About this episode
Dr. David D. Perlmutter and Mark Stachiw join Chris Stachiw, the Doctor of Podcasting, to talk Michael Crichton, Richard Donner, time travel, medieval warfare, and so much more.
———
The Kulturecast is a film and culture podcast from Weirding Way Media, hosted by Chris Stachiw, the Doctor of Podcasting, alongside a rotating table of guest co-hosts. Each week digs into where film and culture meet — and how each one bends the other. Now home to sub-feeds including Required Viewing: A 360° Film Study with Dr. David D. Perlmutter.
New episodes weekly.
Subscribe on Apple Podcasts → https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-kulturecast/id931361376
Spotify → https://open.spotify.com/show/5wjxip9XVYapYuY12yEaGY.
Back the show: https://www.patreon.com/cw/kulturecast
Transcript
Automatically generated, so expect the odd misheard name.
We're in Wayne Media. Let's be careful. Who's going in first? Five young archaeologists have made a remarkable discovery. Help me.
From the best-selling thriller by Michael Crichton. Your father wrote that? But he wrote it 600 years ago. What? I just want to know where my dad is.
Your father is in the 14th century. We need you to help us get him back. A journey back in time. DNA streams are locked in. What about weapons?
Nothing modern goes back. So how do we do it? We're getting a chance of a lifetime. Think of it as the ultimate fail trip. Everybody take cover now!
From Paramount Pictures... There's no escape. and director Richard Donner... We've got 650 years of knowledge on these guys. If we put our heads together, we should get out of here in 20 minutes. a dangerous rescue. The ultimate battle...
Come on! For survival. Let's go! Get up! Paul Walker....
Timeline. Hello, everyone, and welcome to the CultureCast. I'm your host, Chris Stashew, and I'm joined by my good friends all the way from, once again, from West Texas, but maybe, in fact, he may be coming to us from France. Your friend and mine, Dr. David D.
Perlmutter. Hi, Chris. Yes, I am in an undisclosed timeline. And also joining us, because it's one of his favorite films. I'm just kidding.
It is not one of his favorite films. But we did have the pleasure of seeing this film together back in 2003 in theaters. Fan of Michael Crichton films, my father, Mark Stashew. Howdy. And yeah, if you're clicking on this episode because you didn't read the title of the episode, I apologize in advance for what you're about to hear us talk about for the next hour.
But on this episode of The Culture Cast, we are going to be talking about yet another adaptation of yet another Michael Crichton book. This time, maybe it's not nearly as good of an adaptation. It might not be even that good of a book, possibly. We'll talk about that as well. We're going to be talking about 2003's adaptation of Timeline.
So the film is directed by Richard Donner of, well, a lot of things. We'll talk about Richard Donner's name comes with a lot of pedigree. It stars Paul Walker. That's right. A Michael Crichton film with Paul Walker.
Who'd have thunk that? It also stars Francis O'Connor, Gerard Butler, and one of my favorite comedians, Billy Connolly, the film does follow the plot of the book Timeline by Michael Crichton, where somehow a big tech company has figured out a way to fax people into the past, into a specific time in the past. It's a wormhole, not a time machine. They'll have you know that multiple times, though there is, I will point this out to open this episode, there is no scene of a character taking a piece of paper and saying, what is the shortest distance between two lines? And then taking the piece of paper and folding it in on itself and to show a wormhole.
I was disappointed that we didn't get that scene because in every other movie ever with a wormhole in it, that is the scene that we get. So, uh, Mark, I'm going to kick it to you first. What, uh, thoughts on the book, thoughts on the movie. And, um, I just thoughts in general on, uh, what is possibly considered the best Michael Crichton adaptation ever timeline. You know, um, I, I read, restarted list, uh, rereading the book and, uh, This movie, so looking at the movie just in general, it seems a bit disjointed.
Things are rushed over matters which I think are really important. For example, the book makes a lot of hay around the fact that when you go through the machine more than once, it starts having transcription errors. It's an important part of the book. it's an important part of the plot of the book because there is a whole, let's call it, police element that seems to be just basically glossed over in the movie about trying to figure out why this guy died in the early scenes of the movie and in the book out in the desert. And, you know, it's unfortunate. The science is not treated as well as it is in some of the other of Michael Crichton's adaptations, such as Andromeda Strain or Jurassic Park.
It seems much more rushed. And the other thing that struck me is they converted what was essentially, again, like Michael Crichton's books, you know, scientific kind of interesting, you know, here's how science is advanced, here's how it could be used, and how this kind of interesting... aspect of it, of going back in time to a single place, et cetera. And they turn it into a love story between Paul Walker and the other character. And that's really, the book doesn't really do it that way. I mean, you don't really see this interest until very, you know, very late in the book.
I mean, it's probably, you know, seven or eight chapters in before you even start seeing this gel. In the. To me, it was a big disappointment around how they moved the movie from being what it was originally, which was much more about kind of the medieval period and about all this technology into something that was much more about a love story between the Paul Walker character and the female actress. And it just seemed to me to be something that, you know, it was hard, having not read the book, it would be hard to follow because it just seemed to jump really quickly past a lot of things that I think are important when you look at Michael Crichton books and their adaptations. Professor, same question to you.
I know because going into this, you were telling me how big of a Paul Walker fan you are and how big of a Gerard Butler fan you are. So I know that this was checking boxes ahead of time for you as a fan. But Professor, same question to you, sir. Well, I am a fan. And I thought that they, in one case, were and another case are like good actors who were.
And it's really fun, actually, to see somebody at the sort of beginning of their career, and you're going like, wow, that's a young so-and-so, and he looks different. But you can see some of the– in both of them in this movie, you can see some of the promise where they would go on to be the featuring leads in many other films, including Paul Walker in the Fast and Furious franchise. Mark, I agree with your points, but I guess we're going to have a disagreement about– whether the film should have gone in this direction and executed itself the way it did. And I use that in both senses of the term. So this is a Richard Donner film and Richard Donner has not aged into the culture in the sense that like people remember some of the great Richard Donner films, but he's not a Stanley Kubrick or David Lean or somebody that just like, Oh, let's, let's have our, uh, a reprise and, you know, a look back at Richard Donner or something like that.
But here, I think his instinct to not adapt the book in the way that you described, Mark, were probably the correct ones. So, let's talk about Michael Crichton a second. Michael Crichton was a perfect example of Something I envy is that somebody who has an idea, now the idea is never wholly like original in the sense that like nobody had ever thought about using genetic material from trapped in amber to recreate dinosaurs. That had been discussed. I mean, I still think from the last time I looked a couple months ago, there are still people claiming that they're going to do that.
But there's still a scientific consensus like, no, there's not going to be a Jurassic Park. But he read an idea, just like the Andromeda strain. He read about an idea. He read about something in the science. And then he did something most of us are unable to do, which is he sat down his butt in front of a typewriter, I guess eventually in front of a computer, and he wrote and wrote and wrote and wrote a serviceable novel with a plot and people and, yeah, romance and things like that.
And he was famous, so it was not possible that no matter what, a timeline was, no Michael Crichton fan, at least online, you know, thinks timeline is the peak of his career. But it was not possible it wouldn't be adapted. It did have all the things. that you said i read it about when it first came out then i didn't watch the movie i've only watched the movie a couple times for this podcast and i think possibly because i didn't find anything the novel so amazing that I wanted to see it on screen as opposed to Jurassic Park where you go like, oh my gosh, I'd really like to see how they do that on screen. But timeline just sort of felt like black in terms of its ideas. Like the Hollywood pitch meeting wouldn't have, and then they go back in time to the 13th century and they fall in love.
And there's a time you can't change time, but you know, they become people in the past and, okay, well, it's got Michael Crichton's name on it, so I guess I'll give you $ 90 million. By the way, the movie apparently failed by the Michael Crichton criteria to box off success. It was not a very successful movie. The Michael Crichton criteria of success, which is making two to three times the budget of the film back in the weekend alone. Yeah.
