Full episode

The Dog Stars (2026) — "Here it's just us trying to hold on to what was."

1 hr 19 min Clean Full episode
The Dog Stars (2026) — "Here it's just us trying to hold on to what was."
The Kulturecast
0:00
1:19:05
MP3

About this episode

Ridley Scott has spent nearly fifty years imagining how the world ends, and The Dog Stars is his look at what comes after. Adapted from Peter Heller's novel, it follows Jacob Elordi's Hig, a pilot who, after a flu pandemic has wiped out most of humanity, holds the line at a small, isolated community alongside Josh Brolin's hard-edged Bangley. When a stray radio signal pulls Hig past the edge of his map, he finds Margaret Qualley's Cima and her father, played by Guy Pearce, and has to decide whether surviving is the same thing as living.

Dr. David D. Perlmutter joins Chris Stachiw, the Doctor of Podcasting, to talk Ridley Scott, Peter Heller, post-apocalyptic cinema, and so much more.

———

The Kulturecast is a film and culture podcast from Weirding Way Media, hosted by Chris Stachiw, the Doctor of Podcasting, alongside a rotating table of guest co-hosts. Each week digs into where film and culture meet — and how each one bends the other. Now home to sub-feeds including Required Viewing: A 360° Film Study with Dr. David D. Perlmutter.

New episodes weekly.

Subscribe on Apple Podcasts → https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-kulturecast/id931361376
Spotify → https://open.spotify.com/show/5wjxip9XVYapYuY12yEaGY.
Back the show: https://www.patreon.com/cw/kulturecast

Transcript

Automatically generated, so expect the odd misheard name.

We're in Wayne Media. So what'd you do before the world ended? Hello? The world it was. Doesn't exist.

Out there, it's kill or be killed. There's a new bunch in town. They're going after everything that's left. Shoot the roof! The Dog Stars in theaters on IMAX August 28th.

Rated R. Hello, everyone, and welcome to the CultureCast. I am your host, Chris Tashew, and I'm joined by my good friend all the way from West Texas, where this film does not take place. This film has nothing to do with West Texas or Taylor Sheridan or in a lot of ways, it may be the first movie that Dr. Perlmutter and I have talked about that's not great.

Your friend and mine all the way from Texas Tech. He is a professor of media and communications there, Dr. David Perlmutter. Howdy, Chris. Are you a dog star, Professor Perlmutter?

Are you a star of the dogs or whatever the point of this film was? Because on this episode of the CultureCast, Dr. Perlmutter and I are taking a look at Ridley Scott's most recent film. which, as many of you know if you've listened to this show before, Ridley Scott and I don't get along very well. We're going to be talking about his most recent foray into filmmaking. That would be 2026's The Dog Stars.

So The Dog Stars is written by Mark L. Smith. Based on the book, The Dog Stars is the same name by Peter Heller. It is directed by Mr. Ridley Scott.

It stars one of my favorite actors' names, Jacob Elordi, Josh Brolin, Margaret Qualley and Guy Pearce. It's a small cast film with a huge budget, it would seem, or at least somewhat of a bigger budget than one might expect for a movie that came out. And I'm convinced nobody saw or talked about because, Dr. Perlmutter, you were the first person to mention it to me. It is a post-apocalyptic film.

Starring Jacob Elordi, Josh Brolin, Margaret Qualley, and Guy Pearce. Why nobody talked about this movie is beyond me, unless there's a reason. So, Dr. Perlmutter, I am so unbelievably curious. Why, oh why, are we talking about the dog stars today?

Well, Chris, let's see. I have to justify that somehow. No, seriously. We've agreed that we can learn from films where we disagree with some of the decisions of the filmmakers just as much as films where we go, wow, that is fantastic. That's beautiful.

That's stirring and chanting and so on. What they do and what they don't do is just as important. Like those two things are important. What they do is important and what they don't do is important. Right.

So I was curious because. When this movie came out, by chance, I just saw some post in a post-apocalyptic social media site that I frequent. More on that in a moment. And somebody said, hey, did you know that there's a new post-apocalyptic movie coming out with Josh Brolin and directed by Ridley Scott? And I'd say of the several hundred people who commented...

Most said, no, where? What's it called? And it was based on a novel that had some level of popularity. I have not read it, which is also odd because I have been, I believe, since age eight. So that's a lot of decades reading since I read The Great Tripods Trilogy by the wonderful John Christopher, which I reread every two or three years.

I've been in love with post-apocalyptic. And I've also been very interested in how I felt from the response of my students. And again, I get a lot of 18-year-olds who are just coming to college. traditional college student, but we also get a lot of returning students, people coming back after a successful career, still in a successful career to get their degree. So I have some variety. But for the 18-year-olds, I have never seen post-apocalyptic as popular as it is now.

And I'm wondering if that's a social trend that we should be worried about. But I was under the impression post-apocalyptic was very popular. And of course, we've had just over the last 20 years, a lot of extremely popular post-apocalyptic films, TV, video games, movies that are post-apocalyptic. And of course, Ridley Scott is about as big a name director as you can get. We both agree.

I think we haven't actually reviewed a lot of his films together, but we both agree that his career has been challenged as of late. And we can discuss that. You're being, you're being a lot kinder than I would. I wouldn't even say as of late, I would say like Ridley Scott for me has made four good movies and that's about it. He's just, He is very inconsistent as a filmmaker, and as of recently, he has taken to blaming actors for his movies not being good, which is never a good look, given that he was blaming someone who I think is immensely talented in Paul Mezcal.

And he's like, he just wasn't masculine enough for Gladiator 2. And I'm like, yeah, that's the problem with the movie, with the CGI monkeys fighting people in the Coliseum. That's what the problem with that movie was. Yeah, and I guess we can talk about the story that Josh Brolin walked off the set the first day of this movie I was reading and called his agent, said, that's it. I'm not doing this film.

I'm quitting. We can talk about it. But back to your original question. So I was going into this saying, well, it's got a director that– Alien and Gladiator and just there's a lot of movies that I thank Ridley Scott for making, putting in my sort of headcanon of terrific movies. And I honestly have avoided some of his more recent movies just because I don't want to spoil my image.

I had I had of him positively. I also thought, OK, post-apocalyptic it. I've seen bad post-apocalyptic. I've walked away from some. The Walking Dead was a great series for seven seasons and then, in my opinion, collapsed.

And I had no problem DNFing it after that. But I walked into this movie with some hope, with some little bit of hope. And since this movie's theme is about hope, I was walking into this movie with some hope. And then this movie took all hope away from me. So I went an exact opposite character arc as the main character.

And I thought about it. First, my students had never heard this. Obviously, nobody went to see it except maybe the two of us. It really had a tiny, tiny– art house opening and then just disappeared after that. But I think it's interesting to talk about what happened here because As I said, sometimes I wonder, I'm talking to an 18-year-old and I'm going like, yeah, you know, let's just take post-apocalyptic.

