to be the weakest parts of the show because it just doesn't seem like it's addressing the larger conflict. It very much reminds me of Game of Thrones where Dany was stuck in across the narrow sea.

She was stuck there for like three seasons of an eight season show. Half of the show. She's not even in the main part of where the show is taking place. And this reminds me of that. It's like, at some point, they'll get to Middle Earth.

At some point, they'll interact with what's going on in Middle Earth. But right now, they're just fucking around. And it's really uninteresting, unfortunately. And I think it slows down what's otherwise a really interesting show with some really uninteresting castle intrigue in very heavy quotations. We get the return of the Orc Mork.

I'm going to screw that. Up for a while. Marnuk. And really bringing something to the fore that we haven't thought about, or at least I haven't thought about. This is the revelation to the elves, hey, Sauron is making the One Ring to enslave all of the other rings, the Master Ring, which is kind of a big Now we have a ticking clock for these elves who, again, we talked about this in the last episode, how much do they think these rings are free from Sauron's influence?

Well, no matter what, once that one ring is forged, those other three rings become slaves to Sauron and the one ring. So now we have the literal one ring to rule them all line being dropped by the orc. which is pretty great. And this becomes this whole thing of like, oh yeah, there's this Elven Smith that is over here. We have to go to the da-da-da-da-da. Now we get this new, what do you call these?

A side quest? Side quest, yeah. Side quest. Side mission, yeah. Yeah, go and find the Elven Smith that Sauron has at Gundabad and has it at Gundabad for seemingly some time now.

Yeah. What's nice that we have the three elves of this show coming together in this episode. Because Arandir, he just feels like he's been kind of on the outs. And this one, we actually get Galadriel calling him a friend, which seems to kind of knock him aside a little bit. Like, oh, I'm your friend?

Yeah, I guess we've probably been together for like 20, 30 years at this point. So yeah, I guess we're friends now. So it's good to see him. I You know, I do appreciate that there are the different, I don't want to say classes of elves, but the different groups of elves, even just seeing like when they were fighting in the last episode and the way she uses the sword, he uses bow and arrow, the way that she has her armor. He's got that great, uh, looks almost like green man armor.

I really appreciate that. That's pretty awesome. And then, yeah, we're kind of like, all right, let's start this show off properly. 40 minutes into the show. It's like, you know, it took so long for us to get here because of all the Numenor bullshit.

And it's like, yeah, no, I want to see what's going on with Soran and Theo. And I mentioned the fire stuff and it's like, oh yeah, I'm going to, you know, when he says like, death is not always the end. I'm just like, like you said, you know, have you heard about Darth Plagueis the wise? Like here, let me, let me give you access to your father so that I can control you in another way. Yeah.

But, Pretty great. Pretty smart. Weak-willed characters. I love them. Oh, yes.

Weak-willed characters are kind of my favorite. Like, I love a weak-willed character who falls apart and then becomes a villain and then thinks by becoming a villain, they are now the strong-willed character. It's like, nope, you're still weak-willed. Like, I love it because that's where Theo is headed, I believe, in this show, which... again we haven't seen in lord of the rings we've had hinted at with frodo like frodo the ring the power you can't be corrupted by it like what if someone is just corrupted. By it and you know like we we saw the king um but that was so quick it was like you know after an afternoon.

Oh my god yeah no kidding bring me. All the jewels i want all the jewels yeah it's like all right great thanks Yeah. This one, not nearly as good as the previous episode. We are just kind of, you know, I've said this on different episodes. We're just moving the pieces around and we're getting some stuff set up.

We're saying, all right, let's get this side quest going. Let's see what's going on with Theo and Sauron. And then we end with more of the Numenorean stuff. And that's where we have the whole like jumping out of the window stuff. And I just, yeah, I, I look forward to coming back next, well, I guess tomorrow, because we have no time between these episodes.

Three and four are waiting for us, Chris. No kidding. Gotta get out there and do it. I know. So when we come back tomorrow and talk about this stuff, I'm hoping that we don't go anywhere near Numenor.

I don't want to be some sort of Numenor hater, and I don't want people to write reviews about just all these guys do is talk about Numenor and how much it sucks. Well, I'm sorry, guys, but this side plot does nothing for me at all. And to be fair, it really hasn't since the beginning of the show, because we've been mentioning since the first season how uninteresting Numenor and everything going on in Numenor was. So this has been a long time coming, and the more they want to put it into the show and make it a focus, they need to do more with it than they've done. So...

No, I'm I'm excited to see where they go with the next two episodes, because then, yeah, we have we have to wait some time. So I would assume my week. I know like normal people. I'm assuming the fourth episode's ending is going to be a big kind of denouement moment, not because I've looked ahead, but because of the way they released it. Right.

They released the first four episodes. So. You know, if you're doing the traditional cliffhanger thing, you don't have a cliffhanger until the episode where there's not another one. So I'm hoping that there's, you know, the first half of the season is kind of a big build up for the back half. So I'm excited to watch the next two and talk about it.

And if you want to hear that episode, this episode, the previous episode and everything we work on. head on over to weirdingwaymedia.com where this show and all those other shows can be found, like Mike's show, The Projection Booth, like my show, The Culture Cast. Those can all be found at weirdingwaymedia.com. Mike put the website together. It's a great website. It's not Spreaker, which means it's great.

They don't give us enough money. So we're not going to have you go to their website because their website doesn't even look like they take money from us, which we know is not the case. If you want to help us out with money, patreon.com slash culturecast, patreon.com slash projection booth. That's where you can go to kick a couple dollars our way. Otherwise, like, rate and review this show on iTunes and Spotify.

That's where it helps us out the most. And yeah, like Mike said, Come on back for the next episode where we'll talk about episode three and then episode four of the third season of The Rings of Power.

Download the transcript file

More from The Podcast of Power

Similar episodes across the network

Matched by shared keywords.

Transcript

Loading the transcript…