Yeah. So with everything going into it, people, I think, like us, saw the movie and went like, okay, you know, I personally... I thought it was a little long, but like I was entertained and I think Richard Donner, and I'm going to give Richard Donner the credit here, but like who, you know, the team who was saying, okay, we're going to adapt this novel was saying, you know, this like, let's just go back to time loops and, and. Um, wormholes. Yeah.
There's, if I was sitting there reading the script and then, uh, evil, evil tech genius says, uh, Or, or his, one of his, his assistant scientists, I forgot which one says, yeah, you know, we have a wormhole. I actually would go like, even in 2004, wormhole was getting a little silly. It was getting funny. It was not, it was not necessarily like, oh, really tell me more. And like, yeah, I have the piece of paper and the pencil or the Apple or, you know, the folded, whatever.
I think Richard Darner's instinct to go, and by the way, we have a word hole. Let's get go. This film does not allow any conversations to take place unless people are running toward while having them, or they're doing something while having them. And honestly, I think that that's a good instinct. It's an example of when you're presented with sort of, I feel sort of stale and sometimes even silly content.
Like, your audience suspension of disbelief should not be allowed to linger and savor over something and really think about it. Let's just keep going, jump on the horse, you know, tumble down the hill, fall in the river, whatever, just keep moving. And I think in that sense, it was a successful sort of like two hour entertainment and nothing more and nothing less. And I just don't know what it would have been gained by, And this is for me, Mark, and you should be down on this, but I don't know what would have been gained by exploring the themes of the novel, because I didn't find the themes of the novel to be different than 10,000 other science fiction stories and just, okay, let's get to the action and the love affair and medieval knights, who were very well done, by the way, hacking at each other.
Yeah, but you know, Professor, there's a couple issues. One is, And the first thing that struck me when I watched the movie, because I hadn't read the book in a while, is why are they going back? I mean, what is it that they're going to find going back? And the book explains why they're going back, because they want to develop the property that the ruins sit on. And the movie basically has them just go, I mean, why is the professor, why are these people going back?
I mean, what are they going to discover by going back in terms of the wormhole? I mean, it's a complete mystery. I mean, the movie has, the plot lacks a significant aspect. That's one. The second one, which is even more important, which is, you know, all time travel things end up with this time paradox, right?
So how is Merrick able to go back? So he's alive in the 20th century, goes back. So how can he be there and here, right? And there's no explanation. And again, what I like about Michael Crichton, maybe it's different than what you like about Michael Crichton, is he tries to tackle some of those difficult questions that he thinks about them in the book, for example.
He talks about the fact that what they're actually dealing with here is the multiverse. Now, this is, you know, think about this. This is multiverse before, you know, the current Marvel universe where they got all these, you know, multiverse and all this other stuff. And this is way back when they start talking about the idea that there are multiple universes that they're going back to. And that's why they're able to not have this time paradox.
And again, yes, it is an action movie. It's got a lot of action hacking and doing all this other stuff. But again, it pays a lot less fealty to. The Michael Crichton genre that I like. which is really dealing a little bit more, because anybody can write about time travel. Anyone can write about, you know, evil companies.
Anyone can write about, you know, going back, you know, for example, there's the just visiting, you know, has the idea of, you know, people coming out of time, and it's actually fairly humorous. And so I was troubled by the fact that it just spent so little time on the science, which is where Michael Crichton shines, and much more on the action aspects of it. I mean, this could have very easily not even been a Michael Crichton book. This is just about guys traveling back and having medieval running around and creating Greek fire and doing all this stuff, right? Well, and that's where I come in, in terms of this film.
So I think I'm kind of, I think I kind of tread the line between the two of you. So, A, I think towards your point, Mark, and I think to speak to something that is a Michael Crichton thing that was based on a thing he directed, not wrote a book, but he did write the script for the movie. Timeline, as a movie, could have been more like what Westworld, the TV show, is in terms of embracing the science and going in a different direction with it. That's Not what we just got on the page, but a little bit more, a little bit further in depth, a little bit more nuanced, which, I mean, Joe Nolan and Lisa Joy brought to at least the first two seasons of Westworld, which is a question of... humanity and free will.
And again, like things that are hinted at in Westworld, the movie, but not really explored too much. And when they were given the opportunity to do a full on show, that full on show ends up kind of exploring more of those themes and more of those ideas and timeline the movie. To your point, Mark, I feel like has that same issue in reverse, which is They don't want to do any of the science, which and I understand to Dr. Perlmutter's point, like in in 2003, wormholes are a little passe. I mean, you know, the film I'm talking about where it's like, well, we pass from point A to point B and here's the pen going through the paper.
That's Event Horizon that I'm speaking about specifically, which came out in like. 1999 was like four years before this movie even came out. So, and I mean, again, like, like, like the professor alluded to, like, there are so many other films that use wormholes and other things like that. But I think to Mark's point, uh, that is where Timeline, the movie, should have done something differently. It should have been about the multiverse, which I think is, to your point, Mark, that is a much more interesting direction to take this to begin with.
I'm not sure in 2003 they had the wherewithal to think about that being the possible interesting part of it. I mean, in 2003... you know, to speak to the boring or kind of trite and passe nature of the film's plot, in 2003, time travel was very long in the tooth by the time that we're seeing this film come out in 2003. it would have been more interesting if the film had been about, like Mark, you said, the multiverse. And they kind of hint at it in the movie. They're like, why does the wormhole send us here specifically? That's never answered in the movie.
I mean, literally, that is a question that is posed that is never answered. I know it's answered in the book because I remember listening to the book with you, oh, you know, a long time ago. And I remember that, obviously, it's a Michael Crichton book. So, of course, the book is going to. I mean, what's funny is with this movie, you can it's like you can see the parts of the movie that were directly written by Michael Crichton, like when they go into the underground kind of crypt and they find the glasses and the oil skin documents like you, you can read that as Michael Crichton because it's very obvious like that's a great setup.
A bunch of archaeologists go into a tomb and they find a note from another archaeologist who was just there the day before, who somehow is now in the past. That is a great hook. I don't think anyone can argue that. that. But to your point, Professor, and I think, you know, Mark, I think you also kind of got to this as well, like, What this boils down the book to, I think it boils it down too far, and it loses what makes Michael Crichton's things actually interesting, which is it has kind of that Michael Crichton sly wink and a nod. And this just.
I mean, to your point, Mark, and Professor, to your point as well, this just feels like a director for hire, writer for hire. Anybody could have made this. There is nothing about this that makes me think, oh, yeah, this is a Michael Crichton thing. The character of Merrick sort of is kind. Of a little.
A little Jeff Goldblum-y, a little Sam Neill, a little kind of charming, charismatic. But the character, I mean, Paul Walker, I think is, you know, I mean, not to drag him again, but he is horribly miscast in this film. He's just. He's not the kind of actor that plays that kind of role really well, and I think when Paul Walker gets to that point as an actor where he is able to play the kind of characters he's known for, those characters do suit him as an actor better. I'm not a hater or defender of Paul Walker either way.
He has his moments. He's not. a capital A actor, but I don't think he's dismissed completely as an actor. For all of his foibles, he grounded those Fast and the Furious movies a lot more than a lot of the other actors have done towards that franchise. But he is not cast well in this movie because he's just kind of abrasive at all points and he's hard to kind of he's hard to empathize with it's almost like and again this is an issue with the book because this is a character from the book the gerard butler character and gerard butler as an actor is just so charming you just want to spend all of your time with him which obviously given what ends up happening with his character that kind of You can't have that be the character you spend the entire movie with.
But, Mark, to your point, and this is, I think, also just a kind of a trapping of 2003 filmmaking that is not the case anymore. the Paul Walker and Francis O'Connor love story, completely unnecessary, like an unneeded, does nothing, adds nothing, more detracts than anything else from the film, because it gets in the way of other things that it could be talking about. It could be talking about the science or the business, you know, acting poorly. Because again, I mean, even to speak to, you know, In Jurassic Park, the book, there's a lot of talk about InGen and these companies kind of warring with one another in corporate espionage. Yeah, there's some of that in the movie, but there's nowhere near as much in the movie as there is in the book because that's a huge part of the book.