I've read easily thousands of post-apocalyptic stories and books. So it really is hard to surprise me. It's hard to have a novel reveal or twist or a character I haven't seen before, a situation that I haven't seen before. When I was taking notes on this film, I guess I was feeling a little bit old because I think I got into the 40s. And before I got, I gave up of motifs, tropes, plot lines, plot developments, conceits, where, oh my gosh, I was, are they really doing this one?

Are they really doing that the community that seemed so loving and welcoming turned out to be cannibals. And there's a shot of a room full of bodies. And actually, when that was starting, I was thinking to myself, well, the one thing they know they can't do because it's so hackneyed, so cliched, so ridiculous, is it turns out that these are cannibals. And they did it. I don't think they know it was that hackneyed, Dr.

Perlmutter. Every single box of every single cliché When the dog is introduced, no Supergirl criticism allowed here, but the dog is introduced, and I said, oh, poor little doggie, you are not going to survive this movie, are you, little doggie? There's just no way that you're... And they did it. They did it as well.

He meets an old man with a younger daughter, and the main character, Hig, refines his purpose in life. It's not an AI written movie. I'm sure these are real people whose credits are on the screen. I'm sure they didn't use AI. But every single decision here was obviously the average of all decisions made for post-apocalyptic movies in the past.

And we're going to talk about some of them, obviously. But the other part that really got me was just All of this effort. And yeah, a lot of talent, like like the set piece action sequences, James Brolin, Josh Brolin. I keep thinking about his dad, Josh Brolin, my one of my favorite actors ever. I think he does tend to play Josh Brolin, but that's okay.

I'm willing to watch Josh Brolin do anything. And he was the light of this movie, right? And his character, the cynical guy who don't trust anybody, again, the cliche, but he played the cliche so well. And this could have been the character from Sicario who just survived into the apocalypse with some youth drugs or something like that. It was the same guy, right?

But it got me the lack of interest in a– I just imagine this meeting in Hollywood and they're going like, OK, so let's see now. We've got this continuing issue here of– I'm just trying to pick cliche number 37. Yeah. Yeah. OK, we've got maniacs running around in gangs for no particular reason just to destroy everything.

The usual lack of explanation of like, really, is there stuff left to destroy? There's no there's no crops like they just survived by killing the last seven people alive. OK, fine. Now we've got to come up with a name for them. It's got to be new and fresh and original.

It can't be a name that is just so cliched from 500 other names. Let's call them the Reapers. Oh, wow. Yeah, the audience would be blown away. No one would have ever thought of that.

Well, my gosh, if you go, I think if you go to chat GPT and say, I've got a group of post-apocalyptic maniacs running around crazy, killing everybody, and they're just destructive. They have no good values whatsoever. What should I call them? I'm sure chat GPT would put down, you know, in the top 10 reapers, reavers, you know, ransomers, ravagers, you know, just under the R alone. So the lack of energy put into thinking of anything original.

And then I said my last, but here's my real last. And then let's talk about the movie. We've talked about this before. I think in 2026, You are not allowed to make a movie, video game, television show on a familiar theme where everybody has never heard of this theme before. You cannot make a time loop movie where people go, my God, we seem to be in some sort of time loop.

I've never heard of that before. I've never seen a movie or read a book or story about a time loop. We're just going to have to independently figure out everything. Or these people, my God, the dead are walking. What does that mean?

How would we possibly kill walking dead? And then, you know, 60 minutes later, you know what? If you shoot them in the head, that seems to die. Really, we can't do this anymore. We cannot pretend that previous popular culture doesn't exist.

And I've said that there's been a couple of movies out there that done a good job with this, but most like this film pretends like before the collapse, the disease or whatever, no one had ever heard of the past or speculated in the possibility of collapse. There were no post-apocalyptic films in the world of the dog stars, which makes no sense. It's. I mean, I think that speaks to the problem with this movie is this movie exists in a world where it seemingly thinks it's the first ever post-apocalyptic film to exist. And I guess I don't know.

Look, I don't know if that's the Ridley Scott of it all or what it is. I mean, even Ridley Scott has done post-apocalyptic films. Sort of, I guess. I mean, again, you could make the case that I guess Blade Runner is not really post-apocalyptic, but Blade Runner is dystopian. I guess maybe is a better way of putting it.

But I guess the thing that I walked away from, like my big takeaway, and that's exactly what my girlfriend and I were talking about when we watched this movie was why are there so many tropes in this movie that we've seen a million times before in a million other movies done here? Like you said, with no like pointing at the fact that they're doing them, they're doing them in earnest. And I don't understand why. Your film is not well enough known in terms of the source material. The Dog Stars was not this Dan Brown, Da Vinci Code-level hit that everybody was just talking about and nobody could shut up about.

There was none of that with this movie. Or the book, especially, obviously, the book, more importantly. So it's not like we're all coming to this as we're all huge fans of the Dog Stars and, oh, Hig is my favorite character. There was none of that. I didn't even know this was based on a book until you suggested we watch it.

And then I was like, oh, this is based on a book. Okay, I guess that... It makes even less sense that it's based on a book, in my mind. Because it is just... You're gonna laugh.

This is one of the... worst movies I've seen in a long time. Because every choice that they make, like you said, just seems like the most uninteresting, boring choice possible. And it feels very rote. It feels very much like, I've seen this movie a million times before, a million different ways, with a million different actors. How is this movie any different than I Am Legend?

I don't know. How is this movie different than so many other of these kinds of post-apocalyptic? How is this movie any different than The Last of Us? It isn't. None of these things are very different from one another anymore.

They all live in the same kind of slice of the world. I think the one post-apocalyptic thing that I've actually enjoyed in the last decade was the Fallout TV show. Because it has some fun to the apocalypse. It's, you know, It's kind of a lark that the world got destroyed. And like, oh, there's these vault dwellers and they're weird.

And like there's this dichotomy of things where the tropes are actually mineable in a funny way. I mean, even one of my favorite shows, a show that I kept saying over and over during our Waterworld episode, Westworld, it goes post-apocalyptic at the end of its show. And it's awful. Like post-apocalyptic stuff. I almost feel bad that post-apocalyptic stuff is something you like so much because Because for the most part, in the last 10 to 15 years, the post-apocalyptic stuff we've gotten has been not great.

A lot of it has been very rote, very just like buy the books, doing the same thing everybody else has done, not really trying that hard to be that interesting. And it's like post-apocalyptic, what about this is uninteresting? You can start with why society ended to begin with, and go from there. And like, that's interesting. And there's like so many directions and yet it's like, well, they have COVID.

I know the book was written in 2012. So it's not like they have COVID is what the book was getting at. But like you said, I live in a post COVID world now. So you think I'm going to watch this movie and see someone on a ventilator and my brain's not going to go there immediately movie. Give me a break.

Like, give me a break. It's that same thing of like in this world, I get that there are Mennonites, but Jacob and Lordy's character is supposedly like this is supposedly taking place in 2035, which means society has broken down for a handful of years. So you're telling me that in 2030, Jacob and Lordy's character had never seen Mad Max Fury Road? Come on. Yeah, I think there's still life left in the post-apocalyptic genre.

