Season 1 · Episode 9

Required Viewing 09: Laapataa Ladies

1 hr 37 min Clean Full episode
Required Viewing 09: Laapataa Ladies
The Kulturecast
0:00
1:36:39
MP3

About this episode

Two brides in matching red veils board the same crowded train in 2001, and only one of them gets off at the right stop. Kiran Rao's Laapataa Ladies (2024), produced by Aamir Khan and India's official Oscar submission, turns a village mix-up into a comedy of mistaken identity: Sparsh Shrivastava's Deepak goes looking for the wife he lost, Nitanshi Goel's Phool waits on a railway platform for someone to come and find her, and Pratibha Ranta's Jaya quietly makes the most of becoming someone else, with Ravi Kishan's police inspector never far behind.

Dr. David D. Perlmutter joins Chris Stachiw, the Doctor of Podcasting, to talk watching a film from another culture to learn from it, mistaken identity as a core comedy principle, why Indian cinema has no small parts, Hindi remakes of Hollywood films, and so much more.

———

The Kulturecast is a film and culture podcast from Weirding Way Media, hosted by Chris Stachiw, the Doctor of Podcasting, alongside a rotating table of guest co-hosts. Each week digs into where film and culture meet — and how each one bends the other. Now home to sub-feeds including Required Viewing: A 360° Film Study with Dr. David D. Perlmutter.

New episodes weekly.

Subscribe on Apple Podcasts → https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-kulturecast/id931361376
Spotify → https://open.spotify.com/show/5wjxip9XVYapYuY12yEaGY.
Back the show: https://www.patreon.com/cw/kulturecast

Transcript

Automatically generated, so expect the odd misheard name.

We're in. Wayne Media. Thank you. Hello everyone and welcome to Required Viewing, a sub-feed podcast on the CultureCast main RSS feed. I am one of your hosts, the host of the CultureCast, Chris Dashew, and I'm joined by my good friend all the way from somewhere on the plains of West Texas.

It's out there, folks, way out there. It's like the Midwest, but in West Texas. He's a professor of media and communications over there, your friend and mine, Dr. David D. Perlmutter.

Howdy, Chris. Howdy, Professor. How do you feel about... India. We're taking a trip to the Indian subcontinent.

The South Asia of it all is about to be on display because I'm getting to show my love for Indian cinema on this episode of Required Viewing because we're taking a look at 2024's Kiran Rao directed La Pata Ladies. So the film is, like I mentioned, directed by Kiran Rao. It is on a story by Bip Blap Goshwami from his script Two Brides and the film is Well, it's a film that takes place in 2001, so it's technically a period piece, 25 years ago, in a made-up state called Nirmal Pradesh, which is not a real place, which I think... is also a little fun thing that we're going to have to unpack here. Two brides get switched on a train that are wearing the exact same red veils on a crowded train during a, during kind of a time of year when people are seemingly getting married more often than not.

One groom goes home with the wrong bride and another goes home with the exact opposite bride of his own. So two wrong brides with two wrong grooms and hilarity ensues. Maybe hilarity. It is a very, nice satirical film. And I say nice in that it's not barbed.

It's not thorny. It doesn't, it doesn't, it's not that it's trying to be mean, but I don't think the film is trying to change people's minds by being mean, which I think is also something we will be talking about when we get to it. But Dr. Perlmutter, before we even talk about the movie, I want to ask you, How familiar are you with, and not Bollywood, because I used to do a show called Bollywood Cinema Club. I only called it that because of the curb appeal, not because I am a Westerner who does not know that Bollywood is just one form of Indian cinema.

But how familiar are you broadly with Indian cinema? I would say on a one to 11 scale, about two. And I say this because one of the suggestions that I make, especially if I teach a graduate class, like a doctoral level class that people are going on to get their Ph.D., they might be teaching in universities. It's a piece of advice that my father, who was also a professor, gave me is he said, be really careful and very honest about making any commentary or thoughts or ideas or certainly conclusions outside your magisteria. And what I mean by that is that I got a Ph.D., in mass communication, which some people in my field, including me, sort of question whether it exists anymore.

It certainly doesn't exist in the exact same way it did when I was getting my PhD back in the 90s. And that allows me to range pretty far. I've written books on police in the media and war in the media and photojournalism in the media under this broad area of political communication. And it's allowed me to explore a lot of film, television, games, even literature, because there are adaptations going on. But I definitely have these vast magisteria.

If you imagine a forest, I feel really confident in some villages in this forest that are really well lighted for me. And I could want to talk about the films of Kurosawa. I'm there for you. I want to talk about the films of John Ford. I'm there for you.

I want to talk about films about the Southwest. I'm showing up fully loaded for action. India is not completely a dark forest for me, but like I just have never paid professional attention. Or I have to say, and we'll talk about this about this film in relation to my point, personal preference. I've always had a block on the type of Bollywood magical realism, the stereotypical you're having a very serious scene about like.

1940s Indian politics or it's some battle in ancient times. And then suddenly everybody starts dancing and singing. And that to me, just in a personal preference, which doesn't mean it doesn't it's not a statement on quality. It just that was always a little bit of a block. And so I maybe that affected me and I ended up focusing my Klieg light in another other directions.

It's interesting. I have heard what you have just said so many times, both from people that have been on Bollywood cinema club with me talking about Indian cinema, you know, people that love Indian cinema, Indian people, even I have heard the, well, it's just all singing and dancing, isn't it? And then, you know, I don't like the singing and the dancing and I'm not, you know, I, I know where you're coming from is a different place, but I have heard, uh, this kind of like, well, Indian cinema is always, and it's like, yeah, like in, in, in one of these rare cases, I would say a lot of Indian cinema does have song and dance numbers. And we are just now getting to a point where Indian cinema is like, becoming more westernized.

It's becoming more what the West is doing. It is weird in a film, like essentially, let's call it something to the equivalent of The Avengers. It would be weird in the Avengers to have the Hulk and Iron Man and Thor singing a musical number together. In American cinema, it would be weird. In Indian cinema, it's not weird.

And I think for me, it's still more weird for the films to not have those musical numbers, to not celebrate that aspect of the culture. And like you said, it is only something that can be really understood and experienced through the lens of someone who grew up and is Indian. It is just not part and parcel. To give an example that I think is best understood with your specific things that you've talked about with me, you know what's not part of American culture, especially American teenage culture? Climbing mountains or mountaineering films.

But yet, in the country I know that you were born in and grew up in, partially, at least I, I mean, again, like I know you were there for some time, that is a big part of the culture. I mean, that is a huge part of the culture. You've talked about it before in terms of, you know, proving one's manly hood and, you know, the coming of age of, you know, climbing a mountain and, you know, going and getting an Edelweiss. Like that's, that's, you know, maybe it's antiquated culture now. And I know in the future, you and I are going to be talking about a film that's, you know, very much a kind of indicative of the culture of a certain time in Europe, at least for Austria.

But, Here it is again, like I like yourself and I think, you know, you're you are advocating for the same thing I am like we have to meet these films where they want to be met. And I as a Westerner, you know, I have to like you clearly are kind of I would assume an agreement with like, yes, Western cinema has not conditioned me to expect want or. anticipate that there will be full blown musical numbers throughout the entire film. Like that is in, in Western film, everything is kind of genres, genre eyes there. And I say this often, like genres are ghettoized in this country. I don't know why, like, you know, you can watch an Indian film and it can have four different genres in the, in the span of 15 minutes.

And no one is sitting and saying, well, this is mashing too many things up, like inherently putting musical numbers in your film, any kind of film, other than again, by Western standards, a quote, musical is a strange thing. Like, you know, there's the, you know, Buffy, there's the, the musical episode of Buffy or the musical episode of friends or, you know, whatever. And Buffy, in Western cinema, we're so hung up on genres and, you know, like everything has to be in its like narrowly defined lane. You know, you, you hear about it in cooking, you know, Oh, this is Asian fusion. You know, like I'm cooking it's, it's Korean bulgogi, but then it's tacos like, Oh, it's like Korean Mexican food.

Like, or it's just Korean food. I mean, sure tacos and tortillas are Mexican in inspiration, but At this point, it's a world cuisine and a world culture that I think broadly is accepted by large swaths of people and also claimed. by people as their own thing. And that's the thing about Indian cinema is Indian cinema is inspired by the cinema that they were watching, the things that they were seeing, the culture and film that they were watching and interpreting, and then kind of synthesizing into their own films. And one of the things that really resonated is the the joyous singing and dancing, like you said, magical realism nature of it. And for a lot of Western viewers, it is the biggest stumbling block to get over.