It's part and parcel of And that's the thing that Timeline, like I said, as kind of the opening salvo here, for me, Timeline, the movie, boils the book too far down. This is how you. And to speak to why we're probably talking about this movie in terms of a bigger kind of macro look as opposed to the micro look of the movie specifically, this is what happens when you adapt something and you take too much away. You boil down too much. You take too much of the...
The things out of it that make it the thing that it is. And in turn, you just kind of turn this into I wouldn't just say just another Richard Donner joint, because to your point, Professor, like Richard Donner has a pedigree. He directed what is widely considered to be the original superhero movie of note, which is Superman. The Omen is pretty good as well. I mean, beyond that, you know, your mileage is going to vary.
Lethal Weapon, Scrooged, Lethal Weapon 2 and 3 and 4 and Maverick. You know, there's not a lot. Like, Richard Donner's a weird director. Like, he doesn't bring much... to the party. He doesn't detract much from the party.
He's, I don't know, he's like a John Peters stalwart of the industry type. And I think to both of your points, This is not the idea that Jurassic Park is where it's dinosaurs running around, which doesn't jump off the paper the same way, you know, time travel or multiverses just don't jump off the paper the same way dinosaurs do. They just don't. Well, you know what? When you talk about boiling it down, and this is maybe what my problem is. they have just enough.
It was almost like they checked the box. You have to have transcription error. So we checked the box. Don't explain it. Don't really go through it.
Don't really spend any time on, oh, we got an evil company, but we don't really talk about what they've been doing, how they've been doing it. We talk about if you go too many times back, certain things, we'll just check the box. In some respects, I think a better adaptation would have been either to eliminate some of those aspects of it. If you want to have guys, if this movie is about going back to medieval times and saving, you know, and basically influencing an outcome of a historical event or becoming the reason the historical event occurs, that's great. You don't need all that other stuff, okay?
And so they littered in here, that's my biggest problem, is they littered in here various aspects of the book that they don't explain that really are an underlying basis of the book. I mean, the book talks about how evil ITC is and what they've been doing and, you know, that they were running out of money and they had to do this. And the fact that they were, you know, using, in some respects, using the time machine to try to develop this property into kind of like a medieval Disneyland, okay? And they don't explain any of that in the movie, which is fine, right? But they give just enough little pieces of it that it makes for a very disjointed thing.
Quite frankly, they could have swept out, you know, the guy in the desert. Doesn't add anything. Swept out the transcription error. Doesn't really add anything. They could just say, look, the number of times you come back, it affects your brain.
So, you know, Decker becomes, you know, kind of deluded at going back and forth. You could eliminate the science down and just focus on the love story with Paul Walker and the love story with Merrick. And with, you know, going back to medieval times, and this is a movie about, you know, looking at medieval times, etc. I think by just walking through the science, they really didn't do a service and it, quite frankly, made it seem disjointed. It's just quickly passing through these things that either you spend more time with it or don't talk about it at all.
I just think they're passing descriptions of all this stuff. If you haven't read the book, it's like, what the heck is that? Why is that, huh? What are you talking about? I agree, again, partially with both of you.
I agree with your intent. I guess it's a problem I have because my tendency, and I think I've proven it, on many episodes together with you and both of you and with you, Chris, is that I have this grand theory, which is first that we should measure whether a film is successful in what it tries to do, not like impose some Pauline Kael external standard on, like we were talking about negative reviews of jaws that, you know, said that, that, There was too much action. It was too frightening or something. So that's one. It's like a film should be judged within its own genre and goals and accomplishments.
And this film lacks there, absolutely. But the other part of my grand theory, and I'm saying this in sort of curly quotes here, is that I really like hard walls. I like when you have a fantastic premise, like time travel, that everything around it is done with realism and depth, exactly what you're talking about, which I think Michael Crichton in his books tried to do, is he'd have a fantastic premise, but he'd try to build hard wall. This film's walls are as crumbly as the medieval house that they break out of by just, you know, busting a wall, a wall. But to me, that's the problem is that almost all the interesting premises of these, this movie would really just fall apart.
If on a movie screen, I mean, you talked about them too much. Let's just talk about time travel and wormholes. Okay. The Stargate TV series shot in Canada, like this movie, I don't know if you've seen the original Stargate TV series, but But it's incredible how many planets look like Vancouver. You know, you go to 50 alien planets.
It's amazing how many towns in the X-Files look like Vancouver as well. We're in middle America right now. Middle America didn't have that many pine trees. But so we're well into the age of like wormholes being explained and things like that. But let's just go to Mark.
We've had discussions before about corporates. corporations, and business. Okay, now, let's just agree on this. I, in my lab at Texas Tech, invent time travel. Do I, A, patent it, and put it up for sale for $ 50 trillion, or do I perform secret experiments to try to improve the A lot. You know, I mean, just, I mean, the idea that like time travel, the method, like any time travel, like a second going, like I can go back seven seconds or something like that would be met by all the governments of the world.
I mean, I would talk about a premise. You know, there would be a global thermonuclear war to control time travel. If you said that you could go back in time, even if you said, well, I can only go back to France in 1357. Don't you think that Putin, the government of China, and the government of the United States, hell, the government of Tanzania would say, oh my God, you've invented the most powerful weapon and or science ever. Can we throw money at you or kill you or steal it from you?
So the whole premise of the entire movie is, that this company needs to figure out a way to monetize this or like do a little small project when they're anyone on the board, like you, Mark, as their chief counsel, I'm like, you're, you're the ITC chief counsel. And they're all talking about all these little, we're going to go to 1357 France and check this archeological dig. Wouldn't you at that board meeting go like, um, could we like fly to Washington and sit down with the president and the Congress, brief them, and just say, okay, we would like to be a federal contractor at $ 5 trillion per year. Thank you. Just make out the check to this.
Address, right? Well, yeah. That's why I go, don't spend too much time on that. I think Richard Donner did not trust. The source material to be discussed at lengths and used over.
And I kind of see that's what I'm saying. Well, you know, it's not, so I want to be clear. It's not about that. They don't discuss all the technology around the wormhole. Quite frankly, I don't really care about that.
It's the, it's the other things that make the story work in the book that they seem to have glossed over. For example, the, the, in the book, ITC is buying properties all around the world on all kinds of things. They don't explain in the movie why ITC is so hell-bent on trying to understand this, why they're so evil, okay? And they don't really show the evilness. They just show, you know, that he's kind of a deranged guy that doesn't want to bring these guys back kind of thing.
And quite frankly, they actually make him more of a sympathetic character because they When in the movie, he doesn't want to bring them back, not because he's evil, but because he's afraid they're going to end up with transcription errors. Okay. I mean, you know, it's a weird dynamic that doesn't really exist in the book in terms of showing how, you know, how evil he is. Because quite frankly, in the movie, if you just looked at the movie, you'd say, well, doesn't he have a point? I mean, if there's a 20% chance that you're coming back with your inside sliced in half, why are you bringing people back?
Right. I mean, it is an interesting— it makes him more pleasant than he really should be. The other thing is they cut some characters, right? So in the book, there's an attorney that's very, very important. throughout this, Kramer, that doesn't exist in the movie. Now, you can argue that she shouldn't be there otherwise, but she's kind of the knife in a lot of this stuff.
My point about the science is not the wormhole. My point is, The science that they just check the box on, like the transcription error and why is it going back to this one point and what are they trying to do with it, all that gets glossed over. And I think that's an important part of the story in terms of explaining why and how and all this is going on. It's less about exactly how the science works. I mean, that was Jurassic Park.
They really explain how the science works, the DNA and all that other stuff. That's not what I'm focused on. I'm focused on the elements of the science that make the story work so well in the book and not work so well. And by the way, all time travel in the past has this problem about the time travel paradox. He goes back.
So how could he be alive in the 20th century and And also have died in the 14th century. Right. And they don't really get into that and not sure they have to. But that's the typical problem. And it makes a huge glaring glitch in all these things that talk about that.
