About this episode
The secret flame delivers its exposition like a burning bush, Gandalf finally gets the hat (and his name, eight times in five minutes), and Chris makes the case for Daniel Weyman in a role Ian McKellen owns. Galadriel and Arondir lead Marnukh toward Gundabad in a Frodo, Sam and Gollum riff that works better than it has any right to, Sauron plays detective with his orcs’ records, and the episode closes on a torture scene Mike calls one of the most harrowing he’s seen.
___
The Podcast of Power is a weekly Rings of Power breakdown from Mike White and Chris Stachiw — one episode at a time, plus whatever Middle-earth tangents we can't help ourselves from taking.
Mike is the host of The Projection Booth. Chris is the host of The Kulturecast.
New episodes every week. Follow the show so you don't miss one: https://www.spreaker.com/show/the-podcast-of-power
Ratings and reviews on Apple Podcasts and Spotify genuinely move the needle on who finds us — it takes a minute and it helps more than you'd think.
The Podcast of Power is part of Weirding Way Media. https://weirdingwaymedia.com
Transcript
Automatically generated, so expect the odd misheard name.
Welcome to the Podcast of Power, the only podcast on the entire internet from stem to stern. Check your IP address. We're the only ones talking about the IP, which is known as Lord of the Rings, the Rings of Power. Yes, it's a mouthful. And we're here to talk about every single mouthful of this film.
I'm your host, Mike White. Joining me, of course, is Mr. Chris Dashew. I forgot exactly what Tom Bombadil sings, but insert Tom Bombadilio singing. Something about old Tom and his hat.
The road goes ever on and on, I believe is what Gandalf says. At least. Yeah, something about in the misty hills of Mordor, I met a girl so fair till Gollum and the evil one crept up and ran away with her. So you get it. Yeah, I got it.
I got it. Oh boy, we are back and talking about the third episode of the third season. This one is called The Secret Fire. And we are back with some Tombadilio, some Stranger. Well, I guess we can call him Gandalf now or Grand Elf.
And we've even got the Dark Wizard coming back with us. We're on the road to Rune, as they say. So I'm very excited to talk about this one. Yeah, we, of course, have a little bit of, you know, here's what happened in the last episode. So, yeah, we have some more Numenor shit, but at least with this one, we get to, you know, venture out a little bit more.
Like I said, regroup with Gandalf, regroup with the Dark Wizard. We get to start off with the Dark Wizard. I always... fuck up this guy's name karen hines uh welsh actor great great character. I believe you should refer to me by my name my my my my christian name which is. Polando polando yes lieutenant polando is here from homicide to check things out.
When they said that his name was polando i was like what the hell is this guy's polando. And then his former partner that he got sent down here, there's a whole world of mythology we're about to open up with this. Well, so he is one of the blue wizards. He is. He's definitely wearing blue.
He's got the blue thing. Right. I mean, which is what crystal, which is what we talked about before, because, and this has been something that has been mentioned or a lack of mentioning in a lot of the like Lord of the Rings stuff, at least the, you know, kind of the mythology from the books is, the blue wizards have been mentioned, but the blue, we've never seen the blue wizards. So the fact that he is one of the blue wizards and he turned on the other blue wizard is the most interesting outcome as far as I'm concerned for what his character is, because it would seem that he is also Saruman, right? It does.
I mean, he feels very proto Saruman. It could be one of these, like he's reborn as Saruman type thing. I don't know. Like it is Lord of the Rings. There is some of that. kind of mechanics in there with Gandalf, the gray and Gandalf, the white.
So I love that. We actually have an answer to who he is. I like that. The show is not actively trying to be a mystery box show. I don't know how you feel about that, but the first season of the show was very much like a mystery box show.
And I'm glad that this show is like not making us wait episode after episode, season after season for these like big reveals. Oh yeah. Yeah. That is really nice. It's, It's interesting seeing Gandalf, I mean, here I am quoting from Led Zeppelin, and here he looks like he's on the cover of Zoso with all the reeds on his back.
Not nearly as extensive as the fourth Led Zeppelin album cover art, but he's got the twigs on his back. I guess what you do in this land of Rune is you collect twigs and hope that the rains will come back because we do get to see the Dark Wizard trying to grow some flowers and not having a very good time of it. This whole thing is, I mean, they really start this episode off with the bang because we've got, I thought his name was Kamul, but he doesn't go by Kamul in this one. He goes by a different name, but we've got the Nazgul that we saw, Kamul, the fairest of all the Nazgul, coming back and giving a report to the Dark Wizard. Dark Wizard's like, hey, you know, glad to have you back. good thing you went to see Sauron or Sauron.
You know, this is going to be great. You know, I take it your pilgrimage to Mordor was fruitful. It's like, oh, yeah, better believe it was. Now you're going to kneel before me, old man. I really like this confrontation.
I think it's really interesting because we have not up until this point seen Gandalf or the Dark Wizard this season. And to have the way the Dark Wizard is introduced to like more or less undercut the character immediately is very interesting because up until this point, the dark wizard has had a lot more agency than we are seeing here. Like he is being undercut of his agency immediately, which is interesting because I think, again, it lends credence to this idea of, well, Gandalf is, is meant to defeat him. Gandalf is meant to, unify with him in a way that I guess would allow them again, if he is in fact Saruman or proto Saruman or Saruman who is reborn or whatever later, it would make sense that they would have united at some point, because we do get the sense in those, you know, in those films later on that Gandalf and Saruman are, you know, are, are friends of long of time, long past.
So it's, it's interesting. Karen Hines is such a interesting actor because, everything I've seen him in, he's great. And he lends a really like interesting energy to a lot of his roles because he can be really big or he can kind of like slink away into the corner and kind of just sit. And I don't know, like, ferment is what it kind of feels like. He's just angry in this show.