I've personally... never had an issue with it. I understand having an issue with it though, because, and this is the other thing. And I think now it's less of a point than it used to be given. We're looking at a film Avengers doomsday coming out. That's like two hours and 45 minutes and two thirds of all, you know, white cisgendered Americans are going to be going and seeing in the next month and a half.

And movies didn't used to be two hours and 45 minutes. Indian cinema was always, uh, An experience. It was an event. You went to the theater. There was an intermission.

You went out. You got something to eat. You came back to your seat and you finished the movie. Films in India were less of a commodity than they are now. I mean, the commoditization of film and TV in this country, we've talked about it before with people just having...

Peacock TV on with The Office on shuffle like they're listening to Spotify. And I'm not saying there's anything wrong with it. There's nothing wrong with it. I actually, I understand it. If someone is, you know, thinking I'm deriding it, I'm not.

I more often than not have TV and film on or YouTube on more than I do music. I personally find music to be something that you listen to when you're in the car. And I'm not saying you can't listen to it other times, but it's in the car because your ears are needing to be what's active, not your eyes and everything else. Watching things when you're in the car, not the best idea on the planet. But Indian cinema, I think for people in India, best I can interpret it by the way that my Indian friends have communicated it to me.

And then again, doing the research and kind of the legwork and immersing myself in Indian culture as much as I can. going to the movies in India is still a thing. You get your family together, you go. The love for filmmaking and going to the cinema, more specifically, has not been lost in India the way it's been lost in this country. I think that the cinema-going experience was already on its last legs before before the pandemic. And then during the pandemic, it's like, well, I'm not going to go sit in a small room with recycled air with a bunch of people.

Like, hell no, we're not doing it. One of the last things you want to do is go sit in a small room with other people for two hours breathing in their own air. So I understand why cinemas kind of took a hit during the pandemic, but they've never, it's, it's, they've never really come back. They've never really returned to where they were before. And I don't know if they ever will.

In India, this has never been an issue. Like, the cinema culture is as vibrant and as big or bigger than it ever has been now, especially, you know, with the advent of YouTube and Netflix and streaming platforms, which we will talk about, because this film is available right now on Netflix. But all of this to say, if you have an issue with Indian cinema having singing and dancing in it, and you put this very aptly at the beginning of your kind of opening thesis here, imagine watching and American comedy through the eyes. Imagine watching American Pie through the eyes of someone from another culture and them watching it going, what is this all about? I am so confused and lost.

I don't have any interest in watching any further. and it's because they don't understand some of the cultural isms of our culture, it would be a shame for someone's culture and the isms of that culture to be the reason you don't engage with that culture, just because it's seemingly different from what we're used to. But trying to get people to watch movies with subtitles is hard enough, let alone a movie that has characters that are in one scene shooting at each other and in another scene, you know, doing a song and dance number on motorcycles, which is not me making things up. I could show you movies that are literally Forrest Gump meets E.T., with singing and dancing. And the alien is singing and dancing in some of the songs.

Like they, they don't hold back just because there's an alien in the movie. Sometimes there's all kinds of, you know, robots and all sorts of wild stuff, singing and dancing. Like they don't draw a line. And for someone who has lived in this kind of weird world of American cinema, being so strict with the lanes in a horror movie could never win an Oscar. Like Indian cinema doesn't care.

It's so free and open that genres don't care. Conventions don't care. Like, What is important is entertaining the people that showed up. And I can tell you as someone who goes to see a lot of films, as I know you do, sometimes I go see something and I think to myself, how did you fail at the one thing you were supposed to do, which is being able to get me away from the life I'm living for two hours? How did you fail at that?

And if you want to call that entertainment or whatever you want to call that, but that's what these things ultimately at their base core should be doing is giving me something else to think about for two and a half hours. And if you can't do that, and I'm checking my phone and I'm trying to I'm zoned out. You failed. And there are so many American films I go and see that do that. At least Indian cinema still, for the most part, the films that I watch, and I'm not watching all of them because there are so, so, so, so.

You think they release a lot in the United States? Trust me, they release a lot more in India. There's so much to watch, but the things that I watch, at least the love for filmmaking and the want to be entertaining has not been lost and beaten out of it like so much of American kind of commodity filmmaking has. Well, Chris, I think you've raised 76 issues that I'd like to address, I guess, in the five part. Yeah.

In five paragraphs or less, but each paragraph has to be its own idea. Yeah. So trying to narrow down, at least for my response and like looking at this one film. I want to start out by, of course, reminding everybody that part of required viewing is that we're not saying we love this film. Ergo, you should love this film.

And here are the things we love this film. Loving or not loving a film is just data. And so. In my data, I'm going like, you know, I really haven't been watching enough Indian films or I've tried to start to and I have this block that quite a lot of people do. I did mention to you when you suggested this film, and I think I mentioned you before you brought up this film.

In fact, before you brought up doing any Indian film, there is a television series. I believe it's an Amazon sponsored series called Panchayat. which is so adjacent to this movie, it could have been shot in the same village. In fact, one of the main actors, the assistant police director there, is a character in Panchayat, and actually not that different from his Panchayat role. But in classes, like I teach a global communication class, one of the questions I ask students is that, Where does one culture begin and one culture end? Maybe in past eras, if you weren't part of an empire, you could say like, you know, our culture is very different and we do this.

And then those people over there, if you even knew about them, they do that. But we live culturally in terms of big culture, games, movies, television series. We live in a multipolar world. And we've talked about this. We have a tiny country, Korea, so dominant that I would be shocked if any one of my students had never watched any Korean films or TV shows or, you know, comic shows. whatever, you know, K-drama or had not gone and seen a Korean band.

It's Korean culture has so suffused American culture that there are obviously syntheses going on all the time. And so to some extent, using the term Indian cinema versus, say, American cinema is always not going to be a full descriptor because it's This film, La Pada Ladies, let's just start out with something real simple. This is a brilliant, beautiful film that has so many elements that were, the way I like to put it, successful choices for telling a story, for building characterization. Every single person who is shown in this movie is, with one exception, is sympathetic to Once you get to know them, once you get to see them make choices, the challenges that are offered here, you change your mind about people.

You understand people. And this is a very different culture. By the way, it's important to note that to the people making this film, they were having some of the same challenges that we've been bringing up. I... Did something which I usually don't do, but I was so fascinated by this.

And of course, because this film is available on YouTube. The YouTube algorithm immediately gave me 20 videos of the director and the cast and reenactment. videos, especially from the Indian audience watching the film and people doing their own indigenous reactions and talking about, oh, the famous scene in this film where he does this. And I saw a panel. With a number of the major actors and the director, the producer, the I think the executive producer, and they were talking about the villages. And this is a film set for the most part in terms of background.

You're in mostly one Indian village, some other villages. You're at a train station a couple of times. That's about it. And these villages are talked about within Indian culture as the great divide between India. India has these mega cities where, to some extent, there's the power and the money and the universities with the top MBA programs and a lot of the technology factories and so on are.

And then also India has hundreds of thousands of small villages. You said this was set in 2001. Yeah, you can see people having sort of like Nokia like cell phones and they are. Some of them are very modern in the sense that, you know, one of one of the characters aspires to become a. pesticide-free agronomist and go to a university and become somebody who helps villages modernize their agriculture. But then you ought to see other parts of these villages where you go, gosh, just visually, that probably doesn't look different from 1900 or 1800.

And the cast was talking about The fact that in fact, the director, this amazing director, this was only her second feature. I was like I was shocked when I read that because it's such a professional looking piece of work there. Anyway, she was talking about which I have heard so many colleagues and friends from India make a version of this statement. She was taking it. Trains have a huge part of Indian culture that is not as much today.

I mean, I. I don't remember the last time I took a train, but trains are huge in India and all sorts of people get on a train. And she was talking about, you're on a train and you look out the window because you're going between major cities and you see the villages. And Mahatma Gandhi talked about The real India, the India of the villages, the hundreds of millions of people who are doing agricultural work in the villages. So and there's a debate about, you know, what is is that the real India is the modern India is not.

I mean, there's debate within India and I will leave that debate to people within the culture. But that whole question is a question that's very important for us to ask is that in this film. There were cultural practices like you mentioned at the beginning. So at the very beginning of the film, we are introduced to a very, very young, I think the actress was born in 2007 and the film was made just a couple of years ago. So she was in her teens, like 16, 17.