You mentioned Fallout. There are still video games people enjoy playing. I felt, again, the first seven seasons of The Walking Dead were excellent television. I felt the first three seasons of a pretty obscure show, Falling Skies, which was actually– I think Steven Spielberg was a producer. It was really good.

Both of those shows collapsed, and I can tell you why. But basically I think you can have life in the genre, but you must show– and, Chris, this is something that somebody like you who's much more– intimately familiar with the movie industry. You know more people who are in it and you've worked within it. It's something that puzzles me is that, let me just give an example here of something where I guess I'm a grumpy old man or I guess I'm overly literalistic because I'm a journalism professor and I'm always thinking, could this actually happen? My suspension of disbelief has fewer buttresses than most other people's.

So there's an entire sub-genre of post-apocalyptic called prepper fiction. It's very successful. I don't read them very often. I actually have a friend who's in that space and like has written one and we've had some conversations about about this. And I've been intrigued by it because in some way, prepper fiction is a revolt against mainstream post-apocalyptic fiction, which doesn't sweat any details whatsoever.

And let me just give you a very simple one. Fuel, gasoline, the gasoline that's in your car and the gasoline that's in trucks, diesel, and the gasoline that's in airplanes, which features pretty heavily in this movie, goes bad. And I'm not going to go into the details. People can just look it up. But I I'd never seen an airplane in a while in the post-apocalyptic movie.

So that was interesting. And I just thought, you know, in Mad Max, it's explained that they are refining new gasoline. So all these people driving around in cars, they actually have production of gasoline. They're refining it. But regular gasoline goes bad.

And so these movies from the 60s where there's been a little– Charlton Heston starts up a car that's 20 years old. I forgive them for doing that. But in 2026, gosh, you can't have an airplane flying around with– now, I know it's not– clear whether the collapse happened really quickly or gradually. And yeah, if you seal gas in a tank in a certain way, but like him just flying around every day, and then you're going to get a lot of issues. Again, just go look up, do a Google search on this.

But I felt insufficient attention was paid to these small details, including what are the reapers eating? The reapers are so busy burning cities down. Do they have time for hunting and gathering and growing crops? Maybe the prepper fiction can be accused of overly fixating on these details, and you'll get two-page descriptions of how to make a bullet. which is interesting, you know, for some people, that's fine. There's nothing wrong with that.

But then you have mainstream post-apocalyptic fiction to just ignore these completely. And I just felt they could have spent the lack of effort they spent on coming up with a plot. They also just had this lack of effort in just the small details that would have made the film stand out a little bit from the rest of the genre. And I and I don't understand why Ridley Scott, who is making these films now in his 80s, and you think he's making these films as like a testament, like, OK, this is Ridley Scott, especially to a new generation, because you're right. There's a lot of people who have not seen Ridley.

I mean, they've just seen the meme of Alien, right? Or they saw the first Gladiator. I think they saw the first Gladiator is what most people my age have seen that have not seen Alien or Blade Runner. It's Gladiator. That's I think if you were to say like, what is the Ridley Scott film you've seen?

It's Gladiator. I think you're right. Which, by the way, for me is a film that I do not resonate with at all. I find Gladiator to be a spectacle I have no interest in engaging with. other than it has Oliver Reed in it for like five minutes. And then he passed away because of course he did.

Well, let's put it this way. The sword and sandals movie, you go back in time and watch sword and sandals movie with Victor mature in the 1950s and 1960s was a reasonably popular genre, right? And the genre had exhausted itself, uh, And you got to give Ridley Scott and the whole crew there credit that they put new life for one movie into this exhausted genre. Right. Nobody has figured out Taylor Sheridan sort of put some new life into the Western through a TV show anyway.

And you could argue that Sicario and Sicario Davis Soldata were sorts of Western. I would say Taylor Sheridan is the closest example that we have for a revitalization of the Western in a Bigger way than most of these old school genres have been given. Cause like you said, gladiator is a one film entry into a genre. That was look at how many other films came out afterwards that were nowhere near as successful. Alexander Troy, like those all came out after gladiator and they were not as successful.

They just weren't. So what I'm saying though, is that he, he did have a history. I mean, the monster in space movie is, was in the fifties and sixties, a grade Z topic for a movie, right? You, you saw those movies on like the fifth movie on a drive in or something. And he does this incredibly high end, fantastic a list movie alien, which resonates to this day as a classic.

So he has, he had, I don't know, but he has it in him to say, okay, I'm going to take a genre. That's very familiar, perhaps overly familiar, and has a lot of tired tropes and motifs and things like that. And I'm going to reinvent it. But there was no attempt at visible on the screen or audible to do that. Again, I have to give credit and I'll just call out the big battle scene when Bangley which really is an odd name, by the way.

Just so strange. Josh Brolin. I mean, was that like his birth name? He was called or he liked to blow up things when he was a kid, you know, or something. I just I wouldn't give a funny name to somebody like that.

But anyway, Bangley has his, you know, last ditch defense against the Reapers there. Now, that is also interesting. A great example, because the scene is it's a good set piece action scene. Like I was going like, oh, yeah, this is really good action. You know, things are blowing up and Josh Brolin is defending himself against evil.

OK, great. It's the exact same sequence that was in the first season of the television adaptation of the video game Last of Us. I mean, not quite shot for shot, but Nick Offerman plays, and I think this is a problem because he plays a character where the main characters know about this character. Then there's a separate story of Nick Offerman as alone defending himself. I mean, he meets somebody and there's a whole other thing.

But in other words, not only were they taking cliches, but they were taking exact sequences and characters. from previous movies. Now, yes, it was based on a 2012 book, but somebody chose this book. And we hear from Hollywood all the time, well, we had to make changes in the adaptation for it to work. Well, one of the changes you might make is say, oh, yeah, it's 2026. This 2012 plot here is so cliche.

Let's make some changes. They could have made some changes. They always do, right? Yeah, well, they made the change. One of them I went and looked because obviously this film is called The Dog Stars.

So one might be remiss to think that the dog, which was in all the promotional material for the film, would be in the film for more than 10 minutes. But the dog is not. The dog is in the film for, I think, I think probably the dog is on screen for less than half an hour. But it seems way less than that. I don't know why.

It's just probably because so much of the early part of the movie is very much quick cuts. And it's not what the end of the movie is where it's kind of like following the characters doing stuff. It's a lot of just like it's like a montage. And so we don't really get to interact with the dog as much as we would have if the dog had been in the second half of the movie or the second two thirds of the movie. But the first third of this movie where the dog is present is a very different movie than the second half.

And third parts of this movie, like the two thirds of this movie are like it is effectively a post-apocalyptic romantic drama. And that's the part I can't figure out. Like so much of this movie is seemingly inconsistent in tone that I, for the life of me, can't figure out what was the intention of this film at all. At all. I mean, I can buy that this works better as a book.

I really can. And that it has Josh Brolin in it, who is in one of my favorite great films, but it also works better as a book. No Country for Old Men, whose climax barely works on screen, but it works really well in the book. I just, I have, I guess I have a hard time understanding what the point of this movie is. Because like you said, if you're going to just adapt this, fine.