By the way, H.G. Wells didn't have that problem because when you go into the past, he wasn't trying to change it. When you jump to the future, you never have the time paradox. It's only the past that you have that problem with. So how is it that Gerald Butler is alive in the 20th century and also alive in the 14th century and actually dies in the 14th century?
Well, and that's, you know, again, it's funny because we're sitting now on the precipice of Marvel introducing a threat to the MCU that is a character that exists because his timeline was disrupted by the events of the end of Avengers Endgame. And that entire movie spends, you know, Endgame spends all this time trying to explain, well, it's not time travel, but it is time travel. But we're creating timelines and those timelines exist at the same time. But if you get everything back to the original time, it resets everything. And what's funny is if this movie had spent any amount of time on that little idea alone, I think it would have helped the And again, I think you're kind of, I agree.
I agree with you, Professor. But at the same time, I kind of, again, I think it's maybe a different issue. This is coming out post-Jurassic Park, which like everything Michael Crichton post-Jurassic Park kind of has this different feel to it because it's not to say that Michael Crichton wasn't successful before. He was. He created Westworld from scratch, wrote and directed it.
He worked on a whole host of other things, Andromeda Strain, which we've already talked about. And he was already a known quantity by the time this movie's coming out. Everything pre-Jurassic Park is very different post-Jurassic Park. I think, and you know, when we talked about Andromeda Strain, they got bogged down in the science to some respect. Like when we talked about Andromeda Strain, it's like, well, why are they going on and on and on about this stuff?
And in Timeline, it's like, well, why aren't they? And I think, you know, like you mentioned, Professor, maybe Donner didn't trust the source material. I don't know if that's the case because looking into and doing the research about the film, Donner's original cut of the film was longer. Donner's original cut of the film had more of an extended intro explaining the professor's kind of reasoning for going back and those other things, which is interesting because I think, to your point, Mark, for me, that would have helped explain, like, the thing that this movie is lacking is the Michael Crichton, I wouldn't say twist, but the Michael Crichton kind of. Edge on the idea.
And, you know, with Jurassic Park, even the movie Jurassic Park is missing what the book Jurassic Park, in terms of it being a Michael Crichton thing and his idea of The book Jurassic Park, yes, it's about cloning dinosaurs and making dinosaurs, but it's also about, again, pushing science too far without giving forethought as to why we're doing things and pushing science further than it needs to go without self-regulation and self-management of those things. Timeline could have been, again, there is this confluence of bad business practices and accidental time travel, but if it looks like time travel, but then it's explained as multiversal travel, I think that alone, that little wrinkle would have made this movie work just a little bit better because at least, and I think you kind of mentioned this already, Professor, time travel is something that I think for a lot of people going to the films, I mean, you know, again, to speak of Endgame again, when it was more or less confirmed that in Avengers Endgame there was going to be time travel, I was not the only person who rolled their eyes loudly, audibly for everyone to hear.
Because time travel is a crutch. It is a very lazy way of writing. And in a lot of ways, it can be used to, and in something like Endgame's case, do like a lot of fan service and a lot of like oh, remember this thing? Remember this thing? Let's recontextualize.
The other thing is retconning, which time travel loves to do. Just let's change a thing that you saw from before. And Timeline, to your point, Mark, could have done a better job at being a little different than just another time travel thing. And that, I think, to your point, I agree with 100%. That is the biggest missed opportunity, right? with Timeline, the movie.
And again, I don't want to say dumbs down the book, but it really does kind of dumb down the book in a way that Michael Crichton's stuff benefits from not being dumbed down completely. Michael Crichton, I think, writes well enough and interesting enough and has enough on the page to grab onto that you don't have to take everything out of it completely. You don't have to take all nuance out of it completely, because to both of your points, All the characters in this movie are really underserved and underutilized and undercharacterized. They're all very interchangeable, and none of them are really given anything of note or value to do. I mean, there's one character that we're supposed to empathize with, maybe, and then he just dies, and then there's another one who just dies.
All the characters. that aren't Gerard Butler, Paul Walker, and Francis O'Connor or Billy Connolly just die. And it's like, I'm not sure how we're supposed to get invested in any of these characters. I'm not sure how we're supposed to be invested in any of this. And then without enough proper lead up to what's going on, you know, you can't really, if you don't give yourself enough time to wind the spring, the toy doesn't go that far. And that's the thing about Jurassic Park.
If you sit and think about Jurassic Park, oh, the dinosaurs were throughout that movie. I mean, yes, but not really. I mean, they're there, but the movie is not replete with dinosaurs every minute of the film. There's other stuff going on in that movie. This movie can't avoid the fact that it's traveled back in time to 1357.
France. But you know what it could have done? Spent less time there if you're not going to do anything interesting with it and more time setting it up or resolving it in reality or the real world because there are things going on that would be worth talking about or at least setting up if you're doing it on the front end of things that would pay off in the long term. I mean, one of the ways in the book that one of the characters, one of the main villains dies is with a grenade, which they utilize in the first five minutes of them traveling back in time. They, oh, there's got to be a grenade.
Someone brings something back in time. But then it's like, that was literally part of the climax of the book. And it is now being introduced in minute six of the movie or whatever it is when they travel back in time. I don't know if it's that they didn't trust the source material. I think they misunderstood the intention of the source material, which for me is a bigger crime because Michael Crichton's source material is not... it doesn't leave me as a reader wanting.
He puts a lot on the page. This is not some like, well, you know, Fifty Shades of Grey, where it's just, you know, there's a lot left up to the imagination. Like, Michael Crichton puts a lot on the page for the reader. I mean, sometimes, you know, and I think, Mark, you might agree, and Professor maybe as well, sometimes too much. Sometimes he belabors the point with the science sometimes.
Like, this This movie, it's like you don't do it enough. How is it that you don't do it enough? Yeah, I agree with you that the science can sometimes be laboring. Look, here's my point. This could have been a better movie by ignoring the science entirely.
And if this is about a love story about people going back, etc., Don't explain how any of it happens. Don't even try to explain it. Just make it happen, right? There's, I mean, if you look about- There's plenty. Of those rom-com, you know, Keanu Reeves and Sandra Bullock go to the lake house and there's, he's able to send her notes through a magical mailbox.
There's no scene where Keanu Reeves is talking to a scientist. He's like, explain to me how this is happening. It's magical realism and we just understand it. I'll put this in the context of another, one of my favorite movies, Just Visiting. Just Visiting doesn't try to explain how he jumps back and forth in time.
That's not what the movie's about. It's about the humor of having some guy from the medieval times coming to the modern time and trying to deal with all the modern problems. And then jumping back. So I think the problem that they did here is They did just enough of the science to try to make it look like the book, but not enough to really be the book. And they could have gone, in my opinion, gone one of two ways, just eliminate all that stuff and just have the story about some archaeologists going back in time to visit this and to try to make the timeline work.
Or spend more time on the science and spend a lot less time about being back in the medieval times, because the book is really not about the medieval times. It's about going back to save him, come back. But most of the book is about the science and the travel and the problems associated with it. So I think they tried to walk a middle road. They wanted something that was entertaining, but had some of the science.
I think they could have made it more entertaining by having less science or make it more representative of the book. That I completely agree with. And I say this as somebody who, I guess I've been devouring science fiction since I was like single digits. And I easily have read thousands of time travel stories. It's one of my favorite genres along with post-apocalyptic.
And so part of my problem approaching anyone who has written a book, video game, TV series, movie, whatever, on time travel is I've got my checklist of 5,000 questions about time travel. And like, are you going to do, what answer are you going to give that's different than a story written in 1932 that already dealt with this and that sort of thing? I find it interesting that I personally do not think I've seen an original time travel premise in a long time, like an original like plot point. But I do find that sometimes people are able to use these very familiar settings and situations and technology or the unexplained one, as you say, where somebody just magic, there's a portal that opens and they're suddenly in the 1357, which could have worked absolutely.
But they do clever things with it. I want to give two examples. I'm not going to name one. I sort of don't want to give this away, but like, on the internet and probably since my youth, what's the first thing you do when you invent the time machine? Like what would be the most useful thing?