And every time we've seen him, he's like simmering underneath and we don't understand why. And this is like the first time where we see anyone actually challenging him as a character. And it's very interesting because I still don't know where they're going with his character. But I'm glad that we get a better sense of who his character is. They are, again, like we talked about in the last two episodes, they are really rebooting the show.
They really are. Like with this kind of stuff, I'm just like, wow, like this show, they really didn't assume that anyone had been watching this show before this point is kind of what it feels like. I found it very interesting. The line that he has about has the desert sand scorched your mind as deeply as your flesh, because we've never seen these folks. As far as I remember, I don't remember ever seeing these people from their hands.
We saw like their hands and feet and stuff that was like mole, like, like molted, like kind of like, like it looked like it was like charred or like bubbly and like blistery. Yeah. And so I think it was, I think it was supposed to hit a little, um, harder when he took off his mask in the episode i think it was the last episode and it's like oh you know that uh kamul the fair you know and they call him dondrim in this one g-a-u-d-r-i-m so i'm like all right that's not the name that we had in the last one but it's totally this guy because he takes off his mask again to basically be like hey Those scars have healed. Now I am this very handsome man with this beautiful white hair. Don't come at me with talking about how my flesh is scarred here, old man.
So I, I liked the little reveal again. I think I probably would have hit harder. Had I seen what these guys look like before, other than like the back of their hands. It is odd that we didn't see what they looked like before. Right.
I mean, again, like if you're going to do this kind of thing, you would have had one scene where somebody is like, you know, they pull the mask off and somebody like takes off in horror shrieks, or we see them from the back, you know, a shot reverse shot of someone reacting to them, taking their mask off. It is, It is a little odd, but again, at the same time, like they're, they're really trying to fast track what's going on in this show. So there, it does feel like they're kind of skipping some things, you know? I mean, we, you know, you mentioned seeing Gandalf here at the beginning of this episode. Like I, do you understand what happens at the beginning with Gandalf and the Oliphant and the guy trying to stab him?
No, no. And I kept thinking, like, obviously Gandalf had interaction with some of these ruiners before the three wizard type things that the Dark Wizard employs. Like, they were the servants of the Dark Wizard. So I was like, well, is that one of them from that? Because there's one person who seems to recognize Gandalf and is after him.
And then, yeah, I don't know where the... enraged Oliphant comes from. It was great to see an Oliphant, but at the same time, I'm like, okay, what is happening here? It was just chilling there. It was just chilling there, and he hit him into it. Right.
And then he has to fight the Oliphant. It's bizarre, but again, I think it speaks to they're literally showing people that have never seen this show. Gandalf doing what is ostensibly like the most iconic thing. Gandalf does it all of the movies. You shall not pass.
It's that like, it's a like boiled down kind of, I wouldn't say TVified version, but it is a TVified version of it. Like it, I mean, it's the scene with the Balrog, but with an elephant instead, like, I don't know. Again, like so much of this show is, at least these first, these first three, four episodes are really trying to kind of hit beats that we've seen before in other things. And I appreciate it because I do feel like the show is responding to what I would perceive to be a bizarre pace up into this point. Like this show is like really picked up the pace in these four episodes.
Like they've gotten so much done in four episodes compared to the last two seasons. Like, You know what I mean? Like these four episodes could have been a season of their own in the first two seasons of the show. And they like practically were because the pace of that first season was glacial. This season has just been like, boom, boom, one thing after another.
I mean, within the first 15 minutes, we get Gandalf and Tom Bombadil introduced and then Tom Bombadil disappears. Probably for the rest of the show, I'm assuming. Like, we know that Gandalf talks to Tom Bombadil again in the future, right? Because he says, you know, I'm going to go talk to old Tom after... Because he goes to talk to him after the events of Lord of the Rings, right?
Right, right. But I don't know if we ever see him again. So, like, the show is really kind of, like, just clearing off all the pieces. And Gandalf, again, they're doing it with his character as well. Like, very much so.
Like, he is clearly... Obviously, a main character, Tom Bombadil is not. And they have freed Gandalf from Tom Bombadil in the like, I wouldn't say like ham fisted, but he's like, go get the rabbit. It's like, OK, when he comes back, he's going to be gone. Like, obviously, that's what's going on here.
And it's just interesting. Cause I mean, again, that, that kind of reboot nature of things is continuing to carry forward with the, with the more important characters of the show. Not to say that Numenor is not important. And it's not that it's, they clearly think it is. We're just not resonating with it.
But Gandalf is, I think like clearly one of the like four main characters of the show and to reset where he is immediately. Again, it's just, I'm not upset that they're taking into account the show has not been successful as they, as much as they wanted up into this point. It seems like they're actually, actually trying to retool the show in a way that will be more entertaining to more people, which I, I appreciate. Like that takes a lot to, change your show to try to do better. Like, and given, you know, I mean, that thing I was saying on the last episode, like people complaining on the internet, like, oh, well, they just cut money and run like they can't.
So now they have to make this show as good as possible. So I'm glad that they're actually like taking the advice of the people that are watching the show or whomever and trying to do better for the people who are watching the show. I would hope that they would have had all this stuff planned out. I mean, at least the beginning and an end point, you know, I hope that this isn't because I think in the last episode you mentioned, you know, Ryan Johnson, we're just like, all right, I'm going to throw the lightsaber away. And it's just like, well, fuck you.
The last movie doesn't count. And then, you know, you come back to the third movie and it's like, well, fuck you. The last movie doesn't count. Yeah. Yeah.
It never felt like they had a fucking plan when it came to that stuff. Whereas what I would hope with this is, that you should have a beginning and an end. How you get there might change as the show gets made, but I would still hope you are ending at the same place. Anyway, I think also the thing with the Oliphant is really... Timothy Olyphant, who makes a great appearance in this, just came right off of the set of Alien Earth, walked right in here and said, OK, put the big thing on my nose.
I'm ready to go. I think that whole scene is supposed to really also counter. the scene that we get later on with the, what do we call these guys? The Wyvern, the Wyrms, the crazy dragons that they have. Oh, the Felbeasts. Felbeasts, thank you.