And she plays a very, very young, not only like chronologically, like you're looking like, oh my gosh, is that girl 13 years old or something like that? But she was 16, 17, young bride. And in that tradition, they wear a full covering of a beautiful, beautiful red silk dress. I'm going to call it, sorry, but it's not probably, you'll correct me on that. It's the goon got is what it's called.

It's like, yeah, it's, it's, it's not, I mean, you know, I think in the people in the United States would say like, it's, I would say it's not serving the same purpose as a burqa, but it is being used for women to cover their faces in kind of a young bride in a ceremonial way, not a religious way. Right. So, so then there is this, Wow, straight out of 1920s Hollywood through today, the classic mix-up, right, in situation comedies where there's a mix-up. Somebody takes somebody else's luggage by accident. Somebody drives off with somebody's car by accident.

Somebody– there's a mistaken identity by accident. So we're going like– And I bet somebody who's a scholar of Indian cinema would say, yes, there's a tradition in India as well of the comedy based upon mistaken understanding and mistaken identity. So right away, we have this beautiful mixture of something that's pretty centralized in Indian culture that you couldn't– you could imagine like, OK, they're doing an American remake. How would they have– One young guy taking the wrong bride home to his family by accident. Like, I don't what would how would an American bride be wearing that would like, you know, cover her?

I mean, you'd struggle with that one. But then there's the universal of like, oh, I get it. This is going to be a mistaken identity, mistaken communication comedy. Like a genre that's very familiar to us. Right.

Comedy of errors, as it were. Throughout this film, you're going like, oh, this is really interesting because one of the reasons to watch a film from another culture is to learn something. And immerse yourself in another culture. I think you shouldn't be on this earth if you're only interested in your own culture. And I love to learn about something I don't understand or I don't know about other cultures.

Throughout this film, there is this delightful mixture of like, oh, I see in Indian culture, this is a norm or this this is allowed or this is what someone would do in that situation. And then we go like, oh, yeah, this is very familiar. I've seen this in American films. This is part of my culture as well. And so that's why I make a case to students that.

You know, we can certainly say a film is an Indian film and that was the entire cast were born and raised in India. And the production was by an Indian company. And although quite a number of these films, like this Panchayat TV series, have and this show, this movie had Netflix connection. Right. So Netflix, of course, there is Netflix India and they've got you know, they know there's 900 million customers possibly there.

It's a much more free and open market than some others in that part of the world. And so that's if you want to watch a beautiful, entertaining, funny show. poignant story in the name of everything that's holy. Please go watch this movie. But also, you'll be able to sit there and learn about another culture, but also, I guess, learn something about what works in our culture. It's so funny.

You mentioned, like, how could they do this in our culture? Well, I don't think they could set it in 2001. Right. I can tell you that much. It's one of those things that I was thinking about this earlier today.

It's like, you know, we've had this conversation before privately about like, and you said it already, like what, what do we have option wise in terms of comedy anymore? And, you know, a show like Seinfeld could not exist because so many of the kind of the blunders in that show are, well, I didn't have a way to communicate to my friends at home. It's like, well, a cell phone would fix that Jerry. Like, or, you know, Kramer or anybody, like so much of the things that used to be a stumbling block or a communication error, or in this film, like, you know, misidentity are solved by cell phones. You know, when someone asks a question anymore, I'm like, it would be such a shame if you didn't have a thing in your pocket that would allow you to connect to the worldwide web and ask it a question.

Not that I don't know, but I don't think I can give you all the information that you want. Too bad we don't all have cell phones. Like it's, cell phones have changed the way that we live. just like the internet has, but iPhones in general, the ability to have the internet and a camera in the palm of your hands at all time has changed the way we do certain things. And being able to write comedy is one of those things. Sorry to interrupt you, but like, that is interesting to me.

Backrooms, right, is set in what year? 2000. It's like the late nineties, early two thousands, something like that. It's like 1999, I think. I think you have, you know, it's really hard to set a horror movie, right?

It's hard to do anything. I mean, it's hard to do anything now. It's really, you know, like somebody searching for somebody, you know, the streets and yeah. It's still surprising to me that people can miss. It's, it's surprising to me.

Cause I know you're a true crime, you know, you've, you know, talked about true crime and you talk, you worked with police in the past and, It's crazy to me that you can disappear in 2026. You as a person, people disappear in 2026 still. And it's like, how? How does someone disappear in 2026 with flock cameras and iPhones and cameras on street poles and ring doorbells? Like, you know, I always think of the case of Chris Watts, the guy in Colorado who, you know, you know, murdered his family.

Like he got caught cause his next door neighbor had a ring camera and saw him like, it was like, Hey, he doesn't normally put things in the back of his truck at four in the morning. It's like, and how did you know this? Cause my ring camera catches him every day coming and going like normal. And this is the first day he hasn't. And all of a sudden his wife is missing.

Like you can't do anything anymore. But if you exist in a time and place or you, you exist in a country like India who is still rather at in 2001, a broad unconnected in terms of technologically country, you can do a movie like this. I think it's smart to set this movie in 2001 and not 1881. Cause I mean, again, like the conventions of what we're talking about, they're Shakespearean in nature. Like it's, you know, it's, I mean, I'm trying to remember because I didn't read enough Shakespeare in high school or college to remember, but isn't it Much Ado About Nothing?

Isn't that kind of like Midsummer Night's Dream? Like, which one has a misidentified character? Like, one of those does. There's most of the Shakespeare comedies. In fact, I mean, you could list almost any comedy ever made as.

Its core mistaken character. assumptions, intentions, communications, identity, something. I mean, it's sort of a core comedy principle. This one does it so well. You have this mix up of the brides and then it does something else, too, which I thought was just genius. And I I really want I was trying to figure out a way like, gosh, I've got to get students involved.

A lot of our students are interested in being creators of some kind, and I really have to find a way to make a point about this film in particular, where you are introduced to maybe four or five characters that you may have initial negative views on, like, oh, I get it. She's there just to steal from these people. How terrible. Or this is the corrupt police chief. And he's he's also there just to, you know, steal money and like treat people badly.

And and I don't want to give away the film because I know 99 percent of people haven't seen it. But like. You will not be disappointed by this film shows actual character development as opposed to, I think, the two dimensional character development that occurs in a lot of movies where it feels like forced that somebody, you know, they're acting mean or they're negative and prideful or whatever. Then suddenly, oh, OK, I guess I'll stop being that because the screenplay tells me to. You know, I think it's funny.

I always assume anyone who listens to this has seen the movie, because why else are you coming here? My assumption, and you know, because it's interesting, and I think it goes to something like this. I don't think there's a way to spoil this movie other than saying, well, some of the characters don't end up at the beginning the way at the end that they did at the beginning, that's a character arc. Like I would hope that we're seeing, you know, character arcs on screen. Cause, but again, to be fair with American cinema, specifically American cinema, we have been conditioned now in some ways to not get invested, not care.

And to be fair, you know, to speak to the Netflix of it, all this movie is available on Netflix or on YouTube. Like you said, Netflix leading the charge of the further degradation of the quality of content by having things like the second screen experience and being a thing that they're all of a sudden hewing towards, you know, we've talked about it before. If people aren't paying attention, make better content, don't make worse content and just have the things being repeated over and over again. Cause no one's paying attention. The problem is with the content, not with the people.

If the content's not entertaining and exciting and engaging, people are going to check out. It's not the other way around. Like we're not, you know, unless we're making the content like you and I content creators, we're, We are just ingesting and absorbing and dealing with the content as the creator is creating it. And if they're not making good content, why wouldn't I check out? But don't then go, well, now that you've checked out, I'm just going to have the characters repeat what's going on every five minutes in case you are still checked out.

It's like, I hate to tell you this, but for me, if I check out, I'm checked out. I'm not going back and forth here. And I think the thing for me with so much of Indian cinema is Indian cinema, I think, understands the lack of attention span problem that we are now experiencing with short form content. And there's nothing wrong with short form content. Like I, I really also bristle at this idea that like TikTok and YouTube shorts, like there is a place for that content.

And there is a place for, there's clearly a place for that content, A. And B, that content is not going anywhere. Like it's, it's never going away. because it has engaged people in a way that I don't think anyone thought it would have, because if people had thought about it, they would have been doing it before. If you could have made hundreds of thousands of dollars making 15-second videos, people would have been doing it. Movie studios would have been doing it this whole time.