But they clearly made some changes already to the source narrative. So why not change it more? Because this story, I mean, look, this story would have been passe in 2012. Like it's not 2026 and it's passe now. Like 2012, it was passe then, 14 years ago.

I would have said the same things about this movie in 2012. Right. Because those were still cliches in 2012. Yeah. dog. Let me ask you a question.

I've always thought that establishing that a character has a loving relationship with an animal is easier than establishing that with a person because with a person you have to have some explanation uh or some background i mean i get it you can have a character and like on the first day of the alien invasion their husband is killed and then the character is always angry at the aliens okay that that's okay you don't need to have 40 minutes of like their home life or something like that but with animals You can fill in more of a story when you see somebody with a cat on their lap and petting the cat that we don't need to be told the story of that. They love their cat. Right. Or they love their dog.

It could be done more quickly. But as you said. To then have. The. The love of his life, the second time, I mean, his wife was killed.

And of course, it was his pregnant wife. So like the drum bangs even more slowly there. But we don't know exactly when. Are we ever told when his wife died? Because, again, this is 2035, but it's not clear if like the disaster happened in 2012.

And it just is. Like overnight, it was some sort of. I assume it's supposed to be like a length of time more than just a year. Yeah. Yeah.

So his wife has been gone and unborn child has been gone a long time, which meant that he met the dog was obviously dogs. You know, we hope they live 20, 25 years, but like more likely it was a recent dog. Well, he shows the wife with the dog at one point. Yeah. So that's right.

Is it like 10 years maybe? Let's call it 10 years, 12 at the most. Yeah. I mean that just– I guess you needed to have like a footnote. This is where a book is more helpful with that sort of thing.

But it just– the dog bothered me because it just felt like so– So so waving a flag in our face of like, we are going to pull your heartstrings now. Just get ready. Get ready. Get ready. And here it is.

Your heartstrings are pulled. And the dog dies. And now for the rest of the film. I'm thinking about the dog and like what. And then, of course, the film is called The Dog Stars.

So I'm thinking, oh, are they really going to have some sort of scene where he's looking up at the sky and he sees the dog stars and it gives him hope? I like I had written the entire plot. After the first 10 minutes, I swear I could have. I mean, maybe the studio would have accused me of, you know, how those things they sometimes print those scripts in like light blue or different colors so they can see if anybody leaks a script. Right.

The leaking of this script would not have hurt this movie in any way. Well, and that's I guess I just to your point from before and like to go to the Ridley Scott of it all. What about this film and this story drew Ridley Scott to it? This just seems like, and again, I'm not going to say it seems beneath Ridley Scott, but I guess that's the way I would put it. It's just like, I can't for the life of me understand why Ridley Scott is the one directing this film.

And this film was also being touted as like, this film's being filmed in IMAX. For the five people that saw this movie, did you go see it in IMAX? The other three people that saw it other than me and you. And that's the crazy thing. This movie was a $ 70 to $ 110 million budget.

First off, why? And then secondly, it only made $ 38 million. Third question, how did it make $ 38 million? Were they giving away tickets that they pre-bought? Who went and saw this in theaters?

I did not hear a single person talking about this film until you mentioned it to me. But $ 38 million is not an insignificant amount of money in this day and age. It came out around the same time as Spider-Man. Hey, if Back Rooms had made $ 38 million, but of course it made, what, four times that? It made like $ 200 million.

It made twice the budget of this film. Yeah, the catering budget of this film. I want to know who went and saw this film. Why was this film filmed in Italy when it's set in Colorado? Yeah, that was things that bothered me.

I actually did not know that until after I watched the film. And then I said, OK, I'm going to look up some of the background details. And I didn't get a Colorado vibe. No. You know how sometimes those spaghetti westerns, the ones that were filmed in Italy...

You can see, yeah, this is a dusty Western town, and they did a pretty good job of it, right? But of course, all the extras and all the non-player characters are obviously Italian, so maybe that's in the original Westerns. But Josh Brolin. So there's this great story, and anybody can go out there and read about it. And I think– I didn't watch the actual interview, but I just read a transcript where Josh Brolin, I want to say that I've made some jokes in the past about like, yeah, I got to send Steven Spielberg a text and make some suggestions or something.

But I physically have met Josh Brolin when I was very, very young. I was living in Los Angeles and some friends. had dinner with Josh Brolin, and I was there sitting across from Josh Brolin. And this is a very young Josh Brolin. I think he and I are pretty close to the same age. And he's obviously he came from an acting family, but he had an interesting life.

It wasn't as, you know, as nipo as you might imagine uh there i think he earned it and he is a terrific actor well he was a very very polite guy and he came off as one of those people who just is cordial and i've i've heard about that him on the set you know i've never heard he's trouble honest nobody's ever said that josh roland was real trouble on the set he's just really polite i've only heard him give one interview he gave an interview about he was in a movie called jonah hexx. I know exactly what you're talking about. Yeah, and he was answering the question, have you ever been on a movie, doing a movie, and realizing, oh my gosh, this is going to be a disaster? And he gave Jonah Hex as the example.

Well, anyway, the story is that not on the fourth day or the 50th day, but on the very first day of shooting The Dog Stars– Josh Brolin, this pretty cordial guy, his consummate professional, you know, it's his job to act. He shows up, he acts, he goes home, gets so mad that he walks off the set and says, I cannot work with Ridley Scott anymore. And the agent calls, the studio calls everybody. And Ridley says, this is the way I work. I know how the way I work.

And again, you can just go online and find this story. But I found it so interesting that, And he didn't elaborate the exact details. But I thought, gosh, Josh Brolin and Ridley Scott have been in the business a long time. Something was going on there. And I have to think maybe Josh Brolin realized he was being asked to do stuff that he's always being asked to do.

And he thought he knew how to do it, which he does, and maybe didn't need minute direction to To be Josh Brolin. I don't know what the story is there, but this film was so under-publicized that not even Trouble on the Set got publicized. And you and I have talked about Trouble on the Set and how that seems to be a big story. This was such a little story, it didn't even get. Publicity.

And you'd think that story would have gotten a lot of publicity, but the movie was so ignored, it didn't. I was shocked to hear that story about Josh Brolin because, like yourself, I have nothing but assumptions that he is just– again, like you said, there is this– you could make this case like, oh, he's a nepo baby from long before the term was being thrown– bandied about for some like Dakota Johnson. But I don't think he's– I mean, he's such a great actor. I think you can– Your talent can outweigh your nepotism, I think is what it is. Look, if Michael Jordan's son, Michael Jordan Jr., had been a good basketball player, his talent would have been undeniable.

If LeBron James Jr. 's son, Bronny Jr., Had it been a good basketball player, and maybe he still will be, his talent would have been undeniable and there would have been nothing. Even if he was just good, not great, it would still be hard to drag him. And that's the thing with Josh Brolin. Josh Brolin is a great actor, so you can't drag him for being the son of James Brolin.

You could just say he's James Brolin's son, who also happens to be an actor. I love Josh Brolin. I think the worst thing about this movie is that it kind of wastes the time of all the actors. Because Josh Brolin is a great actor. Guy Pearce is a great actor.