That very much, parallels the Felbeast scene with Sauron and we get to see how he treats a creature who has been twisted. And I really like this whole idea of like, oh, these were once eagles, you know, and this is what we did to them. And it's like, all right, so you hang out with orcs that used to be elves and Felbeasts that used to be eagles. Everything is a twisted version of something that was once good and right in this world. And, you know, we talked about it in the last episode with the orcs being twisted versions of elves like this.
So much of this world and the world of Lord of the Rings is about, like, corruption and being corrupted and the corruption of good and good's inability to fight corruption and... I like that it's like poisoning the whole world. Like Sauron is seemingly poisoning the whole world. And the, the kind of, like you said, the, the corrupted versions of things are seemingly drawn to him as well, which makes sense. I mean, he is a, I mean, he's a corrupted God of his own, right?
Like he's a fallen angel essentially. So it makes sense that other kind of fallen things would be drawn to him. And you know what? I am so glad that even though it's now Charlie Vickers with the, you know, because we talked about in the last episode with him, all these orakai running around, or orcs, I guess. I really love that he just has no fucks given for them and just has no problem killing them. throwing them to like the beast, just utilizing them to the most kind of dastardly effect possible.
Even though in the last episode, I guess last episode, but the last season he was like, Oh, you know, the, the, the orcs are, are my friends, you know, they're going to be helping me out. And he's like every opportunity, he's just killing them. It's, it's very, it's, I mean, literally like last episode or two episodes ago, he was putting the ring on that one dying immediately. This one, he's like, Oh, you just don't get it. And throwing him to the Felby's like Sauron is really just a fucking bastard.
And I love it. Like I, I'm, I really, that's genuinely my favorite part of this show is anytime Charlie Vickers, the Sauron is on screen. He's just, he knows what the expectation is. Yeah. It is funny that Mar Nook is still talking about father and I'm like, Oh, okay.
So Adar is, shadow still lingers and just the difference that Adar, the way that Adar treated the orcs versus how Sauron treats them. And I'm, yeah, I'm pretty sure that the orcs all know that they have a very bad deal, especially having, you know, once worked with Adar who treated them like his children. Right. And yeah, Sauron couldn't be bothered and doesn't care, which is, I mean, again, like they made a deal with the devil. So that's what happens.
Like the devil doesn't care. Mm hmm. I am so curious about the politics of Rune because we've got those people that are masked who seem to be the muscle. But then even some of the regular soldiers wear the masks as well. They're just not nearly as elaborate because you have a very clear divide in this courtroom where all of the shenanigans with– the Nazgul and grabbing on to the staff as the dark wizard is about to try to vanquish him the way that the dark wizard like sends out that power blast and everybody gets knocked down or kneels, but not the Nazgul.
He's just like, Nope, I'm not affected. And then by him grabbing onto that staff, it's like that, you know, the whole thing looks like it, explodes but it doesn't you know there's like the power that comes out from there like the you see the outside shot and everything is coming out like it looks like a bomb went off i really like that and seeing the the crystal crack but you have the division in the court of you know the regular people the soldiers are all on one side and then by the dark wizard in a semi-circle are all of these you know it's the the The three that we talked about before that were in the first season, I think, at the end of the first season. And then everybody else is kind of dressed like that.
They all have these robes on, and it almost looks like they're the holy people. So this feels almost like a theocracy in Rune. Well, what's interesting is we have been kind of told up until this point that the Dark Wizard is evil. But it's not imminently clear that that's the case. And again, I think that this is them kind of playing with that, like reboot nature of what's going on.
Cause I kind of get the sense that they changed what the dark wizard is doing now because he did, he did seem a little bit more villainous up until this point, didn't he? And now all of a sudden it's like, well, he's seemingly more misunderstood than villainous. And it's like, okay, so what, like you said, like what, what does that mean for what we've seen up until this point of him being quote in charge unquote? Like I don't, Yeah, it's odd because, again, like so much of Lord of the Rings, the politics of what's going on is not really gone into in the movies. It's more or less just implied or I would actually say probably even better term.
It's more or less inferred. what's going on. Like elves and dwarves don't get along. Nobody likes the orcs. Like, but in this episode, we see orcs interacting with people elves, I guess more specifically in a, not to say they're not people, but they're not, they're elves. Um, in a way that is more extended and pronounced than we've ever seen an orc interact and in a non-antagonistic way.
And it's interesting because I think the show is trying to, to the question you're asking, trying to answer some questions about the politics of the world or raise questions about the politics of the world that the movies were never invested in because they didn't have the time. Like it makes sense that the movies didn't have the time to invest in this. You need long periods of time and massive amounts of world building to get anyone to the point where they're interested in the politics of the world. That's not something that's immediate. Like to George Lucas is, you know, chagrin.
Like you can't just get into that immediately and get people invested. Like you have to really build the world out a lot for people to be invested in the politics of what's going on. You mean people don't want to hear about trade federations and blockades and all that kind of stuff right off the bat? Not in the first movie back after 20 years, no. I also, speaking of politics, I also think that the Dark Wizard is very much working to save face when it comes to...
Because he's humiliated in front of these people that he was the leader of. And the way that he has to backtrack... after he sees the power of the Nazgul and is just like, oh, I made a mistake, ring bearer. You enter the shrine, not as our foe, but as his emissary. Oh, okay. You know, just like very much like, you know, Sauron has accepted our proposal.
Do you hear me in the back? Sauron's accepted our proposal. The union of room and Mordor is complete. We're good. Okay.
Thanks. All right. Goodbye, everybody. Yes. And don't you like that they have Gandalf and Tom Bombadil there?
Yes. Because again, that's like, again, it's one of those like narrative cheats, right? Where it's like, okay, now the characters do know what's going on. Cause I mean, this is the first time Gandalf and the dark wizard have been in the same space together. I would say it's actually like, this is the first time Gandalf and Tom Bombadil have done anything other than be in their house together.