But again, it's like, it's... It's never that easy. And same with, I mean, same with Indian cinema. Indian cinema only now is just dropping the song and dance numbers. This movie has no song and dance numbers.

There are musical numbers where there are things happening on screen and the music is talking about what the characters are dealing with or what's going on. but the characters don't break into song and dance in this film. It is a shockingly Western film. And again, for me, as someone who loves Indian cinema, it is a little bit of a shame that there's not singing and dancing. Cause I, I personally love that about Indian cinema. It's what makes Indian cinema, Indian cinema.

It's like going to a burger restaurant and asking for a hamburger and then offering you a taco instead. It's like, that's not a hamburger. Like it's just on the base of it, it's not what it is. And I'm not saying Indian cinema without music and singing and dancing isn't Indian cinema. It's just like you said, it's become something else.

It's gone further one step further. It's absorbed the culture of other places and the expectations of other places. And it has decided not every filmmaker, but again, I went and saw an Indian film. two weekends ago. And there was no singing and dancing in it either. Like it's, it's not, it's not uncommon now to not have it.

It was for a time uncommon, but we have had the effect on Indian cinema in the opposite direction. Like we are constantly feeding off of one another now in this kind of globally connected world we live in. Yeah. And again, the labels are can change just as much as they don't necessarily apply to all the data points, right? So I always use the example that I do love Akira Kurosawa as a director.

I've never seen a film by him that wasn't successful for me as a viewer. I would have some notes, but I love him. I have had conversations and read in scholarship about him that in his reviews in Japan, there were people who said he was too Western, that you have to watch other Japanese filmmakers like Ozu and get a real Japanese film. And I thought that's always interesting when somebody says that. Well, Kurosawa based a lot of his work On Western novels, he would talk about Dostoevsky.

He asked him, like, his inspiration. He would talk about Van Gogh and Dostoevsky and so on. So we've always had that mixture. What I understand, and again, you know, for part seven of this talk, episode, we need to have a scholar of Indian cinema come in. But Indian cinema, as I understand it, and I've seen now examples of it, has become multipolar.

There are non-Bollywood industries within industry producing films, different kinds of films, films which have these elements which we identify as Western, but may very well be part of Indigenous storytelling traditions. I found one thing that was very interesting here, that it's a great example of And maybe it's an example of Indian cinema affecting American cultural production, because while this film does not have fourth wall breaking in the middle of a dramatic scene, people start singing and dancing and looking at the camera, it does do the conceit of having montage scenes where there is a song that is not exactly describing what's going on, but like is at least talking about the elements of what's going on.

So, for example, there is a montage where the second bride of these two brides that were mixed up and there's there's more there about like how they were mixed up than just an accident, of course. But the second bride is is going around and she's doing all sorts of things she's going and selling some gold she's doing she's going to a travel agency and police officers are following her and a song is played you know you you watch the youtube captions and this the the police are very suspicious they're taking pictures of her they've got masks on they're like following her around And by the way, this film was shot during part of COVID. And I think the crowd scenes, I mean, we don't often talk on this show about blocking and use of extras.

Unless it's like visibly bad. But this one, my God, these crowded train stations, they were working with like 200 extras. And I was just drop jawed in the quality of handling of people in these crowded streets with the background. But anyway, this bride number two. is going around doing all these furtive things, and she's being surveilled. And the song is saying that, oh, she's so shrewd, you know, she's fooling everyone.

Now, if you remember, we've done a couple of shows with Miranda, an East Asia expert in film, and we've got a couple of Korean films and so on. And Miranda has also seen La Pada Ladies because I wanted to ask her about this. And so she told me that this was actually similar to a device that she has seen used. And she gave the example of the television series Vampire Diaries, where they will have this happen. Like there's there's a particular scene in a cemetery where they'll have a song that is sort of semi describing. what's going on without being, you know, actually naming a character.

So I find that's interesting. And we've always had, of course, diegetic, non-diegetic song, music within films. And, you know, I mean, you watch Fast and Furious, of course, the a montage of cars flying through the air and crashing or whatever, there's going to be thunderous music to accompany that. But this is where the song itself comments on what's happening. The other time this happened in a film we did, if you remember, we had this exact adjacent discussion about the film To Leslie set in Southwest, where our main character, Leslie, who is this beaten down woman, you know, alcoholic, she's lost everything in life and she's sitting in a bar and a Willie Nelson song comes on, you know, are you, are you happy?

Basically, I forgot the exact word, but are you happy being where you want to be? And she, It's not quite a fourth wall moment, but you're like she just says, oh, you've got to be kidding me. I'm sitting here in a dive bar, you know, at the rock bottom of life. And here's Willie Nelson asking me, are you happy where you want to be? So it's interesting to me, these sort of crossovers.

And you don't know whether that Indian film may have had an influence on American filmmaking, but they're using. similar devices which i think are successful. It's very funny you know miranda bringing that up you know i i i guess for some people was a was a montage the limit i mean you know like in the karate kid right like. You're the best around no one's gonna ever keep you down like what I guess if the characters start acknowledging that there's music playing, it's when it's one step too far. I don't know. It's very weird.

Like American audiences is so finicky about like, Oh, it's a certain thing, but then, you know, like we got to cut this part out. Like you can't have the characters acknowledge that there's music, but we can play music, but it could also be diegetic, but the characters can't acknowledge it unless it's part of the plot. The characters can't sing it. I always look at Indian cinema's use of musical numbers as like, What we have talked about so much with other things, and we just talked about it with About Schmidt, which is effectively audience facing dialogue or a monologue. The musical numbers are just what's going on inside the character's mind or kind of like a weird, like you said, magical realism externalization of the scene or. a feeling or, you know, kind of, again, like it's, it's always, and it's always something that for the most part, unless specifically shown otherwise, it's kind of just taking place in this weird, I wouldn't say like ad space, but where does the 20th century Fox logo exist in the world?

Like it exists just like in the nebulous space. And I think that Indian cinema, sometimes the musical numbers just exist in a nebulous space. They don't, you know, they're not grounded in the reality of, the film. And, you know, sometimes the characters break into musical numbers in the sets of the scenes that they're in and that is taking place. But a lot of it is like you already mentioned, like it's just magical realism and it is a cultural expectation and understanding that we as the audience are expecting it.

And it's not something that's like, well, when this shows up in the movie, I'm surprised, you know, it, You don't go to a, let's just say Conjuring 6 comes out tomorrow, right? It doesn't, but let's just say, for example, it does. Would you go to the Conjuring and be surprised if there were jump scares? It's again like, no, because your cultural expectation is when you go and see that movie that it's trying to creep you out or freak you out or be scary or be unsettling or whatever the intent of the filmmaker is. And I would say the same thing with Indian cinema.

The intent of the filmmaker is apparent and clear on the screen. You're trying to understand the, the characters, like so much of Indian cinema, it's less about the singing and the dancing, but more about actually giving us, and you, I think you already mentioned it, giving us fully fledged, fully realized characters that feel like a real person and real people are not in a single genre. Like people inhabit, you know, people contain multitudes like it, like any one of us, like what, You know, we even talked about something like, again, to go back to about Schmidt, something we just talked about. On the surface, Warren Schmidt is the world's most boring man, but he contains multitudes. Even someone as kind of uninteresting and boring as him.

And.... Indian cinema is the same way. Like it is genuinely trying to show, I think the most successful thing about Indian cinema is it's trying to show real characters, like actually fully formed characters on screen. Every character that interacts with anyone in these movies, that's a speaking role is seemingly well thought out and the actors are taking it seriously. It's, I don't know to say acting is not just a job in India still, but acting I think is still a thing you can go do.

And working actors. I'm not saying there aren't working actors in the United States, but... The treatment of acting in cinema and films and the experience is so different in India that it hasn't been lost, that it's a part of the mainstream and everybody watches it. So the amount of hands out to be given something to eat or an eye to be seen is so much more in India. It's the world's most populous country.

Like, you know, I always talk about this and this might blow your mind. Indian cinema, like directors and producers, have not for the longest time cared about releasing their films in the United States. I wonder why you, because in India, you don't have to work that hard. You're, you're competing with other movies, but you're not having to get over the hurdle of getting people out to the cinema to begin with. And in the United States, we're having to convince people to go to the movies to let alone like see a new movie or then engage with it further beyond that.