Jacob Elordi is a great actor. Margaret Qualley, also a great actress. They're all great. In everything I've seen. them in other than this, they're great. They're in some of my favorite movies.

Guy Pearce specifically. He's in Prometheus and Alien Covenant. I do not... And again, to speak to the Ridley Scott of it all, both of those films are directed by Ridley Scott. Who...

Again, I... I don't understand Ridley Scott in 2026, I guess, because he made Gladiator 2, a film that had been bandied about, to go back to that term again, for however long, 20 years. It was however long from the day Gladiator 1 came out, they had been talking about Gladiator 2. It's kind of what it feels like. And then it gets made, and it's just one of the most bizarre films I've ever seen.

To speak to the bad publicity around this film, Paul Mezcal, who was supposed to be in this film, ended up not being in this film because Ridley Scott dragged him and then claimed it had nothing to do with the fact that he didn't like the acting stylings of Paul Mezcal. But now it's come out recently, in the last couple months, that that is in fact the thing that Ridley Scott's like, I don't like his acting in Gladiator 2. That's why Gladiator 2 was unsuccessful, was his acting. And he was supposed to be in this movie. So I can't imagine wanting to work with Ridley Scott anymore after he says those kinds of things.

And I'm sure he was saying those things on the set of Gladiator 2. And I'm sure he was saying them on the set of this movie when that was going on as well. Like, it just... All of a sudden, to me, Ridley Scott seems like a kind of director out of time. It's almost like Martin Scorsese, where I'm like, I'm not saying all your best movies are behind you, but they might be.

And that's okay. There's nothing wrong with that. I don't see a problem with it. You had a time where you were making all these great films, but that time is not... infinite. It's finite.

And the fact that you had any of it at all, I think is the thing that you should rest on in terms of laurels, because like this movie, I don't even, I don't understand what the point of making this movie was when all the, all the film does is just retread old tropes. Some of which Ridley Scott was part of treading when they were being retread to begin with. I just can't for the life of me, understand what, drew people into this story. Cause that's the thing. Like these actors worked on this film for a whole host of reasons.

And if I don't want to be cynical and assume it was purely monetary, there must've been something about this script that drew them to this film. And I can't even find that because the characters are so unbelievably flat that they are not, they don't jump off the screen. I hope they jumped off the page, but I don't care about the story enough to go find out. I, I remember. Another scene where, where they're in the Grand Junction, right?

And they discover, oh gosh, you know, Grand Junction turns out to be evil people. They turned out to be cannibals. There's this character, Darlene, who's the head of the community. This is a block I have, again, from having read a thousand post-apocalyptics. And I felt the television series The Last of Us did committed these two sins as well.

And you'd think like, gosh, can anybody learn from what didn't work in something that was out like four or five years, three years ago? The head of the community is somebody that in a post-apocalyptic world, we can completely understand how there might be people who just say, great, this is my opportunity. I've always been evil, but I've never, but there used to be like police and security cameras and I couldn't get away with evil as much as I can now. And I'm just going to be evil. Okay.

And there's in a post-apocalyptic world, there might be people who say, look, we have to rebuild civilization and stick together and be good. But it does seem like one thing is that they would be a premium on competence because like the line between life and death is so thin. It's like going back 35,000 years to Paleolithic, our ancestors hunting and gathering. I don't think you can be an incompetent hunter and gatherer and have your gene pool survive. Right.

Right. You can't say, well, I'm really a pretty bad mastodon hunter. I'm just going to go after this mastodon and I'm going to throw all the rules out and let's see what happens. Right. Well, good work.

Good luck. I don't think you will be passing on your genes to somebody else. And I felt with this Grand Junction community, it felt so badly different. Constructed and Darlene, good actress. I'm blanking right now.

Allison Janney. Yeah, good. Very good. I like her. She's a good actress.

Oh, yeah. She was completely unconvincing as the ruthless dictator. of a post-apocalyptic community to me. And again, maybe, I don't know if we've been given a little bit more backstory and there's something there. And then the second part, which always gets me, and they did this again in The Last of Us, which is, okay, I have captured Jason Bourne. All right.

I mean, forget that Higg is not Jason Bourne. But let's just say I've got Jason Bourne under custody. So, of course, I ask my minions to walk along within punching chopping distance of him at all times with my guns held loosely. And that's how I stopped Jason Bourne from escaping. Right.

Yeah. Listen. Yeah, they were a post-apocalyptic evil community with nefarious this and that, but they were so freaking bad at it that the implausibility was not cannibalism. The implausibility was like, how did they survive this far? I'm so glad you brought up the Grand Junction part of this movie, the five-minute foray into a more interesting, completely, tonally bizarre movie.

So the entire premise of this movie, Once the Dog Dies, And again, no spoilers there, because if you watch this movie and you sit in this movie for more than five minutes, you know that if there's a dog introduced, the dog's got to die, because this movie is just batting 100% on all tropes. All of a sudden, this movie goes to Grand Junction, where our character, Hig, has been trying to get to the entire film. He's taken the side quest to meet Margaret Qualley and Guy Pearce. And so now he's gone to Grand Junction. And like you mentioned, we meet Alice and Janney.

And it's clearly, it's a messed up community already. It's already completely strange and weird and like anachronistic in and of itself. And then Allison Janney says, OK, Margaret Qualley, you're going to marry someone here. And that's that's just the way it is. And it's like, OK, so that's weird.

Again, it's very Fallout reminds me of Fallout, the TV show, which obviously this came before that. So whatever. I mean, I'm not saying like this is inspired by that. I'm just saying that that's what it reminded me of. And then, like you mentioned, all of a sudden, Jacob Elordi just starts lighting people on fire.

And then they run into a room where these people are totally cannibals. And it's like, wait, who cares? What does any of this matter if this is then all of a sudden just going to be dealt with in the most, like, well, Chekhov's grenades, I guess. Josh Brolin hands Jacob Elordi some grenades at the beginning of the movie and goes, hey, make sure you're low enough when you're flying to throw them. And then we see At the end of the movie, he blows up Grand Junction, I guess, because these people were cannibals and they deserve to die.

And I'm not saying they don't, but it's just weird. This movie takes a weird foray into... It's like dumb Cormac McCarthy. I know what this is trying to be in 2012. The film The Road came out in 2009, which was pretty successful.

Cormac McCarthy's a great author. this is no Cormac McCarthy. Like this is really like dumbed down Cormac McCarthy. Like it's trying to be the road, I guess. But the, I mean, again, like that has that, that film is great. That book is great.

It actually has something to say. This movie never says anything. I'm not, I am struggling for a purpose and point when I watched this film and then to have the film just end on. And then we all live happily ever after the end, like, what? Like it's to go from grand junction to a movie, just kind of ending in the span of about 20 minutes is so just like whiplash jarring.

I, I wonder if the people who made this movie actually sat with the film after making it and watched it and said, Oh, this is, this is actually what we want to put out. Okay. Because by the end of the film, as the credits rolled, I was like, I can't believe what I just watched. Like, it's just, The entire purpose of the movie is summed up in 10 minutes. And it's so uninteresting and just unengaging to then have the movie end, but 10 minutes later, it's like, well, what was even the point?