Right, exactly. A little bit of hanging out outside, you know, Gandalf out looking for his staff and everything. And here you get to see, you know, some staff action going on, which is kind of cool. And yeah, the whole thing of him with the light and the staff and like the light going out. I'm just like, what?
Wait, what? You have a faulty staff or are you just a faulty wizard? Are you not quite at your full power yet? I don't think he's at his full power yet, isn't it? I think I think that's what it is, right?
Like, I think you're right. Yeah. Yeah. The scene with the Oliphant was kind of strange and it does seem to go on for a long time. And it's like they even make the point of it later on when finally he's back.
Gandalf is back with Bombadil and it's like, oh, you're all dirty. It's like, oh, yeah, I had to take care of this Oliphant. OK. Yeah. So it's it feels like there's a long period of time that happens between the opening scene and And then when we finally get back to that, and it probably just feels long because it's more fucking Numenor stuff going on.
But at least it's, you know, the better version of the Numenor stuff. It's the stuff with the Isildur, which is great. I like Isildur. Well, and I was going to say, like, it's... For me...
Isildur and Elendil and the stuff that's like kind of taking place in middle earth, but also taking place in Numenor. That is the only somewhat interesting version of that. Like it's, it's still uninteresting. Cause I know that they're involved in what's going on in Numenor, but at least they're removed from Numenor a little bit, you know? Well, removed enough that, He doesn't even know that his own daughter's dead.
And that becomes a reveal later on in the episode. I don't. So there is in more fucking intrigue that's going on in Numenor. It's this whole thing of Isildur meeting with this guy. And now Ryan, I believe his name is the Andrew Richardson character.
And by the way, I don't know if they shot this on a volume or if this was in a real location, but the location that they have this conversation that they have take place in looks gorgeous. I was going to say, they really went out of their way to make them have a conversation in the most beautiful place possible, huh? Yeah, I mean, it looks like, I don't even know what it looks like. Those rocks in the back remind me a little bit of Iceland. I don't know where they're shooting at this season, but it looked terrific.
And then the actor that plays Isildur, he's just, you know, handsome son of a bitch. And the other guy's not too bad looking either. So I like this whole thing, you know, and they're talking about how they're digging oysters with their bare hands and eating like kings. So we have like the nostalgia for the past and just like, okay, you know, like we might get back to where we were. It's great, but you know, you can keep it.
But this whole thing of like, all right, there is a traitor in our midst, which I'm like, okay, is there a traitor in your midst? Like, it felt like the daughter got ganked pretty honestly. You know, you talked about the whole thing and the guy behind the door type of thing. It's like, all right. Yeah, we saw that, but apparently, and so that's why I'm like, I don't know if this guy is lying to Il Sildur, if he's the traitor, because I, but then later on, like, so the trap gets set and there's this whole like, oh yeah, we're going to meet out at this temple and that's where this exchange is supposed to happen.
And then it turns out that it's the bad guys are actually there and yada, yada, yada. So I'm like, well, did this guy set them up? Did somebody else set them up? Because at first I thought for sure that this, this relatively new character, again, I know I've seen him before. it doesn't, it looks like he's trapped in the crossfire. It doesn't look like he actually set this stuff up.
But at first I thought for sure he was just going to stand up and walk over and be like, okay, he'll sell door. Fuck you. I trapped you. Yeah. I don't, I don't like, again, like I don't understand what's going on with some of the new menorah stuff because I was wondering that same thing about like, well, who, who set the trap?
Did they just set, I guess they just set the trap to get Elendil captured. But to what end? Cause I, he is training the soldiers to, on the other side by the way on the other side of numenor on the other side of the numenorean island because they're not on middle earth which is the part that i was most surprised by i thought they i thought for sure they were on middle earth it's so wild to me that it took three seasons for them to include a fucking map. Oh yeah oh and they were using that map like crazy because that's what we're getting go from back from numenor and we rejoin the whole uh I keep wanting to call him Morgoth, but that's not his name. The whole Marnuk.
Marnuk. There we are. Jeez. His storyline with the two elves. And my God, as soon as they join up and he's got his hand shackled and it's these two people wandering through with him, I'm just like, yep, yep, yep.
What's taters, precious? Well, it's funny is when we talked about the first season of the show, we mentioned that gandalf and the harfoots and how that was like the original movies and then you know again like we have here now a reprisal of that like oh here okay here we go like here's the thing you've seen before in the original movies like you've seen the get you know the the golem and the frodo and the samwise like and it's it's that same thing like it's trafficking in it and they knew it was successful then though so they're doing it now and i don't blame them i don't like i i get it like and it works like there is something charming about having the three of them these kind of three disparate personalities all interacting with one another.
But the echoes are so loud you know i can't eat elvish food you know it's like all right gollum uh we know that you can't eat the lembas bread all right i mean these things i think well, even Gollum had a little song that he sang and was singing down by the little pool where he's catching the fish and smashing the fish on the rocks and stuff. Because here we actually have a orc who recites poetry. And it's a really nice scene. Even though I'm kind of slagging on it for being such an echo of that Gollum relationship, I'm just like, well, this is really nice. I like this.
And I like that Again, like you said, we've got the Sam-Frodo-Gullum relationship, and Erendir is definitely doing his best Samwise impersonation, where it's just like, I don't trust him. I'm surprised he's not like, he's a villain! Well, I was going to say, the thing that makes it interesting about him, Marnuk, as a character, is he does have some Like, nuanced to him. I mean, I wouldn't say just as much as Gollum, but they're going for as much as Gollum. They're trying to make him a sympathetic, empathetic, nuanced character, and it works.