Like it's in India. We don't have to make, you know, go, go for it. That is a fascinating part. And that's why I think you're doing, um, great work in bringing Indian cinema to the American audience is that it isn't necessarily the intention. I think it is with networks like Amazon and Netflix, where they want to build their gigantic Indian audience and they see great profits there, but also they wouldn't mind exposing it.

And they do like you can get out on Amazon and see hundreds and hundreds of Indian movies and Netflix, but The culture there of the star is, I think, more like the 1940s in America. I have been saying that for as long as I've been watching these movies, I have been saying exactly what you just said. Yeah, I want to talk about the second bride, Jaya, who has an alias in the movie. And she's played by this Indian actress who I'd never heard of, never seen. She's very young.

I think this is her second or third. No, this may be her first or second movie. And she had been on some serials, television serials. Pratibha Ranta. And so I just said, OK, I'll look up Pratibha Ranta.

Oh, my gosh. This is a woman. I think she's in her early 20s. I think more comments have been made about her and more pictures have been posted about her than Marilyn Monroe, Barbara Stanwyck and Scarlett Johansson in their entire lives combined. Yeah.

The frenzy of like. this star was seen at a restaurant with this other star or this star is at a fashion show and look at what she's wearing. I remember a comment many, many years ago. So one of the great loves of Hollywood, you know, Hollywood is famous for, you know, unhappy marriages, but one of the great loves of Hollywood was Carol Lombard and Clark Gable. And unfortunately that true love, which everybody talked about was, was a real true love ended when Carol Lombard was killed in an accident. And I remember reading a description of, of Clark Gable, who was the matinee idol of his time, and Carol Lombard, who was a genius comedic actress and dramatic actress, and certainly a matinee idol as well.

And by the way, I think that is a phrase that I don't think can be applied to American cinema anymore. I don't even think anyone would know what that even means other than like people may, I don't even know if people my age know that term. I don't even think people my age know what a matinee is, genuinely. Yeah. Yeah.

By the way, that's a film that shows before six o'clock, by the way. But in India, I think they do know what, maybe the term, but they know what it means. And so anyway, so there was this description, I think it was like an old Hollywood history that I read maybe 40 years ago of Carol Lombard and Clark Gable showing up for, I don't know whether it was the Oscars, but it was some ceremony of, And they get out of their limousine and they are so radiant and so attractive. And they're dressed, you know, the tuxedo and the glittering gown that the entire you can hear this gasp from the press, the police guarding the area with the ushers. The crowd, everyone just gasps because they're in the presence of gods.

This was this description from 1930s. And I feel like, you know, when I read now about Indian fandom, this ethereality of the actors is so interesting because And when they play in a movie like this, where they're playing ordinary people, you know, this isn't about Schmidt adjacent movie. Like none of these people are famous. They're, they're, you know, a young bride who's very nervous about being a bride and her role as a, as a woman. And there's another bride who aspires to go to university and there's, two young men who are sort of uncertain about what their future is going to be.

These are small, small roles in the sense of the grand scheme of things. Nobody is playing a general or a technocrat industrialist. And it's really remarkable, the acting achievement. I won't say it's tougher to be an Indian actor than it is to be an American actor, but there's so much more of a dimension for them, their acting than and they're being in public than it seems like we have had for the last 60 years. I don't know when people stopped expecting that everyone who's going to be acting is doing it for the right reason.

And I'm not saying that, you know, I expect every single person to do the job for the right reason, but the more people you add to the mix, the less people are going to be doing things for the right reason, just based on the law of averages. The more people you add the more chances you have for things to be turned into something else in terms of the profession. And I think there's a lot of people that are just in the world of acting that aren't doing it for the reasons of the love of filmmaking or the love of the craft or because they've been called to it. And I think you're right. I think that it does.

There is something about Indian cinema that I feel like is ethereal that you can't grab onto. It just kind of When I watch a trailer for an Indian movie, I get excited in a way that I don't get excited for American cinema. And I say that with all love for American cinema, but Indian cinema, they're not beating me over the head with what the movie's about. They're just showing me some wild stuff and trying to get me in the door, not trying to make me feel like I'm smart. Because that's always the thing about American trailers is it's the now kind of well-regarded idea that American cinema, cinema goers don't want to feel dumb.

And so their trailers are shown in chronological order so that people can watch the movie in trailer form. And when they see the movie, not feel dumb. And if the point of the movie is to make me feel dumb, make me feel dumb. Like it's, it's art. The intention of art is coming from A, the artist, but then B, from the consumer of the art.

Julie Brand and I were talking about The Last Unicorn last night, and there are readings of that that the author did not intend, but the author doesn't sit and fight with the people about. Because again, at some point when you release something, it's out of your hands. It's in the world. It has been put out into the ether. And once the ether has it, the ether will not let go.

I mean, you know, there's that age-old phrase like the internet never forgets. And it doesn't, you know, Barbra Streisand in the, what was it? What was it, Dr. P? What was that, the 80s or 90s where they were doing that?

Where she was trying to get her picture of her house taken down? And so what it did, was it just the Streisand effect? Unfortunately, right. It's become famous for what she was trying to do there. Yeah.

It's like Beyonce at the Superbowl, the same thing. It's like, I want all these kind of like, like not embarrassing, but kind of like unflattering photos of me performing during the Superbowl taken down from the kind of, you know, like the AP or Reuters or whomever after Beyonce performed the Superbowl. And so what happened was people just started posting it more and, you know, running ads and articles about these are the photos Beyonce wants taken down. Like, I'm sure that was not her intention was to have it highlighted that she wanted these photos taken down by showing these photos and scrolling through all of them. Like that was never the intention.

And I know the intention of American cinema was not to degrade the job and the kind of the skill and craft that goes into American cinema. But I think like so many other things in Western culture, we have turned something that had a higher calling. People felt compelled and called to, I mean, you hear about it, like, people are called to teaching. People are called to acting. I'm called to be a businessman.

That just doesn't have the same ring to it. I'm called to make money. There's just something about it that doesn't ring the same as called to acting or teaching or these other kind of professions that are not looked down on, but again, derided because you have a calling for it. And when you talk about someone who has a calling of being a capitalist and making money, they're often not pleasant people to be around. People that are having a calling to being actors or teachers or engage in the arts or things like that, they tend to be very odd, idiosyncratic people, but they're also trying to create, and the act of creation is not an easy undertaking.

I mean, again, to speak to people that are business owners that create businesses, it's not easy. Running a business is not easy. Being an actor is not easy, but I think with the way things have happened with, again, like you said, multipolar cultures influencing one another, we have influenced other cultures to, again, increase the output of film and TV and also decrease the quality. Because, again, if people don't care about the quality and all it is is quantity... Just give me 35 seasons of I Married a Murderer on Investigation Discovery where every single episode is effectively woman gets murdered by husband or husband gets murdered by wife.

And that's every single episode. But yet that is a successful show that has had a large fan base and continues to because it's just something that people consume because they could just put it on in the background and have it just on. And you can't just have this movie on. Right. La Pada Ladies is not a film that's just on in the background.

And if that's, if you're doing that after, you know, again, like if you're doing that the first time you watch it, why are you watching this movie? Maybe if you've seen it two or three times, I get it. But this is a movie that at least the first time you watch it is commanding your attention. And I feel like for the most part, there is still that expectation in Indian cinema of, I need to command the attention of the person watching it because there are 8 million things trying to command their attention. I also believe that this film is a great case study, and we talk about required viewing.

Let's say you're a filmmaker, and I would hope anyone who is creating a film would, at some base level, say, I would like to entertain people. I would like people to watch this and enjoy watching it. Now, obviously... There are cases where you might say, no, I want them to be extremely uncomfortable watching this film. But just at a base level, the function of film to entertain is not...

Opposed to the function of film to make you think to bring up difficult issues. And again, if you go on YouTube and you see the discussions by the director, the producers, the cast members, there was a seriousness there about we wanted to call attention to. the villages and the lives of poor people in the villages. And we wanted to give voice to people who often in mainstream culture in America or Korea or India don't have a voice. Let's talk about some of the minor characters here. The younger bride, the one who really, really is very young.

She gets completely lost and nobody takes her home. So she gets off the train and she's just lost. at a train station all alone and she's all in tears and like panicking you know everything she's lived with her family and then she's going to live with her husband's family in her husband's village and you know she sort of thought her life was all set and she's just completely abandoned and she meets A person who I guess physically is a little person. She meets another person who at first you think is disabled and there's something else turns out there. And she meets an older woman who runs a little, you know, food stand, tea shop. It's called, but she sells like roti and samosas and things like that.