It's one of the most shocking summer blockbusters, quote unquote, I've ever seen. Yeah, the grenade, I guess, again, this is me being grumpy, but like, do you really... Can you really carry grenades around when you're captured and they didn't search them for anything in particular and no guards are attentive? There's always been a little element in all fantasy science fiction and speculative fiction, but it's just as much true in any action thriller where the hero is enhanced by the shocking shoddiness and incompetence of the henchmen of the villain. Right.

Yeah. And I just, yeah. And I was sitting to myself now, I, as I understand it, Ridley Scott is very much a shoot everything. And then the film comes in editing type of director, as opposed to, you know, famously Alfred Hitchcock had like the entire movie in his head and just shot what he was in his head and, So there's different kinds of directors. But that doesn't excuse that what you shoot in the first place just is so riven by– there's nothing there.

I don't think anything was left on the editing floor or could have been put in the movie that would have changed any of these things. So you wonder, I mean, was this– Was this– I mean somebody had to spend a certain amount of money by the end of the fiscal year or something like that. The motivations– I'm sure you've seen Tootsie, which maybe we should review sometime. Dustin Hoffman has that great scene where he's this method actor and he's playing a tomato in a commercial. This is how far his career has gone down.

And, no, it's remembered that one of his problems on set is he needs motivation. You're a tomato. Why do you need a motivation to be a tomato? But you need some motivation as an actor. Like, why am I here besides the paycheck?

What am I doing here? And I can imagine, oh, Ridley Scott. I get to direct a film with Ridley Scott. They've got a budget. It was based on a bestselling book.

I get to travel to Italy, apparently. Yeah. It's beautiful where they are. I mean, maybe it's like that whole Michael Caine thing where it's like, I just go where the, I go where the film takes me. And I often take films that are in the Bahamas or somewhere where it's like nice to be when I'm not on set.

I don't know. Is that a bad reason to take a film? I guess I wonder what $ 110 million buys you in 2026. And if it looks like this, I feel like they overspent. Yeah, so many sequences in this film.

I was thinking about this, that it could be, they could have been shot by student filmmakers. And you would have noticed that, okay, they have fewer explosions and things like that. But a lot of the sequences in this film didn't feel like they were part of a big budget movie. They just felt like somebody put a camera and a guy looked up in the sky wistfully and longingly. Okay.

Yeah. Yeah. With Waterworld, as we talked about in the previous episode, we talked about Waterworld. At least all the money that was spent was up there on the screen. I couldn't have remade this in my bathtub, right?

It was up there. Well, and that is the thing about this movie that I think is hard for me to understand. If we take a step back, like you said, and look at it as just purely a It's a Ridley Scott film, and that's why the actors got involved. Because, hey, you know, Jacob Elordi always wanted to work with Ridley Scott. And, you know, Josh Brolin always wanted to work with Ridley Scott or whatever.

I mean, Guy Pearce has already worked with Ridley Scott. So Guy Pearce has an experience of working with Ridley Scott. I just, I guess maybe they, you know, maybe they were just trying to spend some money. Maybe Scott Free was looking to spend some money before the end of the year. 20th Century Studios was like, We got like $ 100 million here burning a hole in our pocket.

Wouldn't you love to be the guy that they're just like, make a move? We got all these books. You want to option this book? I don't know. That's the other thing.

I went and looked at the screenwriter, Mark L. Smith, as a pretty solid track record of things that he's written. He wrote The Revenant, which I know a lot of people liked. He wrote Twisters, which was pretty successful when it came out two years ago. He is born in Colorado, so he probably feels some connection to the story.

Because again, this is a Colorado story. I think the thing that's surprising is, you know, everybody involved at every level seems competent. And I don't understand where the lack of competency, like where the competency got lost, I guess, in the equation. Because everybody at most levels that I can tell in terms of like, outward-facing, higher-level people are good at what they do. And yet, this is the movie we got?

Just to speak to all the tropes and everything else, but it is a unfocused mess of a movie because the way the film ends is very disjointed and strange although josh brolin just managed to somehow survive this attack on their compounded now they live with the mennonites and and that's it it's like and that's just it it just ends like it's not even it's not one of these movies that like overstays its welcome it's not one of these movies that's like you know three hours long and i can see where the budget was and why people didn't even why people didn't kind of interact with it the way the director wanted is because it's a long film and people don't go see long films. It's like less than two hours.

It's not even a two hour long movie, but it just, it kind of just meanders. And one of the reviews I read was like, it's a low energy, low stakes blockbuster. And it's like, yeah, I guess. So what are we saying that it's, it's like two steps above a Hallmark movie, I guess. Yeah.

I mean, you could, I guess, I guess I've never seen a movie like that, but maybe there is a need for a movie that has similar themes to a Hallmark movie, but are a little higher stakes instead of him, you know, being a big city boy come to the small city. He's, you know, it's the folks apocalypse and he's getting stranded on his airplane in the middle of nowhere. And he finds this farm with a father and daughter and there's high stakes romance. Like, Maybe that's what this is. I don't know.

Like, I guess maybe for me, this seems like a lot of these like romantic novels that have come out in the last like 10 to 15 years where they're kind of like not tawdry, but you know what I mean? Like, I'm not saying it's that kind of book, but there's so much of this like male gazing on the Margaret Qualley character from Jacob Elordi that it's just like, is this meant to be one of these like romantic films too. Because if it had been that, okay, I kind of get it. But it doesn't even make a decision to be that either. It kind of just chooses to do nothing.

And every time you think it's getting going with something other than just the most obvious of choices, it decides to just pivot away and go back towards the obvious. It's like, wait a second here. Even when given the opportunity to do something different, we're not interested in doing it for very long. The most interesting parts of this movie, they literally give you a little, a hint of like the LaCroix, like they just, they wave it over you and then it's gone. Yeah.

You said the word romantic and let's talk about the ending here a moment. So we spent a lot of my life in Pennsylvania where there were very large Amish communities and you tended to interact with them because they often had came to farmers markets and you would buy furniture, buy food from them. Here in West Texas, we have driving distance, a very large Mennonite community. And I've known some people from that community and you can go to Costco and you see them every weekend coming to buy stuff with their families. I felt a little uncomfortable here that the Mennonites were turned into what happens sometimes in like earnest movies where you have Native Americans, indigenous peoples who are. wise and wonderful and aren't tainted by civilization and it's so it's not it's not racism it's sort of a reverse racism in a way of like they're they're somehow simpler and we should listen to them now i happen to hear mennonites come to shop at costco so the idea that mennonites are like people who are living in the 14th century and have like are completely independent is just false.

Now, it is true. And actually, that's funny. There's a post-apocalyptic novel, which I don't think will ever get made into a book. I think it's called When the English Fell, and it's actually a story set in northeastern United States about a collapse through the eyes of Amish people of like what's happening on this civilization over here. So I just I thought I did feel a little uncomfortable.