Again, this is the most empathy I've ever had towards an orc in Lord of the Rings. and that's the intention i mean that and and it's it's it's well served the actor adam young portraying marnuk is great the writing i think works well having it be a rondeer and galadriel with him i think was very smart if it had just been one or the other I don't think it would have worked as well. There's a lot of really successful stuff going on in... In these first three episodes, there's a lot of, like you said, echoes of things that worked before, but they haven't been done so much elsewhere that they're not going to work again. That's the other thing we haven't talked about. It's not like, okay, so we have Frodo and Samwise and Gollum, and everybody's been doing that for the last 20 years.
Not really. Again, Lord of the Rings has not been re-litigated to death like Star Wars has over and over again, where every time we see a character with a lightsaber... it causes pause. That's what they want with Star Wars, is they want characters with lightsabers. And here, it's like, you know what? We can have that, but we don't have to have the specific characters doing it.
We can kind of riff on it, which I do appreciate. Oh, absolutely. No, it's a good riff. It's a familiar tune, but it's a good tune. It's something that reminds you of something that you like, and at the same time, it doesn't feel like it's just a carbon copy.
You know, and you do have the moments like this whole thing of like, OK, Galadriel seems to trust the orc way more than Arandir does. And there's the whole like, you know, all right. He says that, you know, there's going to be this battle that's coming up and not to go this way. And it ends up not happening, but then it ends up happening. And that's what makes Arandir trust him and trust him.
Full-throatedly. Because throughout the... I think it's... I can't remember if it's... No, it's much more the next episode.
But you get these moments, even somewhat in this episode, where it's like, do you trust this person? Do you not? As soon as he leads them into... Man, oh man, I'm sucking with these names today. As soon as he leads them into Gundabad, it's like, hey, I'm a general.
And open up and all this stuff. And you're like, oh, has this been a trap all along? And it's that whole... Is it, is it not just going back and forth for quite a while? Do you trust this guy?
Do you not trust this guy? How much do you believe him? I like this. I like this whole subplot. I don't think it's going to last for much longer than the next episode.
Hopefully he will be continued to be used in some way throughout the rest of the season. Cause yeah, I actually appreciate having an orc character that, I mean, it reminds me a lot of, you know, playing B and D and you can have all of these different types of characters in your party. Would you want to work? Maybe, you know, like, sure, I'll take a halfling. They're great at stealing stuff.
I mean, obviously, Bilbo Baggins, one of the best thieves in the world, right? Well, that's what I was going to say. Like you said, it really leans into, I think, modern tastes when it comes to. the way people resonate with fantasy, because like you said, there are people that are like, fuck it. I want to be an orc. Like I don't, I resonate with the orcs and they're like, you know, their way of being.
I, I, you know, what's funny is when you look at the way orcs act, like I know people like that, like, you know what I mean? Like the way he's acting, like, I'm not saying like, I know people that are orcs, but I know people that are characterized this way and, the way this orc is being characterized and giving him like really humanistic qualities as a character is really smart because that I've, and again, like, look, Peter Jackson was adapting the books. The books don't talk about the orcs this way. They just don't like, you know, I think I want to say that might be one of J.R.R. Tolkien's like failings as an author.
And I think he may have even spoken to it as like the orcs are just kind of written very flat. Like, and again, like that's, That was the intention. Like the story that he was writing, the orcs were a tool of Sauron. It's much more interesting now that we kind of have, you know, 50, 60, 70 years on from the original source material being written that people are interested in something else. Like they're like, oh, well, could the orcs have some nuance to them?
The answer is yes. And like you've said, like it actually makes it a very interesting kind of modern reinterpretation of the events from Sauron. the, the, the books. I mean, you know, like to talk about star Wars again, like it's like poetry. It rhymes. Like there's been precedent for these things happening before is what it's effectively saying.
And it's like, yeah, I mean, that makes sense. I guess like, okay, you know, history repeats itself. That makes sense. Like they're doing anything that's like overtly that unique, like going out in a party together to go commit some sort of goal or achievement, like not something anyone wasn't doing in this world, but us getting to follow along with it does, yeah, it leans into things that are familiar, but in a little bit of a remixed way, not too much. They didn't remix it too much, but you know, I think they did it just enough to kind of make people who have not seen the show before feel at ease with watching this show.
It is interesting that we have, um, kind of a theme in this episode of winged creatures. We have the butterfly that's going to come back, but the butterfly that, uh, Margo, uh, Martin Martin, Jesus. looks like he's going to eat and then he ends up putting it in his bag and then that comes back later on when we basically redo the scene from. Speaking of redos yes. From the fellowship of the rings you know i'm just waiting for uh galadriel to like start you know the eyes roll back in the back of her head you know had all of those centipedes and stuff come out like would have been like so happy. It's like, oh, great feeding time.
But you've got that. And then you have the bird that the Nazgul turns into a crow and and basically a lot of crows, it seems like. And then we have the whole messenger thing. Many spies have many eyes. Exactly, yes.
I like that they answered that question. They were like, okay, how do the Nazgul control the world around them? Because we're shown that they have power over the undead world. Like, oh, so they can corrupt living beings into beings like themselves that they can then utilize to do their bidding. Like, okay, cool.
Like, yeah, like that's I didn't need that. Thank you for showing me that. Like, there are things that the show is doing that I'm like genuinely appreciative of because it does further flesh out the world, not in a way that I needed, but in a way that just like further colors in some of the little spaces in between things that were going on before. Yeah, I especially like when they go from the one crow to the many crows and we go back to the map. The crows are over the map, and then we come back to Charlie Vickers' Sauron with all of those crows there, and it's like getting all the news, right?
It's like the way that he's staying in touch with all of the things that are happening in Middle-earth. And then we actually have a problem here that he wants to get to where they're at and can't get there fast enough, so that's where we have the whole Felbeast coming in, where it's like, oh, if Yeah, you could take this and maybe, you know, with a horse, you'll get there in a month. And it's like, no, no, I want to get there a lot faster. Thank you very much. So saddle up the fell beast.
Let's go. Great, great scene with that. And yeah, like you said, we've got the last little bit here for a little while. I imagine we'll see Tom Bombadil again this season. But this is also an interesting thing to the whole like go find the rabbit thing like you were saying.