And they all have their interesting layers and they take her in. Eventually they adopt her and she has this ersatz family there of these people who are no one looks at them. Maybe somebody buys a samosa from the woman or somebody gives some alms to the beggar or somebody buys a tea from the little person. But they're basically the kind of people that don't get your attention in any society for more than the second. And there's so much there.

There's so much depth and wisdom and beauty. I haven't actually cried at a movie in a long, long time. But like, man, there are a couple of scenes there that was so beautiful and so meaningful. And they were so much speaking about like how we should treat each other with more kindness and love and gentleness that I just thought, my gosh, this film should be required viewing. Like on planet Earth, like let's all take a holiday, you know, like Russia and Ukraine, Iran, United States, Great Britain, Canada, Korea.

Let's declare, you know, March 17th to be La Pata Ladies Day and just all watch this movie and appreciate our common humanity. Well, and I think, you know, that is that's such an important part about this movie is the. There is so much that makes us different, but yet there is still so much commonality and so many common spaces. And, you know, there's this moment in the film where Jaya, one of the two brides, the one who's trying to get away to become a farmer, she and one of the women in this village, like they kind of connect on their love of fried lotus root. And the woman is like, you know, I always cook this for my family and they don't like it, but you like it.

And, you know, like you mentioned, by the end of the film, this other bride has now another found family of her own in this town with Poole, who is, you know, the woman who was the other bride who was lost and Deepak, who is. the pool's husband, but also the man who took Jaya off the train with him. It's, it's really, I think, like you said, like, it's just, it's an important message in this day and age that like family, family doesn't necessarily mean the people that raised you. It doesn't even mean the people that you surround yourself with on a daily basis. It's, I feel like the people that are your family know that you're their family and that they're your family. And it's not, it's, you know, if I were to say to some of my close friends, like, we're family, I don't think they'd be like, no, we're not.

They wouldn't push back. It's one of these things where I do think, like you said, like, there's so much room in the world for positivity, and there's so much room in the world for growth, and I don't know, like, there's a scene in the film where the woman who runs the tea stand gives, uh, an, um, a man kind of a sample and she gives him one sample and, you know, pool's like, why are you doing that? You ain't got to charge him. And she's like, you know, there's, you know, there's nothing in my life we're celebrating right now, but there's clearly a lot in his, and she gives him another spoonful and it's like, okay. like even this little interaction alone, I think speaks to a human interaction and environment that I wish existed more in all these countries.

Cause I'm sure, you know, like this isn't the norm in India. You know, I'm sure that people are, you know, like not to like, you know, Indianophile things, but like India is not a great place in and of itself. There are problems in India. It is a rather conservative country with a lot of conservative oppressive things that aren't great. But again, you can also sit and say, but there's also a lot of good and there's a lot of good that we can learn from each other and from watching another culture kind of unpack its own issues.

I mean, you know, the thing that we haven't really talked about is what is the iconography and meaning of the veil that these women are both wearing. And it is a loss of identity in a culture where women are and have been always, I think, struggling to have an identity of their own because India is a very male-centric culture, as a lot of cultures tend to be. I mean, so many cultures are that way. And women in India do, you know, struggle for their own autonomy and for their own kind of being taken seriously and to be seen. You know, it's very interesting.

One of the scenes in this movie is literally Deepak showing the police chief a picture and going, see, see? And it's like, I can't see anything. Her face is covered. Like it's, The jokes write themselves, but it's not mean. It's just pointing out the reality of women struggle to be seen as it is, and then you cover up their faces, and then what do you do?

Now it's literally... you know, it's, it's figuratively, they're hard to be seen and they're having a hard time being seen, but then literally in the movie, they're having a hard time being seen because their faces are being covered up by veils. It's, you know, it's, the movie has so much going on and it's, it's having such interesting kind of conversations, both seriously and kind of, again, like satirically that I would agree with you. Like this movie, I think checks all the boxes of something that is smart, pointed, but also still being entertaining at the end of the day, like entertaining still above all else, which is again, not a thing that I can guarantee anymore with American cinema. And there is one character, one of the husbands who is very easily identifiable and stays and even gets worse as a villain.

But other than that, most of the people have these redemptive moments and the way that those are achieved is the gentleness of them, the deafness and nuance there that is Again, I don't want to use Indian cinema to bash American cinema or the other way around. It's not for me to say I wish more Indian films had less musical dancing numbers. That's not my point. In fact, I do get to have– all human beings get to have cultural preferences in what they enjoy, but that's not my point as a critic. But I did love the way that– like this is a women's empowerment movie.

This is a women's empowerment movie, and it is done without attacking necessarily any of the men in this movie. In fact, if you go online and you see some of the discussion in the movie, there's one particular scene where the young husband, husband number one, who makes the mistake at the train station, and he has married the very young bride. And there's a flashback to when I'm not sure it's clear culturally whether this is the first time they've ever physically met. This is before their marriage. And he is sitting with her.

And again, this is something where, you know, in American culture, it would be unusual that this would be the first time they would have this conversation, but maybe the first time that they met. He says to her, I don't know many words of English, but I do know I love you. And such a great moment, such a great moment. Oh man, it's his sixties. And that was a beautiful, beautiful moment.

And I can tell you, I think there are 100 million comments on, you know, I didn't read Hindi social media, but like If you just take an extrapolation for comments in English about that moment, people will say like, oh, the most beautiful moment in the film was when he says, I love you in English. Right. And it just it's. it was just a moment of humanity. This man is not trying to oppress his bride. He's he's not just more than a few years older than her.

They're coming from a culture. And I think we have to you know, I'm not disagreeing with you, Chris, but like we always have to be careful about when we use certain words like in situations of extreme poverty, where you're leaving, you're living literally a subsistence level, you can completely understand why cultures are. And we use a word like conservative or liberal or whatever. And we know that the definitions of those words have changed over time. You know, to be a conservative in Botswana in 1960 is maybe different than being a conservative in the, what was in Botswana 400 years before, right?

And like today, being a conservative or 50 years ago, being a conservative. So you can understand village culture, you know, poverty culture is inherently conservative because if you take the slightest risk, you can all die. You can all starve. Somebody comes along and says, hey, let's plant this new form of seed, you know? Okay, well, the risk is my family starves, or I be a conservative and I plant what my father planted and his father planted, right?

Or we change something up. And in fact, there's a really interesting discussion in the film where the second bride, the more adventuresome one, the one that has more adventures in terms of movement, she's the one who wants to become an agronomist and advise farmers on new farming practices. And Her mother says, yeah, but who will do the housework for the family if you're not doing it yourself? Right. And, you know, it is it's a question we haven't answered in our civilization.

Right. It's like when when we have two working couples, like who does certain things that needs to be done and, you know, different couples work out different arrangements and so on. But my point is that all of all of the political message, the social message of the film is is done with this just nuance that sometimes I feel we in the West fail to do with our gigantic sledgehammer where somebody wants to make a point, a message in a movie. And they could learn from this movie. Like Mickey 17? uh yeah it's such an easy it's such an easy punching bag but it is a movie that's talking about hyper like it's poo-pooing hyper capitalism but it's like a hundred million dollar movie like come on guys like it's it's the gdp of a small african country and that's what you put into one movie like it's no it there there is something genuine here about the message and you know i i do also think And it's funny because there's a scene in the film, speaking of politicians, there's a scene in the film where a politician tries to co-opt Deepak. and his search for his girlfriend, or his wife, I guess, like you mentioned, is technically his wife.

They are married. But again, in any other film, especially an American film, it would be his girlfriend. Because again, it's the thing that I think is so funny. American cinema has such a hard time with realistic characters or getting characters right or making characters sympathetic or empathetic. And this movie, you have two characters who ostensibly, this is their first time meeting in the film, and like you said, that I love you moment between the two of them is so genuine and earned, and I don't know, it's just, it's so well done that you just, you look at American cinema, and like you said, I don't want to use this as an opportunity to drag American cinema, it's just, I'm pointing out that American cinema is just not rising to the occasion it used to in terms of giving us believable, interesting characters, because I haven't seen anything in American cinema in a while that was as believable and kind of impactful as that scene between two characters that have, again, ostensibly only met in this one scene.