And this used to be, Mark, you, you, you must remember this, like, like sitting there and saying, well, you know, if I had a time machine, I would go back in time and kill Hitler. Right now, interestingly, there have been actually very few movies, TV shows that, films, books, where that was the actual plot. But years ago, I saw an episode of a TV series where this was the actual plot. Like, they actually send some... I'm using the word actually here, but it's.
It's Twilight Zone. It's the Twilight Zone 2000. No, no, no. Don't give it away. I'm not going to give it away, but I know what you're talking about.
I don't want to tell the audience this. There's a reason why I'm doing that. Well, I mean, you can if you want, but I just... Because I want people to see it. Or stumble on it.
So I didn't want to source it. These people go back in time... And they undershoot or overshoot, I guess, which way do you call it? They find Hitler as a baby in a cradle, right? So that, to me, was clever, right?
Because you're thinking, I'm going to go back in time and kill Hitler and put him in a cafe in Vienna in 1913, and he'll look like Hitler. And trust me, from biographies I've read, he'll be talking like Hitler in 1913. And also... the time traveler who's going to do this has steel. We're going to talk about this in regards to timeline, because I have a real problem with how these people are introduced as archeologists and then break all the rules of archeology and also introduced as civilians. Like, like the Gerard Butler and the lady archeologists are not introduced as X special forces people, but then of course they immediately start killing people.
But, but in this episode, They go back and they find Hitler as a baby. So suddenly there's the moral dilemma is like, oh, do you feel comfortable killing a baby? Even if you know what this baby is going to do like 40 years later. So I thought that was a really interesting spin on that. And then the second interesting spin, and I'm going to come back to timeline, was this movie I've recommended before.
And I'd like to do it sometime. A hallmark movie of all things. I mean, very, very adjacent to what you're saying about Keanu Reeves movie there, but a Hallmark movie where a woman goes into a time loop. Movie is called round and round. She goes into a time loop.
You know, we've talked on this show before about how it's not plausible anymore to have time travel, post-apocalyptic or alien invasion where everybody in the movie has never heard of time travel, post-apocalyptic or alien invasion, right? Yeah. Yeah in timeline it's like hey this is what marty mcfly did in back to the future i mean at least at least endgame had the wherewithal to mention that i mean they do have that scene where it's like you mean like in back to the future it's like okay makes sense you can't not mention. It well you know they don't mention but in this movie round and round this woman who's not a big like science fiction nerd discovers herself in a time loop and she tells her boyfriend about this and instead of him going like in any movie somebody would say oh you're crazy time loops What's a time loop?
I've never heard of that. It doesn't exist. He says, hey, let's go talk to my friends at the comic book store. And sure enough, there are these nerdy guys at the comic book store, and they have been rehearsing their whole lives of what to do if they find themselves in the time loop, and they help solve the issue of the time loop. So there are clever ways to do this.
In this film, I think, Mark, you hit the nail on the head here, or the mallet on the helmet, I guess, for this movie, is that it's too... It should have either dropped parts of the plot or... fallen into parts of the plot. So let's just take the example of the characters that I said. I personally can't stand this because I work at a university where I see all these people who've dedicated their lives to, say, archaeology or chemistry. And they would not surrender those values that they've spent 30 years developing.
And in fact, the film, and I know this is from the book, the film talks about the romance between Paul Walker and the lady archaeologist, Kate, Isaac Kate, right? And that you're not going to be able to love her. She's not going to be able to love you because she's so dedicated to archaeology, right? So immediately when she goes back in time, she kills somebody. And I do think people who are not trained to be archaeologists you know, assassins or special operators, there, there probably would be some hesitation, but before you like, you know, ram an arrow into somebody, but you know what, there would really be some hesitation before you smash an archeological treasure that you have 700 years later talked about how, who, what kind, I mean, I know they were, they were thinking it would be some sort of like, haha reveal or, When she's an archaeologist, she says, who would smash this beautiful carving?
And it ends up her smashing. But she does it without any hesitation whatsoever. She doesn't have a moment of ethics, of professional ethics. Do you know how broken an archaeologist would be if even by accident they destroyed some sort of artifact? dropped it or something like that. I will tell you because I've actually met archaeologists who talked about earlier in their career, like, yeah, I was on a digging site and I jammed it.
I wasn't supposed to be using a pick and I chipped off the ear of this statue or whatever, apropos of the film. So there were just a lot of things in this movie that didn't ring true And I'm not going to, I'm not defending this movie and the audience that it was intended for. I think we have to keep going back to that is that the people, the film did not succeed in what intended to do. It doesn't matter whether it pleases the three of us, the fun, the cut that was released in the theater, which I, I, this is why I said Richard Donner or the studio, because I suspect what was going on was the studio said, Hey, let's get to the action. You know, hey, let's get to the romance.
And as Mark, being a much more astute studio executive than the ones who control this production, it didn't work for anybody. Yeah. You know, a couple of things I want to say. I'll start with what you were just talking about in terms of the archaeology. They were trying, I mean, the smashing the thing was the precursor to him getting his ear cut off, right?
I mean, it's the, look, this is, we're doing the exact same things that we find in the 20th century happened back then, as opposed to changing things, right? But they don't deal with, they kill all these people that probably weren't killed originally, right? I mean, what happened to all those soldiers and the whole lineage going on? With respect to time travel, I actually think there's a Star Trek episode of the original series, City on the Edge of Time. that does a better job of dealing with all of the timeline stuff without getting into the science. I mean, it deals with the dilemma, which you were exactly talking about, about Edith Keillor, who ends up being the seminal feature of the reason that the United States did not get into World War II and whether they let her die with the car hitting her or not.
So they're dealing with that huge moral dilemma that you're talking about, that this doesn't talk about at all. This is just all about action and all that. The other thing I will say, and I don't know if you're a student of Spider Robinson, the author, but he actually has a very interesting short story about time travel that is fundamentally different than anything that we've talked about. And I think it's actually a very interesting idea. The story is about a missionary couple who go to somewhere in Central, I think it's Central America or South America, and for whatever reason, get rounded up and thrown into a jail for 15 years, okay?
Yeah. And they come out of the jail and they are true time travelers. They're time travelers in the sense that their world was 15. They had no contact with the outside world for 15 years. And all of a sudden they've jumped forward 15 years.
So they're like people from the past. now in the future, sitting there looking and saying, who's president? That guy was, you know, and I think Richard Nixon was mentioned, you know, Richard Nixon was, you know, he was disgraced. He went away and all of a sudden he's president. What are you talking about? Right.
And so it's a, it's an interesting twist on the time travel without any science, without anything. It's just time travel because someone was in, was, you know, completely out of touch for 15 years. It's actually an interesting twist. twist on this time travel without any science etc but i agree with you i think the studio wanted this to be an action movie and they they had they i think michael crichton and and maybe the the the producer director wanted to keep in some of the science and that's why we get this hugely abbreviated bits of science which really doesn't help anybody It just, you know, I think they could have shortened the movie and put in other stuff. Hey, more action. You want more action?
Let's put in more fights. Right. I mean, do you ever want that? And just forget about the science. Nobody cares.
I want to just divert everything. Can we talk about the medieval part of this? Because we keep saying this is a time travel movie, but like the time travel part, it's like five minutes, right? Yep. Total screen time of them, like, you know, uh, 18 and their joints.
And like, even talking about time travel, it's maybe like 10, 50 to maybe 10 minutes. Most of this. And this is, I want to ask you, cause you know, you're different ages and we're, we're coming from different perspectives. I think Monty Python has ruined serious medieval movies because I cannot watch guys in medieval armor running around swinging their sword without, Like, it's seen humorously. I just have a hard time pulling off.
Now, I know there have been serious movies set into the late 60s, but I think there's a reason why there's so few. And they put some money into realism here. I mean, I did not research whether that was the real helmet of realism. a French knight or the real sword of a British knight. But, you know, let's face it, the costume departments of, say, the BBC and Hollywood probably have some pretty good medieval armor to pull out from. But, oh my gosh, just endless scenes of people hacking each other.