And I mean, they're there. He's found a new love who's given him hope again. And he looks up at the stars and, you know, the dog stars and he names it after his dog. And that's the kind of stuff which I don't know, maybe maybe in a 70s movie, it would have worked. But again, gosh, it's 2020.

2026 or or 2012. And those things don't feel romantic to me. They just feel forced and uncomfortable. It goes back to this idea of like, does every film need a romantic plot or subplot? And I thought that we as a Hollywood kind of moving entity had decided that we didn't need that anymore.

It wasn't required to have a romantic interest for the leads in our films. And yeah, you know, Margaret Qualley and Jacob Elordi are great opposite one another, obviously. But it doesn't serve any purpose, and it feels so obvious and just kind of played out that because neither one of them are really given much characterization, all we know is, well, they're in love because he ran into her family's farm, and that's it. Well, obviously. And wouldn't you want to be with someone who looked as good as him?

It's just. Very lazy. And it's lazy in a way that I don't expect from films anymore, because with everything in the world now, with the amount of things that there are to watch in the world, you would think that we would want to be elevating ourselves past the basic tropes, because the basic tropes just for most people don't cut it anymore. I mean, even for most just the person who watches on average, you know, one or two things a week, I think that they would watch this movie and go, man, I've seen this like a million times before. And that's the thing about this movie.

It's like, it's, it almost is skating by on the trope so much that we don't get any characterization of any of these characters at all. Like I couldn't tell you what Guy Pearce's character is other than he's kind of like Josh Brolin. What is Josh Brolin's character? Well, like you said, he's kind of just Josh Brolin. He's playing this character we've seen, several other times before, but we kind of just internalize that that's just kind of Josh Brolin on top of everything else.

Margaret Qualley and Jacob Elordi aren't given much characterization either. Nobody in this film is given any characterization. other than the bare minimum, which we ourselves understand just based on the tropes that these characters are inhabiting as it is. Like, Margaret Qualley's character is not written any differently than any of these kinds of characters are ever written in any of the most obvious, tropey, post-apocalyptic movies I've ever seen. Would you agree? Like all these characters in the movie are the most obvious, basic, most lazy, trite, played out versions of the characters.

They are. And it's just like I don't even understand how you can make a movie like this in 2026. Yeah, I was thinking about this because you mentioned Fallout and I have not. played the game sustainably, but like I've, I've played the game a little bit because I wanted to talk to students. And then I watched what's had been shown so far, the, the TV series. And I've had some good discussions with students.

And these are the kinds of discussions where they tell me stuff. And I, sort of try to build a theory around it. And so they were telling me in, in fallout about vault number 17 and vault number 46 and things like that. And I said, so each vault has its own trope, right? Kind of.

Yeah. Yeah. So like, I mean, there's a, and I remember a TV series of the past. It's like what the, what the quantum leap series where they're They're going to an alternative Earth, and each alternative Earth is slightly different or a lot different than us, than our timeline. And then there was this hilariously bad, but it was like a great idea, this Harlan Ellison Canadian TV series from the 70s called The Star Lost, where there was this generation ship.

And I think it had 100 people. communities of modules where, I mean, and of course, as all generationships, it had broken down and all of these communities developed independently. And yes, there was indeed like an Amish one and there was a medieval one and whatever. So the point is that if you're going to put all of your eggs in one type of situation, where you don't have the ability to say, okay, well, you know, that we spent 20 minutes on Vault 19. Let's go over and explore Vault 56, right? That you really have the pressure on to find something new and original.

And I find it interesting that Like, if you went to a studio today and said, I've got an idea. It's going to be a Western. It's going to be set in the Old West. And there's a sheriff. And he has to protect the town against these three bad guys dressed in black suits and black hats who are trying to rob the bank.

Like, you're pitching this to Warner Brothers. And I would assume some producer would go like, And what else happens? No, that's it. That's the entire plot. And I don't think that would get greenlit, right?

I think you'd get laughed out of the room. Yeah. But... Unfortunately... I mean, again, I love post-apocalyptic.

It's my joy genre. I will watch anything else. I'm happy watching things. I'm doing analysis with you or with others together. But post-apocalyptic is my first love in terms of literary genre.

And I'm worried that maybe we are completely spent on it. And it's interesting to me that the place where the creativity is going on is this ultra-specific world of prepper fiction, which has not really penetrated big Hollywood moviemaking, although it's pretty popular as a literary genre. So are we– what is that line from Edward G. Robinson? Is this the last days of Rico?

Are we– Are we spent out? Are we exhausting the post-apocalyptic genre? What was interesting to me when I looked up This to find out, OK, maybe young people like this movie. Well, none of my students had heard of it, seen it, wanted to go see it. OK.

And then I looked up online and there were people who were saying this. I guess this is sort of my wrap up note and sort of a takeaway that I want to I bring up several times with those other movies. You see people sometimes defending a movie online that is well critiqued. And I saw people saying, you know, I don't understand the criticism. I really enjoyed this movie.

It was a wonderful movie. OK, that's fine. And yes, but. The movie did so badly. First, there must have been only a few of you.

Second, you didn't love the movie enough to go back more than once. And third, you didn't evangelize the movie to your friends. In another episode, we have talked about in the time travel that we do these shows, Jaws, and how Jaws was one of those movies that sort of invented the summer blockbuster and It was also I remember grabbing friends and saying, let's go see this again. I want to see this again. I want to see this again.

I want to see this again. And, yep, this is what Dog Stars was a movie that I guess some people did like it. And I have no problem with that. But like you didn't like it enough to make it a successful movie in any way. Well, and I'm with you on that.

There is a lot of value in word of mouth still. Look at Backrooms and Obsession. I mean, those movies, it's not that they didn't have big advertising campaigns, but they didn't have advertising campaigns where everyone was beating down the door about Obsession and Backrooms. Those movies were successful based on pre-existing audiences, which this movie had, by the way, because it was a rather successful book, but also like you said, word of mouth and people telling other people to go watch it that had no interest engaging with it. And I didn't hear anything about this movie at all.

I heard more obsession and back rooms and other things in the end of Oak street, even a film that I was evangelizing for a while after it came out, which again, could be somewhat post-apocalyptic in its own right. I mean, it's not really, but again, it's more than this movie is. I think at least it does more than this movie is ever even hoping to be. But I think like you just said, I mean, for me, it's just, who was this movie for? I'm not sure.

Who did this movie engage with in a positive way? I'm not sure. Who is this movie going to be for in the long run? Jacob Elordi completionist, Margaret Qualley completionist. Like, I don't, I don't know because nothing that I saw in this movie would lead me to believe that this movie is going to be remembered at all.

I think it's, you know, so many of these kinds of movies come out every year where they're a big budget film that gets forgotten. And I just sit and wonder to myself, like, this was $ 110 million. It's like the GDP of a small country. And here we are with like, A movie that barely made any money, that nobody went and saw, and it's going to be what now? It's going to sit on VOD? and Blu-ray until the cows come home?