Yeah. And the dimensionality of it gets me too. We had a discussion for one episode talking about the Maltese Falcon with Mike White. And one of the remarks that we made was that everyone on screen was no matter how small their role was, did a fantastic job. And I was lamenting again, I guess, although Mike used this term about the grumpy old man shaking his cane at the sky or yelling at the clouds.

I am very self-conscious because I hope you typically the oldest person in the room when we get together, whoever is with us, that I don't want to be doing that. But I do want to say that, like, I find it interesting and I have not watched enough Indian film yet. to make this a blanket statement, that they also seem to have kept the tradition from British television and movies from the 30s through the 70s and American television, where the minor parts were still had major talents in them. That little family group there of the older woman who's running the food stand, the little person, the beggar. Oh, my gosh. What great actors.

Like distinctive actors, like I wanted to know more about them. Like I always wanted to be like, can we do another movie of just their lives or something like that? And it's like Peter Lorre or Sidney Greenstreet appearing in a movie. And, you know, from a 40s or 50s movie, you know, they're only going to be on screen once. for like a total of maybe eight or nine minutes. I was rewatching Casablanca last night because I know eventually we're going to discuss it, but Peter Lorre shows up and I've watched Casablanca maybe 19 times.

And I know intellectually Peter Lorre is only going to be in a few scenes and then killed. But man, you eat up those few minutes and because it's Peter Lorre. And you can tell that Humphrey Bogart is it while the star is, you can see he's happy to bring on Peter Lorre, take over the screen for a few minutes doing Peter Lorre. And he knows that that's like reflecting and enhancing his role in the movie. And That's what I also detected, which, again, I'm not an expert in Indian film, but I felt between the actors, there was a lot of generosity.

Right. In deferring that, you know, you're playing this role, which is helping me play my role. I mean, we use this word chemistry. That's something else. I just came away from this going like, my God, the chemistry of everyone, like the police chief, one of the police in the film. is, does she have a line?

There's a woman police officer. And at first, all you see is her looking brusque and tough. In fact, she hits with a stick, somebody who's coming in to ask for help. And you're going like, OK, she could be a one-dimensional character in most things. And then later on, when there's a moment where the police chief has to make a decision to do the right thing, and help one of the main characters, she has this just one moment.

I don't think it's actual close-up. It's like half screen where she's looking at her chief and going, oh, please, chief, do the right thing. Show mercy. Help this person. And that's it.

And I was thinking, like, I want to find out more about her. Please. Who is this wonderful actress who's given so little but does so much with it? There's this phrase that I've heard before and there's no small parts. And I think Indian cinema is like the most, the most obvious advocate of that.

You know, there it's funny, you know, there are no small parts. And I, I, you know, I don't know if you noticed this in the research that you did, or if this was again, something that would not have prickled your ears because again, your exposure to Indian cinema is not as kind of vast as mine is, but the gentleman who produced this film, Amir Khan is, he was originally going to be cast as the police officer role, which by the way, if he had been in the role as the police officer, it would have been beyond distracting because Amir Khan is, to say he's as big as Tom Cruise is to kind of diminish how big Amir Khan is. That's like being kind of reductive in the comparison because Amir Khan is a bigger actor than Tom Cruise is, and I wouldn't say in a lot of ways, in every way.

And If he had been the police chief, it would have been imminently distracting. The casting director cast someone else instead of him because the other actor was better for the role. That's a great story. It's insanity is what that is. Yeah.

Oh, it's a lot of things. It's yeah. I always question intentionality. But when a story like that comes across my plate, all I can think is. well, like you said, there's a lot of generosity here that we just don't see in at this level of filmmaking, because a producer intruding and being part of a film is not unknown in any part of the world, especially this one. But it's very funny that it's like, well, you know, if he had been this role, I would have been distracted the whole movie.

You would have been distracted the whole movie. You wouldn't even know who Amir Khan is and you would have been distracted. Like he's just It's one of those things where sometimes the best actor for the role is the person who shows up and does the best performance, not just because of who they are. And having your producer in the movie not being cast in one of the main roles because someone else is better for the role, like you said, I think is very generous in a way that I don't expect from the arts. So you're saying it was a mistake. to turn down Ben Affleck, who was considered first, right?

Yeah, right, yeah. So that's the thing. I love Indian cinema, and I don't just love Indian cinema for the Indian films, but I also love Indian cinema for the Indian films that are remakes of American films. And sometimes they are remakes in the literal sense, like this is a film that is being remade with the approval of the studio. I can only think of one of those films.

It's called Lal Singh Chadha. It is Forrest Gump. In India, it is a literal remake of Forrest Gump to the point where it's, I think it's produced by Paramount and possibly even Tom Hanks. And the main star of that film, to give you an idea of who it is, is Amir Khan. The guy who is in this movie not being cast as the police chief.

Like, the visibility, like you said, of these actors is... We have comparatives in the United States, but no one in the United States is going... in mass and standing outside of Tom Cruise's house waiting to see a hand wave of him the way that Indian people have and fans of Amitabh Bachchan for years. Every, I think it was like every Sunday for 20, 30, 40 years, he would come outside of his house and wave at all of his fans. And there would be hundreds, if not thousands of people out there every weekend. And then he would go back inside.

That's a cultural response to something that is not... there's not a compare. Like sometimes it's like, well, it's like this, you know, it's like to like, say like it's a mere con is like Tom Cruise. Like there's not a comparative because the paparazzi are the only ones doing that in the United States. Like I guess, and people standing outside of, well, I know that Walton Goggins is going to be doing the stage play and I want him to sign something. So I'll stand outside of Broadway and harass him to get an autograph.

But people aren't doing that just to get a glimpse of an actor. Like Cause you could see him on screen or in pictures and movies and other things, but people want to get a glimpse of him. Like that's, that, that's just, that response is not a thing that is, I don't know if it's like, it's gone in our culture or if it's just, there's not a. it's not baked into our culture. This there's, there's not the overwhelming response to it. Like I can think of things like the Beatles or Michael Jackson or these other kinds of like performing artists that people respond to that way.

But that as like a thing that happens consistently in our culture is not a thing. Yeah. So obviously we, we agree that this was an incredibly successful film on every vector of required viewing approaching a film. I, I, It's funny, when I watch a movie, I do, like this time, if I've never seen it before, I try to watch it at least twice, and I don't look up anything about the film before I watch it, because I want to have as much of an innocent eye, although, as we've talked about before, you never watch the same film twice, you never watch the same actor twice. But here, I was about as innocent as you can get, because I, with the one exception of this, the second in command there, who's a sort of somewhat dim-witted second-in-command at the police station, I had not seen or heard of any single person in this movie.

And so all my, oh yeah, she's a megastar and 100,000 people show up at her house to see her wave. That was all ex-post watching. And so it was really just a wonderful revelation. I can't help I don't even know what the analogy is. Like, you know, you're living a long time in one location.

And for some reason, you've just never taken a walk or a drive in one direction. You find this beautiful valley, you know, full of adorable animals and beautiful trees and rocks and brooks and things like that. And I want to thank you, Chris, because I need to have an undergraduate education in Indian cinema. Now I've, I've put that off too long for 60 years and I need to get to work and I hope you'll be my teacher and I'll work hard to get a good grade. I was going to say, you know, I haven't really talked about it anywhere, but this is probably as good a spot as any to mention it.

But I did used to do a show called Bollywood Cinema Club. I have a large portion of banked episodes that I'm going to be running here in the next couple weeks, actually, probably like a month or so. And Then I will be getting back to creating new Bollywood Cinema Club content probably once every other week because there is so much. I can go see it in theaters and there is no reason because, and I, and you know, this is where I want to end this because, you know, I think what's important is for me to address something that's kind of not been addressed since the film came out. Triple R came out and people seem to love it.

Has anyone talked about it since? Has anyone had a conversation about Triple R since or the mainstream mentioned anything about what the actors from the film or the directors from the film have been doing in Indian cinema since? Because they've been working on all kinds of stuff. Raja Muli and Rama Rao and all the other actors have been doing all kinds of stuff since. They're not just working on the next Triple R film.

They're all doing their own thing. And it's disappointing to me as someone who loves Indian cinema and wishes it was part of... It's like anything else. I don't want someone to just go only watch Indian cinema. I want it to be part of a healthy film watching diet of, you know, Indian films and American films and, you know, maybe some other foreign cinema as well.