And let's go back, by the way, to what you mentioned, the very first scene, right? So this Taub guy in medieval clothing ends up as an extra on Breaking Bad, and he's found on the road. Wait a minute. So he's taken to the hospital. He has these anomalies, like, you know, it looks like a piece of paper that's been torn, but he also was murdered by somebody with a huge blade.
But then the police and the doctors, you know, breaking all law, right? No, a murder has taken place, but the police say, well, yes, a giant corporation who, uh, you know, helps our tech base, you know, no problem. Just take everything. And in fact, the, uh, the head of the tech company says, now I want all the medical records too. How many laws were violated there?
Well, and that's again to go. I think that's the issue I really have with this movie in a, in a post Westworld, uh, like world of doing things is the, you know, in the time of 2003, the corporate intrigue of the film was seen as uninteresting when the corporate intrigue and the things that happened before them going back in time ends up being the stuff that I want to know more about, because it seems like there's actually some legs to what's happening. I mean, like Mark mentioned in the book, it's not even like the time travel is not even, the point. It's about essentially doing a Westworld style thing where you're kind of monetizing, as one would do in a capitalist world, monetizing time travel in a Michael Crichton-esque way that makes sense.
You've been taking people back in time to see, you know, 1357 France. People have always wanted to do that. I mean, People always want to go down to the Titanic and rich millionaires and billionaires have been taking advantage of that too. I mean, it's, it's kind of, it's, it's that, I mean, and, and the fact that that was not interesting enough and they had to boil it down to, we're going to travel back in time so that we can have people swinging swords in a Errol Flynn-esque medieval romp. Like, A, to the professor's point, I don't think medieval culture fiction is serious.
I think there's very few things that can be taken seriously. Mark mentioned Just Visiting, which is. In that camp of things that I find it hard to. take seriously in light of because Just Visiting came out in 2001, two years before this film. And it is a film that is set around the same time in the same part of the world in the kind of back in time parts. And it does those much more interesting.
And it, like Mark mentioned, doesn't belabor the time travel at all. It's magical realism. Merlin is in the movie, essentially. And that's how they time travel, which is the other way you kind of get away with it if it's just magic. That's the thing.
Michael Crichton makes the magical seem real using science fiction tropes. And that's the big, I think, missed opportunity for this movie is, yes, that part is interesting, but the corporate intrigue and espionage is something that I think is, you know, look at, you know, to speak to HBO and Westworld, look at Secession. I mean, that is a show that is literally just a show based on espionage, corporate espionage, corporate intrigue, like backstabbing in a corporate kind of business setting. We now know in a world post that show being successful and making all the people from that show immensely famous if they weren't already and immensely successful if they weren't already. And in some cases, revitalizing some of their careers and reintroducing them to a whole new group of an audience of people.
We know that people are amenable to corporate intrigue and espionage. So shying away from it and saying, well, we don't want to do that. Just get to the part where people are swinging swords at each other. It is a just general misunderstanding of the taste of the audience as well, because like you've both mentioned, I think by trying to do a little bit of everything, they do nothing successful at all. I mean, I'm not going to say that this is a bad movie, because I think to call this a bad movie is unfair.
It's not trying to be anything other than an entertaining hour and a half, two hour romp. And, you know, Michael Crichton wasn't necessarily trying to end world hunger or anything else with his books. I mean, I would say, and you know, Professor, I think you put it pretty aptly, Michael Crichton was trying to entertain. And if you were at least somewhat entertained by a book that he wrote, or a film adaptation of a book that he wrote, I think that that is a success in terms of Michael Crichton. And you know, the kind of more serious trappings and the kind of more introspective and interesting science fiction questions This film doesn't ask them.
And I think if you look at something like Westworld, it asks those questions and maybe asks them too much and kind of lets those questions get in the way of having that entertaining kind of film. And, you know, I think, you know, we have so many things that came out post-Jurassic Park. And this is. 10 years after Jurassic Park. In between this and Jurassic Park coming out was Rising Sun, Disclosure, Congo, Lost World, Sphere, 13th Warrior, which I think probably needs to be mentioned here because I covered the 13th Warrior a long time ago on the CultureCast.
But it is the movie that this movie wishes it could have been in the medieval parts. And that's because that is a... Again, it has a weird kind of framing device. I think it's like these are scrolls that were found and it's an account of kind of a Muslim kind of from the Ottoman Empire or something in kind of medieval England. And it's this whole kind of fish out of water thing.
But there's also this pseudo horror thing going on with the eaters of the dead. It is more, I think, what Michael Crichton can do with that world than the movie version of Timeline is. And like we've already kind of alluded to, the book Timeline is not really about the 1357 Castle Guard France. Like, it's part of the book, but it's not the focus. And the movie, I think, just thinks that is somehow the most entertaining part.
That is the most exciting thing. Getting to back in time is going to be so exciting for the audience that they're just going to have a hard time containing themselves when Paul Walker and Gerard Butler are swinging swords on screen. And it's like, I mean, I guess maybe, but you haven't given them anything interesting to do, and that feels... What's sad is because they rush to the part of the movie that they think the audience wants to see, they skip over the part that is the non-pedestrian part of the film. The part that we see is rather pedestrian.
There's nothing about them traveling back in time that, other than the fact that they're telling us they're traveling back in time, it could have been any medieval thing, period. Like, it could have been any medieval fiction, period. Because there's nothing that sets it apart. Because again, they have to get all of their equipment and everything there because... Can't bring anything back in time with you, even though, like we've already all talked about, you can kill as many people as you want, but don't bring glasses back.
But you're bringing back stuff that, you know, is made in the 20th century back there because you're wearing clothes that were done. You're not going back naked. But at the at the at the I'll say this much. As a movie on on its own, ignoring the Michael Crichton aspect. It's an okay movie.
It's worth watching. It's entertaining. It's got, you know, it's got two love stories in it. It's got a bunch of action. It's got all that.
If you want to say, you know, as an adaptation of a book, is it a good one? I would say no. Okay. So, you know, it succeeds in the sense of if what you're wanting to do is have some two love stories and set in a medieval time period and, you know, and have a. Bunch of action.
Yeah, it succeeds in that because 90% of the movie is just exactly that. And, you know, you could argue that they should have less or more of any of that. But, you know, if you want to look at it as an adaptation, no, I don't think it does as good a job as it should have in trying to hew to, to your point, the book is not about time travel. It's not about medieval times. It's about what the corporation's doing and how it's, you know, twisting people's lives and destroying people's lives by its actions. which has very little to do in this movie.
And like I said, they actually turn on its head by making Doniger actually a sympathetic character because he doesn't want to bring people back who may get transcription errors. He's not not wanting to bring them back because he doesn't want to spend the money or because he doesn't like them or whatever else. It's very simple. He wants to bring them back because he's worried about them coming back and being cut up and not surviving. He says at least they'll survive back in the medieval times.
They won't survive here if they get transcription errors. And he's absolutely right. This is this discussion that I've always loved having. And I remember once in class, and we were actually in a mixed group of science students and then our communication students. And this is a panel on the portrayal of science in media, fictional narrative media.
And the argument that I made was that, look, You're never going to please 100% of the scientists all of the time, whenever you do anything. Don't even imagine that every chemist is going to like everything you do in a movie. It would be too dull a movie if you stopped for everything. But you do have to pick and choose how many suspensions of disbelief that you're going to linger over and sort of call attention to the problem, or you're just going to, like, rush over that bridge. And here, literally, as I said, almost every conversation is had while running or riding or jumping or floating, things like that.
1952, Ray Bradbury writes, probably the most famous establishing of the genre of science fiction, go back in time, the problem of changing the past, Sound of Thunder. And I mean, it's a pretty old story, but like I People go back in time and something they do, which is incredibly tiny and minor, changes the future that they return to, the present that they refer to. Mark, you're absolutely right. This movie just said, okay, well, we're just going to skip over that because we're sending people back in time. They kill people who presumably may have had descendants today.