Which, you know. Let's talk about the exposition dump because it is. Dude, it's the burning bush, right? I mean, it's literally like the burning bush from the Bible. Like here, here, by the way, let me impart to you secret knowledge.
Like. Yeah. Yeah. Where the rabbit is. The rabbit literally turns into the fire.
So Gandalf interacts with the secret flame, which tells him all about who the blue wizard is. Is that the Flame of Ardor? I don't know what that is. Okay. Because he says that, right?
When he's about to... When he fights the Balrog, right? Oh, yeah. Okay. Anyway, yeah.
The Flame of. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. It's weird because I don't remember them... I guess that is the only other time they've mentioned it. I don't remember them going...
The Flame of Arnor is the Flame of the Sun, right? I think so, yeah. I don't... I don't know. It's weird because it feels very biblical.
Oh, yeah. It feels like we're being thrown into a Terrence Malick film for a few minutes here. Yeah. All of a sudden, it's like, let me tell you about the world you live in. It's like, whoa, what the.
I am the fire. I am the alpha and the Omega. I built the heavens and the stars. I mean, yeah, he's communing with God here. Literally.
And it's just like all of, all of a sudden, seemingly he's communing with God, like out, out of nowhere. It's, it is a, what I would call it. It is a narrative cheat. Oh yeah. Yeah.
It is very much finding the, the wise person that's going to tell you the secrets of the story in order to get you going because this basically puts him on his own quest of hey you know what they're still good in that blue wizard you can help this guy out so maybe he's not your enemy maybe you should try to save this. Person Which, again, I I don't feel like at the end of the last season, that was where they were going with this. No, no. I feel like the end of the last season was like, OK, he's going to have to fight him. And now it's like, well, no, he's actually going to have to convert him to the ways of good.
And it's like, I mean, OK, I'm not complaining. It's just it was not what they had set up last season. And I'm I again, I'm not complaining that they're pivoting. It's just you're pivoting awfully quickly. I mean, on it on a dime, like, you know.
But again, if you're trying to get people engaged with the show that weren't before, this is the this is the way you go about doing it as far as I'm concerned. And also just kind of dropping in there like, oh, yeah, when he betrayed his partner, it was so bad that it laid all of Rune to waste. and that nice little like transition, it's all green and beautiful. And the camera's kind of moving around. And then the, the other blue wizard disappears and all the green goes away and it becomes the desert landscape. I'm like, that's nice.
I like how they're shooting this, you know, good, good use of the special effects. Well, and again, given that we have like this omniscient narrator, all of a sudden, like they can kind of do whatever in the mind of Gandalf, I guess is, is what it is. It's, look, it, it is a little heavy handed because they literally cut away to like, let me tell you something. And it's like, okay, it's fine. But again, if, if you're trying to get people up to speed that we're not watching the show, you kind of had to like, Because people are going to recognize Gandalf, that's for sure.
That is the one thing we haven't mentioned. Bro, they make sure you recognize who the fuck he is like five minutes into it. They give him the hat and everything. It's like, okay, they had to get rid of Tom Bombadil so they could give Gandalf his hat. It's what it feels like.
Very indiana jones it's like here you go kid you had a tough day but. Yeah like here's the hat it's like okay he's gandalf we get it like for the first two seasons not calling him gandalf for this first episode you know the third episode of the first third season be like he's gandalf he's gandalf that's gandalf it's like well fucking said it one time up into this point now you've said it eight times in the last five minutes Yeah. What really gets me, though, is when he puts on the hat and his head is lowered and then he raises his hat and it's Ian McKellen. It's like, oh, OK, come on. I got it.
I would have loved that, by the way. I would I again, I would not be surprised if we talked about on the last episode. I wouldn't be surprised if they do something like that, like have it like, you know, and then he pans up and it's, you know, it puts the hat on and looks up and it's Gandalf as Ian McKellen. I wouldn't be surprised. It's fucking crazy to think of just like, cause Ian McKellen, they made him look old and now he is old.
And when you see, like I saw the trailer for doomsday yesterday and my wife's just like, what the hell's Ian McKellen doing in here? And I was like, Oh, he's Magneto in this. Remember from 30 fucking years ago. Exactly. Andrea, Andrea, I can't blame her for not remembering.
That was literally 30 lifetimes ago for some of us. Like, we've had other Magnetos in the interim, you know, Michael Fassbender was there for a while. I mean, that movie was out a long time ago. Yeah. My God.
Oh yeah. Days of future past was what? 15 years ago now, something like that. Like wild. Yeah.
Oh my God. It's, it's funny. You know, we, we talked about it a little bit last season. We talked about a little bit in the first season, but yeah, I do want to mention, I really like the actor who plays Gandalf. That is, for me, that is and was always going to be the hardest job of anybody on the show was playing a character that we've already seen who is, I think, you know, say what you will about Magneto, right?
Like, whatever, fine. Ian McKellen's iconic character is Gandalf, right? Magneto, whatever. Like it great. Like I understand for some people that's your Ian McKellen thing.
For me, it's Gandalf. Like Gandalf is when I think of a wizard, I think of Gandalf. Like that's what I would like to think of as a wizard is Gandalf. Like, benevolent with a wry wink and a nod. And, you know, the, you know, finger up next to the nose, like, you know, he, he knows more than he lets on.
And I love that about Gandalf and the actor who plays Gandalf in this show is given the thankless task of following up Ian McKellen's again, like it's one of those things where Ian McKellen is forever associated with that role. casting the actor who they have, David Wayman, as Gandalf, I can't imagine the amount of stress that he was under trying to play this character. because it is a character that is so iconic elsewhere because of someone else, but he's really good. He, I think he's up there for one of my favorite parts of this show, like him and, and the actor who plays Durin and Deesa, like they're all kind of the emotional. And I mean, Robert Aramayo, frankly, like all of the main characters are very good.