Like foreign cinema broadly, like doesn't have to be Indian cinema. Like go, go watch, you know, Mexican filmmaking or Spanish filmmaking, or I don't know, like Eastern European filmmaking. There's so much filmmaking to be had outside of our admittedly large room, but it is a room. There is a door and there is so much else outside of it that we could if we wanted to have access to it. And because of streaming and YouTube and everything else, the time has never been better to watch foreign cinema of any kind.

I mean, I see shows on Netflix all the time that are being advertised to clearly American audiences that are not in English, but the show doesn't even say that it's not in English anymore. And I appreciate that because I don't think we need to, it's not that we do or don't need to draw attention to it, but I want people to watch things and not have a reason to not just based on a preconceived notion that they might have had. Because like you alluded to at the top of this episode, there is an assumption that Indian cinema is going to be singing and dancing. And as you've clearly seen, it's not. Maybe we'll watch a film from five years ago, 10 years ago, 15 years ago, and it'll have it.

And even 15 years ago, there were films that didn't, but it wasn't the norm. And it's becoming... more of the norm even now. And for someone who loves Indian cinema, it's a bummer, but if it gets more people to watch Indian cinema and hopefully go further, don't just stop the conversation here, go further and want to, like you said, have a furtherance conversation. Those are the people I want to talk to. And my hope is even though triple R didn't make substantial waves in the long term.

It made a big impact initially, but there hasn't been a lot since. My hope is that people can remember that they did enjoy Triple R and that I don't have to struggle and fight to get people to at least make room for an Indian film to watch or to give a chance to, because Indian cinema is not just satirical comedy dramas. Like I am going to pick the next time we do an Indian film, we're going to watch an action movie that would not be any different if you cast Steven Seagal in it. Again, it's like sometimes there are things that bridge the divide between two cultures. And I wanted to end this by somewhat apologizing to you as well, because for as good as this movie is and for as much as I enjoyed this movie, throwing you into the cultural deep end of an Indian comedy is about as hard of a thing to do as it would be handing you a test for the end of the class at the beginning and saying, hey, you got to pass it right now. culturally comedies are the hardest thing to understand or appreciate.

And I'm not talking about Indian. I'm talking about in general, because there's so much slang and cultural milestones and markers and things that just are not. Look, English is a hard enough culture and the American culture is hard enough to understand. You know, we're just now living in a time and place where Europeans are like, we get ranch dressing. We finally understand ranch dressing.

Like, The range dressing's been around for 40 years and we're just, oh, it's just now making it across the pond. We love it now. Like for as large as the world is, remember the world is, the world can be as small as an about Schmidt, just the 10 miles that surround you. It can be that small. And for some people it's, For as connected as we are, some people want it to be that way.

And those people sometimes are beyond saving. But my hope is even they would be amenable to a big Indian action movie where at the end of it, there's one liners and guys are getting, you know, thrown off of a cliff to end the film. Like, I would hope you would be amenable to that regardless of the language involved. But comedies, man, they're they're having a hard time stateside, let alone internationally. Yeah.

And this has been a longtime discussion. Famously, Seinfeld was not as successful internationally. You can look up all the adaptations of The Office. And of course, The Office, the U.S. office, was an adaptation of a British office, a short run series. But it changed a lot. to be successful at the American market.

And then it's been tried in many other markets and has not, to my knowledge, has been as successful. And you're right. There's a reason Fast and Furious, and one of the things I do in my class using Fast and Furious as an example, is you look at the American domestic box office, and then you look at the international box office, and Hollywood tremendously depends on the international box office. In fact, they'll often say, like for even a hit film, you'll make your money back on the American office, you'll make your profit on the international box office. And an MCU film and a Fast and Furious film, you don't need subtle, you know, cultural understanding, you know, cargo crash, big boom, right?

And international language does not need You could just dispense with the subtitles for most of those films. But I want to end on an example of how this film bridged cultures because it was using comic situations which were familiar, but did them so well. I went online and I found the screenplay of the movie, which was originally called Two Brides, based on a book and a story. And there's some complicated stuff there you mentioned, but like The screenplay is fascinating because– and you have to tell me whether this is common. I'm going to read one little section from the screenplay when Deepak and Phool, P-H-O-O-L, the young bride and young groom, are– on this long journey to his village, and they originally get on a bus, and they get on a train.

It's very Indian, you know, that connection of having to travel on these conveyances, which aren't as familiar to middle-class Americans anymore. The screenplay, the lines, the spoken lines are in Hindi. The stage directions, the instructions are in English. I find that very interesting. So, Scene five exterior moving bus.

The newlyweds travel cattle class. That's very interesting because in the film they're talking about you see their go third class. And so there's an implication there must be a second and first. It's telling you, you know, he can't afford even for his wedding ride. He can't afford more than third class.

And but they have no problem. I mean, I, as an outsider, would feel uncomfortable saying, oh, I think I'm not going to use the word cattle class to describe. But but they internally say it's a cattle class. And of course, everybody know there knows what they mean. They're all packed in like cattle, which leads to one of the the initial.

So anyway, the newlyweds travel cattle class atop a bus with all kinds of other co-passengers and their luggage, including a goat. And I thought that's so interesting because, again, as a white Westerner. I would be very uncomfortable if I said, oh, yeah, it's a movie based in India. So you got to have somebody having a goat. You know, I feel like, OK, maybe that comes off as somewhat condescending or something.

But again, they're in the culture. And so they actually specified there's got to be a goat. Fool relaxes a bit against Deepak as the bus rattles off down the bumpy road, leaving clouds of dust in its wake. As they eat the parokas and chat, you know, and I had to look up because I mean, I've eaten Indian food before, but I apparently I have eaten the parokas, but I forgot what it was called. Fool now looks happy seeing the passing landscape through her veil.

And then they. go on to have, again, dialogue in a native language. But I just, again, this is such a great movie for showing how Cultures can be bridged and crossed and so that a movie doesn't necessarily 100 percent belong in the category of it's this is an Indian movie and somebody from California or Nebraska or Texas. Gosh, you're going to have too much trouble understanding what's going on here. The stuff that you don't understand, like, OK, if you have to look up on your phone what a pakora is, that's fine. doesn't have anything to do with 99% of what's going on in the movie. So, Absolutely.

Just a beautiful film. And thank you. This was the right one. I disagree with you. You're wrong again, Chris.

This is the right film to get me going on my Indian film journey. You only get one challenge of the professor per semester, sir. How dare you use it this early? There's still two months left in the year. No, I just I would not put this in front of someone who had never seen an international film ever and expect them to vibe with it.

But someone who has kind of like yourself, you know, and like you mentioned, you know, there are people who have pushed you to watch things you may not have watched otherwise. And you have pushed people to watch things that they may not have watched otherwise. Like you yourself are the right kind of person for this kind of film because you're already amenable to international cinema. But yeah, comedies are hard. But the next one won't be a comedy.

It'll probably be something a little bit different. You know, this movie was fun, but the next movie will be fun in a different way. So until then, if you want to follow Dr. Perlmutter and I talking about film, you can follow us over at weirdingwaymedia.com, where this show and my show, The Culture Cast, the original show that this one spun off from, can be found. Head on over there.

Don't go to Spreaker. They don't give us enough money for me to pimp their website, so I'm not going to. And their website looks terrible. So come on over to weirdingwaymedia.com. That's where this show and all the other shows on the network can be found. like, rate, and review the shows on iTunes, then Spotify.

Those are the only places that ratings matter, and that's the only place where the algorithm does anything. If you find it on YouTube, if you're listening to this on YouTube, this is what we call a podcast, not a video. I know, shocking if you made it this far and you're still wondering what this is. Yeah, come on back for the next episode. Maybe an Indian movie, maybe not, but it won't be an Indian comedy that much, I can promise you.

Thank you.

Download the transcript file

Similar episodes across the network

Matched by shared keywords.

  • Bollywood Cinema Club · Jun 26, 2024

    Cirkus (2022)

    4 shared keywords: bollywood, hindi_cinema, indian_cinema, netflix

  • Bollywood Cinema Club · Nov 15, 2023

    Dhoom 3 (2013)

    4 shared keywords: aamir_khan, bollywood, hindi_cinema, indian_cinema

  • Bollywood Cinema Club · Oct 4, 2023

    Ishq (1997)

    4 shared keywords: aamir_khan, bollywood, hindi_cinema, indian_cinema

Transcript

Loading the transcript…