Until 20, 30 years from now, somebody puts it out on physical media claiming that this is a long-lost Josh Brolin, Jacob Elordi film while the rest of us roll our eyes because we saw it when it came out and know that that's not the case? I don't know. I try not to be cynical about stuff like this, but there are some of these things where I'm just like, $ 110 million is a lot of money. And I've seen several of these films this year now where I'm like, who put this much money into this movie thinking it was going to be successful enough to make it back? It's like The Bride, which has become my punching bag this year.

But I saw that movie in theaters, and I can't for the life of me understand why anyone who was involved in the making of that movie thought they were going to make that much money back to sink that much money into it. And I say the same thing about this movie. Just look at it as a purely transactional engagement. They spent so much money on a movie that nobody advocated for after it came out. So literary success does not translate into film success.

We already know that. But I think as time goes on, they really have to be discerning as filmmakers as to what they are adapting into films. Because making a fourth of your budget back ain't great. or even a third, or however. They're not making enough back to justify any of this. And I appreciate actors are getting paid.

I appreciate all these people are getting paid and making money. But the product still has to have some value on the other end of it. And I, for one, cannot see the value of this movie, because I don't think it justifies its own value to begin with. You and Mike White did a great episode on the end of Oak Street. I just want to say, oh, thank you.

Yeah. Yeah. The only thing I would add is there's a term that I've invented, which I think is sort of cute. And I want to get it out there is I call it postal code apocalyptic when only a very small. It's pretty good region of space. has the apocalypse and like the rest of the world is okay.

I'm not sure that what was clear. Maybe, and you know what, to, to end this episode, maybe that is where this goes as post-apocalyptic is super niche specific things, as opposed to broadly the world has ended because as we know now living in the world we live in now, like you could make a case that we're living in dystopian times now. And I think a lot of people would make that case and they might not be incorrect in making it, And this looks nothing like what the movie said it would. So how can the movies accurately predict what the apocalypse apocalypse is going to look like? I think a lot of us are just maybe jaded by all of these things, like you said, looking the same, feeling the same, but never, ever having anything to say about any of it other than just like using it as is very cheap. and convenient set dressing for uninteresting stories that have no stakes.

Like for all of its faults, fallout is an interesting show only because it's like the apocalypse is, can be, can be fun for some people. And like, there will be people that take advantage of it. Why not tell that story? Like, as opposed to like the story of people looking to survive, like not that it's not interesting, but like that story kind of only has, it doesn't have very much legs. So yeah, I yeah, when you wanted to watch this, I was interested to see what it was, because like you said at the end here, I didn't hear a single person talking about this movie.

And we may be one of the few groups of podcast networks that ever cover this movie in terms of it having just come out. And that's understandable because it is where the crawdads sing. But post-apocalyptic. I don't know. It's like one of those kinds of things.

There were books that came out that were popular and they've been turned into movies in the last 10 to 15 years. This is one of them. That didn't translate. There's a lot of things that didn't translate. Literary success does not translate to film success.

That Thursday Murder Club book series that came out. That movie, they're not making any more of those on Netflix, I don't think, but that book series is wildly successful. It goes to show you how niche film is in and of itself when literature can be still so successful, and the films based on the literature are not as successful. It still shows that there is a wide. Ocean between film goers and movie goers.

So just be careful what you adapt folks, because it's even the most successful books can be turned into the most, uh, milk toast movies looking at you dog stars. The other part that I remember from the 1970s was that there was pretty regularly post-apocalyptic or, you know, science fiction TV movies, uh, And they were shot with a pretty low budget. And if anybody wants to go back and look at, for example, Steven Spielberg's knockout debut, Duel, which was a TV movie. And there were other ones. I remember there was a movie Heat Wave and there was a movie Gargoyles.

And they were fun movies shot at really low budgets, but they did a good job. And I think this is this continuing problem of like, why is it Hollywood can only make a statement with $ 110 million? So we just need more. This should have been a $ 3 million film. It could have been a $ 3 million film.

There's nothing in this film that required going to Italy or some excessive– I guess it was a tax remuneration or some Italian company was involved or something. I don't know. But the point is that it's sad that the only way to tell a story is to tell it spending this massive amount of money. And you've shown examples on this Back Rooms. We keep going back to Back Rooms.

You don't have to have a gigantic budget to tell a story lots of people want to watch. No. And it's really– It's been the case for a while, and it's, I guess, only assumed that the horror genre can be the one to do that. But that's not the case. I mean, post-apocalyptic, you could do that.

You could do that with all kinds of things. It's just, I feel like we don't necessarily anymore look for reasons to do things cheap. We just find reasons to save money when we're doing things expensively. And it's like, well... You know, you can make a lot more money if you don't spend a lot of money to begin with.

Like, your ceiling is a lot higher when the floor has not been, like, just, like, beaten into the ground. And, like, these movies, man, like, I forget what it is. Like, Avengers Doomsday has to make, like, a billion dollars to break even or something. Like, good God. Come on.

What? No. Like, that's kind of an unacceptable thing now that we're at. And, like, the fact that even these, like, To your point, what would have been a smaller budget movie 40 years ago? Even now, it's like, well, even the small post-apocalyptic movie is $ 100 million, so it's got to make its money back.

Are we just getting to the point now where the only movies anyone can make are movies that are financially successful and are cheap? Because otherwise, we can't make a $ 500 million movie expecting to make $ 600 million. Right. Because then no $ 500 million movie will ever be made. Because all $ 500 million movies will not make their money back.

That's just not how this works. And here's yet again another example of a movie being way too expensive, not making enough money, and then everybody else who wasn't involved in the making of the movie going, well, see, these kinds of movies don't make any money. It's like, it shouldn't have been expected to make $ 150 million. It should have been expected to make maybe $ 300 million. I don't know, $ 38 million.

And on a budget of $ 5 million, that's a pretty good return. On a budget of $ 120 million, that's a pretty terrible loss. So you had asked for a while to watch a movie that neither one of us really resonated with, and I think we got it. But I think for me, it's always interesting to watch a film like this because, like you've already said, films that are not successful... The reasons they're not successful are as legion as why films are successful.

And those are interesting conversations to be had on both sides of the coin. Yes, it's unfortunate this film's not good, but you know how many movies come out that aren't good? Like, a lot. Like, more than are good or great. So, that's kind of how the way these things are.

So.... If you want to find Dr. Perlmutter and I talking about films that are good, for the most part, head on over to weirdingwaymedia.com, where this show and the show that Dr. Perlmutter and I do once a week together on the feed for this show, Required Viewing, is. You can find all of those and more at weirdingwaymedia.com.

Like, rate, and review this show on iTunes, then Spotify, in that order. That helps us out the most. Those are the two places where podcasting is happening in a fashion that can be helpful to us. If you want to head on over to Patreon to help me out financially, patreon.com slash culturecast is where you can do that. It helps out the show, helps us keep the lights on, even though the lights are going to stay on anyways.

It helps us maybe subsidize the cost. Other than that, Dr. Bromutter, thank you so much for picking this film. I wish it was better, but it isn't, but it was a good conversation. And as always, we'll catch you on the next episode.

Download the transcript file

Similar episodes across the network

Matched by shared keywords.

Transcript

Loading the transcript…