I mean, we find out, you know, I don't know, Madame Curie's grandfather was killed by Merrick, you know, so you know or or you know make a list of famous scientists or stage leaders or whatever or or or me you know. You killed the great great grandfather charles de gaulle like okay. Yeah no i think i think it would be funny if there was a podcast talking about this film and suddenly one of the Somebody had gone back in time and killed our great-great-great-grandfather. But that's, I guess that's where I understand that this became a traditional thriller action movie, an okay one. I think we're all saying that because I sat through this for two hours and I didn't, fume with anger at Chris for recommending to watch it or suggesting that we watch it.
I think actually this is a good, this great exam discussion we're having is an example of the challenges of what do you have when you have something that raises a lot of ideas and That maybe either you dive into or you just float over. Maybe you should have fewer ideas. Maybe you should make the premise simpler, something like that. I don't know what the solution is. And there have been a lot of, as we suggested, hundreds of other thousands, if you start going to short stories and novels, solutions out there.
But this film just didn't. ring true in the setting and the manner it was. And maybe it would have been better if they'd said, Michael, you know, the whole mechanical technology time travel thing doesn't work. Can we just have a bunch of archaeology students who are digging up a site in 1357 walk through a magic time portal and end up in 1357? Can we just do that? Well, and that's the thing.
I mean, if that's the movie they had wanted to make, don't make it based on the book. And that's the, I mean, you know, you mentioned the conversation we're having here. I think the conversation ultimately ends up being, why adapt something if you lose what makes it an adaptation more or less immediately? It's like, you know, adapting Jurassic Park and they're just, no, well, we're just going to leave the part about the dinosaurs out. Like, Or how did the dinosaurs come into being?
We don't get that scene in the Jurassic Park movie where it's, you know, hello, John. And, you know, this is dino DNA. I mean, I know people are really find the dino DNA to be iconic and Mr. DNA to be iconic. But that scene does so much heavy lifting in that movie. because it allows you to understand what it is the movie is doing, what it is the kind of point of the science is.
And again, to your point, Mark and Professor, the science needs to either be doing all the heavy lifting or get out of the way completely. And in this movie, it should have just been out of the way completely, but then it doesn't need to be timeline. Then it just needs to be, you know, Paul Walker and Gerard Butler playing accidentally fall into a hole in an archaeological. Dig and go back in time. I mean, you know.
You want to make a fun movie, just do Bill and Ted's Excellent Adventure with Paul Walker and Gerard Butler, where they go back in time in a magical time booth. I don't know. The funny thing is, they're such charismatic actors that the movie doesn't even play to their strengths as actors, and they come off both rather stilted. Paul Walker, especially. Gerard Butler, I think, is kind of effortlessly charming, which I think, to his credit, that's why he...
I mean, I'm not saying Paul Walker obviously passed away, but... and I would assume he'd still be working right now too, but Gerard Butler is one of those actors who likes to get dragged by a lot of people because he kind of just, I wouldn't say makes dumb movies, but he makes a lot of really weird, weird choices. He's like Nicholas Cage. He just kind of likes to seemingly work. A lot, but he's very actors. He's very charming though.
Like the Scottish and Scottish and British actors. They, God bless them. They love that paycheck. You know, we talked about Jaws and now this is my opportunity to get in the anecdote about Michael Caine and Jaws 4, the revenge that I did not get in before about how he got a call from his agent. You know, there's a movie and allegedly Michael Caine tells different versions of this story, but allegedly he said, well, what's the movie about?
And his agent said about a million pounds. And Michael Caine says, great, I'm in, you know, And those British actors, you did the long Sean Connery podcast. And Sean Connery, God bless him. I loved him so much. I still love him.
But man, it was a guarantee there was a dog of a movie if Sean Connery was in it for decades. Because he just, you knew he was going to pick a bad script, but they wrote him that nice paycheck. And I think there's more of a tradition there. of just like, well, it's a, it's a, it's a, it's a job. Actor is like an old profession in England. Like it's a profession that's been there forever.
You know, you can say acting came from that area of the world in terms of being a serious profession. And I don't think you'd be wrong. Like, and that's, That's the thing. Gerard Butler, he's so good in this movie that I think he carries an otherwise uninteresting kind of flat movie that just goes through the motions and just kind of checking the boxes in a post-Jurassic Park world. And Gerard Butler genuinely, by the end of the movie, I'm like, I can see how in three years he is going to be the lead in 300.
A movie that doesn't necessarily need a whole lot of plot or dialogue, but he is charming in that movie. And that ends up putting him on the map as an actor who is still doing a lot of things today. But that's kind of, for me, the biggest takeaway from the movie is Even in a movie that kind of falls apart under the weight of a premise that it doesn't want to approach, the best thing about the movie is Gerard Butler, of all things. You know, back to one other thing I want to kind of point out about the movie versus like Jurassic Park. I don't understand what the point of this movie is.
So, for example, in Jurassic Park, I think Malcolm has a line that, that sums up the entire reason for the movie and where Michael Crichton was trying to go, and where he says, you know, hey, John Hammond, you don't understand, just because you can doesn't mean you should, okay? Famous line. Where's that line here? There's, I mean, I don't understand the purpose of any of this, right? I mean, there's not, what is the purpose of the movie?
Because Michael Crichton has a purpose in Timeline, the book. There's no there's nothing in here that states what the purpose of this movie is. Okay. Why, why show this movie? I mean, if it's just to have guys rumping around in medieval times and doing all this, Hey, that's great.
But it doesn't really explain what, what's the purpose of this movie other than that. I mean, this could be, you know, a hundred other movies that just have, you know, let's have a, let's have a fight scene and everybody fights and, you know, that comes out, you know, that good guy wins. Okay. But that's not, what's the purpose. Do I need to explain what the purpose of this?
I mean, money? Michael Crichton had integrity. Let's all agree on that. I don't think Michael Crichton ever became one of these authors that just said, well … I guess I can wrap a fish in newspaper and they'll slap my nape on it. No, he barely wanted to write Jurassic Park 2.
He wrote Jurassic Park 2 because Jurassic Park, the film, was so immensely successful that he was like, well, I'd be kind of dumb to not capitalize on it. But he didn't just sit and write 8 million Jurassic Park books after Jurassic Park. I think he had scruples. And I'm not saying Donner doesn't have scruples, but it feels like. The people who wrote this movie....
Are viewing it through a lesser lens. And that happens with adaptation. I mean, you know, look at Stephen King and Stanley Kubrick. Stephen King is still convinced that Stanley Kubrick did not do The Shining justice, even though The Shining is a great film in and of its own, but it's not a great adaptation of the book if you are a fan of the book and what the book does. And that's the thing.
This movie is a poor adaptation of a book if you are a fan of what the book does. If you just want to watch a movie where Paul Walker and Gerard Butler are running around in their mid-20s slashing people with swords. There aren't any other movies like this one. So I guess this is the one that you have to watch. But I think it's just, it's weird that even with someone like Crichton, who at this point, 10 years on, has been a noted financial success in Hollywood, even his stuff is being kind of dumbed down for the masses unnecessarily.
Because again, like like we've already all talked about, time travel is not something that's really hard to explain to people. People can get behind time travel. Having dinosaurs being cloned with frog DNA is a little bit more heavy lifting than time travel. But yet this movie seems to think, well, time travel, that's all the audience is going to understand. So let's just move on.
You know, oh, it's just like faxing, huh? You know, like that thing that's so popular, like we're just moving on. Like, What? I wonder if this wasn't just like a lot of movies that put a headline, you know, big actor in them and expect them to be successful. You know, it's Michael Crichton.
After all, he wrote Jurassic Park. You got to watch this movie. It feels like it. Yeah. And it's just it's the same kind of thing, you know, right.
That's what it feels like, because, again, it could have been a much better movie if they just ignored all the Michael Crichton stuff and just had these guys going these. archaeologists going back into time fighting you know this stuff etc I would be 100% by that and And quite frankly, it would have simplified the movie and it might have made it even more exciting. But, you know, this I think it feels like they just did it because he had his name on it. He'd done Jurassic Park. It was so successful. Oh, I got to go see that.