Like they, you know, I know we had our issues with Galadriel in the first two seasons, but I think everybody that they've cast in this show has kind of come into their own as the characters that they're playing. And it doesn't, it doesn't feel kind of like playing Lord of the Rings dress up like it did before up until this point. Like this really, the show has come into its own. And I really think a lot of that is is and was the smart casting but i like i said man i'm i'm shocked at how good of a job daniel wayman is doing with a character that is so iconic elsewhere that is it's like what mads mickelson did with hannibal like it's a thankless task but if you're gonna do it like you gotta really nail it and i think he really.
Does i found it very fascinating the whole thing of digging into marcus paths and it becomes almost like a little detective story where Soran is like, okay, tell me more about this guy. It also felt a little, it felt like how I work with AI at times because he's like, all right, so you brought me this information that he was at the Battle of Eregion. All right, that's great. And he was a master of the whip and he's really good at torture and all that stuff. That's terrific.
But here, now let me give you prompts for the next session. I want to know everything he did there. where he fought you know it's like he's giving all of these directions and i'm just like okay uh i guess the orcs keep really good records. Or something like oh yeah the the orc record keepers we've never seen like. Right right it's like okay like does he go back does he does he go down to like the the archives you know to the morgue and start looking through like old newspaper clippings and stuff he's just. Like oh well i'll find out i'll let me find out the the truth about this guy Yeah, because that is kind of fascinating how we actually find some of the elves that were there.
And I know I'm kind of skipping ahead quite a bit because there is the whole thing of the replay of the fellowship part with the Nazgul coming along, all of the butterflies that I guess distract them. Okay, cool. Whatever. Sure. Those fucking elves, man.
That scene... probably one of the most harrowing scenes I've seen and it's it could just be because it's a torture scene. You mean when Sauron blows them. Up oh my god yeah like oh it's such a piece of shit yeah here's this this stuff that is going to basically burn you from the inside out whatever you do don't. Cough and that was horrific man and then Sauron's like but yeah like we don't really care so go ahead and cough and it's like whoop Jesus Yeah. To end the episode with that, it was just like, it was.
Like that weird cut of like, they use the cut of them exploding to like smash cut into something else. Like, or I guess it's a dissolve actually. Like it's, it's so weird. There's so many weird choices that the show has been doing with editing. And I appreciate it.
Like they were doing it. Was it last episode where they cut, where they, they zoomed out of the, into the ring and then out of the ring as well. Like, wasn't that the last episode? Like they've been doing a lot of really interesting editing stuff. Like the show is becoming more stylistically interesting than it was before.
Like it, it does feel like a different show in a lot of ways, which I mean, again, like, you know, I didn't dislike the show before. I'm enjoying the show a bit more now than before, but I, I didn't hate the show the way the people who I think that they've been retooling the show for hated or were vocally hating the show. Right. I totally agree. And it's interesting because it's the same people writing and directing this.
It's not like they brought in a whole new crew of people. No. And they're, they're just, I think they're just leaning into different things. And yeah, you know, I also do think that they're just, it feels a lot more like big beats as opposed to small beats. You know, a lot of big beats, like constantly, like one after another, after another, after another, like it's, it is a tad overwhelming at times.
There is a little bit of whiplash with like the amount of stuff going on not in a bad way it is just because they're so i mean because there are so many characters like you you know this is the first time we've seen gandalf this season right. I think there was like one shot of him like going over a mountain or something last episode and it's like all right. You know, like no dialogue, nothing. Okay. Yeah.
Don't forget this guy's still around. Yeah. Don't forget Gandalf is straight up in this show. Like, and that's the thing he's so far removed from everything else that because he's so far removed from everything else, like it, the world does feel disjointed. I'm very curious as to when all the characters will start kind of converging.
Like, is it going to be, end of this season. It's going to be end of next season, but there's going to come a time where we have like Gandalf and L because like Gandalf hasn't met Elrond or Galadriel or any of them yet. And we know that he's going to have this huge history with them and have this kind of like whole kind of complex relationship to three of them as we've seen in the Hobbit. Uh, so it's, I don't know, like I'm, I'm excited for what the show is building to because it's, it does kind of feel like the show's finally like lit a fire under its own ass, which two seasons in. Okay.
Yeah. Better wait than never. I guess. I totally agree. I didn't think it needed it.
Like, I don't know. Like, I guess, I guess they only have five seasons. So there you go. But it does feel like all of a sudden, like things are just happening very, very quickly. Like, there's not a lot of like, Oh, like here's some meandering with Sauron and who is Sauron?
Like, remember the first season of this show, how kind of meandering it was in terms of the, who is Sauron? Like, I'm glad that there's none of that because yeah, if I was watching the first season of this show, I would be kind of irritated, frankly, with like the kind of mystery box aspect of it. Like here, it's just like the show's able to operate out in the open in a really kind of much more interesting way. Yeah. Was it the end of the first season where we had the three rings already forged?
And that kind of surprised you and me? Yeah, that was the end of the first season. Yep. Okay. Yeah.
And then, yeah, the whole second season. I mean, the second season, the forging of the Worven rings seemed like it was very quick. But it happened off screen. Got them out. Yeah.
Yeah. And then it took, I think it was the nine for the men that seemed to take the longest time. And it's weird because they always talk about how they were for kings, but really none of these people are kings. I mean, none of the Nazgul, I would not consider them as being kings of men. Well, are they kings of men because Sauron appointed them as such?
It feels like it. It almost feels like they're his deputies. Right. Which, again, speaks more to his feelings on things less the actual yeah the act well they show it in the fucking first movie don't they they show all the the the the you know the the for the nine men all those like decrepit white men so huh That is weird. I mean, again, you know, part of me.
Well, that's Galadriel telling that story. So she would know. That's the thing. I was like, part of it feels like, you know, those facts turned into story turned into, you know, legend. Like, but no, it's Galadriel.