Just like, hey, go see Sean Connery movie because I like Sean Connery and I've seen him in five other movies that I like. So I'm going to go watch him in this, even though it's a piece of junk. And I know that people like to drag Congo. But I will. And I think that this is probably the kind of the last thing I will say about this.
And you guys can have your moment as well. But people drag Congo because it's a lesser Jurassic Park came out after Jurassic Park. It's not as good as Jurassic Park. Michael Crichton has had a lot of his works adapted, and not a lot of them have really been great. I mentioned a lot of those things in between Jurassic Park and Timeline, and I don't hear anyone saying, well, that's my favorite movie.
I loved Sphere or Disclosure. But what's funny is if you look at Congo, Congo is the only true thing that Crichton did other than Jurassic Park that kind of was successful in the way Jurassic Park was. And Congo is a, in a lot of ways, for I think most people, a lesser Jurassic Park in terms of, oh, it's a Michael Crichton thing and it's got animals and, you know, but Jurassic Park came out like 10 years after Congo. Congo got written in the 80s. Congo is a very different book.
And I mention all this because Congo the movie is nothing like Congo the book in a lot of ways. I mean, Congo the book and Congo the movie are very different. And yet Congo the movie is a better version of Congo than the book Congo is. I've read the book Congo. It's fine.
Congo the movie is an entertaining action romp circa 1995. It has monkeys, it has monkeys smoking cigars and drinking martinis and talking, and it's got Bruce Campbell. It's got all kinds of wild, weird stuff about it. And it retains the idea that Michael Crichton came up with and does some other stuff. But it's not a good adaptation of the book.
But that's okay, because the book is just, the book's fine. timeline was not some sort of like, this is the holy tome in scripture. We cannot deviate from the book. They clearly didn't care about deviating from the book. So they deviated in this really weird direction that stripped it of all of its kind of interesting things that made it more of a thing that Michael Crichton wrote and less of a thing that anyone could write. And, you know, I think of something like Dan Brown's The Da Vinci Code in terms of adaptation.
When you adapt someone's book, sometimes it works better on the page than it ever would on the screen. And The Da Vinci Code is a book that doesn't really work very well as a movie because there's a lot of stuff in the book that's kind of a character just going and saying, well, let me sit for 10 minutes and tell you about this. And that just it doesn't work that well in a movie. TV show, different story. You just have these exposition dumps where the film slows down to a crawl and everybody sits and talks around a table for 10 minutes.
And it can work. It worked in Jurassic Park. But the idea, there's a careful balancing act where you have to explain the idea but not over explain it because if you... over-explain it, there's too many questions. If you under-explain it, there's too many questions. So you kind of have to do this balancing act.
And this movie is not engaged in that. And that's why, for me, it's like, just don't adapt the Michael Crichton thing. Like Mark said, it is literally being adapted because Michael Crichton is one of the most successful authors to adapt other than a Stephen King. And so, yeah, if there's a Michael Crichton thing out there that can be adapted, you know, it was probably going to be adapted post-Jurassic Park. Why certain things have not been adapted since is still weird to me with Michael Crichton stuff.
But yeah, a lot of this just feels like from the studio that brought you Jurassic Park, yet another thing by the guy who wrote Jurassic Park, but not adapted by the people who had adapted Jurassic Park. And that's the difference. Yeah. And I guess this is my wrap up of this is that I never was a Michael Crichton fan in the sense that like, Oh, I knew Michael Crichton book. I can't wait to read it.
But I, from the interviews he gave and just things I've read about him and the books that I did read, I had respect. I have respect for his work. artistic integrity that he really, he loved ideas. He, he read science. I mean, a lot of his ideas came from reading actual scientific journals, not just like a newspaper article about something. Uh, so I just respected him for his process.
He became a brand name. And today, it's funny, I was looking this up. I actually go to a library and check books out to read. And I see Tom Clancy, who died many years ago, is publishing a book, I guess, every three or six months or something. He's become a brand.
The estate, I guess, said fine. And so new people are writing Tom Clancy books every six months. And there's a bunch of famous authors who've become these necromantic creations you know just they're still publishing even though they passed away I think it's interesting with Michael Crichton there seems to be some more restraint because there's been a couple of books published based on unfinished manuscripts there's been like a couple one sequel but they haven't quite just thrown away all all self-control so maybe maybe there's that's still that little bit of legacy that He seemed to care about his craft. And even in this movie, you can tell just from the little dribbles of the basic plot outline that there was somebody who was, yeah, this is important to me.
This is not just schlock. Like I want it to be something more. And I want to end on that because I don't want to give this impression that that Michael Crichton was just purely driven by commercial motives, even if some of the people who were working in his name and, you know, to produce things based on his work pretty much had only commercial motives. And, you know, here's my wrap up. I think this is a fine movie.
If you want action movies in medieval times and on two love stories, including Paul Walker and Gerard Butler, I think it's fine. as an adaptation, I think they missed the mark in, in, in many respects of what we said, but I'll say this final one, which kind of strikes me. They didn't really, I, it almost like they went back and they had an original cut that didn't have some of the science in it. And someone, perhaps Michael Crichton pushed back and said, we got to have some of that in here because that's important to me. The transcription errors important to me, the thing, you know, this, that, and something or other. I think, what they missed was all of that could have been handled differently and still been in the movie and actually done a better job of connecting up.
I mean, they could have talked about all that. Without having these little vignettes of pop up on the, on the screen about, you know, the guy in the desert and, Oh my God, they, you know, his, his, his, his veins don't show up, et cetera. I think that, I think this, some of it may be a production problem that they shot a different movie and then they wanted to, then they cut it back. And then they said, we got to add stuff back in. And they didn't go back and rethink what they actually.
Should have done. Because they could have put, for example, the whole transcription error, the issue with going back too many times, people dying, et cetera. They could have done that differently by having people just talk about it and say, you know, hey, when you go back, there's really some real big issues with this. You know, guys have come back and their veins haven't lined up and their bones haven't lined up. And it's been a big issue.
And we had this guy come back and his You know, he died in the desert because of this, et cetera. And they didn't really do that. And I think that's the that's where I think the major failing with this is if you want to have an adaptation and you don't want to follow it slavishly and you still think. But you got to kind of retain the themes of it. And that's where I think they kind of missed the mark here as an adaptation.
They didn't retain the themes of the book. They just retain the entertainment part of the book and not the themes of, hey, this is an evil corporation doing this stuff, and there's all kinds of problems they're going to do. They're making an atomic bomb, essentially, without understanding what they're actually doing and what the effect it may have, et cetera. But again, it's a good movie if you want to seize action. It's got some great characters.
It's got some great actors in it and actresses, and it's entertaining. But as an adaptation, I think it falls short. Of the mark. So if you want to hear us talking about an adaptation of a Michael Crichton movie or book that's not as compromised in terms of the science, maybe overly scientific, check out when the three of us talked about The Andromeda Strain, which you can find over at weirdingwaymedia.com, where this show and so many other shows are. can be found, including required viewing, which the professor and I do once a week. Every Thursday, we sit and do an episode, not necessarily a movie you should watch, but maybe why you should watch it if you do want to watch it. from a 360 degree perspective.
Also do my normal show, The Culture Cast. And also you can find on my feed, Culture Meltdown, which is a crossover show that I do with my friend Brian Renfro, whose show Movie Meltdown can also be found on weirdingwaymedia.com. Like, rate, and review this show on iTunes, then Spotify. Patreon.com slash CultureCast is where you can go to kick a couple dollars my way. But most importantly, in these trying times, iTunes and then Spotify helps us find our audience and helps our audience find us.
Thank you both so much for joining me for this romp through yet another Michael Crichton film, and we'll catch you on the next episode.
Similar episodes across the network
Matched by shared keywords.
-
S1E5 — College
2 shared keywords: chris_stachiw, weirding_way_media
-
Episode 0 — Never Tell Me the Odds
2 shared keywords: chris_stachiw, weirding_way_media
-
S1E4 — Meadowlands
2 shared keywords: chris_stachiw, weirding_way_media