Like she was there. Yeah. I mean, it makes sense. Like she knows. It kind of makes sense that you've always had nine rings and nine Nazgul.
So it's like, why aren't they the same people? I guess they're not. Yeah. apparently. Sure. Sure.
I mean, I don't, I ain't going to argue. I know someone else is going to argue and bitch and moan and get angry. Like I'm not that guy. Like I will say like, maybe, maybe we're not Stephen Colbert level Lord of the Rings fans, but that doesn't mean you can't enjoy the show. Like, and it also doesn't mean you're going to hate the show.
If you are that level of fan, like, yeah, get over yourself. I feel like we should get, I feel like we should get either Stephen Colbert or, uh, airplane facts with Max, like one of those two guys. Cause like, I think Max might know more about Lord of the Rings and, uh, than Stephen Colbert does. I, I just want the people who make Lord of the Rings to love Lord of the Rings because it is something you kind. Of have to love to get involved with.
And, um, if that Stephen Colbert project never comes out, I'm going to be really disappointed. They wrapped up filming on the search for Gollum though. I don't know if you saw that like yesterday, like literally like yesterday or today. So yeah. So we're, that movie is at least coming out a film talk about completely and utterly unnecessary.
How, how has no one complained about that being unnecessary? Is it because Andy circus is involved? The show is unnecessary because it was not made by Peter Jackson directly, but the movies are okay. Cause Andy circus is involved. Like, Okay.
Have you seen Animal Farm? I, in fact, fucking have. Did you see Animal Farm? I haven't yet. It's fucking atrocious.
Trailer did its job and kept me away. In the end, you know what my favorite part of Animal Farm was on the page? The happy ending. Wow. Yeah.
Right. And they look at themselves and they look at the people and they can't tell which is which. I mean, that's a very happy ending. Yeah. That is not, uh, that is not the way the film by Andy circus ends.
I can tell you that much. Isn't it? This is not a spoiler for animal farm, the book, but in the book, doesn't the horse die? I'm pretty sure the horse does not die in the movie. Yeah.
The horse does not die in the movie. Hmm. They literally like, they change the point of the story. Like it, It would be like if in Lord of the Rings, Sauron was the good guy. Like what?
Like Sauron had a point the whole time. Like, you know, we just need hegemony among the cultures of Middle Earth. Like what? No. Yeah.
Yeah. I mean, that's I mean, that's yeah, it's good God. This is sure this isn't what some people wanted in terms of a Lord of the Rings TV show, but it's a pretty good show. I will continue to echo that. Well, I just, I feel crazy sometimes because I literally don't know anyone else who watches this show.
I can't say that for a lot of other shows that are on TV. Like, I know someone who watches most of, like, the big shows. Or I could at least be like, hey, did you watch this? Or I haven't watched it yet, but I'm going to. Every time I mention that you and I are covering the show or watching the show, I feel like I'm trying to convince someone of something that is like, you know, well, you know, like, oh, the Earth is flat.
Like, what the fuck? Like, it's a Lord of the Rings show. Like, why is it... Why is it like a fantasy show with the one of the most well-known IPs of fantasy? Like, why are we having a hard time convincing people to watch this show?
Like, it's odd. It's very odd because it's, you know, unless the show shits the bed completely by the end of this season or the end of the next two seasons, like it's been more consistently engaging than a lot of the fantasy TV and films I've watched have been including, but not limited to those Hobbit movies. I would say so far, this show has been better than those Hobbit movies. I, yes. I, so I have yet to go back and watch the first two seasons.
I think maybe when this whole thing is done, I will watch it from the beginning to the end, which you can't really say like that. I do a lot. Uh, there aren't that many TV shows that I go back and rewatch, uh, But I do rewatch Lord of the Rings all the time. So will I rewatch this series? Maybe I might.
And I would kind of be tempted to do so. Yeah, no, I'm totally with you. It's if you want to watch something in that world of that version of Lord of the Rings. And again, there are people that look, we love those Lord of the Rings movies. There are people that did not like those Lord of the Rings movies when they came out. like and still don't because they're not they're not the books as they envisioned them when they read them and i get it but you know i don't know i guess the reductive language online is is not willing to at least watch the show and then have an opinion which is a shame because it's i feel like all anyone ever heard about this show was a bunch of weird stuff that doesn't matter like It's a really good show.
It's really well written. It's really, really well acted. And you know what? I'm not going to complain about this. The effects look really good.
And of course they do. Amazon spending a fucking boatload of money on this show. So yeah, like. Let's just hope that whoever's doing the special effects isn't driven out of business because they undersold themselves because we've seen that happen. No kidding.
Oh, you want to take us to the end? Yeah. So with episode three, I think firmly in the rear view, we will now be continuing on to the fourth and halfway point of the season. The fourth episode that they just released outright, which, you know, what are you going to do when you have an eight episode season? Release the first four episodes immediately.
Right. I mean, you know, fucking cares. Right. Why not? Makes our lives way easier, apparently, except it doesn't.
It makes them way harder. So yeah, on the next episode and the halfway point of our season and of the season of Lord of the Rings, Rings of Power, we're going to be talking about the fourth episode of the third season. That episode is... Well, aptly titled Gundabad. So until then, like, rate, and review this show on iTunes and Spotify.
Head on over to weirdingwaymedia.com where this show and all the other shows that Mike and I work on can be found, like his show, The Projection Booth, my show, The Culture Cast, a whole bunch of stuff. can be found over there. That is our new website. Mike put it together. And yeah, go take a look. Go find some audio that's not ours and listen to it.
Give some other shows on the network a listen. And yeah, come on back for the next episode where we are hilariously at the halfway point of a TV show that's been out for three days.
More from The Podcast of Power
Similar episodes across the network
Matched by shared keywords.
-
Inside Scoop with Patrick Hinds: Golden Girls, True Crime, and TV Magic
1 shared keyword: recap
-
The Lord of the Rings Trilogy
1 shared keyword: lotr



